Maternal effects and heterosis influence the fitness of plant hybrids

Here we tested two possible nonexclusive explanations for the maintenance of a hybrid swarm between Senecio jacobaea and Senecio aquaticus; first, that genotype-by-environment interactions involving water and nutrient clines are involved in hybrid fitness, and second, heterosis in early hybrid generations may provide an initial hybrid advantage that contributes to hybrid persistence. In three climate chamber studies, fitness and root growth were measured for parental species and natural and artificial F1 hybrids, in order to determine whether hybrids occur in habitats where they are more fit than parental species. Natural hybrids, which are generally back-crossed to S. jacobaea, always equaled S. jacobaea in growth characteristics. Maternal effects played a role in the fitness of F1 hybrids, with offspring from S. jacobaea mothers exhibiting higher fitness than those from S. aquaticus mothers, and compared with parental species and natural hybrids. Natural hybrids are not distributed in zones where they are most fit with respect to nutrient and water regimes. Superior fitness of early generation hybrids may contribute to hybrid swarm stability.     

The enemy release and EICA hypothesis revisited: incorporating the fundamental difference between specialist and generalist herbivores

The success of invasive plants has been attributed to their escape from natural enemies and subsequent evolutionary change in allocation from defence to growth and reproduction. In common garden experiments with Senecio jacobaea, a noxious invasive weed almost worldwide, the invasive populations from North America, Australia, and New Zealand did indeed allocate more resources to vegetative and reproductive biomass. However, invasive plants did not show a complete change in allocation from defence to growth and reproduction. Protection against generalist herbivores increased in invasive populations and pyrrolizidine alkaloids, their main anti‐herbivore compounds, did not decline in invasive populations but were higher overall compared with native populations. In contrast, invasive plants lost additional protection against specialist herbivores adapted to pyrrolizidine alkaloids. Hence, the absence of specialist herbivores in invasive populations resulted in the evolution of lower protection against specialists and increased growth and reproduction, but also allowed a shift towards higher protection against generalist herbivores.     

The effects of herbivory and competition on the invasive alien plant Senecio inaequidens (Asteraceae)

Abstract. Senecio inaequidens DC. (Asteraceae) is an invasive alien plant introduced to Europe from South Africa in around 1896. It contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids that are toxic to livestock and humans. S. inaequidens would therefore be an economic and ecological problem if it became established and abundant in natural or farmed grassland ecosystems. We conducted field experiments using a split‐plot design to determine the effects of rabbit grazing, interspecific plant competition, mollusc and insect herbivory on growth, survival and reproduction of S. inaequidens. Plants were grown from seeds of three different ecotypes under standardized greenhouse conditions and transplanted into field plots. Rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus L.) were excluded from experimental plots using rabbit fences. Competition was manipulated by either creating subplots with bare ground or leaving the vegetation cover intact. Data were recorded between June and August 2002. Ecotypes differed significantly in morphological parameters, and in their responses to invertebrate herbivory. Interspecific plant competition and rabbit grazing significantly reduced growth and reproduction of S. inaequidens. Regrowth shoots of S. inaequidens produced after rabbit grazing were not subsequently eaten by rabbits. Unpalatability of regrowth shoots may be attributable to changes in pyrrolizidine alkaloid composition with plant age. Mollusc herbivory significantly reduced the number of capitulae produced. We found adults of Longitarsus jacobaeae Waterhouse (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), a specialist herbivore of European Senecio jacobaea L. (Asteraceae), feeding on 79% of S. inaequidens plants. 320 larvae of Tyria jacobaeae L. (Lepidoptera: Arctiidae) did not feed on S. inaequidens under free‐choice field conditions. We conclude that S. inaequidens is able to survive and reproduce in disturbed grassland ecosystems. L. jacobaeae might be a suitable agent for biological control of S. inaequidens in European introduced populations in the future.     

Pre-oviposition period of the ragwort seedfly,Pegohylemyia jacobaeae,introduced for the biological control of ragwort,Senecio jacobaea

Abstract

Laboratory studies on the effect of diet on the pre-oviposition period of the ragwort seedfly showed that ovarian development is not delayed by asynchrony between adult emergence and ragwort flowering, and that nutrients are required from sources other than ragwort The pre-oviposition period was, however, extended because of absence of oviposition sites. Day-degree summation (calculated from development rates measured in controlled conditions) indicated that, under temperatures in the field, females were gravid 2 weeks before oviposition sites became available. Eggs were laid on transplanted flowering ragwort before field plants flowered. Extended pre- oviposition period reduces effectiveness of ragwort seedfly as a biological control agent of ragwort as it results in poor synchronisation of seedhead damage.     

