Life cycle assessment in the minerals and metals sector: a critical review of selected issues and challenges

Background, aim and scope

The mining sector provides materials that are essential elements in a wide range of goods and services, which create value by meeting human needs. Mining and processing activities are an integral part of most complex material cycles so that the application of life cycle assessment (LCA) to minerals and metals has therefore gained prominence. In the past decade, increased use of LCA in the mineral and metal sector has advanced the scientific knowledge through the development of scientifically valid life cycle inventory databases. Though scientifically valid, LCA still needs to depend on several technical assumptions. In particular, measuring the environmental burden issues related to abiotic resource depletion, land use impacts and open-loop recycling within the LCA are widely debated issues. Also, incorporating spatial and temporal sensitivities in LCA, to make it a consistent scientific tool, is yet to be resolved. This article discusses existing LCA methods and proposed models on different issues in relation to minerals and metals sector.

Main features

A critical review was conducted of existing LCA methods in the minerals and metals sector in relation to allocation issues related to indicators of land use impacts, abiotic resource depletion, allocation in open-loop recycling and the system expansions and accounting of spatial and temporal dimension in LCA practice.

Results

Evolving a holistic view about these contentious issues will be presented with view for future LCA research in the minerals and metals industry. This extensive literature search uncovers many of the issues that require immediate attention from the LCA scientific community.

Discussion

The methodological drawbacks, mainly problems with inconsistencies in LCA results for the same situation under different assumptions and issues related to data quality, are considered to be the shortcomings of current LCA. In the minerals and metals sector, it is important to increase the objectivity of LCA by way of fixing those uncertainties, for example, in the LCA of the minerals and metals sector, whether the land use has to be considered in detail or at a coarse level. In regard to abiotic resource characterisation, the weighting and time scales to be considered become a very critical issue of judgement. And, in the case of open-loop recycling, which model will best satisfy all the stake holders? How the temporal and spatial dimensions should be incorporated into LCA is one of the biggest challenges ahead of all those who are concerned. Addressing these issues shall enable LCA to be used as a policy tool in environmental decision-making. There has been enormous debate with respect to on land use impacts, abiotic resource depletion, open-loop recycling and spatial and temporal dimensions, and these debates remain unresolved. Discussions aimed at bringing consensus amongst all the stake holders involved in LCA (i.e. industry, academia, consulting organisations and government) will be presented and discussed. In addition, a commentary of different points of view on these issues will be presented.

Conclusions

This review shall bring into perspective some of those contentious issues that are widely debated by many researchers. The possible future directions proposed by researchers across the globe shall be presented. Finally, authors conclude with their views on the prospects of LCA for future research endeavours.

Recommendations and outlook

Specific LCA issues of minerals and metals need to be investigated further to gain more understanding. To facilitate the future use of LCA as a policy tool in the minerals and metals sector, it is important to increase the objectivity with more scientific validity. Therefore, it is essential that the issues discussed in this paper are addressed to a great detail.     

Expression of apoplastically secreted tobacco osmotin in cotton confers drought tolerance

Osmotin or osmotin-like proteins have been shown to be induced in several plant species in response to various types of biotic and abiotic challenges. The protein is generally believed to be involved in protecting the plant against these stresses. Although some understanding of the possible mechanism underlying the defense function of osmotin against biotic stresses is beginning to emerge, its role in abiotic stress response is far from clear. We have transformed cotton plants with a tobacco-osmotin gene, lacking the sequence encoding its 20 amino acid-long, C-terminal vacuolar-sorting motif, under the control of CaMV 35S promoter. Apoplastic secretion of the recombinant protein was confirmed and the plants were evaluated for their ability to tolerate drought conditions. Under polyethylene glycol-mediated water stress, the osmotin-expressing seedlings showed better growth performance. The transformants showed a slower rate of wilting during drought and faster recovery following the termination of dry conditions in a greenhouse setting. During drought, the leaves from transgenic plants had higher relative water content and proline levels, while showing reduced H₂O₂ levels, lipid peroxidation and electrolyte leakage. Importantly, following a series of dry periods, the osmotin transformants performed better in terms of most growth and developmental parameters tested. Most relevant, the fiber yield of transgenic plants did not suffer as much as that of their non-transgenic counterparts under drought conditions. The results provide direct support for a protective role of osmotin in cotton plants experiencing water stress and suggest a possible way to achieve tolerance to drought conditions by means of genetic engineering. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Environmental controls and patterns of cumulative radial increment of evergreen tree species in montane,temperate rainforests of Chiloé Island,southern Chile

