Cation amelioration of aluminum toxicity in wheat

Aluminum is a major constituent of most soils and limits crop productivity in many regions. Amelioration is of theoretical as well as practical interest because understanding amelioration may contribute to an understanding of the mechanisms of toxicity. In the experiments reported here 2-day-old wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Tyler) seedlings with 15-millimeter roots were transferred to solutions containing 0.4 millimolar CaCl₂ at pH 4.3 variously supplemented with AlCl₃ and additional amounts of a chloride salt. Root lengths, measured after 2 days in the test solutions, were a function of both Al activity and the cation activity of the added salt. Percent inhibition = 100 {Al³⁺}/({Al³⁺} + K_m + α{C}^β) where {Al³⁺} is the activity of Al³⁺ expressed in micromolar, {C} is the activity of the added cation expressed in millimolar, and K_m (= 1.2 micromolar) is the {Al³⁺} required for 50% inhibition in the absence of added salt. For Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, and Na⁺ the values of α were 2.4, 1.6, and 0.011, respectively, and the values for β were 1.5, 1.5, and 1.8, respectively. With regard to relative ameliorative effectiveness, Ca²⁺ > Mg²⁺ ≈ Sr²⁺ K⁺ ≈ Na⁺. Other cations were tested, but La³⁺, Sc³⁺, Li⁺, Rb⁺, and Cs⁺ were toxic at potentially ameliorative levels. The salt amelioration is not solely attributable to reductions in {Al³⁺} caused by increases in ionic strength. Competition between the cation and Al for external binding sites may account for most of the amelioration.     

Apparent phytotoxicity of mononuclear hydroxy-aluminum to four dicotyledonous species

It has long been assumed that Al³⁺ is an important rhizotoxic ion in acid soils around the world, but the toxicity of Al³⁺ relative to mononuclear hydroxy-Al [AlOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂] has been examined in detail only for an Al-sensitive wheat variety ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Tyler). That plant appears to be sensitive to Al³⁺ but not to AlOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂. New experiments, and reanalyses of previously published experiments, provide evidence that dicotyledonous species may be sensitive to mononuclear hydroxy-Al and that Al³⁺ may be nontoxic, or less toxic, to those plants. Despite these consistently measured differences between wheat and the dicotyledons, the determination of relative toxicities (Al³⁺ vs mononuclear hydroxy-Al) may be an intractable problem. Because of hydrolysis equilibria, (AlOH²⁺) and (Al(OH)⁺₂) are equivalent to (Al³⁺)k₁(H⁺)⁻¹ and (l³⁺)k₂(H⁺)⁻², respectively, in which k₁ and k₂ are the first and second hydrolysis constants (braces denote activities). Thus, any expression of root elongation as a function of mononuclear hydroxy-Al can be alternatively expressed as a function of (Al³⁺) and (H⁺). Toxicity attributed to mononuclear hydroxy-Al may actually be Al³⁺ toxicity that increases as pH rises (i.e. Al³⁺ toxicity ameliorated by H⁺).     

Use of a Gouy-Chapman-Stern Model for Membrane-Surface Electrical Potential to Interpret Some Features of Mineral Rhizotoxicity

A consideration of mineral toxicity to roots only in terms of ion activities in the rooting medium can be misleading. A Gouy-Chapman-Stern model, by which relative ion activities at cell-membrane surfaces may be estimated, has been applied to problems of mineral rhizotoxicity, including the toxicity of Al3+, La3+, H+, Na+, and SeO42-, to wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) roots. The Gouy-Chapman portion of the model is expressed in the Grahame equation, which relates the charge density ([sigma]) and electrical potential (E0) at the surface of a membrane to the concentrations of ions in a contracting bulk solution. The Stern modification of the theory takes into account changes in [sigma] caused by ion binding at the membrane surface. Several theoretical problems with the model and its use are considered, including the fact that previous authors have usually related the physiological effects of an ion at a membrane surface to the computed concentration (Ci0) of the unbound ion rather than its computed activity (ai0). This practice implies the false assumption that Ci0 is proportional to ai0. It is demonstrated here that ai0, computed from external activities (ai[infinity symbol]) by a Nernst equation [ai0 = ai[infinity symbol]exp([mdash]ZiFE0/RT), where Zi is the charge on the ion, F is the Faraday constant, R is the gas constant, and T is the temperature], correlates well with ion toxicity and that Ci0 sometimes correlates poorly. These conclusions also apply to issues of mineral nutrition.     

