Determining Observer Reliability in Counts of River Otter Tracks

ABSTRACT In many research projects, reliability of collected data is dependent on reliability of field observers. However, it is uncommon for observer reliability to be either measured or reported in wildlife research. We tested whether observer skill affected outcomes of a northern river otter (Lontra canadensis) track survey conducted by the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department. Observers recorded presence of tracks at bridge sites (n = 250) throughout a 27-county region in east Texas, USA. Logistic regression indicated that observers were significantly associated with frequency of reported otter tracks. Because observers were not assigned to bridges at random, we tested and found associations between the bridges surveyed by each observer (SURVEY ROUTE) and habitat variables (WATERSHED, VEGETATION-TYPE, WATER-TYPE, BRIDGE-AREA) that may have influenced otter presence and probability of detection. A standardized tracker evaluation procedure indicated that experienced observers (n = 7) misidentified 37% of otter tracks. Additionally, 26% of tracks from species determined to be “otter-like” were misidentified as otter tracks. We recommend that observer skill in identification of animal tracks and other indirect signs be measured to detect and reduce observer errors in wildlife monitoring.     

An experimental analysis of the water relations of eggs of Blanding's turtles (Emydoidea blandingii)

Eggs of Blanding's turtles ( Emydoidea blandingii ) were incubated in the laboratory under hydric conditions eliciting different patterns of net water exchange between eggs and surrounding air and substrate. Eggs incubated on wet and intermediate substrates increased in mass during the first half of incubation and decreased in mass during the second half, and their mass just before hatching was slightly lower than at oviposition. Eggs incubated on dry substrates and on platforms above substrates declined in mass throughout incubation, with a rate of decline greater in the second half of incubation than in the first. The size of hatchlings was related to the hydric environment in which eggs were incubated and, possibly, to the net flux of water across eggshells. However, variation in size of hatchlings was not as great as has been reported for other species with flexible-shelled eggs, owing presumably to the constraints on water exchange imposed by the more complex eggshells of Blanding's turtles.     

Water Relations of Chelonian Eggs and Embryos: Is Wetter Better?

The exchange of water between a chelonian egg and its subterraneanenvironment is influenced by numerous factors, the most importantof which are (1) structure of the calcareous layer of the eggshell,(2) water potential and temperature in the nest, and (3) fractionof the eggshell that actually contacts soil in the nest cavity.Eggs with relatively porous shells tend to absorb large quantitiesof water from cool, moist environments and to lose large amountsof water to warm, dry ones. Net water-exchange by such eggsalso tends to be more favorable (= positive) when soil contactsthe entire eggshell than when a large fraction of the shellis exposed to air trapped inside the nest cavity. In contrast,eggs with relatively impermeable shells usually exchange onlysmall amounts of water with their environment, regardless ofthe physical conditions that prevail inside the nest. The patternof net water-exchange, together with size (and water content)of the freshly laid egg, determines the amount of water thatis available to sustain the embryo. An embryo having accessto a relatively large reserve of water will consume more ofits yolk and grow to larger size before hatching than will anembryo having access to a smaller reserve of water. Large, well-hydratedhatchlings may survive better than small, dehydrated animalsduring the trek overland from nest to water. If so, a cooler,wetter nest will also be a better nest.     

CEPHALOPODS AND FISH: THE LIMITS OF CONVERGENCE

Resemblances between cephalopods and fish 1. Modern cephalopods (coleoids < 1000 species) resemble modern fish (30,000 species) more closely than any of their ancestors did. They have not been replaced by the more diversified group in geological time. 2. The main body of the article (pp. 245–283) reviews these resemblances. They are to be found at all levels of analysis. 3. Basic physiological mechanisms of molluscs (pp. 262–5) have been incorporated into systems with performances comparable to those of vertebrate systems. For instance the cephalopod locomotory system (pp. 249–56) and hydrostatic control system (pp. 256–60), structurally very different from their fish counterparts, have similar adaptive radiation. 4. Behaviour (p. 278) and growth of the brain (p. 265) are characteristically vertebrate-like. 5. Cephalopods and fish are considered as occupying the same broad adaptive zone though modal differences (pp. 283–5)-in reproductive habits, growth rate and light-dependent behaviour where extraocular photoreceptors appear to be important - mean that they occupy different areas within that zone. (ii) Evolution of convergence 6. Evidence is presented (pp. 287–293) for considering the convergence as due not merely to similar physical demands of the marine environment, but to dynamic interactions between cephalopods and vertebrates from the late Palaeozoic onwards. 7. The convergence was set on its way when the two groups, independently of each other, acquired locomotory methods that allowed them to increase in size. 8. It is argued that reduction and eventually complete loss of the chambered shell (in all but sepiids) was an evolutionary response to the needs of increased mobility and to the need to go deeper as vertebrate predators pushed out into oceanic waters. 9. The ammonites (pp. 291–2) present a partial model of the course that coleoid ancestors may have taken. 10. Coleoids subsequently reinvaded surface and coastal waters, competing successfully in a teleost habitat. Their most striking adaptations are ones that they share with teleosts. 11. Behavioural interactions in a vertebrate-dominated environment have probably been responsible for the vertebrate-type eye of cephalopods (p. 293). 12. The conclusion that the common adaptive zone shared by cephalopods and fish has been achieved by mutual interactions between the two groups evokes no special evolutionary principles. It assumes that all cephalopod species have (at some period of their evolutionary history) been in competition for food with some vertebrate species and that vertebrates are a source of selection pressures - largely operating through visual behaviour - that maintain and promote convergence upon the ‘fish’ modal type. 13. Selection pressures also operate within behaviour space to maintain and promote the special differences that separate any competitively successful species from all others. Coleoids as a group appear to have retained adaptations associated with such molluscan features as high growth rate and rapid turnover of the population. They are still characteristically crepuscular in habits and have extensive vertical mobility.     

