Reply to the first systematic response by the Global Footprint Network to criticism: A real debate finally?

We respond to a reaction of the Global Footprint Network/GFN on our 8-point criticism of the ecological footprint. We also refer to, and comment on, an associated debate in this journal between Giampietro and Saltelli, 2014a, Giampietro and Saltelli, 2014b, on the one hand, and Goldfinger et al. (2014), on the other. We conclude that criticism on the footprint is accumulating and coherent across the various studies and disciplines and among the different authors. This was the first time that Wackernagel/GFN systematically responded to our criticisms. Hence, our response contains several original elements and the resulting exchange can be seen to add value to the existing literature. It ultimately allows readers to better make up their mind about the different viewpoints on the ecological footprint.     

Impact on energy metabolism of quantitative and functional cyclosporine-induced damage of kidney mitochondria

In this study we have measured, under experimental conditions which maintained efficient coupling, respiratory intensity, respiratory control, oxidative phosphorylation capacity and protonmotive force. Succinate cytochrome-c reductase and cytochrome-c oxidase activities were also studied. These investigations were carried out using kidney mitochondria from cyclosporine-treated rats (in vivo studies) and from untreated rats in the presence of cyclosporine (in vitro studies). Inhibition of respiratory intensity by cyclosporine did not exceed 21.1% in vitro and 15.9% in vivo. Since there was no in vitro inhibition of succinate cytochrome-c reductase and cytochrome-c oxidase activities, the slowing of electron flow observed can be interpreted as a consequence of an effect produced by cyclosporine between cytochromes b and c₁. Cyclosporine had no effect on respiratory control either in vitro or in vivo. Statistically significant inhibition of the oxidative phosphorylation was observed both in vitro (6.6%) and in vivo (12.1%). Moreover, cyclosporine did not induce any change of membrane potential either in vivo or in vitro. Our findings show that cyclosporine is neither a protonophore, nor a potassium ionophore. In cyclosporine-treated rats we noticed a decrease of protein in subcellular fraction, including the mitochondrial fraction. The role of the inhibition respiratory characteristics by cyclosporine in nephrotoxicity in vivo must take account of these two parameters: inhibition of the respiratory characteristics measured in vitro and diminution of mitochondrial protein in cyclosporine-treated rats.     

Roles of Subunit NuoK (ND4L) in the Energy-transducing Mechanism of Escherichia coli NDH-1 (NADH:Quinone Oxidoreductase)

The bacterial H⁺-translocating NADH:quinone oxidoreductase (NDH-1) catalyzes electron transfer from NADH to quinone coupled with proton pumping across the cytoplasmic membrane. The NuoK subunit (counterpart of the mitochondrial ND4L subunit) is one of the seven hydrophobic subunits in the membrane domain and bears three transmembrane segments (TM1–3). Two glutamic residues located in the adjacent transmembrane helices of NuoK are important for the energy coupled activity of NDH-1. In particular, mutation of the highly conserved carboxyl residue (_KGlu-36 in TM2) to Ala led to a complete loss of the NDH-1 activities. Mutation of the second conserved carboxyl residue (_KGlu-72 in TM3) moderately reduced the activities. To clarify the contribution of NuoK to the mechanism of proton translocation, we relocated these two conserved residues. When we shifted _KGlu-36 along TM2 to positions 32, 38, 39, and 40, the mutants largely retained energy transducing NDH-1 activities. According to the recent structural information, these positions are located in the vicinity of _KGlu-36, present in the same helix phase, in an immediately before and after helix turn. In an earlier study, a double mutation of two arginine residues located in a short cytoplasmic loop between TM1 and TM2 (loop-1) showed a drastic effect on energy transducing activities. Therefore, the importance of this cytosolic loop of NuoK (_KArg-25, _KArg-26, and _KAsn-27) for the energy transducing activities was extensively studied. The probable roles of subunit NuoK in the energy transducing mechanism of NDH-1 are discussed.     

Ascorbic acid prolongs the viability and stability of isolated perfused lungs: A mechanistic study using 31P and hyperpolarized 13C nuclear magnetic resonance

Ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) has recently shown promise as a means of more accurately gauging the health of lung grafts and improving graft performance post-transplant. However, reperfusion of ischemic lung promotes the depletion of high-energy compounds and a progressive loss of normal mitochondrial function, and it remains unclear how and to what extent the EVLP approach contributes to this metabolic decline. Although ascorbate has been used to mitigate the effects of ischemia–reperfusion injury, the nature of its effects during EVLP are also not clear. To address these uncertainties, this study monitored the energy status of lungs during EVLP and after the administration of ascorbate using ³¹P and hyperpolarized ¹³C NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance). Our experiments demonstrated that the oxidative phosphorylation capacity and pyruvate dehydrogenase flux of lungs decline during ex vivo perfusion. The addition of ascorbate to the perfusate prolonged lung viability by 80% and increased the hyperpolarized ¹³C bicarbonate signal by a factor of 2.7. The effect of ascorbate is apparently due not to its antioxidant quality but rather to its ability to energize cellular respiration given that it increased the lung’s energy charge significantly, whereas other antioxidants (glutathione and α-lipoic acid) did not alter energy metabolism. During ascorbate administration, inhibition of mitochondrial complex I with rotenone depressed energy charge and shifted the metabolic state of the lung toward glycolysis; reenergizing the electron transport chain with TMPD (N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine) recovered metabolic activity. This indicates that ascorbate slows the decline of the ex vivo perfused lung’s mitochondrial activity through an independent interaction with the electron transport chain complexes.     