Aluminum enhancement of plant growth in acid rooting media. A case of reciprocal alleviation of toxicity by two toxic cations

The generally rhizotoxic ion Al³⁺ often enhances root growth at low concentrations. The hypothesis that Al³⁺ enhances growth by relieving H⁺ toxicity was tested with wheat seedlings ( Triticum aestivum L.). Growth enhancement by Al³⁺ only occurred under acidic conditions that reduced root elongation. Al³⁺ increased cell membrane electrical polarity and stimulated H⁺ extrusion. Previous investigations have shown that Al³⁺ decreases solute leakage at low _pH and that the alleviation of H⁺ toxicity by cations appears to be a general phenomenon with effectiveness dependent upon charge (C³⁺>C²⁺>C^l+). Alleviation of one cation toxicity by another toxic cation appears to be reciprocal so that Al³⁺ toxicity is relieved by H⁺. It has been argued previously that this latter phenomenon accounts for the apparent toxicity of ALOH²⁺ and Al(OH)⁺₂. Reduction of cell-surface electrical potential by the ameliorative cation may reduce the cell-surface activity of the toxic cation.     

Al3+-Ca2+ interactions in aluminum rhizotoxicity

Several mineral rhizotoxicities, including those induced by Al³⁺, H⁺, and Na⁺, can be relieved by elevated Ca²⁺ in the rooting medium. This leads to the hypothesis that the toxic cations displace Ca²⁺ from transport channels or surface ligands that must be occupied by Ca²⁺ in order for root elongation to occur. In this study with wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) seedlings, we have determined, in the case of Al³⁺, that (i) Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, and Sr²⁺ are equally ameliorative, (ii) that root elongation does not increase as Ca²⁺ replaces Mg²⁺ or Sr²⁺ in the rooting media, and (iii) that rhizotoxicity is a function solely of Al³⁺ activity at the root-cell membrane surface as computed by a Gouy-Chapman-Stern model. The rhizotoxicity was indifferent to the computed membrane-surface Ca²⁺ activity. The rhizotoxicity induced by high levels of tris(ethylenediamine)cobaltic ion (TEC³⁺), in contrast to Al³⁺, was specifically relieved by Ca²⁺ at the membrane surface. The rhizotoxicity induced by H⁺ exhibited a weak specific response to Ca²⁺ at the membrane surface. We conclude that the Ca²⁺-displacement hypothesis fails in the case of Al³⁺ rhizotoxicity and that amelioration by cations (including monovalent cations) occurs because of decreased membrane-surface negativity and the consequent decrease in the membrane-surface activity of Al³⁺. However, TEC³⁺, but not Al³⁺, may be toxic because it inhibits Ca²⁺ uptake. The nature of the specific H⁺-Ca²⁺ interaction is uncertain.Abbreviations {Al³⁺ }₀ chemical activity of Al³⁺ at the root-cell membrane surface - {Al³⁺ }_E chemical activity of Al³⁺ in the external rooting medium - E₀ electrical potential at the root-cell membrane surface - HXM²⁺ hexamethonium ion - TEC³⁺ tris(ethylenediamine)cobaltic ion     

A scale of metal ion binding strengths correlating with ionic charge, Pauling electronegativity, toxicity, and other physiological effects

Equilibrium constants for binding to plant plasma membranes have been reported for several metal ions, based upon adsorption studies and zeta-potential measurements. LogK values for the ions are these: Al(3+), 4.30; La(3+), 3.34; Cu(2+), 2.60; Ca(2+) and Mg(2+), 1.48; Na(+) and K(+), 0 M(-1). These values correlate well with logK values for ion binding to many organic and inorganic ligands. LogK values for metal ion binding to 12 ligands were normalized and averaged to produce a scale for the binding of 49 ions. The scale correlates well with the values presented above (R(2)=0.998) and with ion binding to cell walls and other biomass. The scale is closely related to the charge (Z) and Pauling electronegativity (PE) of 48 ions (all but Hg(2+)); R(2)=0.969 for the equation (Scale values)=-1.68+Z(1.22+0.444PE). Minimum rhizotoxicity of metal ions appears to be determined by binding strengths: log a(PM,M)=1.60-2.41exp[0.238(Scale values)] determines the value of ion activities at the plasma membrane surface (a(PM,M)) that will ensure inhibition of root elongation. Additional toxicity appears to be related to softness, accounting for the great toxicity of Ag(+), for example. These binding-strength values correlate with additional physiological effects and are suitable for the computation of cell-surface electrical potentials.     

Relative effectiveness of calcium and magnesium in the alleviation of rhizotoxicity in wheat induced by copper,zinc, aluminum,sodium, and low pH

Plant and Soil - Root elongation in short-term experiments with wheat (Triticum aestivum&;nbsp;L.) seedlings demonstrated that the following ions were rhizotoxic in the order Cu2+&;gt;Al...     

