Beta-strand recombination in tricalbin evolution and the origin of synaptotagmin-like C2 domains

Two protein families involved in membrane traffic, tricalbins and synaptotagmins, contain several copies of C2 domains and are related based on their sequence and domain architecture. Paradoxically, tricalbin and synaptotagmin C2 domains belong to different structural types with apparent circular permutation of terminal beta-strands. To understand whether a topological switch took place, we analyzed tricalbin and synaptotagmin-like C2 domains using two-dimensional structural analysis. We found that yeast tricalbins contain five to six C2 domains. One of these C2 domains possesses many features of synaptotagmin-like C2 domains and also carries a conserved C-terminal strand that is similar to its structural equivalent in synaptotagmin-like C2 domains, suggesting a structural permutation event. Indeed, among higher eukaryotes, animal tricalbins have evolved a C2 domain with synaptotagmin-like topology indicating that the structural conversion has taken place. Investigation of plant synaptotagmins, however, proves that they are direct tricalbin orthologs. Our analysis shows that beta-strand recombination is a possible evolutionary mechanism to generate new structural topologies with altered functional properties.     

Triggered Ca2+ influx is required for extended synaptotagmin 1-induced ER-plasma membrane tethering

The extended synaptotagmins (E-Syts) are ER proteins that act as Ca²⁺-regulated tethers between the ER and the plasma membrane (PM) and have a putative role in lipid transport between the two membranes. Ca²⁺ regulation of their tethering function, as well as the interplay of their different domains in such function, remains poorly understood. By exposing semi-intact cells to buffers of variable Ca²⁺ concentrations, we found that binding of E-Syt1 to the PI(4,5)P₂-rich PM critically requires its C2C and C2E domains and that the EC₅₀ of such binding is in the low micromolar Ca²⁺ range. Accordingly, E-Syt1 accumulation at ER-PM contact sites occurred only upon experimental manipulations known to achieve these levels of Ca²⁺ via its influx from the extracellular medium, such as store-operated Ca²⁺ entry in fibroblasts and membrane depolarization in β-cells. We also show that in spite of their very different physiological functions, membrane tethering by E-Syt1 (ER to PM) and by synaptotagmin (secretory vesicles to PM) undergo a similar regulation by plasma membrane lipids and cytosolic Ca²⁺.