Patterns of karyotype evolution in complexes of sibling species within three genera of African murid rodents inferred from the comparison of cytogenetic and molecular data

Here we report on the analysis of three rodent sibling species complexes belonging to the African genera Arvicanthis, Acomys and Mastomys. Using cytogenetic and molecular approaches we set out to investigate how karyotype and molecular evolution are linked in these muroid sibling species and, in particular, to what extent chromosomal changes are relevant to cladogenic events inferred from molecular data. The study revealed that each complex is characterized by a distinct pattern of karyotype evolution (karyotypic orthoselection), and a specific mutation rate. However we found that the general pattern may be considerably modified in the course of evolution within the same species complex (Arvicanthis, Acomys). This observation suggests that karyotypic orthoselection documented in numerous groups is not so much a reflection of selection of a definite type of chromosomal mutation, as suggested by the classical concept, but is due to genome structure of a given species. In particular, karyotypic change appears related to the quantity and chromosomal location of repeated sequences. The congruence between the chromosomal and molecular data shows that chromosomal changes are often valuable phylogenetic characters (Arvicanthis and Mastomys, but not Acomys). However, most importantly the approach underscores the value of incorporating both in order to gain a better understanding of complex patterns of evolution. Moreover, the fact that every cladogenetic event in Mastomys is supported by two pericentric inversions allowed us to hypothesize that genetic differentiation is initiated by the suppression of recombination within inverted segments, and that the accumulation of multiple pericentric inversions reinforces genetic isolation leading to subsequent speciation. Finally, the low sequence divergences distinguishing karyotypically distinct sibling species within Arvicanthis and Mastomys emphasizes the power of combining cytogenetic and molecular approaches for the characterization of unrecognized components of biodiversity.     

Karyotype of the rare Johnston’s genet<Emphasis Type="Italic">Genetta johnstoni</Emphasis> (Viverridae) and a reassessment of chromosomal characterization among congeneric species

We present herein new data on karyotypes of members of the genusGenetta. G- and C-banded chromosomes of the Johnston’s genetGenetta johnstoni Pocock, 1908 (2n = 50 / FNa = 92) are described for the first time, and compared with those ofG. genetta (2n = 54 / FNa = 92). In addition, the standard karyotype ofG. maculata (2n = 52 / FNa = 96) was studied. A reassessment of taxonomic attribution of previously published material allowed us to characterize (2n, FNa, and chromosome morphology) the karyotypes of three genets, previously unknown (G. pardina, G. letabae andG. tigrina). Our results show that despite a rather low interspecific variability in 2n and FNa, all the species of genets (exceptG. pardina andG. maculata) appear differentiated when chromosomal morphology is taken into account. Although chromosomal banding data are limited, confrontation of G-band karyotypes with preliminary molecular phylogenetic results reveals that karyotypic evolution within the genusGenetta might involve various rearrangements like Robertsonian and tandem translocations, pericentric inversions, and centromere fissions; thus providing at least for some taxa a solid postzygotic isolation. Finally, our study suggests that cytogenetic analyses might constitute a useful tool for questioning interspecific boundaries, especially within the taxonomically debated complex of large-spotted genets.     

Unusually extensive karyotype reorganization in four congeneric Gerbillus species (Muridae: Gerbillinae)

Comparative analysis of the G- and C-banding patterns in four morphologically poorly differentiated Gerbillus species (G. pyramidum, G. perpallidus, G. tarabuli and G. occiduus) was carried out. These gerbils have similar karyotype morphology with 2n and NF equal to 38/76, 40/76, 40/78 and 40/80, respectively. Our study revealed that possibly 70 Robertsonian (Rb) fusions, two pericentric inversions, one tandem translocation and at least 13 non-identified rearrangements have occurred during the karyotypic evolution of these species. The number of chromosomal changes by which any of these species differ from each other ranges from 33 to 49. One Rb fusion was common to two of the species, with only a single autosome-gonosome translocation shared by all four, suggesting a monophyletic origin of these karyotypically highly divergent species. Based on the chromosomal data obtained here, the systematic and geographic implications for these North African species are also discussed.     

