Specific-locus mutations induced in eukaryotes (especially mammalian cells) by radiation and chemicals: a perspective

In the course of discovering the first mutagen (X-rays) just over 60 years ago, Herman J. Muller asked whether X-rays induced single-gene mutations and/or chromosomal (multiple-gene) mutations. To a large extent, his question has set the agenda for mutagenesis research ever since. We explore historically the answers to this question, with special emphasis on recent developments in the field of mammalian cell mutagenesis. Studies indicate that ionizing radiation and many chemical mutagens/carcinogens induce both gene and chromosomal mutations; however, only certain genetic systems permit the recovery and analysis of both classes of mutations. Few chemical mutagens induce only gene mutations in mammalian cells; instead, most mutagens appear to induce both classes of mutations, with chromosomal mutations (especially multilocus deletions) predominating at high doses. These results have implications regarding the mechanisms of mutagenesis, the role of chromosomal mutations in carcinogenesis and hereditary disease, and the type of data required for risk assessment of physical and chemical mutagens/carcinogens.     

Effect of the uvs-2 allele of Neurospora crassa on the mutagenic potency of two N-hydroxylaminopurines and 2-aminopurine in the ad-3 forward-mutation test

The mutagenic potencies of 3 purine analogs were determined in the ad-3 forward-mutation test in growing cultures of heterokaryon 59 (H-59), a nucleotide excision repair-deficient (uvs-2/uvs-2) 2-component heterokaryon of Neurospora crassa. Two N-hydroxylaminopurines, 2-amino-6-N-hydroxylaminopurine (AHA) and 6-N-hydroxylaminopurine (HAP), were potent and strong mutagens, respectively, whereas 2-aminopurine (AP) was a moderate mutagen. Dose-response curves showed that AHA and HAP were about equally mutagenic at low doses but that AHA was more mutagenic than HAP at high doses. Comparison of these results in H-59 with our earlier results in heterokaryon 12 (H-12) of N. crassa, which is identical to H-59 except for being DNA-repair-proficient (uvs-2+/uvs-2+), shows that the defect in nucleotide excision repair due to uvs-2 has little or no effect on the mutagenic potencies of these 3 purine analogs. Therefore, the nucleotide excision-repair pathway in N. crassa that is deficient in H-59 does not appear to have a major role in the repair of pre-mutational lesions induced by these 3 purine analogs. On the other hand, based on the controls of these experiments, the frequency of spontaneous ad-3 mutants was 4 greater in H-59 than in H-12. This result suggests that the nucleotide excision-repair pathway in N. crassa that is inactivated by the uvs-2 mutation has a major role in the repair of lesions that would lead to spontaneous mutation at the ad-3+ region if they were not repaired.     

Molecular and classical genetic analyses of his-3 mutants of Neurospora crassa. I. Tests for allelic complementation and specific revertibility

A collection of 81 his-3 mutants of Neurospora crassa was analyzed in assays for allelic complementation and specific revertibility. In these studies, the linearity of the complementation map of the his-3 cistron (Webber, 1965) was confirmed and mutants were classified as complementing with non-polarized or polarized complementation patterns, or non-complementing. In the assays for spontaneous or induced revertibility, 89% (71/80) of the mutants reverted either spontaneously or after treatment with the chemical mutagens N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, ethyl methanesulfonate, 2-methoxy-6-chloro-9-(3-[ethyl-2-chloroethyl]aminopropylamino) acridine dihydrochloride, nitrous acid or hydroxylamine. The frequency of revertible mutants among the non-polarized complementing mutants was 96% (45/47), and 79% (15/19) for the polarized complementing and 79% (11/14) for the non-complementing mutants. The results of these classical genetic assays for allelic complementation and specific revertibility suggest a correlation between complementation pattern and presumptive genetic alterations at the molecular level among his-3 mutants similar to that found with ad-3B mutants induced by nitrous acid (Malling and de Serres, 1967), ethyl methanesulfonate (Malling and de Serres, 1968), or ultraviolet (Kilbey et al., 1971).     

