Physical factors driving intertidal macroalgae distribution: physiological stress of a dominant fucoid at its southern limit

Climate change is driving species range shifts worldwide. However, physiological responses related to distributional changes are not fully understood. Oceanographers have reported an increase in ocean temperature in the northwest Iberian Peninsula that is potentially related to the decline in some cold-temperate intertidal macroalgae in the Cantabrian Sea, namely Fucus serratus. Low tide stress could also play a role in this decline. We performed one mensurative (in situ) and two manipulative (in culture) experiments designed to evaluate the interactive effects of some physical factors. The first experiment analysed field response to low tide stress in marginal (mid-Cantabrian Sea and northern Portugal) versus central (Galicia) populations of F. serratus. Then a second experiment was performed that utilized either harsh or mild summer conditions of atmospheric temperature, irradiance, humidity, and wind velocity to compare the responses of individuals from one marginal and one central population to low tide stress. Finally, the combined effect of sea temperature and the other factors was evaluated to detect interactive effects. Changes in frond growth, maximal photosynthetic quantum yield (F (v)/F (m)), temperature, and desiccation were found. Three additive factors (solar irradiation, ocean and air temperatures) were found to drive F. serratus distribution, except under mildly humid conditions that ameliorated atmospheric thermal stress (two additive factors). Mid-Cantabrian Sea temperatures have recently increased, reaching the inhibitory levels suggested in this study of F. serratus. We also expect an additive secondary contribution of low tide stress to this species decline. On the northern Portugal coast, ocean warming plus low tide stress has not reached this species' inhibition threshold. No significant differential responses attributed to the population of origin were found. Mechanistic approaches that are designed to analyse the interactive effects of physical stressors may improve the levels of confidence in predicted range shifts of species.     

CHANGES IN NUTRIENT CONTENT OF PALMARIA PALMATA IN RESPONSE TO VARIABLE LIGHT AND UPWELLING IN NORTHERN SPAIN1

Light has been identified as one of the main factors affecting seaweed ecophysiology. We investigated the dependence of nutrient metabolism on sun and shade light conditions and whether episodes of upwelling of nutrient‐rich subsuperficial water could reduce the summer nutrient limitation driving physiological changes in Palmaria palmata (L.) Kuntze. We measured the major nutrient pools, photosynthetic pigments, and light curves, under sun and shade conditions during a summer period when one upwelling was recorded. The redundancy analysis (RDA) produced two clear groups: sun‐ and shade‐acclimated algae. Light was the major predictive factor. Sun‐acclimated algae exhibited higher carbon (C) and lower nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) content in association with the storage of floridoside (main C reserve) to benefit from higher irradiance (under nutrient limitation). Among N pools, N reserves (phycoerythrin, nitrate) were a lower proportion of the total N in sun‐acclimated algae, suggesting their degradation to fulfill the N demands of the cell. The orthophosphate content was also lower in sun‐acclimated algae, indicating its utilization as a nutrient reserve. In contrast, N within cell walls and membranes and chl a contributed to a similar proportion of the total N in sun‐ and shade‐acclimated algae, suggesting a response to sustain cell integrity. Transient high nutrient concentration due to the upwelling was unrelated to the nutrient content of the thallus. The storage of C as floridoside from high light exposure was shown to be the driving force for the metabolic adjustment of P. palmata at the end of summer before the onset of dormancy.     

Genetic relationships of the hydrocoral Millepora alcicornis and its symbionts within and between locations across the Atlantic

Although the hydrocoral Millepora alcicornis is a prominent and ecologically relevant amphi-Atlantic reef builder, little attention has been given to its endosymbionts which are also involved in the survival and adaptation success of the species in different environments. In this study, we resolve the genetic relationships between M. alcicornis and its symbionts (Symbiodiniaceae) within both sides and across the Atlantic. The COI and 16S-rDNA regions were selected for the host tissues, and the 23S-rDNA and ITS regions were chosen for the symbionts. Phylogenetic networks consistently showed that host populations from the eastern Atlantic archipelagos (Canary and Cape Verde Islands) were more related to western Atlantic populations than they were between them. However, results for Symbiodiniaceae species varied according to the molecular marker used. Samples from Mexico were grouped as Symbiodinium sp. (formerly Symbiodinium clade A) by both markers. Specimens from Puerto Rico were grouped as either Symbiodinium sp. or Breviolum sp. (formerly Symbiodinium clade B), according to the molecular marker used. Most samples from the eastern Atlantic were identified as Breviolum sp. by both markers, except for one sample from the Canary Islands and two samples from the Cape Verde Islands, which were identified as Cladocopium sp. (formerly Symbiodinium clade C) using ITS-rDNA. These results suggest that these two genera of Symbiodiniaceae may cohabit the same M. alcicornis colony. Because hydrocorals from the Canary Islands were phylogenetically related to the western Atlantic, but symbionts were more related to those of the Cape Verde Islands, the origin of the coral and its symbionts is probably different. This may be explained either by “horizontal” transmission, i.e. acquisition from the environment, or by a change in the dominant symbiont composition within the host. The flexibility of this hydrocoral to select symbionts, depending on environmental conditions, can provide new insight to understand how this coral may face ongoing climate change.

