On the relationship between evolutionary and psychological definitions of altruism and selfishness

I examine the relationship between evolutionary definitions of altruism that are based on fitness effects and psychological definitions that are based on the motives of the actor. I show that evolutionary altruism can be motivated by proximate mechanisms that are psychologically either altruistic or selfish. I also show that evolutionary definitions do rely upon motives as a metaphor in which the outcome of natural selection is compared to the decisions of a psychologically selfish (or altruistic) individual. Ignoring the precise nature of both psychological and evolutionary definitions has obscured many important issues, including the biological roots of psychological altruism.     

Evolution,altruism, and the prisoner's dilemma

I first argue against Peter Singer's exciting thesis that the Prisoner's Dilemma explains why there could be an evolutionary advantage in making reciprocal exchanges that are ultimately motivated by genuine altruism over making such exchanges on the basis of enlightened long-term self-interest. I then show that an alternative to Singer's thesis — one that is also meant to corroborate the view that natural selection favors genuine altruism, recently defended by Gregory Kavka, fails as well. Finally, I show that even granting Singer's and Kavka's claim about the selective advantage of altruism proper, it is doubtful whether that type of claim can be used in a particular sort of sociobiological argument against psychological egoism.     

Optimization of batch processes involving simultaneous enzymatic and microbial reactions

Two general models for batch simultaneous enzymatic and microbial reaction (SEMR) processes are presented, the second derived from and simpler than the first and accounting for enzyme denaturation. Using the second model and parameter values from the literature, simulation was used to examine a range of enzyme addition rate strategies (in which the rate was a linear function of time) for a relatively fast ethanol fermentation and for a longer duration citric acid fermentation, both using cellulose as the substrate. For the ethanol process it is optimal (for a specific objective function which accounts for product value and enzyme cost) to add all the enzyme at the beginning of the process. But for the citric acid process a linearly decreasing enzyme addition rate, coupled with the addition of a small fraction of the enzyme at time zero, is better than pure batch operation or operation with the best constant enzyme feed rate.     

Effects of invertebrate predation on the seasonal succession of a zooplankton community: a two year study in Lake Aydat,France

Saline playa lakes represent major geomorphic and hydrologic components of internal drainage basins in the arid to semiarid interior of Australia. These lakes mark the outcrop areas of regional shallow groundwater; thus, they are effective hydro-chemical sinks for elemental concentration and authigenic formation of carbonate, evaporite, and silica/silicate minerals.Field observations and petrochemical characterization of playa sediments from drainage basins in Western and Central Australia indicate that localized discharge of groundwater, from shallow aquifers in calcrete deposits, plays a fundamental role in geochemical evolution of playa-lake marginal facies. The available data indicates also that although evaporative concentration and salt recycling are major controls on geochemistry of the playas, yet a simple evaporative concentration model does not provide a complete explanation for brine evolution and particularly the geochemical process-product relationships observed in the individual playa lakes. The distribution of the chemical facies in the playas, in relation to geomorphic setting of the internal drainage basins, reflects a significant impact of variation in groundwater discharge pattern on the geochemical evolution of the playa lakes. Accordingly, the development of chemical facies in individual playas have progressed through repeated episodes of evaporative concentration, groundwater-level fluctuations and ion-exchange processes.     

ESR and ENDOR of primary reactants in photosynthesis

The primary reactants in photosynthesis are defined as the chemical entities on which charges are generated and stabilized after capture of a photon by the photochemical trap: PIX ^hv P ^* IX P ⁺ I ^– X P ⁺ IX ^–, where P stands for the primary electron donor, P ^* for its excited singlet state, I for the first (ESR-detectable) electron acceptor and X for the secondary acceptor complex. The ESR and ENDOR experiments which have played a rÔle in the identification and characterization of P, I, and X in the bacterial and plant photosystems are comprehensively reviewed. The structural and kinetic information obtained with magnetic resonance techniques are integrated with results obtained with optical spectroscopy to give a unified picture of the pathway of primary photochemistry in photosynthesis. Nomenclature of Primary Reactants In the interest of uniformity this review introduces a nomenclature of the primary reactants that deviates in some respects from the commonly used labels. The nametags used here and listed below are abbreviations of the molecules that are identified as primary reactants, with the exception of the donors, for which I have retained the commonly accepted designation. Photosystems: PS 1, photosystem 1 of plants; PS 2, photosystem 2 of plants; pBPS, the photosystem of purple bacteria; gBPS, ditto of green bacteria. P: Primary donors: P700 (PS 1), P680 (PS 2), P860 (generic label for BChl a containing purple bacteria), P960 (generic label for BChl b containing purple bacteria), P840 (generic name for green bacteria). I: First acceptors: Chl a (PS 1), Ph a (PS 2), BPh a,b (pBPS). X: Secondary acceptors: F _x (PS 1), pQ ₁ (PS 2), uQ ₁ or mQ ₁ (pBPS), B (gBPS). Tertiary acceptors: F _A,B (PS 1), pQ ₂ (PS 2), uQ ₂ (pBPS), F ₁ (gBPS).This paper is based on a lecture given at the Joint Meeting of the Belgium, German (FRG), and Netherlands Societies for Biophysics, Aachen 1980     

Electromyography of the gluteal muscles in Hylobates,Pongo, and pan: Implications for the evolution of hominid bipedality