We investigated the local environmental controls on daily fluctuations of cumulative radial increment and cambial hydration of three dominant, evergreen tree species from montane, Coastal rainforests of Chiloé Island, Chile (42° 22′ S). During 2 years (1997–1998 and 1998–1999) we recorded hourly cumulative radial increments using electronic band dendrometers in the long‐lived conifer Fitzroya cupressoides (Cupressaceae), the evergreen broad‐leaved Nothofagus nitida (Nothofagaceae), and the narrow‐leaved conifer Podocarpus nubigena (Podocarpaceae). We also measured soil and cambial tissue hydration using capacitance sensors, together with air and soil temperature and rainfall during the period of the study. In addition, we collected cores of these tree species to evaluate how dendrometer measurements reflect annual tree ring width. One‐year long daily time series of cumulative radial increments suggests that radial growth of Fitzroya cupressoides was initiated slowly in early spring, with a maximum in early summer. Multiple regressions showed positive relations between daily precipitation and radial index (i.e. the difference in cumulative radial increment of two consecutive days) in the three species. According to path analysis there was a significant direct effect of changes in tree hydration on radial index of the three focal species. In emergent, pioneer species such as Nothofagus and Fitzroya, radial index was negatively affected by changes in maximum air temperature and photosynthetically active radiation, probably because of high evapotranspiration demand on warm sunny days. The shade‐tolerant species Podocarpus nubigena was positively affected by photosynthetically active radiation. Our diel scale findings support the use of tree ring widths for reconstructing past climate in these southern temperate forests and provide evidence that rainforest trees may be highly sensitive to future declines in rainfall and temperature increases during summer.     

Expression of baculovirus anti-apoptotic p35 gene in tobacco enhances tolerance to abiotic stress

Expression of baculovirus anti-apoptotic p35 gene in plants on biotic stress responses has been well studied but its function on abiotic stress has not been documented. In the present study, the p35 gene from Autographa californica multiple nucleopolyhedrovirus (AcMNPV) was expressed in tobacco. A detached leaf assay was used to test tolerance of p35 transgenic plants to various abiotic stress responses. Expression of p35 gene in tobacco gave tolerance to treatment with methanol and H₂O₂ and also delayed leaf senescence under starvation in the dark. Germination of T₀ seeds on NaCl-containing medium also demonstrated to increase salt tolerance.     

Response of birds to climatic variability; evidence from the western fringe of Europe

Ireland’s geographic location on the western fringe of the European continent, together with its island status and impoverished avifauna, provides a unique opportunity to observe changes in bird migration and distribution patterns in response to changing climatic conditions. Spring temperatures have increased in western Europe over the past 30 years in line with reported global warming. These have been shown, at least in part, to be responsible for changes in the timing of life cycle events (phenology) of plants and animals. In order to investigate the response of bird species in Ireland to changes in temperature, we examined ornithological records of trans-Saharan migrants over the 31-year period 1969–1999. Analysis of the data revealed that two discrete climatic phenomena produced different responses in summer migrant bird species. Firstly, a number of long-distance migrants showed a significant trend towards earlier arrival. This trend was evident in some species and was found to be a response to increasing spring air temperature particularly in the month of March. Secondly, (1) a step change in the pattern of occurrences of non-breeding migrant bird species, and (2) an increase in the ringing data of migrant species were found to correlate with a step change in temperature in 1987–1988. These results indicate that, for migrant bird species, the impact of a sudden change in temperature can be as important as any long-term monotonic trend, and we suggest that the impact of step change events merits further investigation on a wider range of species and across a greater geographical range.     

