Waddington redux: models and explanation in stem cell and systems biology

Stem cell biology and systems biology are two prominent new approaches to studying cell development. In stem cell biology, the predominant method is experimental manipulation of concrete cells and tissues. Systems biology, in contrast, emphasizes mathematical modeling of cellular systems. For scientists and philosophers interested in development, an important question arises: how should the two approaches relate? This essay proposes an answer, using the model of Waddington’s landscape to triangulate between stem cell and systems approaches. This simple abstract model represents development as an undulating surface of hills and valleys. Originally constructed by C. H. Waddington to visually explicate an integrated theory of genetics, development and evolution, the landscape model can play an updated unificatory role. I examine this model’s structure, representational assumptions, and uses in all three contexts, and argue that explanations of cell development require both mathematical models and concrete experiments. On this view, the two approaches are interdependent, with mathematical models playing a crucial but circumscribed role in explanations of cell development.     

Biochemical and immunological analysis of human immunodeficiency virus gag gene products p17 and p24.

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) p24 was purified to homogeneity and subjected to NH2-terminal sequencing. The sequence determined perfectly corresponded to the amino acid sequence predicted from the nucleotide sequence of a middle portion of the HIV first open frame: the gag gene. Edman degradation of purified HIV p17 revealed instead a blocked NH2 terminus. Hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies to p24 and p17 were developed and used to immunologically characterize these two HIV gag gene products. They identified two gag precursor polyproteins in the cytoplasm of HIV-infected cells: Pr53gag, which corresponds to the primary translational product, and Pr39gag, which corresponds to an intermediate product of cleavage of Pr53gag. These monoclonal antibodies allowed us also to study posttranslational modification of HIV p24 and p17. p24 was found to be phosphorylated, which is a very unusual feature for a major retroviral core protein. p17 was found to be myristylated, as are all NH2-terminal gag proteins of the known human retroviruses.     

Standardized and simplified nomenclature for proteins common to all retroviruses.

We propose a revised standardized nomenclature for the proteins common to all retroviruses on the basis of biological function, enzymatic activity, and/or virion location data. (We do not discuss proteins specific for subfamilies or only some retroviruses.)     

Molecular characterization of gag proteins from simian immunodeficiency virus (SIVMne).

A simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) designated SIVMne was isolated from a pig-tailed macaque with lymphoma housed at the University of Washington Regional Primate Research Center, Seattle. To better establish the relationship of SIVMne to other immunodeficiency viruses, we purified and determined the partial amino acid sequences of six structural proteins (p1, p2, p6, p8, p16, and p28) from SIVMne and compared these amino acid sequences to the translated nucleotide sequences of SIVMac and human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2 (HIV-1 and HIV-2). A total of 125 residues of SIVMne amino acid sequence were compared to the predicted amino acid sequences of the gag precursors of SIV and HIVs. In the compared regions 92% of the SIVMne amino acids were identical to predicted residues of SIVMac, 83% were identical to predicted residues of HIV-2, and 41% were identical to predicted residues of HIV-1. These data reveal that the six SIVMne proteins are proteolytic cleavage products of the gag precursor (Pr60gag) and that their order in the structure of Pr60gag is p16-p28-p2-p8-p1-p6. Rabbit antisera prepared against purified p28 and p16 were shown to cross-react with proteins of 60, 54, and 47 kilodaltons present in the viral preparation and believed to be SIVMne Pr60gag and intermediate cleavage products, respectively. SIVMne p16 was shown to contain covalently bound myristic acid, and p8 was identified as a nucleic acid-binding protein. The high degree of amino acid sequence homology between SIVs and HIV-2 around proven proteolytic cleavage sites in SIV Pr60gag suggests that proteolytic processing of the HIV-2 gag precursor is probably very similar to processing of the SIV gag precursor. Peptide bonds cleaved during proteolytic processing of the SIV gag precursor were similar to bonds cleaved during processing of HIV-1 gag precursors, suggesting that the SIV and HIV viral proteases have similar cleavage site specificities.     