Solution structures of alpha-conotoxin G1 determined by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy

Two-dimensional NMR data have been used to generate solution structures of alpha-conotoxin G1, a potent peptide antagonist of the acetylcholine receptor. Structural information was obtained in the form of proton-proton internuclear distance constraints, and initial structures were produced with a distance geometry algorithm. Energetically more favorable structures were generated by using the distance geometry structures as input for a constrained energy minimization program. The results of both of these calculations indicate that the overall backbone conformation of the molecule is well-defined by the NMR data whereas the side-chain conformations are generally less well-defined. The main structural features derived from the NMR data were the presence of tight turns centered on residues Pro5 and Arg9. The solution structures are compared with previous proposed models of conotoxin G1, and the NMR data are interpreted in conjunction with chemical modification studies and structural properties of other antagonists of the acetylcholine receptor to gain insight into structure-activity relationships in these peptide toxins.     

Effect of the homokaryotic state of the uvs-2 allele in Neurospora crassa on formaldehyde-induced killing and ad-3 mutation

Formaldehyde was tested for its killing and mutagenic activities in the ad-3 forward-mutation test in Neurospora crassa. The test was conducted in 3 two-component heterokaryons (dikaryons) of N. crassa in order to determine the effect of the uvs-2 allele, which causes a defect in nucleotide excision repair, on formaldehyde-induced killing and the induction of ad-3 mutants. These dikaryons were homokaryotic for uvs-2+ (H-12), homokaryotic for usv-2 (H-59), and heterokaryotic for uvs-2 (H-71). Formaldehyde induced killing and ad-3 mutants in H-12, but the presence of uvs-2 in the homokaryotic state (H-59) resulted in a 9-fold increase in killing and a 40-fold increase in the induction of ad-3 mutants. This increased sensitivity to formaldehyde-induced killing and mutation conferred by uvs-2 in the homokaryotic state (H-59 vs. H-12) is similar to that noted by others in Escherichia coli. Salmonella typhimurium and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The dikaryon heterokaryotic for uvs-2 (H-71) has the same sensitivity to formaldehyde-induced ad-3 mutation as H-12, indicating that uvs-2 is recessive to uvs-2+.     

2-Amino-N6-hydroxyadenine induces gene/point mutations and multiple-locus mutations, but not multilocus deletion mutations, in the ad-3 region of a two-component heterokaryon of Neurospora crassa.

The mutagenicity of 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine (AHA) has been studied in Neurospora crassa by treating a two-component heterokaryon (H-12) and recovering specific-locus mutations induced in the ad-3 region. This assay system permits the identification of ad-3A and/or ad-3B mutants resulting from gene/point mutations, multilocus deletion mutations, and multiple-locus mutations of various genotypes, involving one or both loci. Genetic characterization of the ad-3 mutants recovered from experiments with AHA in H-12 shows that 98.9% (270/273) of the ad-3 mutants are gene/point mutations (ad-3R), 1.1% (3/270) are unknowns, and none is a multilocus deletion mutation (ad-3IR). Among the gene/point mutations, 3.3% (9/273) are multiple-locus mutations (gene/point mutations with a closely-linked recessive lethal mutation [ad-3R + RLCL]). Another 25.3% (69/273) are multiple-locus mutations with a recessive lethal mutation located elsewhere in the genome [ad-3R + RL]. Heterokaryon tests for allelic complementation among the ad-3BR mutants showed that 90.8% (139/153) of the mutants were complementing, and 20.3% (31/153) were leaky. In addition, 32.5% (38/117) of the ad-3AR mutants were leaky. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that AHA produces specific-locus mutations in the ad-3 region of N. crassa by base-pair substitution. The data from the present experiments are compared with the data for 2-aminopurine (2AP)-induced ad-3 mutants in H-12 (de Serres and Brockman, 1991). Whereas, 2AP is a weak mutagen in H-12, AHA is extremely potent (Brockman et al., 1987). In contrast with 2AP, AHA induces ad-3 mutants exclusively by gene/point mutation in H-12. We conclude that whereas AHA induces ad-3 mutants predominantly by AT to GC base-pair transitions, 2AP induces ad-3 mutants by a wide variety of mechanisms including: (1) AT to GC and GC to AT base-pair transitions, (2) frameshift mutations, (3) other, as yet unidentified, intragenic alterations, (4) small multilocus deletion mutations, and (5) multiple-locus ad-3R mutations with closely linked recessive lethal mutations.     