When cells lose water: Lessons from biophysics and molecular biology

Organisms living in deserts and anhydrobiotic species are useful models for unraveling mechanisms used to overcome water loss. In this context, late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) proteins and sugars have been extensively studied for protection against desiccation stress and desiccation tolerance. This article aims to reappraise the current understanding of these molecules by focusing on converging contributions from biochemistry, molecular biology, and the use of biophysical tools. Such tools have greatly advanced the field by uncovering intriguing aspects of protein 3-D structure, such as folding upon stress. We summarize the current research on cellular responses against water deficit at the molecular level, considering both plausible water loss-sensing mechanisms and genes governing signal transduction pathways. Finally, we propose models that could guide future experimentation, for example, by concentrating on the behavior of selected proteins in living cells.     

Effect of heavy metals and temperature on the oxalate oxidase activity and lignification of metaxylem vessels in barley roots

The effect of Cd on oxalate oxidase (OxO) activity and its localisation were analysed in barley root. In Cd-treated roots OxO activity was strongly induced in the region 2–4 mm behind the root tip and in the area toward the root base. In situ analyses showed that Cd-induced OxO activity was localised to the cell wall (CW) of early metaxylem vascular bundles and surrounding parenchyma cells and was accompanied by lignification of metaxylem vessels. OxO activation was also observed during treatment with other heavy metals (HMs), salt treatment and at elevated non-optimal temperature. In contrast to HM activation of OxO and lignification, high temperature and NaCl indeed activated OxO but did not induce lignification of metaxylem vessels. These results suggest that oxalate oxidase as an H₂O₂-generating enzyme is activated in response to several stresses, however the ectopic lignification of metaxylem vessels is activated specifically by HMs. This HM-induced premature root xylogenesis due to ectopic lignification of metaxylem vessels probably causes shortening of the root elongation zone and therefore a reduction in root growth.     

The Relative Importance of Abiotic and Biotic Transformation of Carbon Tetrachloride in Anaerobic Soils and Sediments

The relative contributions of abiotic and microbial processes and the role of dissolved species in the reductive dechlorination of carbon tetrachloride (CT) by natural soils and sediments were investigated. Microcosms were constructed using soils or sediments and site water from three locations, and then amended with electron acceptors and/or donors to stimulate the growth of iron- and sulfate-reducing bacteria and to promote the formation of minerals that can react with CT. Before spiking with CT, half the replicate microcosms were sterilized in order to measure the rates of abiotic CT transformation without any direct contribution from microbial dechlorination. Abiotic reaction rates were significantly greater than microbial rates for a range of initial CT concentrations, and for both iron- and sulfate-reducing conditions. In most cases, abiotic reaction rates were indistinguishable from total reaction rates (abiotic plus microbial), indicating a negligible microbial contribution to CT transformation. While in most microcosms the soil/sediment acted as the abiotic reductant, under certain conditions the supernatant was more reactive with CT than was the solid phase. For these conditions, we propose that the reactive species in the supernatant consisted of aqueous natural organic matter that underwent reduction or other transformation by S(-II) generated by sulfate-reducing bacteria.     

Proteomic analysis of chicory root identifies proteins typically involved in cold acclimation

Chicory (Cichorium intybus) roots contain high amounts of inulin, a fructose polymer used as a storage carbohydrate by the plant and as a human dietary and prebiotic compound. We performed 2‐D electrophoretic analysis of proteins from root material before the first freezing period. The proteins were digested with trypsin and the peptides analyzed by MS (MALDI‐TOF/TOF). From the 881 protein spots analyzed, 714 proteins corresponded to a database accession, 619 of which were classified into functional categories. Besides expected proteins (e.g. related to metabolism, energy, protein synthesis, or cell structure), other well‐represented categories were proteins related to folding and stability (49 spots), proteolysis (49 spots), and the stress response (67 spots). The importance of abiotic stress response was confirmed by the observation that 7 of the 21 most intense protein spots are known to be involved in cold acclimation. These results suggest a major effect of the low temperature period that preceded root harvesting.