Effects of cytokines on in vitro growth of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes obtained from human primary and metastatic liver tumors

Summary Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) were isolated from 22 human primary and metastatic liver tumors, and expanded in vitro in the presence of either interleukin-2 (IL-2, 100 U/ml) plus tumor necrosis factor (TNF, 1000 U/ml), IL-2 (1000 U/ml) plus IL-4 (1000 U/ml) or IL-2 (1000 U/ml) alone. TIL proliferated in culture in 20/22 cases. Among different cytokine combinations, TNF and IL-2 were most effective in promoting the outgrowth of CD3⁺ CD8⁺ T lymphocytes (mean ± SEM: 90%±5) in the cultures of TIL from primary liver tumors. Cytotoxicity against autologous tumor cells was demonstrated in all early cultures of TIL from primary liver cancers in the presence of IL-2 plus TNF. In contrast, cultures of TIL derived from colon cancer metastatic to liver had significantly lower levels of autotumor cytotoxicity and proportions of CD3⁺ CD8⁺ cells (40%±13) than those of TIL from primary liver tumors. The addition on day 0 of interferons ( or ) to TIL cultured in the presence of TNF and IL-2, significantly augmented cytotoxicity against autologous tumor. In contrast, incubation of TIL in the presence of IL-4 and IL-2 did not result in increased autotumor responses in the cultures of TIL from primary liver tumors. The expansion (-fold) of TIL (day 30) cultured in the presence of IL-2 alone compared to that in the presence of TNF and IL-2 was significantly greater for hepatocellular carcinoma (median, 280 vs 260) than for autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes (36 vs 27), cholangiocarcinoma (42 vs 51) or TIL from metastatic colon cancer (39 vs 30). Outgrowth of TIL in IL-2 plus TNF offers an opportunity for in vitro enrichment in cells with autotumor cytotoxicity in primary liver tumors. However, this cytokine combination was unable to promote and sustain growth of autotumor effectors from TIL in metastatic liver cancer.Supported by ACS grants IM27 077 and IM588 A (TLW) and Organ Transplant Program Project 1P01-CA-4744501 AZ     

Assessment of in vivo natural antitumor resistance and lymphocyte

Clearance of IV-injected tumor cells has been correlated with levels of natural killer (NK) cell activity in recipient animals. Studies of in vivo tumor cell clearance strongly suggest a relationship between levels of NK cell activity and antitumor or antimetastatic effector function. This study outlines the applicability of three radiolabels, [125I]iododeoxyuridine, ( [125I]dUrd), indium-111-oxine chelate ( [111In]Ox), and chromium-51 (51Cr), to studies of tumor cell clearance in vivo. The suitability of these labels for analysis of the in vivo migration patterns of normal lymphocytes or thymus-derived T cells cultivated in vitro (CTC) is also discussed. The results indicate that [111In]Ox and 51Cr compare favorably with the more widely used [125]dUrd as radiolabels for the assessment of IV-injected tumor cell clearance from the lungs of mice. The rates of clearance of both [111In]Ox and 51Cr, like that for [125I]dUrd, correlate closely with levels of NK-cell activity of the host. Further studies with [111In]Ox reveal that treatment of recipients with anti-asialo GM1 serum, a regimen known to suppress NK-cell activity, demonstrates the appropriate reduction in isotope clearance from the lungs after NK suppression. However, clearance data obtained by monitoring levels of radioactivity in the liver after IV injection must be viewed cautiously, since the same cells labeled with [111In]Ox and [125I]dUrd had a different pattern of clearance from the liver. The same inconsistencies in clearance were observed when [111In]Ox and [125I]dUrd were injected intrafootpad (i.f.p.). Similar effects were observed when [111In]Ox or 51Cr was applied to studies of CTC migration. Levels of [111In]Ox and 51Cr remained high in the liver after IV injection, while [125I]dUrd was rapidly cleared. Normal spleen or thymic lymphocytes exhibited the expected homing to the spleen after labeling with [111In]Ox, indicating a suitability of this label for migration studies, except possibly in the liver. These results with CTC and normal lymphocytes should be considered during the formulation of immunotherapy protocols based on cell migration data, since the choice of radiolabel can result in widely divergent levels of radioactivity accumulated in some organs, and may not provide an accurate representation of the presence of viable, intact, or functional cells.     