The gluteal musculature of primates has been a focus of great research interest among those who study human evolution. Most current theorists agree that gluteus superficialis (= maximus) need not have changed its action in the step from pongid to hominid, but dispute has arisen over a purported change in action and role of the gluteus medius. To clarify the functions of gluteus medius, gluteus superficialis, and tensor fasciae femoris during ape locomotion, we conducted a telemetered electromyographic study of these muscles in two gibbons, one orangutan, and four chimpanzees as they walked bipedally on the ground and on a horizontal tree trunk, walked quadrupedally on the same substrates, and climbed a vertical tree trunk. The results indicate that the gluteus medius of apes is not, as has been previously suggested, primarily an extensor of the thigh; its action is chiefly that of medial rotation. The role of the gluteus medius during bipedality is the same in apes and humans–to provide side-to-side balance of the trunk at the hip. The change in the hominid lateral balance mechanism can be viewed as primarily osteological, allowing preservation of the same muscle function with an extended thigh. As a result, the stride length is increased and there occurs a diminution of the demands placed on other muscles to maintain anteroposterior balance at the hip and knee. Our data also support the view that vertical climbing may be specifically preadaptive to bipedalism. One may picture the earliest hominid as part biped, when on the ground traveling between scattered food trees, and part climber, when moving from the ground to food.     

Investigation of double turnovers in Photosystem II charge separation and oxygen evolution with excitation flashes of different duration

The characteristics of double hitting in Photosystem II charge separation and oxygen evolution in algae and chloroplasts were investigated with saturating excitation flashes of 3 μs, 300 ns and 5 ns duration. Two types of double hitting or advancement in S-states were found to occur in oxygen evolution: a non-photochemical type found even with 5 ns flashes and a photochemical type seen only with microsecond-long flashes, which have extensive tails. The non-photochemical type, occurring with a probability of about 3%, is sensitive to the physiological condition of the sample, and is only present in algae or chloroplast samples that have been freshly prepared. In chloroplasts incubated with ferricyanide, a 3-fold increase in double advancement of S-states is observed with xenon-flash illumination but not with 300 ns or 5 ns laser illumination. However, double turnovers in Photosystem II reaction center charge separation are large with xenon flash or 300 ns laser illumination but not with 5 ns laser illumination. This indicates that quite different kinetic processes are involved in double advancement in S-states for oxygen evolution and double turnovers in charge separation. Various models of the Photosystem II reaction center are discussed. Also, based on experiments with chloroplasts incubated with ferricyanide, an unique solution to the oxygen S-state distribution in the dark suggested by Thibault (Thibault, P. (1978) C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris 287, 725–728) can be rejected.     

A COMPARATIVE CYTOCHEMICAL STUDY OF VOLVOCACEAN MATRIX POLYSACCHARIDES1

The colonial matrices of the volvocacean algae were examined for the presence of sulfated and carboxylated polysaccharides. These results were compared to a similar examination of the single-celled Chlamydomonas reinhardtii Dang. The colonial algae examined were Pandorina morum Bory, Eudorina elegans Ehr., Platydorina caudata Kofoid, Pleodorina californica Shaw, Pleodorina illinoisensis Kofoid and Volvox carteri var. nagariensis Iyengar. Alcian blue staining of whole colonies at pH 0.5 and 2.5 showed evidence for the presence of both sulfated and carboxylated polysaccharides in the extracellular matrix. Quantitative measurement of alcian blue bound to solubilized matrices supported the in vivo results. There was a trend toward an increase in sulfated polysaccharides in the more evolutionary advanced forms with the exception of Pleodorina. This trend was readily seen in the sulfate: carboxyl ratios: Pandorina morum—0.4, Eudorina elegans—1.0, Platydorina caudata—2.1 and Volvox carteri—2.2. The acidic nature of the Pleodorina matrix with a sulfate: carboxyl ratio of 0.2 appeared to be more like that of Pandorina rather than that of the more advanced Volvox.     

The old REH theory remains unsatisfactory and the new REH theory is problematical - a reply to holmquist and jukes

Summary In response to criticism of REH theory (Fitch 1980), Holmquist and Jukes (1981) have mostly avoided the criticism or misunderstood it. Since they themselves state in their response that Amino acid sequence data alone cannot be used to estimate total nucleotide substitutions, they agree with the criticism. Most of their paper treats the newer theory (here designated as the REHN theory) which attempts to use the nucleotide sequences encoding proteins to better estimate total nucleotide substitutions (Holmquist and Pearl 1980). Since I made no criticism of REHN theory, their comments are frequently beside the point of my original criticism of REH theory. Nevertheless, it is shown here that REHN theory is also unsatisfactory in that: One, the varions are now more clearly defined but in such a way as to preclude the same codon from suffering a nucleotide substitution in more than one evolutionary interval. Two, the set of codons that accepts silent substitutions is identical to the set that accepts amino acid changing nucleotide substitutions. Three, the uncertainty in the REH estimate is considerable in that alternative excellent fits to the same observatuonal data may give alternative REH values that differ significantly even before stochastic variation and selective bias are considered. Four, the fit of their model to data is an irrelevancy where there are zero degrees of freedom.     

An exceptional amino acid replacement on the distal side of the iron atom in proboscidean myoglobin

Summary Amino acid sequence determination of elephant myoglobin revealed the presence of the unusual substitution E7 His Gln. Stereochemical analyses suggest that the most suitable residue which can functionally substitute for His at this position in vertebrate globins is Gln. Physiochemical studies imply that the slower rate of autooxidation of elephant myoglobin is the result of this substitution which may confer some selective advantage on the species. Comparative sequence data of paenungulate myoglobins suggest that the His Gln mutation probably occurred in an ancestor of Elephantinae.