     

Open-sea cultivation by transplanting young fronds of the kelp Saccharina latissima

Saccharina latissima is an economically and ecologically important native kelp. As its limited supply from wild stock cannot meet increasing current and future demands, methods for its cultivation in the ocean need to be developed. This kelp is now beginning to be farmed off the Atlantic coast of Spain using a regular method similar to the “forced cultivation” technique used with Asian kelps (kombu). Its cultivation is also a growing enterprise in other European countries. In this study, the open-sea farming of S. latissima using the transplanting method is tested on a commercial scale. This cultivation method has not been studied with kelp species outside Asian waters. The tested method includes the following steps: indoor production of seedlings, pre-culture in greenhouse tanks, and open-sea cultivation by transplanting young fronds. Results demonstrate that open-sea cultivation using transplanted young fronds is a technically and biologically viable method. The mean yield obtained (7.8 kg fresh wt per meter rope equivalent to 45.6 t fresh wt per hectare farm) is satisfactory, considering the low densities of transplanted fronds (25–30 fronds per meter rope). Moreover, these values are comparable to those reported in previous cultivations with this species, as well as in the farming of similar kelps. The transplanting method used in conjunction with the regular cultivation method has valuable practical applications for the commercial farming of S. latissima.     

Reproductive patterns in central and marginal populations of a large brown seaweed: drastic changes at the southern range limit

Understanding the factors determining geographic ranges and range shifts of species is a central issue in ecology and evolutionary biology. Research addressing distributional borders from a demographic perspective frequently focused on reproductive traits, finding reproduction reductions or failure at the range margin. However, some of the observed changes in marginal locations could be the result of adaptive adjustments to local, unfavourable conditions, though they have been rarely interpreted from this point of view. In this study we investigated the reproductive patterns of the seaweed Fucus serratus in central and southern marginal locations (SW UK, N Spain) over a 3‐yr period. Our main goals were: 1) to determine the spatial (centre‐margin) and temporal variation in reproductive traits and 2) to test if this variation fits with life‐history predictions for stressful environments. Threshold size for reproduction declined at the range margin, in accordance with life‐history predictions. Nevertheless, we also observed parallel drastic reductions in the percentage of reproductives, reproductive allocation and plant size. The reproductive capacity of marginal locations was thus dramatically reduced in relation to central ones. Furthermore, the decline became more pronounced over the study period. Our results suggests that the viability of marginal populations is at risk. This situation clearly differs from the pattern observed during the last decade. At that time, the species was able to growth and reproduce beyond its distributional boundary at similar rates than inside its range in N Spain. The seaweed was then expanding its distribution and the position of the boundary was set by dispersal limitations. At present, the southern boundary of this species seems to be directly influenced by very unfavourable abiotic conditions, which may be linked to the present scenario of climatic change or to environmental fluctuations acting at shorter‐time scales.     

Habitat distribution models for intertidal seaweeds: responses to climatic and non‐climatic drivers

Aim Because intertidal organisms often live close to their physiological tolerance limits, they are potentially sensitive indicators of climate‐driven changes in the environment. The goals of this study were to assess the effect of climatic and non‐climatic factors on the geographical distribution of intertidal macroalgae, and to predict future distributions under different climate‐warming scenarios. Location North‐western Iberian Peninsula, southern Europe. Methods We developed distribution models for six ecologically important intertidal seaweed species. Occurrence and microhabitat data were sampled at 1‐km² resolution and analysed with climate variables measured at larger spatial scales. We used generalized linear models and applied the deviance and Bayesian information criterion to model the relationship between environmental variables and the distribution of each target species. We also used hierarchical partitioning (HP) to identify predictor variables with higher independent explanatory power. Results The distributions of Himanthalia elongata and Bifurcaria bifurcata were correlated with measures of terrestrial and marine climate, although in opposite directions. Model projections under two warming scenarios indicated the extinction of the former at a faster rate in the Cantabrian Sea (northern Spain) than in the Atlantic (west). In contrast, these models predicted an increase in the occurrence of B. bifurcata in both areas. The occurrences of Ascophyllum nodosum and Pelvetia canaliculata, species showing rather static historical distributions, were related to specific non‐climatic environmental conditions and locations, such as the location of sheltered sites. At the southernmost distributional limit, these habitats may present favourable microclimatic conditions or provide refuges from competitors or natural enemies. Model performances for Fucus vesiculosus and F. serratus were similar and poor, but several climatic variables influenced the occurrence of the latter in the HP analyses. Main conclusions The correlation between species distributions and climate was evident for two species, whereas the distributions of the others were associated with non‐climatic predictors. We hypothesize that the distribution of F. serratus responds to diverse combinations of factors in different sections of the north‐west Iberian Peninsula. Our study shows how the response of species distributions to climatic and non‐climatic variables may be complex and vary geographically. Our analyses also highlight the difficulty of making predictions based solely on variation in climatic factors measured at coarse spatial scales.     