Unimpaired ability to generate adherent lymphokine-activated killer (A-LAK) cells in patients with primary or metastatic liver tumors

Summary Adherent lymphokine-activated killer cells (A-LAK cells) obtained from human peripheral blood mononuclear cells represent a population of potent antitumor effectors enriched in interleukin-2(IL-2)-activated natural killer cells. This study shows that A-LAK cells can be successfully generated from the blood of patients with liver cancer not treated with adjuvant chemotherapy or irradiation. Mononuclear cells were isolated from the blood of 33 patients with liver tumors (6 benign, 10 primary malignant, 17 metastatic) at the time of liver resection. A-LAK cells were separated by adherence to plastic following activation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells in 1000 U/ml recombinant IL-2. A-LAK cells (enriched up to 92% in CD3^–CD56⁺ cells) showed better subsequent expansion and two to six times higher antitumor cytotoxicity per cell than unseparated LAK cells cultured under the same conditions. The ability to generate A-LAK cells with superior in vitro cytotoxicity from the blood of most patients with liver cancer indicates that adoptive cellular immunotherapy may be a feasible and new way of treatment for primary and secondary hepatic neoplasms in man.     

Alterations in cell-surface carbohydrates of rat large granular lymphocytes associated with interleukin-2 activation

The activation of large granular lymphocytes (LGLs)/natural killer (NK) cells with interleukin-2 (IL-2) has been shown to increase the ability of these cells to lyse NK-resistant tumor target cells. Activated LGLs, termed LAK (lymphokine-activated killer) cells, have been demonstrated to be of therapeutic value in vivo against metastatic tumors. The mechanism by which IL-2 induces broadened cytolytic capability, as well as the molecular basis of target recognition and killing by the activated cells has not yet been elucidated. Since carbohydrate moieties have been demonstrated to be of possible significance in the cytolytic cascade of a variety of effector cells, the current study was undertaken to determine if the activation of LGLs with IL-2 is accompanied by an alteration of cell-surface carbohydrates. Two-color flow cytometry was performed to identify LGL/NK cells in populations of nylon wool-nonadherent splenic mononuclear cells and to assess the binding of various lectins to activated as well as nonactivated LGLs. Increases were observed in the binding of four lectins to LGLs after IL-2 activation; Triticum vulgaris (wheat germ agglutinin), Phytolacca americana (pokeweed mitogen), Lycopersicon esculentum (tomato lectin), and Griffonia simplicifolia I-B4 (GSI-B4). The wheat germ, pokeweed, and tomato lectins recognize complex carbohydrates structure consisting of GlcNAc(Bl,4GlcNAc)n while GSI-B4 recognizes alpha-D-galactose terminal end groups. Lectin binding to the activated LGLs was homogenous (i.e., flow cytometry revealed only a single population of fluorescent cells). Lectin binding to LGLs prior to activation was more heterogeneous, however, the tomato lectin uniquely revealed a bimodal distribution of receptors. These data indicate that LGL/NK cells from the rat are heterogeneous in their ability to bind specific lectins, and that IL-2 activation of these cells results in altered expression of specific cell-surface carbohydrates.     

Functional heterogeneity between NKR-P1bright/Lycopersicon esculentum lectin (L.E.)bright and NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim subpopulations of rat natural killer cells.

