Contingent Conclusions: Year of Initiation Influences Ecological Field Experiments,but Temporal Replication is Rare

Interannual variation in experimental field conditions produce variability in the results of experiments monitored over multiple years, termed here “year effects.” When experimental treatments are replicated in separate years, interannual variation may influence treatment effects and produce significant treatment by initiation‐year interactions. Understanding the frequency and strength of these effects requires initiating identical experiments across years. We conducted a review of literature covering more than 500 experimental articles published in 7 journals between 1966 and 2008. Only 5% of the 276 general ecological field studies initiated experiments in multiple years. This rarity was even more evident in the journal Restoration Ecology, in which none of the 173 surveyed experimental studies initiated experiments in multiple years. In contrast, 48% of the 58 field experiments published in an agronomy journal were replicated across years. We found only 17 studies that tested treatment by initiation‐year interactions. Despite their rarity, 76% of these studies found significant interactions between treatment and initiation year. We conclude that the results of many ecological field experiments are likely to be contingent on the year in which they are implemented. We discuss the importance of treatment by initiation‐year interactions in ecology and restoration, factors that have hindered the inclusion of temporal replication in the past, and some suggestions for the appropriate design and analysis of temporally replicated experiments. We argue for more deliberate investigation of temporal contingency in ecological experimentation, especially in the field of restoration ecology, which may be particularly sensitive to treatment by initiation‐year interactions.     

Effect of Seed Source, Topsoil Removal, and Plant Neighbor Removal on Restoring California Coastal Prairies

Grasslands are hot spots of biodiversity but are now widely threatened by changes in patterns of disturbances, such as grazing and fire regimes, exotic species invasions, and cultivation. The goal of this experiment was to find the most appropriate combination of treatments to reintroduce Danthonia californica, a formerly dominant perennial bunchgrass, into degraded California coastal prairies. Danthonia californica was sown from seed and transplanted at two sites and at two grazing intensities (grazed/ungrazed) in a multifactorial experiment testing the effects of (1) local versus nonlocal seed sources; (2) topsoil removal; and (3) reduction of plant neighbors. Seed emergence was very low, suggesting that transplanting may be a better option to reintroduce D. californica. Although transplants grown from nonlocal seeds survived better initially at both sites, transplants from local seeds had higher survival after 1.5 year at one site. This suggests that short‐term plant establishment studies may be misleading. Topsoil removal greatly enhanced transplant survival, and neighbor removal primarily increased transplant growth. Our results suggest that removing topsoil prior to transplanting seedlings grown from local seeds is the most promising method to reintroduce D. californica. However, the benefits of removing topsoil to provide safe sites for plant establishment should be weighed carefully against potential negative effects on the native seed bank and microbial communities on a site‐specific basis .     

Isolation and characterization of rhizosphere bacteria with potential for biological control of weeds in vineyards

AIMS: Deleterious rhizosphere inhabiting bacteria (DRB) have potential to suppress plant growth. This project focuses on the isolation of DRB with potential for development as commercial products for weed control. METHODS AND RESULTS: Bacteria were isolated from the rhizosphere, rhizoplane, and endorhizosphere of seedlings and mature plants of wild radish (Raphanus raphanistrum), annual ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) and capeweed (Arctotheca calendula) growing in vineyards in the Swan Valley, Western Australia. A majority (81.5%) of the 442 strains was obtained from either rhizospheres or rhizoplanes. Rapid screening techniques were developed to evaluate in the laboratory and glasshouse the effects of bacteria on plants. Strains were screened in the glasshouse for deleterious effects on annual ryegrass, wild radish, grapevine rootlings (Vitis vinifera) and the legume cover crop subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum). Three strains were identified using the Biolog system and 16S rRNA gene sequencing as two strains of Pseudomonas fluorescens (WSM3455 and WSM3456) and one strain of Alcaligenes xylosoxidans (WSM3457). One of the P. fluorescens (WSM3455) strain produced hydrogen cyanide, an inhibitor of plant roots and a broad-spectrum antimicrobial compound. CONCLUSIONS: Three strains specifically inhibited wild radish but had no significant deleterious effects on either grapevine rootlings or subterranean clover. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study suggested manipulation of the weed seedling rhizosphere using identified DRB as a potential biocontrol agent for wild radish.     