Combining physiological threshold knowledge to species distribution models is key to improving forecasts of the future niche for macroalgae

Species distribution models (SDM) are a useful tool for predicting species range shifts in response to global warming. However, they do not explore the mechanisms underlying biological processes, making it difficult to predict shifts outside the environmental gradient where the model was trained. In this study, we combine correlative SDMs and knowledge on physiological limits to provide more robust predictions. The thermal thresholds obtained in growth and survival experiments were used as proxies of the fundamental niches of two foundational marine macrophytes. The geographic projections of these species’ distributions obtained using these thresholds and existing SDMs were similar in areas where the species are either absent‐rare or frequent and where their potential and realized niches match, reaching consensus predictions. The cold‐temperate foundational seaweed Himanthalia elongata was predicted to become extinct at its southern limit in northern Spain in response to global warming, whereas the occupancy of southern‐lusitanic Bifurcaria bifurcata was expected to increase. Combined approaches such as this one may also highlight geographic areas where models disagree potentially due to biotic factors. Physiological thresholds alone tended to over‐predict species prevalence, as they cannot identify absences in climatic conditions within the species’ range of physiological tolerance or at the optima. Although SDMs tended to have higher sensitivity than threshold models, they may include regressions that do not reflect causal mechanisms, constraining their predictive power. We present a simple example of how combining correlative and mechanistic knowledge provides a rapid way to gain insight into a species’ niche resulting in consistent predictions and highlighting potential sources of uncertainty in forecasted responses to climate change.     

Nutrient uptake and growth responses of three intertidal macroalgae with perennial, opportunistic and summer-annual strategies

An important life history trait of macroalgae species is the physiological ability to cope with nutrient limiting conditions, which seasonally occur in temperate coasts while other environmental factors are adequate (e.g., sufficient light). Nitrogen (N) and Phosphorus (P) uptake kinetics and field growth limitation were investigated in the perennial Bifucaria bifurcata, the opportunistic Ulva intestinalis, and the summer-annual Nemalion helminthoides from Asturian coasts (N Spain). We performed 4 nutrient uptake experiments (ammonium, nitrate, nitrate + ammonium, and phosphate) and monitored the growth and N content of field individuals in the presence/absence of artificial nutrient supply to assess potential growth limitations. B. bifurcata was not actively growing during summer thus low nutrient demands probably relied on stored pools and/or the low background nutrient levels in seawater, as generally observed for perennials. Corresponding N content and uptake rates in this species were the lowest. The opportunistic U. intestinalis showed kinetics suitable for assimilating N quickly at high external concentrations in order to fulfill the high nutrient demands that support its fast-growing strategy. This response is well adapted to seasons and sites of high nutrient loading but signs of nutrient starvation during summer (decreasing growth and N content) were found in the pristine studied area. N. helminthoides showed an intermediate response in terms of thallus N content and uptake affinity, together with an inducible activation of nitrate uptake. This response assured the uptake of transient nutrient pulses without the nutrient storage response of perennials, or the costly enzymatic machinery of opportunistics. This allows N. helminthoides to effectively exploit low background nutrient conditions interrupted by transient peaks during spring-summer, when most ephemerals found difficulties to survive and perennials suspend their active growth. P uptake did not differ greatly between species suggesting its secondary importance compared to N in the tested algae.     

INORGANIC NITROGEN AND PHOSPHORUS UPTAKE KINETICS IN PALMARIA PALMATA (RHODOPHYTA)1

The N and P uptake responses were studied in a northern Spanish population of the edible red seaweed Palmaria palmata (Linnaeus) Kuntze. The fronds were incubated at different concentrations, and the nutrient depletion in the medium was measured at successive times to calculate uptake rates. Palmaria palmata uptake response was biphasic and nonsaturable for inorganic P. This would allow the species to exploit transient pulses of high P concentration in natural and fertilized conditions. Such a response is a common feature of algae avoiding nutrient deficiency. At average concentrations measured in the ocean, the response was nonsaturable for inorganic N sources, except for ammonium in autumn and winter when it is not the major N source. In contrast to the general rule of ammonium being taken at a higher rate than nitrate, we found similar affinity for both nutrients corresponding to the minor role of ammonium as N source for field populations over the year.