In this report, we present data on heterogeneity of rat NK cells utilizing a combination of antibody and lectin-binding characteristics. Among NKR-P1bright NK cells, two discrete populations characterized as Lycopersicon esculentum lectin (L.E.)bright (60 to 80%) and L.E.dim (20 to 40%) were identified by flow cytometry. Comparison of the morphology of sorted NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright and NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim cells indicated that both were greater than 90% LGL. An analysis of the functional capabilities of the sub-populations indicated that NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright NK cells were more efficient in lysis of YAC-1 target cells (1743 LU20/10(7) cells) than were NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim cells (504 LU20/10(7) cells). Conversely, NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim NK cells were much more efficient at lysis of antibody-sensitized erythrocytes (antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC)) (1412 LU20/10(7) cells) than were NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright cells (165 LU20/10(7) cells). Lysis of antibody sensitized P815 target cells yielded similar results as NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim cells and NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright cells had 905 LU20/10(7) and 189 LU20/10(7), respectively. Additional experiments indicated that NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright NK cells had the capacity to trigger lytic activity via NKR-P1 whereas NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim NK cells did not. NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright sorted cells had a greater capacity to form conjugates with YAC-1 target cells than did NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim sorted cells. Conversely, NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim NK cells were demonstrated to form E-A rosettes whereas the NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright NK cells were not. Additional experiments indicated that tomato lectin itself was not responsible for the differences in reverse ADCC activity or ADCC activity among the subsets. However, lysis of YAC-1 target cells was modulated to some degree by the lectin. These data indicate that NKR-P1bright/L.E.bright and NKR-P1bright/L.E.dim subpopulations of rat NK cells have different capacities for: 1) triggering through NKR-P1; and 2) E-A rosette formation and lysis of antibody-sensitized target cells by ADCC.     

Non-secretory solitary plasmacytoma of the spleen

A case of primary nonsecretory plasmacytoma of the spleen is reported. On laparotomy and splenectomy a 920 g spleen was removed, measuring 16×14×6 cm. The cut surface of the entire spleen showed that the tumour occupied most of the splenic tissue. A bone marrow aspirate and trephine, skeletal survey showed no signs of myeloma. Biopsy of the liver and regional lymph nodes was normal. Immunocytochemistry of the splenic tumour showed positivity for pan-B and plasma cell markers. After splenectomy the patient was treated with chemotherapy according to protocol VBCMP (M2).     

Fc receptors on mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells.

Mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells have been previously thought to be lymphocytes that lack any detectable cell surface markers. The present study presents evidence for receptors for the Fc portion of IgG on these cells. By adsorption of cytotoxic spleen cells on monolayers of sheep erythrocytes (E) plus IgG antibodies to sheep erythrocytes (EA), 50 to 96% of the total cytotoxic reactivity could be removed. Parallel adsorption of cells on E monolayers or on EA monolayers coated with protein A, to block the Fc portion of IgG, resulted in little or no depletion of cytotoxic activity. The presence of Fc receptors on the NK cells was confirmed by combining EA rosette formation with velocity sedimentation at unit gravity. Peak cytotoxicity occurred at the same sedimentation velocity as the peak of Fc-positive cells. After EA rosette formation, there was a shift to a higher sedimentation velocity in the Fc-positive cells and in the natural cytotoxic activity. The increase in sedimentation velocity of NK activity that was observed in these experiments indicated that most of the cells had only bound a small number (three or four) of antibody-coated erythrocytes. Together, these data indicate that cells with Fc receptors account for most of the total lytic activity of normal mouse spleen cells.     

