Undertaking a randomised controlled trial in the police setting: methodological and practical challenges

Background

There has been an increased drive towards Evidence Based Policing in recent years. Unlike in other public sector services, such as health and education, randomised controlled trials in the police setting are relatively rare. This paper discusses some of the methodological and practical challenges of conducting a randomised controlled trial in the police setting in the UK, based on our experience of the Connect trial. This pragmatic, cluster-randomised controlled trial investigated the effectiveness of a face-to-face training intervention for frontline officers in comparison to routine training. The primary outcome was the number of incidents which resulted in a police response reported to North Yorkshire Police control room in a 1-month period up to 6 months after delivery of training.

Main text

The methodological and practical challenges that we experienced whilst conducting the Connect trial are discussed under six headings: establishing the unit of randomisation; population of interest and sample size; co-production of evidence; time frame; outcomes; and organisational issues.

Conclusion

Recommendations on the conduct of future randomised controlled trials in the police setting are made. To understand the context in which research is undertaken, collaboration between police and academia is needed and police officers should be embedded within trial management groups. Engagement with police data analysts to understand what data is available and facilitate obtaining trial data is also recommended. Police forces may wish to review their IT systems and recording practices. Pragmatic trials are encouraged and time frames need to allow for trial set-up and obtaining relevant ethical approvals.

Trial registration

ISRCTN Registry, ID: ISRCTN11685602. Retrospectively registered on 13 May 2016.

     

Common principles in protein folding and antigen presentation.

The regular recurrence of hydrophobic amino acid residues along a peptide sequence determines the formation of a longitudinal hydrophobic strip when the peptide forms an alpha-helix. An understanding of the ways this may affect both folding of nascent proteins and antigen presentation should facilitate vaccine and therapeutics design.     

Oxygen metabolism and catecholamine secretion during chloralose anesthesia in lambs.

Anesthetic agents are required when restraining animals in most forms of animal research. In particular, alpha-chloralose is a widely used anesthetic for respiratory and cardiovascular research despite limited controlled studies investigating whether chloralose could represent a variable influencing cardiorespiratory reflexes in acute animal studies. We previously used a chronically-instrumented neonatal lamb model to determine that chloralose had important effects on oxygen delivery and on basal hemodynamics. To investigate the influence of chloralose on oxygen metabolism and catecholamine secretion in relation to these hemodynamic changes, we studied 12 lambs before and after infusion of chloralose (30 mg/kg, i.v.) or control saline vehicle. Chloralose caused no differences in arterial or mixed venous oxygen contents, arterio-venous oxygen difference, or oxygen delivery, consumption, or extraction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Unraveling regulatory networks in plant defense using microarrays

DNA microarrays are being used to comprehensively examine gene expression networks during the plant defense response that is triggered when a plant encounters a pathogen or an elicitor molecule. In addition to identifying new genes induced during defense, these studies are providing new insights into the complex pathways governing defense gene regulation.     

Is there an inner nose?

Although behavioral and neuropsychological data regarding the existence of images for odors are inconclusive, reconsideration of earlier EEG work provides reasonably clear evidence for an inner nose. However, further EEG studies and neuroimaging data seem essential for conclusive demonstration of an inner nose.      

Distribution and hormonal regulation of membrane progesterone receptors β and γ in ciliated epithelial cells of mouse and human fallopian tubes

Background  

The controlled beating of cilia of the fallopian tube plays an important role in facilitating the meeting of gametes and subsequently transporting the fertilized egg to its implantation site. Rapid effects of progesterone on ciliary beat frequency have been reported in the fallopian tubes of cows, but the identity of the receptors mediating this non-genomic action of progesterone is not known. We recently identified a member of the non-genomic membrane progesterone receptor family, mPR gamma, as a candidate for mediating these actions of progesterone. Here, we investigated the possible presence of a related receptor, mPR beta, in the fallopian tubes of mice and women as well as the possible hormonal regulation of mPR beta and gamma.     

SSWAP: A Simple Semantic Web Architecture and Protocol for semantic web services

Background  

SSWAP (Simple Semantic Web Architecture and Protocol; pronounced "swap") is an architecture, protocol, and platform for using reasoning to semantically integrate heterogeneous disparate data and services on the web. SSWAP was developed as a hybrid semantic web services technology to overcome limitations found in both pure web service technologies and pure semantic web technologies.