Interactions among Ca2+, Na+ and K+ in salinity toxicity: quantitative resolution of multiple toxic and ameliorative effects

Root elongation by wheat seedlings (Triticum aestivum L. cv. Scout 66) was not inhibited by NaCl or KCl up to 130 mM in culture solutions or by high Na⁺ (2 mg g^-1 FW) or K⁺ (4 mg g^-1 FW) in the root tissue, provided that [Ca²⁺]>2 mM in the rooting medium. At [NaCl], [KCl], or [mannitol] >250 mOs, root elongation was progressively inhibited, irrespective of high [Ca²⁺]. In contrast, shoot elongation was sensitive to any diminution of water potential, and Ca²⁺ alleviated the toxicity only weakly. At solute concentrations <250 mOs, the following interactions were observed. Ca²⁺ alleviated Na⁺ and K⁺ toxicity to roots by at least three separate mechanisms. K⁺ was more toxic to roots than Na⁺, but Na⁺ was more toxic to shoots. Low levels of K⁺ relieved Na⁺ toxicity, but low levels of Na⁺ enhanced K⁺ toxicity. Tissue concentrations of Na⁺ were reduced by Ca²⁺ and K⁺ in the rooting medium, and tissue concentrations of K⁺ were enhanced by Ca²⁺ and Na⁺. Several hypotheses relating to salinity toxicity can be evaluated, at least for wheat seedlings. The osmoticant hypotheses (salinity intoxication occurs because of diminished water potential) is true for shoots at all salinity levels, but is true for roots only at high salinity. The Ca²⁺-displacement hypothesis (Na⁺ is toxic because it displaced Ca²⁺ from the cell surface) is correct, but often of minor importance. The K⁺-depletion hypothesis (Na⁺ is toxic because it causes a loss of K⁺ from plant tissues) is false. The Cl^--toxicity hypothesis (the apparent toxicity of Na⁺ is induced by associated Cl^-) is false. The results indicate that, apart from osmotic effects, high levels of Na⁺ in the rooting medium and in the tissues are not toxic unless Ca²⁺ is also deficient, a condition probably leading to inadequate compartmentation and excessive cytoplasmic accumulation. This study related growth to ion activities at plasma-membrane surfaces. These activities were computed by a Gouy-Chapman-Stern model then incorporated into non-linear growth models for growth versus toxicants and ameliorants.Key words: Calcium, potassium, salinity, sodium, toxicity      

Cell membrane surface potential (psi0) plays a dominant role in the phytotoxicity of copper and arsenate

Negative charges at cell membrane surfaces (CMS) create a surface electrical potential (psi(0)) that affects ion concentrations at the CMS and consequently affects the phytotoxicity of metallic cations and metalloid anions in different ways. The zeta potentials of root protoplasts of wheat (Triticum aestivum), as affected by the ionic environment of the solution, were measured and compared with the values of psi(0) calculated with a Gouy-Chapman-Stern model. The mechanisms for the effects of cations (H(+), Ca(2+), Mg(2+), Na(+), and K(+)) on the acute toxicity of Cu(2+) and As(V) to wheat were studied in terms of psi(0). The order of effectiveness of the ions in reducing the negativity of psi(0) was H(+) > Ca(2+) approximately Mg(2+) > Na(+) approximately K(+). The calculated values of psi(0) were proportional to the measured zeta potentials (r(2) = 0.93). Increasing Ca(2+) or Mg(2+) activities in bulk-phase media resulted in decreased CMS activities of Cu(2+) ({Cu(2+)}(0)) and increased CMS activities of As(V) ({As(V)}(0)). The 48-h EA50{Cu(2+)}(b) ({Cu(2+)} in bulk-phase media accounting for 50% inhibition of root elongation over 48 h) increased initially and then declined, whereas the 48-h EA50{As(V)}(b) decreased linearly. However, the intrinsic toxicity of Cu(2+) (toxicity expressed in terms of {Cu(2+)}(0)) appeared to be enhanced as psi(0) became less negative and the intrinsic toxicity of As(V) appeared to be reduced. The psi(0) effects, rather than site-specific competitions among ions at the CMS (invoked by the biotic ligand model), may play the dominant role in the phytotoxicities of Cu(2+) and As(V) to wheat.     

Assessing the Rhizotoxicity of the Aluminate Ion, Al(OH)(4)

Dissolved aluminum (III) in acidic soils or culture media is often rhizotoxic (inhibitory to root elongation). Alkaline solutions of Al are also sometimes rhizotoxic, and for that reason toxicity has been attributed to the aluminate ion, Al(OH)₄⁻. In the present study, seedlings of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv Tyler) and red clover (Trifolium pratense L. cv Kenland) were cultured in aerated aluminate solutions at pH 8.0 to 8.9. The bulk phases of these solutions were free of reactive polynuclear hydroxy-Al (including the extremely toxic species AlO₄Al₁₂[OH]₂₄[H₂O]⁷⁺₁₂ [Al₁₃]) according to the ferron (8-hydroxy-7-iodo-5-quinolinesulfonic acid) assay. At an aluminate concentration of 25 micromolar (23 micromolar activity) and a pH of 8, root elongation was less than 40% of Al-free controls, but at pH 8.9 elongation was 100% of controls. The hypothesis is offered that aluminate is nontoxic and that the inhibition at lower pH values is attributable to Al₁₃ postulated to have formed in the acidic free space of the roots where the ratio /{Al³⁺/}//{H⁺/}³ may rise above 10¹⁰. At this value hydroxy-Al in over-saturated, alkaline solutions begins to undergo rapid conversion to polynuclear species.