A PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF THE SYNUROPHYCEAE USING MOLECULAR DATA AND SCALE CASE MORPHOLOGY

The phylogeny of the Synurophyceae was investigated by parsimony analysis of scale case characters and small-sub unit (18S) ribosomal RNA (rRNA) sequence data. Analysis of 1 eustigmatophycean (outgroup), 3 chrysophycean, and 10 synurophycean 18S rRNA sequences corroborated the inference from ultrastructural information that the Synurophyceae is a monophyletic assemblage . Tessellaria vol-vocina, which had been tentatively proposed as a member of the Synurophyceae, was confirmed as the earliest lineage within the Synurophyceae by both the molecular analysis and an evaluation of published ultrastructural data. A second set of analyses investigated the relationships among Tessellaria volvocina, 6 Synura species, and 10 Mallomonas species/varieties, with particular reference to the validity of current classifications of the Synurophyceae and the characters upon which they are based. The molecular and scale case phylogenies were not totally resolved but were largely congruent. The data sets were combined to produce another phylogeny, which showed greater resolution. The combined phylogeny weakly supported our representatives of Synura and Mallomonas as monophyletic groupings and also upheld several of the sections within these genera that are recognized by current classifications. However, some changes to the classification and delineation of these genera are recommended and predicted. Both our 18S rRNA sequence and scale case data sets were more appropriate for examining the branching order among the more closely related text rather than resolving the deeper branching points of the synurophycean phylogeny .     

Multigene phylogeny of Synura (Synurophyceae) and descriptions of four new species based on morphological and DNA evidence

We used phylogenetic analyses based on multiple gene sequences (partial nr SSU and LSU rDNA, partial pt LSU rDNA, psaA and rbcL) from 148 strains (including three outgroups) and scale ultrastructure to examine phylogenetic relationships among species of the colonial genera Synura and Tessellaria. The phylogenetic tree based on the combined dataset was congruent with ultrastructural characteristics of the scales. Synura was divided into three major clades, two including species in section Synura, and one representing section Peterseniae. One clade, consisting of seven strains of S. uvella (section Synura), diverged at the base of the genus. The second clade consisted of the remaining species belonging to the section Synura. The third clade, containing organisms in the section Peterseniae and characterized by scales possessing a keel, was monophyletic with strong support values. Based on our findings, S. uvella needs to be in a separate section from other spine-bearing species, and we therefore propose new sectional ranks; Synura, Peterseniae, Curtispinae (presence of body scales with slender spines, tubular scales and caudal scales). We further propose four new species based on phylogenetic analyses and unique scale characters: S. longitubularis sp. nov., S. sungminbooi sp. nov., S. soroconopea sp. nov. and S. lanceolata sp. nov. Lastly, we propose a new genus name, Neotessella, to replace the invalid use of the name Tessellaria.     

Scale Biogenesis in Synurophycean Protists: Phylogenetic Implications

The Synurophyceae is a class of golden-brown, freshwater, photosynthetic flagellates with a world-wide distribution. A well-developed taxonomy exists where genera and species are distinguished by colony or cell morphology or by the siliceous scales that cover the cells. However, phylogenetic relationships within the class are poorly understood, and incongruous taxonomic concepts occur. This study reviews scale morphology from field-collected samples and controlled culturing experiments as well as from studies of scale biogenesis. The information is used to identify homologous silicification surfaces among taxa and to document the diversity of the resulting scale structures. Thirty-two character states are coded into 11 characters in a cladistic analysis of 13 pivotal taxa. Colonial species are emphasized. One most-parsimonious phylogenetic tree is found (HI = 0, CI = 1). Synura lapponica is shown to be most closely related to Tessellaria volvocina. S. sphagnicola emerges at the base of the tree. Mallomonas caudata and the S. petersenii clade emerge from within Sectio Synura. Chrysodidymus synuroideus appears as an ancestral taxon in the Synura spinosa-like clade (i.e., Series Spinosae). The poorly understood developmental bases for some characters, especially secondary scale structures, are identified and may help focus future research.