Qualitative differences in the spectra of genetic damage in 2-aminopurine-induced ad-3 mutants between nucleotide excision-repair-proficient and -deficient strains of Neurospora crassa.

The mutagenic effects of 2-aminopurine (2AP) have been compared in the adenine-3 (ad-3) region of two-component heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa: nucleotide excision repair-proficient (uvs-2+/uvs-2+) heterokaryon 12 (H-12) and nucleotide excision repair-deficient (uvs-2/uvs-2) heterokaryon 59 (H-59). This forward-mutation, morphological and biochemical, specific-locus assay system permits the recovery of ad-3A and/or ad-3B mutants in 3 major classes: gene/point mutations, multilocus deletion mutations, and unknowns, and 3 different subclasses of multiple-locus mutations. Previous studies (Brockman et al., Mutation Res., 218 (1989) 1-11) showed that 2AP treatment of growing cultures of H-12 and H-59 gave no difference between ad-3 forward-mutation frequencies over a wide range of 2AP concentrations in each strain. In the present experiments, genetic analyses of ad-3 mutants recovered from these experiments has demonstrated qualitative differences between the spectra of the 3 main classes of ad-3 mutations. In H-12, 84.2% (203/241) resulted from gene/point mutation, 11.6% (28/241) from multilocus deletion mutation, and 4.1% (10/241) were unknowns. In contrast, in H-59, 43.0% (99/230) resulted from gene/point mutation, 55.7% (128/230) from multilocus deletion mutation, and 1.3% (3/230) were unknowns. In addition, quantitative differences were also found between the spectra of ad-3 mutations in 1 subclass of multiple-locus mutations, but not 2 additional subclasses. The first subclass consisted of 1.7% (4/241) and 9.6% (22/230) gene/point mutations with a closely linked recessive lethal mutation, in H-12 and H-59, respectively. The second two subclasses consisted of (a) 0.4% (1/241) and 0.4% (1/230) multilocus deletion mutations with a closely linked recessive lethal mutation, and (b) 13.3% (32/241) and 15.2% (35/230) gene/point mutations with a separate recessive lethal mutation elsewhere in the genome, in H-12 and H-59, respectively. Data from studies by others have shown that 2AP inhibits adenosine deaminase, resulting in nucleotide precursor pool inbalance, and that 2AP can saturate the mismatch repair system. As a consequence of either effect of 2AP, the spectrum of 2AP-induced mutation could include frameshift mutations and chromosome aberrations such as multilocus deletions in addition to base-pair substitutions. The defect in DNA repair due to the uvs-2 allele, which has been shown to be a deficiency in pyrimidine dimer excision (Worthy and Epler, 1974), most probably has some other excision-repair deficiency (Macleod and Stadler, 1986; Baker et al., 1991).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The genetic toxicology of 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine in eukaryotic organisms: significance for genetic risk assessment

A collaborative study was designed to assess the mutagenicity of 2-amino-N6-hydroxylaminopurine (AHA) in a wide variety of eukaryotic assays systems in terms of potency and specificity. Earlier studies in Salmonella and Neurospora had shown that AHA was an extremely potent mutagen which appeared to cause predominantly AT to GC base-pair transitions. This discovery was viewed as an unusual opportunity to explore the general utility of different eukaryotic assay systems for genetic risk assessment. The objective was to determine whether AHA would show comparable potency and specificity in those eukaryotic organisms used to evaluate mutagenic potential of environmental chemicals for the human population. The data presented in this report show that AHA was mutagenic in all the eukaryotic assays utilized; however, the level of effect was found to be assay system-dependent. In addition, in assays where other base analogs were used as positive controls, differences in relative potency were observed from those obtained in the earlier studies with Salmonella and Neurospora. When alkylating agents were used as positive controls in the higher eukaryotic assays, AHA was found to have a mutagenic potency comparable to ethylnitrosourea (ENU), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) or methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) for many of the assays. With regard to mutagenic specificity, AHA appears to induce gene/point mutations in eukaryotic organisms, resulting predominantly from base-pair substitutions, predominantly AT to GC base-pair transitions; however, there was some unexplained variation in the ratio of these base-pair transitions and other transitions and transversions as a function of assay system. In addition, studies on the induction of micronuclei have shown that AHA induces chromosomal damage at high concentrations and low levels of survival.