Climate envelope, life history traits and the resilience of birds facing global change

Few studies have examined how life history traits and the climate envelope influence the ability of species to respond to climate change and habitat degradation. In this study, we test whether 18 species-specific variables, related to the climate envelope, ecological envelope and life history, could predict recent population trends (over 17 years) of 71 common breeding bird species in France. Habitat specialists were declining at a much higher rate than generalists, a sign that habitat quality is decreasing globally. The lower the thermal maximum (temperature at the hot edge of the climate envelope), the more negative are the population trends and the less tolerant these species are climate warming, regardless of the thermal range over which these species occur. The life history trait 'the number of broods per year' was positively related to recent trends, suggesting that single-brooded species might be more sensitive to advances in food peak due to climate change, as it increases the risk of mistiming their single-breeding event. Annual fecundity explained long-term declines, as it is a good proxy for most other demographic rates, with shorter-lived species being more sensitive to global change: individuals of species with higher fecundity might have too short a life to learn to adapt to directional changes in their environment. Finally, there was evidence that natal dispersal was a predictor of recent trends, with species with high natal dispersal experiencing smaller population declines than species with low natal dispersal. This is expected if the higher the natal dispersal, the larger the ability to shift spatially when facing changes in local habitat or climate, in order to track optimal conditions and adapt to global change. Identifying decline-promoting factors allow us to infer mechanisms responsible for observed declines in wild bird populations facing global change, and by doing so allow for a more pre-emptive approach to conservation planning.     

Comparative analysis of growth rings in perennial forbs grown in an Alpine restoration experiment

Recent studies have demonstrated that growth rings are widespread in the roots of forbs, and there is evidence that the rings are formed annually. However, the annual nature and development of the growth rings has not yet been examined in comparative experimental studies. In this study growth rings were analysed in the main roots of four alpine forbs (Lotus alpinus, Trifolium thalii, Silene willdenowii and Potentilla aurea) that were grown in an alpine restoration experiment for 6 years. All individuals of L. alpinus and T. thalii, and some individuals of S. willdenowii showed six clearly demarcated growth rings, demonstrating that the rings were formed annually. P. aurea did not show distinguishable growth rings. In L. alpinus and T. thalii there were fluctuations in growth ring width that were consistent between individuals and also between species, and matched variations in climatic growth conditions. Results of the present study indicate that conclusions drawn from previous studies suggesting that growth rings in the roots of forb species are most likely formed annually are also valid for alpine plants. In terms of annual ring width patterns, this study also provides the first strong evidence for consistent responses of different forb species and individuals to commonly experienced variations in habitat conditions.     

Comparison of the effect of elevated CO2 on an invasive species (Centaurea solstitialis) in monoculture and community settings

The ongoing increase in atmospheric CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) is likely to change the species composition of plant communities. To investigate whether growth of a highly invasive plant species, Centaurea solstitialis (yellow starthistle), was affected by elevated [CO₂], and whether the success of this species would increase under CO₂ enrichment, I grew the species in serpentine soil microcosms, both as a monoculture and as a component of a grassland community. Centaurea grown in monoculture responded strongly to [CO₂] enrichment of 350 mol mol^–1, increasing aboveground biomass production by 70%, inflorescence production by 74%, and midday photosynthesis by an average of 132%. When grown in competition with common serpentine grassland species, Centaurea responded to CO₂ enrichment with similar but nonsignificant increases (+69% aboveground biomass, +71% inflorescence production), while total aboveground biomass of the polyculture increased by 28%. Centaurea's positive CO₂ response in monoculture and parallel (but non-significant) response in polyculture provoke questions about possible consequences of increasing CO₂ for more typical California grasslands, where the invader already causes major problems.     