Evolution of the Cleidoic Egg Among Reptilian Antecedents of Birds

Evolution of the avian egg from the naked amniotic egg of ancestralreptiles probably was the outcome of intense predation by soilinvertebrates and microbes on a highly integrated and coadaptedcomplex of characters. The calcareous shell which from its inceptionafforded a measure of protection to eggs against attacks bysoil organisms became progressively thicker and more complexin the face of continuing selection for antipredator devices.However, increases in thickness and complexity of eggshellsled to simultaneous reductions in the amount of liquid waterthat could be absorbed by incubating eggs from the substrate.Because embryos initially were dependent upon uptake of substantialquantities of water from the environment to satisfy their needsfor this solvent, adaptive increases in thickness of the eggshellrequired coupled increases in the amount of water containedby eggs at oviposition, thereby reducing the degree of dependenceof embryos upon external sources of water for successful completionof development. The rigid-shelled eggs resulting from this evolutionarysequence absorbed little (if any) liquid water during incubation,and the eggs contained sufficient water at oviposition to sustainembryos to hatching. Such eggs were functionally cleidoic andhad attained an avian level of organization.     

Structure of shells of eggs of Callisaurus draconoides (Reptilia, Squamata, Iguanidae)

Female zebra-tailed lizards (Iguanidae: Callisaurus draconoides ) lay roughly ovoid eggs with thin, highly extensible shells. The outer surface of the eggshell is a thin, calcareous crust of calcium carbonate in the calcite morph. Immediately beneath the crystalline matrix is a shell membrane composed of multiple layers of fibres organized into an undulating series of troughs and crests, apparent in both cross-section and surface view. The outer surface of the shell membrane is differentiated into a tightly woven fibrous mat that may serve to anchor the calcareous layer to the membrane. Organization of the eggshell into a series of troughs and crests serves to increase the surface area available for contact with the substrate and, presumably, to increase the capacity of the eggshell to stretch as the egg absorbs water.     

Bias in interspecific allometry: examples from morphological scaling in varanid lizards

The traditional approach to allometric analysis entails the fitting of a straight line to logarithmic transformations of the data, after which parameters in a two-parameter allometric equation are estimated by back-transformation to the original scale. We re-examined published data for dimensions of the limbs in 22 species of varanid lizards to illustrate the biases that can be introduced into allometric analyses by applying the aforementioned protocol. Statistical models fit to the original data by linear and nonlinear regression conformed better with underlying assumptions than did models obtained by back-transformation from logarithms, and the former generally were better than the latter for describing limb dimensions over the full range in body size. Allometric exponents estimated by the traditional method therefore were based on inappropriate and inaccurate statistical models and, consequently, were biased and misleading. Investigators can avoid problems such as these by performing preliminary graphical and statistical analyses on data in their original scale and by validating the fitted model. Logarithmic transformations should be used sparingly and only for cause.  © 2009 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2009, 96 , 296–305.     

THE PHYSIOLOGICAL ECOLOGY OF REPTILIAN EGGS AND EMBRYOS. AND THE EVOLUTION OF VIVIPARITY WITHIN THE CLASS REPTILIA

1. Eggs of Crocodilia and Chelonia, like those of birds, have a pair of egg membranes separating a thick layer of albumen from the calcareous shell. In contrast, eggs of oviparous Lepidosauria have only a single shell membrane, upon which relatively small amounts of calcium carbonate are deposited; and the volume of albumen in eggs is extraordinarily small at the time of oviposition. 2. With the possible exception of certain geckos and some chelonians, eggs of oviparous reptiles seem always to absorb water from the substrate during the course of normal incubation. In so far as the rate of water absorption exceeds the rate of water loss by transpiration from exposed surfaces, the eggs swell during incubation. The term ‘cleidoic’ cannot be used to describe eggs of this type. 3. Embryos of lizards and snakes influence the water potential of extra-embryonic fluids contained within their eggs, thereby maintaining or increasing the gradient in water potential that drives water absorption. 4. Embryos of Crocodilia and Chelonia obtain a substantial portion of the calcium used in ossification of skeletal elements from the inner surfaces of the eggshell. In contrast, embryonic lizards and snakes draw upon extensive reserves of calcium present in the yolk, and obtain little (if any) calcium from the eggshell. 5. All reptilian embryos seem to produce substantial quantities of urea as a detoxification product of protein catabolism. Contrary to expectation, uricotelism may not be common among reptilian embryos, even in those few instances where development takes place within a hard, calcareous egg. 6. In eggs of Crocodilia and Chelonia, respiratory gases seem to pass by diffusion through pores in the calcareous eggshell and through spaces between the fibres of the pair of egg membranes. No pores have been observed in the shell of lepidosaurian eggs, and so gases presumably diffuse between the fibres of the single (multilayered) shell membrane. 7. Metabolism of reptilian embryos is temperature-dependent, as is true for most ectothermic organisms. For each species, there appears to be a particular temperature at which embryonic development proceeds optimally, and departures from this optimum elicit increases in developmental anomalies and/or embryonic mortality. 8. Viviparity has evolved on numerous occasions among species of the Squamata, but seemingly never among Crocodilia or Chelonia. Since the evolution of viviparity entails a progressive reduction in the eggshell, only those organisms whose embryos do not depend upon the eggshell as a source of calcium may have the evolutionary potential to become viviparous. 9. Evolutionary transitions from oviparity to viviparity could have been driven by selection related to (i) thermal benefits to embryos consequent upon retention of eggs within the body of a parent capable of behavioural thermoregulation; (ii) protection of the eggs from nest predators and/or soil microbes; and (iii) more effective exploitation of a seasonal food resource by early emerging young.