The analysis of pyrrolizidine alkaloids in Jacobaea vulgaris; a comparison of extraction and detection methods

Introduction – Pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) serve an important function in plant defence. Objective – To compare different extraction methods and detection techniques, namely gas chromatography with nitrogen phosphorus detection (GC‐NPD) and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC‐MS/MS) with quadrupole analysers for analysing PAs in Jacobaea vulgaris. Methodology – Both formic acid and sulfuric acid were tested for PA extraction from dry plant material. For GC‐NPD, reduction is required to transform PA N‐oxides into tertiary amines. Zinc and sodium metabisulfite were compared as reducing agents. Results – The lowest PA concentration measured with GC‐NPD was approximately 0.03 mg/g and with LC‐MS/MS 0.002 mg/g. The detection of major PAs by both techniques was comparable but a number of minor PAs were not detected by GC‐NPD. With the LC‐MS/MS procedure higher concentrations were found in plant extracts, indicating that losses may have occurred during the sample preparation for the GC‐NPD method. Zinc proved a more effective reducing agent than sodium metabisulfite. The sample preparation for LC‐MS/MS analysis using formic acid extraction without any reduction and purification steps is far less complex and less time consuming compared to GC‐NPD analysis with sulfuric acid extraction and PA N‐oxide reduction with zinc and purification. Conclusions – In terms of sensitivity and discrimination, formic acid extraction in combination with LC‐MS/MS detection is the method of choice for analysing PAs (both free and N‐oxides forms) in plant material. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Allelopathic vs. autotoxic potential of a grassland weed—evidence from a seed germination experiment

ABSTRACT

Background: Mechanisms affecting invasiveness of non-indigenous species have received much attention. Few studies have investigated invasions by native plants. Invasive native species such as common ragwort (Jacobaea vulgaris) may become noxious weeds. They challenge farming and nature conservation by outcompeting fodder plants or rare herbs. One mechanism that can result in outcompeting plants is by allelopathy.

Aim: We evaluated the potential of J. vulgaris to suppress germination in common and rare grassland species by allelopathy.

Methods: In a germination chamber experiment, we exposed 22 species and J. vulgaris itself to ragwort leachate. We controlled for osmotic effects by germination tests in mannitol solution and water. We assessed germination percentage—time —synchrony and radicle length.

Results: Leachate reduced germination percentage, germination time, synchrony and radicle length. These effects were similar for J. vulgaris, indicating autotoxicity. Rare species germinated less than common species but were not more sensitive to the phytotoxic effects of J. vulgaris. Restraining effects of the leachate were similar to the mere osmotic effect.

Conclusion: Our results question allelopathy as the main driving mechanism behind J. vulgaris gaining dominance. However, the impact of J. vulgaris might depend on the composition of the invaded plant community due to species-specific effects.     

Simulated herbivory counteracts the effects of grass competition on the invasive fireweed (Senecio madagascariensis)

Competition, herbivory and their interaction play a significant role in determining the competitive ability and survival of individual plant species. Understanding these processes and interactions can improve the efficacy of biocontrol programs against invasive weeds. Senecio madagascariensis (fireweed) is an invasive weed of South African origin that reduces pastoral productivity and poisons livestock in several countries, notably Australia. Although competitive pastures can suppress the weed’s growth in Australia, its competitive nature is poorly understood in relation to its invasion success. This greenhouse study assessed the growth and reproductive yield of fireweed growing in competition with six native and introduced grasses present in both South Africa and Australia. Since fireweed is a target for biocontrol in Australia, we examined whether its response to grass competition changed with herbivory (simulated by 40% leaf removal). The effect of grass competition and herbivory on the weed’s biomass and floral productivity was examined during a 12‐week pot trial in South Africa. Floral numbers were unaffected by both grass competition and herbivory. Biomass was used to calculate Relative Interaction Indices (RII) to quantify the weed’s competitive or facilitative response. This index compares a specific measurable trait, such as biomass, of fireweed growing alone, to fireweed growing with grass to determine the level of competitive suppression or facilitation resulting from the interaction. Despite the lack of species‐specific effects of grass competition, the presence of grass suppressed fireweed’s foliar, root and whole plant biomass the most when herbivory was absent. With herbivory, fireweed did not suffer from any measurable competitive suppression. This lack of competitive suppression may be due to an induced allelopathic response, given the levels of pyrrolizidine alkaloids common in many Senecio species. Since this result may weaken the case for biocontrol, the weed’s competitive responses should be verified in relation to actual insect herbivory.     

Biological control ofSenecio jacobaea in Northern California,an enduring success

Senecio jacobaea, a poisonous weed from Eurasia, was brought under successful biological control in the Ft. Bragg, California area by 1976, through the combined action of the defoliating cinnabar moth (Tyria jacobaeae) and a root feeding flea beetle (Longitarsus jacobaeae). In 1987, 4 previously infested Ft. Bragg sites (3 sites where control had been documented and another unstudied site) were examined.Senecio jacobaea densities at these sites were 0.0, 0.0, 0.01 and 0.18 plants/m², indicating both continued and improved control of the weed. The flea beetle and the cinnabar moth both persist at the sites, despite very low numbers ofS. jacobaea plants. The control ofS. jacobaea has resulted in the return of near natural vegetation at the 2 coastal prairie sites and regained productivity at the 2 pasture sites. c/o American Embassy APO San Francisco 96301     

Host specificity of the ragwort flea beetle Longitarsus jacobaeae (Waterhouse) (Coleoptera:Chrysomelidae)

Abstract

The ragwort flea beetle, Longitarsus jacobaeae, was tested for host specificity against representative species of native New Zealand Senecio. Adult feeding and oviposition tests were carried out under quarantine with and without a choice of host plants. Larval development was assessed using potted plants. It was concluded that L. jacobaeae is highly specific to Senecio jacobaea and that it is extremely unlikely to be damaging to native New Zealand Senecio species.