Allozyme Variability among Populations of Three Species of Brush-Furred Mice (Lophuromys,Rodentia, Muridae) from the Bale Mountains National Park (Ethiopia)

Allozyme variability was examined in populations of three endemic species of the species complex Lophuromys flavopunctatussensu lato: L. chrysopus, L. brevicaudus, and L. melanonyx. These species replace each other in adjacent altitudinal belts of the Bale Massif in Ethiopia. A deficit of heterozygotes at several loci was found in most samples of all species studied. Moreover, the samples included animals homozygous for two or three minor alleles and heterozygous for alleles that are rare and unique for the given species. It is suggested that the Bale Massif are inhabited by numerous genetically isolated populations of eachLophuromys species, which exchange genes at an extremely low rate. Genotypic disequilibrium observed in most samples is explained by the fact that most sampling localities comprise ranges of two and more micropopulations. In our view, microgeographic subdivision of the populations is caused by recurrent fragmentation of habitats during the Pleistocene glaciation of the Bale Massif and subsequent prolonged isolation of local populations. Gene drift accompanying these processes resulted in high genetic differentiation of the local populations, which probably persisted until the present. Geographical isolation of the Bale Massif, its uniquely diverse ecological conditions, and extraordinary allozyme structure of the Lophuromys populations suggest that these populations represent remnants or direct descendants of relic local populations.     

High allozyme variation in populations of three spiny rat species from Upper Amazonia: association with ecology and evolution]

The allozyme variation in three spiny rat species of the genus Proechimys from Upper Amazonia was studied in relation to their ecology and evolution. The ecological environmental factors and biotopic distribution of species were analyzed. The unusually high allozyme variation was found in P. simonsi and P. sp. (2n = 34) inhabiting native forest biotopes. A relatively low allozyme variation in P. brevicauda was assumed to be associated with eurybiotic properties and the ability of this species to adapt to anthropogenic biotopes. Data on chromosome homeology and reconstruction of chromosome rearrangements in six spiny rat species were correlated with allozyme variation. The results suggested that chromosome rearrangements played the major role in evolution of the spiny rat species, and that the reorganization of the P. brevicauda genome was not random. P. simonsi and P. sp. (2n = 34), which live in native forest biotopes and carry an excessive genomik "informational load", were assumed to be highly susceptible to any novel external factors. These species are potentially able to produce new chromosome forms and are most significantly affected by deforestation.     

A new chromosomal race of the common shrew <Emphasis Type="Italic">Sorex araneus</Emphasis> (Lipotyphla,Mammalia) found in Russia

Karyotyping of the common shrews Sorex araneus from the poorly studied region of the Northwest of Russia revealed the belonging of individuals to two chromosomal races, Lemi and St. Petersburg. The Lemi race, previously known only from Finland, was discovered for the first time on the territory of Russia and thus replenished the list of S. araneus chromosomal races that are distributed within the Russian part of the species range (27 races out of 74 known in the whole species range at the moment). The studied individuals showed a high level of chromosomal polymorphism, caused by Rb translocations.     

Recent radiation in West African Taterillus (Rodentia, Gerbillinae): the concerted role of chromosome and climatic changes

West African gerbils of the genus Taterillus constitute a complex of seven sibling species distributed from sudano-guinean to saharo-sahelian regions. They display radically rearranged karyotypes despite low genic divergence and a very recent differentiation, that is, within the last 0.4 Myr for the six most derived species. We here provide a comparison of the seven specific karyotypes and perform a cladistic analysis using chromosomal rearrangements character states. When a posteriori polarized mutations were mapped onto the phylogenetic tree, 38 rearrangements were identified as fixed during the evolution of these rodents. This makes Taterillus one of the most striking examples of accelerated chromosomal evolution within placental mammals. Taking into account the types of chromosomal changes involved, divergence times between lineages, genetic distances, as well as reassessed geographic distributions, we suggest that (1) speciation in West African Taterillus was driven by chromosomal changes, and (2) the paleoclimatic oscillations of the Sahara desert have played a major role in their evolution. In particular, elevated plasticity of the Taterillus genome, as suggested by the patterns observed for some repetitive elements, would have led to a higher probability of mutation. We hypothesize that the process underpinning cladogenesis most probably involved highly underdominant genomic rearrangements that were fixed following pronounced populational bottlenecks resulting from drastic climatic and subsequent environmental changes. Major African rivers formed significant barriers to dispersal, limiting expansion during the more moist and so favorable periods. This scenario would explain the current parapatric species distributions and their relationship to the West African hydrographic features.     