Thiophosphorylated proteins in chromaffin cells are chromaffin vesicle matrix proteins

Bovine adrenal chromaffin cells were incubated with inorganic thiophosphate, using a protocol similar to experiments with inorganic phosphate, in order to determine the source of previously observed thiophosphoproteins. Incubation of cultured cells with [³⁵S]thiophosphate resulted in its incorporation into cell constituents within 2 min. SDS PAGE of the treated cells showed incorporation of label into a broad 97–121 kDa band that was evident after 5 min of treatment and increased progressively to the 40 min exposure limit. Monolayers of chronically treated cells were fractionated into subcellular constituents. The only particulate fraction containing radiolabelled proteins was the chromaffin vesicle fraction. Two-dimensional electrophoresis of the treated cells and isolated chromaffin vesicles showed a majority of proteins in the acidic region of the first dimension gel. A fluorogram of the gel revealed two regions of radiolabelled proteins at acidic and neutral regions of the 2-D gel. These were within the boundaries of the 97–121 kDa band. The thiophosphorylated proteins were released as soluble proteins upon osmotic or freeze-thaw lysis of the vesicles. Chromaffin vesicles isolated from either cultured cells or adrenal medulla tissue were energized by 2 mM ATP but not by the analog adenosine 5′-O-(3-thiotriphosphate). The 97–121 kDa proteins in intact or lysed vesicles prepared from adrenal medulla tissue were not thiophosphorylated by either inorganic thiophosphate or adenosine 5′-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) in the presence or absence of energization by ATP. Nearly complete loss of radiolabel from matrix proteins treated with chondroitinase ABC suggests that it is a component of vesicle proteoglycans.

The results demonstrate that chromaffin vesicle matrix proteins are rapidly and intensely thiophosphorylated in cultured chromaffin cells but not in isolated vesicles. The data suggest that phosphorylation must play an important role in the normal function of these vesicle proteins.     

Envelope proteins of human T cell leukemia virus type I: characterization by antisera to synthetic peptides and identification of a natural epitope

Three peptides corresponding to selected regions of the env gene products of human T cell leukemia virus type I were synthesized by solid-phase Merrifield techniques. The sequence of peptide designated SP-65 was identical to the predicted C-terminal 12 residues of the transmembrane protein p21env, and peptide SP-74 was inferred from a region shown to be highly conserved among mammalian retroviruses. The third peptide, SP-70, was derived from a C-terminal region of the surface glycoprotein gp46. Antibodies to each peptide were raised in rabbits and were used to identify and further characterize the proteins coded by the env gene. Despite being present at very low levels in purified viral preparations, these proteins were chromatographed by reverse-phase high pressure liquid chromatography and were located by Western blot analysis of the column fractions. Anti-SP-70 recognized the surface glycoprotein (gp46) and also its C-terminal cleavage fragment (gp16). Anti-SP-65 and anti-SP-74 both reacted with the hydrophobic transmembrane protein (p21) and provided evidence that this protein does not undergo apparent C-terminal processing during viral maturation, unlike the trans-membrane protein of murine leukemia virus. As expected, anti-SP-74 also reacted with homologous proteins from other Type C and Type D viruses, confirming that peptide SP-74 corresponds to a broadly conserved region of retroviral transmembrane proteins. SP-70, which is predicted to be quite near the C terminus of the major surface glycoprotein, was also reactive with sera of HTLV-I-positive patients, indicating that this peptide corresponds to, or is part of, a native epitope recognized by the natural host.     

Reactivity of a sulfhydryl group of the ras oncogene product p21 modulated by GTP binding

We have studied the sensitivity of sulfhydryl groups of a highly purified p21 protein of the v-rasH oncogene to a thiol-specific reagent, N-ethylmaleimide (NEM). Approximately 70% of GTP binding and autokinase activities of p21 were inactivated by NEM, and excessive amounts of GTP or GDP protected p21 activities. Thiol titration revealed the presence of one fast reactive cysteine residue, the susceptibility of which is modulated by GTP binding. A total of 4 and 6 residues, respectively, became titratable upon denaturation and reduction, suggesting the presence of a disulfide bond. This GTP-modulated sulfhydryl group was identified as Cys-80 in the following tryptic peptide sequence: NH2-Thr-Gly-Glu-Gly-Phe-Leu-Cys-Val-Phe-Ala-Ile-Asn-Asn-Thr-Lys-COOH. This is based on the comparative tryptic peptide mapping of [14C]NEM-modified p21 in the presence and absence of GTP. The GTP-modulated peptide co-chromatographed with a synthetic peptide of the predicted sequence. Amino acid analysis of the purified [14C]NEM-modified peptide from tryptic digests of p21 also confirmed its identity. This region of p21 shares an extensive sequence homology with various G-proteins and appears to be in the vicinity of the GTP-binding domain of these proteins.