Modeling the growth of individuals in plant populations: local density variation in a strand population of Xanthium strumarium (Asteraceae)

We studied the growth of individual Xanthium strumarium plants growing at four naturally occurring local densities on a beach in Maine: (1) isolated plants, (2) pairs of plants ≤1 cm apart, (3) four plants within 4 cm of each other, and (4) discrete dense clumps of 10-39 plants. A combination of nondestructive measurements every 2 wk and parallel calibration harvests provided very good estimates of the growth in aboveground biomass of over 400 individual plants over 8 wk and afforded the opportunity to fit explicit growth models to 293 of them. There was large individual variation in growth and resultant size within the population and within all densities. Local crowding played a role in determining plant size within the population: there were significant differences in final size between all densities except pairs and quadruples, which were almost identical. Overall, plants growing at higher densities were more variable in growth and final size than plants growing at lower densities, but this was due to increased variation among groups (greater variation in local density and/or greater environmental heterogeneity), not to increased variation within groups. Thus, there was no evidence of size asymmetric competition in this population. The growth of most plants was close to exponential over the study period, but half the plants were slightly better fit by a sigmoidal (logistic) model. The proportion of plants better fit by the logistic model increased with density and with initial plant size. The use of explicit growth models over several growth intervals to describe stand development can provide more biological content and more statistical power than "growth-size" methods that analyze growth intervals separately.     

Spawning rhythms of common snook in Florida

Common snook Centropomus undecimalis were sampled monthly from the Jupiter–Lake Worth area of Florida's Atlantic coast during 1989 and 1991 (1452 fish) and from Tampa Bay on Florida's Gulf of Mexico coast during 1988 and 1989 (2090 fish). Group-synchronous oocyte development was demonstrated. Ovarian maturation began during March or April on both coasts. Spawning was first detected histologically in April during 1989 and 1991 on the Atlantic coast and during May in 1988 and in April in 1989 on the Gulf coast. In each year, spawning ended during October on the Atlantic coast and during September on the Gulf coast. Ovarian histological evidence suggested that individual females may spawn every 1·1–2·5 days between 1400 and about 2000 hours. Final oocyte maturation occurred independently of either tidal cycle or lunar phase, and some common snook were observed in prespawning or spawning condition on every day sampled. Spawning occurred in or near major inlets to the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico, in secondary passes to larger inland bays and bayous, and around nearshore islands.     

WAX AND WANE OF MICROCYSTIS (CYANOPHYCEAE) AND MICROCYSTINS IN LAKE SEDIMENTS: A CASE STUDY IN QUITZDORF RESERVOIR (GERMANY)1

Benthic stages of the annual life cycle of the meroplanktonic cyanobacterium Microcystis spp. in relation to microcystin (MCYST) dynamics in sediments of a shallow lake (Quitzdorf Reservoir, Germany) were investigated. Based on changes in the absolute abundance of benthic Microcystis, the annual life cycle was subdivided into four phenological stages: reinvasion, pelagic growth, sedimentation, and overwintering. Habitat‐coupling processes, such as reinvasion of the pelagic zone in spring as well as autumnal sedimentation, were particularly triggered by changes in water temperature. During reinvasion substantial losses of Microcystis were detected. Only a minor part of benthic Microcystis (about 3%) formed the inoculum for pelagic growth. Between 65% and 85% of the benthic Microcystis stock disappeared during the reinvasion phase. Because these colonies were neither detected within the sediments nor in the pelagic inoculum, it was concluded that they were subjected to decay. The occurrence of extracellular MCYSTs in the pelagic zone during this period, which cannot solely originate from the pelagic Microcystis population, supports this conclusion. Dynamics of benthic Microcystis and MCYSTs were characterized by almost identical successions with a decrease during reinvasion, an increase during sedimentation, and remarkable invariability throughout pelagic growth and overwintering. It can be deduced that MCYSTs are preserved within benthic resting stages of Microcystis because they could play a role during overwintering or reinvasion.