Phylogenetic position of the saola (Pseudoryx nghetinhensis) inferred from cytogenetic analysis of eleven species of Bovidae

Previous morphological and molecular analyses failed to resolve the phylogenetic position of the critically endangered saola (Pseudoryx nghetinhensis) with respect to its placement in Bovina (cattle, bison, and yak) or Bubalina (Asian and African buffaloes). In the present study, G- and C-banding, Ag-staining and FISH with 28S and telomeric probes was undertaken for 17 bovid species. An analysis of these data allowed us to identify 49 structural rearrangements that included autosomes, gonosomes and 17 different NOR sites. The combined data set was subjected to a cladistic analysis aimed at: (i) providing new insights on phylogenetic relationships of the saola and other species within the subfamily Bovinae, and (ii) testing the suitability of different classes of chromosomal characters for phylogenetic reconstruction of the family Bovidae. The study revealed that nucleolar organizing regions (NORs) are phylogenetically informative. It was shown that at least one, or sometimes two of these characters punctuate divergences that include nodes that are the most basal in the tree, to those that are the most recent. In this context, the shared presence of three NORs in saola and species of Syncerus and Bubalus strongly suggests the saola's placement within the subtribe Bubalina. This contrasts with Robertsonian rearrangements which are informative only at the generic level. These findings suggest that NORs are an important and frequently overlooked source of additional phylogenetic information within the Bovidae that may also have applicability at higher taxonomic levels, possibly even for Pecora.     

Karyotype reorganisation in the subtilis group of birch mice (Rodentia, Dipodidae, Sicista): unexpected taxonomic diversity within a limited distribution

Conventional cytogenetic studies of Sicista subtilis and S. severtzovi (Dipodidae, Sicistinae), both attributable to the subtilis group of birch mice, revealed extensive karyotype diversity with 2n = 16-26 and NFa values of 26-46 indicating the overwhelming non-Robertsonian nature of chromosomal reorganization in these species. The numerical and structural chromosome variability was principally found in specimens located within a confined region of the East European (Russian) Plain. The approximately 135,000-km(2) area occurs in the vicinity of the Don River bend between 49°13'N/43°46'E and 51°32'N/36°16'E. The detection of cytotypes sharing similar 2n and NF values, but having morphologically distinct chromosomes, suggests that these may result from polymorphisms present both within recognized species and in cryptic taxa not hitherto described. We conducted a comprehensive, comparative chromosome banding analysis of 52 birch mice (21 localities) referable to the subtilis group and report the presence of 5 distinct karyotypes, each characterized by a combination of stable, variable, and partly overlapping 2n/NFa values. These karyotypes differed from each other by 10-29 structural chromosomal rearrangements (18.1 ± 6.3) that comprised Rb fusions/fissions (42.2%), pericentric inversions (31.1%), and tandem translocations (22.2%). The composition, and the high numbers of these chromosomal changes, is likely to provide an effective means of post-mating isolation, suggesting that taxonomic diversity within the subtilis group is larger than currently accepted. Additionally, we report the frequent fixation of tandem translocations in sample populations, one of which was found in a polymorphic state representing, as far as we are aware, the first case of an in statu nascendi tandem fusion in wild populations. Moreover, our data revealed that bi-armed chromosomes were involved in fusions detected in some of the subtilis taxa. In each instance, however, fusions were preceded by pericentric inversions that transform one or both bi-armed chromosomes into acrocentrics resulting in either centromere-telomere or Robertsonian translocations. Finally, a phylogenetic scenario inferred from a cladistic analysis of the chromosomal data suggests that the extensive karyotypic diversification within the subtilis group in the south-east region of the Russian Plain most likely results from fragmentation of a continuously distributed, ancestral population. It is thought that this occurred at the last glacial maximum (18,000-14,000 years B.P.), and that the process of isolation has been exacerbated by increasing human activity in the region in modern times.