The role of genetic constraints on the diversification of Iberian taxa of the genus Aquilegia (Ranunculaceae)

The microevolutionary process of adaptive phenotypic differentiation of quantitative traits between populations or closely‐related taxa depends on the response of populations to the action of natural selection. However, this response can be constrained by the structure of the matrix of additive genetic variance and covariance between traits in each population ( G matrix). In the present study, we obtained additive genetic variance and narrow sense heritability for 25 floral and vegetative traits of three subspecies of Aquilegia vulgaris, and one subspecies of Aquilegia pyrenaica through a common garden crossing experiment. For two vegetative and one floral trait, we also obtained the G matrix and genetic correlations between traits in each subspecies. The amount of genetic variation available in wild populations is not responsible for the larger differentiation of vegetative than floral traits found in this group of columbines. However, the low heritability of some traits constrained their evolution because phenotypic variability among taxa was larger for traits with larger heritability. We confirmed that the process of diversification of the studied taxa involved shifts in the G matrix, mainly determined by changes in the genetic covariance between floral and vegetative traits, probably caused by linkage disequilibrium in narrow endemic taxa. © 2013 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2014, 111 , 252–261.     

Differential responses of alpine and non-alpine Aquilegia species to increased ultraviolet-B radiation

Abstract. Two species of columbines, Aquilegia caerulea (which lives in alpine environments) and A. canadensis (a lower-elevation species) responded to artifically increased levels of solar UV-B radiation by becoming significantly shorter and developing a significantly greater number of leaves. The degree of shortening was greater in A. canadensis , the non-alpine species, while the number of leaves increased faster in A. caerulea . Significant differences in gashandling and water-use physiological responses were noted, with UV-B treatment leading to decreased water-use efficiency in both species. Concentrations of flavonoids increased significantly in both species following light exposure, whereas alkaloids in A. caerulea appeared to be destroyed by UV-B. No significant changes occurred in β-carotene concentrations in either species.     

Gene flow between nascent species: geographic,genotypic and phenotypic differentiation within and between Aquilegia formosa and A. pubescens

Speciation can be described as a reduction, and the eventual cessation, in the ability to interbreed. Thus, determining how gene flow differs within and between nascent species can illuminate the relative stage the taxa have attained in the speciation process. Aquilegia formosa and A. pubescens are fully intercompatible, yet occur in different habitats and have flowers specialized for pollination by hummingbirds and hawkmoths, respectively. Using 79 SNP loci, we genotyped nearly 1000 individuals from populations of both species in close proximity to each other and from putative hybrid zones. The species shared all but one SNP polymorphism, and on average, allele frequencies differed by only 0.14. However, the species were clearly differentiated using Structure, and admixed individuals were primarily identified at putative hybrid zones. PopGraph identified a highly integrated network among all populations, but populations of each species and hybrid zones occupied distinct regions in the network. Using either conditional graph distance (cGD) or Fst/(1‐Fst), we found significant isolation by distance (IBD) among populations. Within species, IBD was strong, indicating high historic gene flow. IBD extended approximately 100 km in A. pubescens and 30 km in A. formosa. However, IBD between the species was very weak and extended only a few km beyond hybrid zones, suggesting little recent gene flow. The extensive sharing of SNP polymorphisms between these species suggests that they are very early in the speciation process while the low signal of IBD suggests that they have largely ceased gene exchange.