Cadmium-containing granules in kidney tissue of the Atlantic white-sided dolphin (Lagenorhyncusacutus) off the Faroe Islands

Top predators from the northern sub-polar and polar areas exhibit high cadmium concentrations in their tissues. In the aim to reveal possible adverse effects, samples of five Atlantic white-sided dolphins Lagenorhyncusacutus have been collected on the occasion of the drive fishery in the Faroe Islands, for ultrastructural investigations and energy dispersive X-ray microanalyses. Cadmium concentrations were less than the limit of detection in both immature individuals and ranged from 22.7 to 31.1 μg g^?1 wet weight in the mature individuals. Two individuals with the highest cadmium concentrations exhibited electron dense mineral concretions in the basal membranes of the proximal tubules. They are spherocrystals made up of numerous strata mineral deposit of calcium and phosphorus together with cadmium. Cadmium has been detected with a molar ratio of Ca:Cd of 10:1 in the middle of these concretions. To our knowledge, this is the first report of such granules in a wild vertebrate. The role of these granules in the detoxification of the metal and the possible pathological effects are considered.     

Flower change in Oenothera drummondii Hooker as a response to pollinators' visits

Flower change in Oenothera drummondii Hooker as a response to pollinators' visits. The colour and shape of flowers of Oenothera drummondii change owing to senescence, pollination and/or nectar withdrawal. This phenomenon is interpreted as a signal emitted by the plant to 'inform' the potential pollinator of its new status as a rewardless flower. This method of signalling might be important for the pollinators in order to save energy in seeking the correct flowers and for the plant to ensure visits to those flowers that have not yet been visited.     

Maximum energy assimilation rates in the Djungarian hamster (Phodopus sungorus)

Summary Physiological limits to energy budgets were estimated in Djungarian hamsters (Phodopus sungorus) using food balance and respirometric methods. The summer acclimatized, reproductively inactive hamsters could balance their energy budget at-2° C, assimilating 91.1 kJ·animal^-1· day^-1 after gradual cold acclimation, whereas non-acclimated hamsters showed negative energy balance assimilating only 54.4 kJ·animal^-1·day^-1. At the same ambient temperature, multiparous females (although neither pregnant nor lactating at the time) maintained positive energy balance assimilating 81.6 kJ·animal^-1·day^-1. Hamsters are capable of rapid adjustments of their maximum assimilation rates to meet their current energy demands, but only up to the value of about 3.5xBMR. It is concluded, that the actual energy budgets of small mammals keep, all the time, fairly near the upper physiological limit, with body reserves ready to buffer short-term oscillations.     

Adenine nucleotide contents and energy charge of Azotobacter vinelandii grown at low phosphate concentration

The effect of a low phosphate concentration on intracellular adenine nucleotide content, oxygen consumption and poly--hydroxybutyrate deposition was investigated with N-free and NH ₄ ⁺ batch cultures of Azotobacter vinelandii. When the microorganisms were cultured under low-phosphate concentrations the cells contained much larger amounts of poly--hydroxybutyrate, but displayed lower oxygen consumption activities and energy charge values than did control cells. Also, the ratio ATP to ADP was much higher in control cells and the intracellular levels of ATP were lower in low-phosphate cells.     

Seasonality,aestivation and the life history of the salamanderfish Lepidogalaxias salamandroides (Pisces: Lepidogalaxiidae)

Synopsis Changes in the age/length structure of Lepidogalaxias salamandroides populations in temporary waters of south-western Australia were monitored over a 51 month period by regular field sampling. Each year the study area experienced a summer drought of approximately five months duration. During the drought period Lepidogalaxias burrows into the mud and aestivates and substantial mortality occurs during this period. Body lipid reserves decrease during this period suggesting that they are the main energy source used during aestivation. The amount of lipid remaining after aestivation appears to be important in determining when female fish reproduce. Males die after reproduction and achieve a maximum age of only about 12 months. Some females also reproduce and die at this age while others defer reproduction for another year. Fecundity is much higher in these older, larger fish: they must however, survive two drought periods before they reproduce. The evolution of the life history style shown by Lepidogalaxias salamandroides is discussed with respect to the well defined seasonality of the region and it is suggested that selection for reproduction at an early age is balanced by the constraints of offspring survival during the aestivation period.     

A possible contribution by glial cells to neuronal energy production enzyme-histochemical studies in the developing rat cerebellum

Summary Recent reports have revealed that certain neurons do not survive in vitro in the presence of glucose, which is the primary substrate and exclusive source of energy in the brain. But these neurons can survive in the presence of low-molecular-weight agents such as pyruvate, which are supplied by glial cells (Selak et al. 1984). To test whether this result also holds true in vivo, we investigated the distribution of hexokinase, lipoic dehydrogenase, -hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase, and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activities in the developing rat cerebellum. Hexokinase activity was relatively higher in glial cells than in neurons. After postnatal day 8, the activity of hexokinase could hardly be detected in Purkinje cells, whereas it was highest in Bergmann glial cells. Purkinje cells were the only type of neuron with high levels of lipoic dehydrogenase at all ages tested. -Hydroxybutylate dehydrogenase activity was also high in Purkinje cells, especially in those from young rats. Relatively high glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity was demonstrated in basket and stellate cells from adult brain. Thus, it appears that, in vivo, certain neurons utilize relatively little glucose, and it is indeed possible that glial cells may supply some substance(s) other than glucose, for example pyruvate, as the primary source of energy.