Lymphokine-activated killer cells in rats. IV. Developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes, large granular lymphocytes, and lymphokine-activated killer cells

The developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes (LAL) large granular lymphocytes (LGL) and the activation of these cells into lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells by rIL-2 was investigated. Highly enriched populations of LAL were isolated from Fischer 344 spleen cells by a combination of nylon-wool filtration (to remove B cells and macrophages), treatment with a pan T cell antibody plus complement (to remove T cells) and incubation in L-leucine methyl ester (to remove LGL). The resultant cells were highly enriched in morphologically identifiable LAL which expressed asialo GM1 and partially expressed the OX8 surface marker. The enriched LAL did not contain detectable NK cytotoxic activity, did not express pan T cell (OX19), Ia, Ig, or laminin surface markers and contained less than 0.2% LGL. Incubation of LAL in a low dose of rIL-2 (100 U/ml) induced the generation of LGL having NK activity within 24 h of culture. Longer culture periods (48 h) resulted in a continued increase in the percentage of LGL and higher levels of NK activity. However, with this low dose of rIL-2, little or no LAK activity (i.e., reactivity against NK-resistant target cells) was generated. With a high dose of rIL-2 (500 U/ml), LAL responded by first generating LGL with NK activity (within 24 h), with subsequent generation of LAK activity by 48 h. Evidence that the development of granular lymphocytes from LAL was responsible first for NK activity and then LAK activity was demonstrated by depletion of the generated granular NK or LAK effector cells by second treatments with L-leucine methyl ester. Concomitant with the induction of LGL with NK or LAK activity, rIL-2 also caused LGL to proliferate and expand four- to five-fold in 48 h. This occurred in the presence of high or low dose rIL-2. These results indicate that LAL are the precursors of LGL/NK cells, that LAL, LGL/NK cells and LAK cells appear to represent sequential developmental or activation stages and that LAL may comprise major source of LAK progenitors in lymphoid populations having few LGL or mature active NK cells.     

Natural killer-sensitive targets stimulate production of TNF-alpha but not TNF-beta (lymphotoxin) by highly purified human peripheral blood large granular lymphocytes

Highly purified populations of large granular lymphocytes (LGL) have been shown to mediate natural killer (NK) cell activity. The mechanism of target cell killing by NK cells is as yet undefined; however, it has been postulated that such killing may involve soluble cytotoxic factors produced and secreted by NK cells. The data presented show that NK-sensitive, but not NK-resistant, tumor cell lines induce highly purified populations of human LGL to produce factors with cytotoxic and/or cytostatic activities. We have identified one of these factors as tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), and have shown that production of this factor is enhanced by recombinant human interferon-gamma (rHuIFN-gamma). We have also examined the role of TNF-alpha in the cytotoxic function of NK cells. The data show that although highly purified LGL populations produce low levels of TNF-alpha, the cytotoxic/cytostatic activity of this lymphokine on tumor target cells does not correlate with the cytotoxic activity of highly purified populations of LGL on tumor target cells. Furthermore, NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity is not reliably inhibited by antibodies directed against various epitopes of recombinant human TNF-alpha and/or recombinant TNF-beta (lymphotoxin) or rHuIFN-gamma. These data show that although TNF-alpha is produced by highly purified NK-containing LGL cell populations, this factor does not appear to be responsible for NK cell cytotoxicity against classical NK target cells such as Molt-4 or K562. We suggest that NK function can be attributed to a combination of factors rather than to a single factor alone, and that at least two major phenomena are involved in LGL function: the rapid cytotoxic events which lead to the cell lysis measured in classical in vitro NK assays such as against K562; and the release of factors such as TNF-alpha with cytotoxic/cytostatic activities which would inhibit the growth of invading tumor cells in vivo.     

Cultures of purified human natural killer cells: Growth in the presence of interleukin 2

We have isolated highly enriched populations of LGL, which are virtually devoid of mature typical lymphocytes (as enumerated by morphological and surface antigen analysis using monoclonal antibodies e.g., OKT3) in comparison to T cells which contain greater than 95% sheep erythrocyte-forming cells and are devoid of LGL and $\text{NK}\text{K}$ activities. Both types of cells grew in the presence of crude or partially purified IL-2. Cultures of LGL could be initiated consistently even in the absence of lectins and the cultured LGL retained their characteristic morphology and cytotoxic activity. However, within 7–10 days after initiation, the cultured LGL changed in surface phenotype to become antigenically indistinguishable from cultured T cells.