Current Practice of Public Involvement Activities in Biomedical Research and Innovation: A Systematic Qualitative Review

Background

A recent report from the British Nuffield Council on Bioethics associated ‘emerging biotechnologies’ with a threefold challenge: 1) uncertainty about outcomes, 2) diverse public views on the values and implications attached to biotechnologies and 3) the possibility of creating radical changes regarding societal relations and practices. To address these challenges, leading international institutions stress the need for public involvement activities (PIAs). The objective of this study was to assess the state of PIA reports in the field of biomedical research.

Methods

PIA reports were identified via a systematic literature search. Thematic text analysis was employed for data extraction.

Results

After filtering, 35 public consultation and 11 public participation studies were included in this review. Analysis and synthesis of all 46 PIA studies resulted in 6 distinguishable PIA objectives and 37 corresponding PIA methods. Reports of outcome translation and PIA evaluation were found in 9 and 10 studies respectively (20% and 22%). The paper presents qualitative details.

Discussion

The state of PIAs on biomedical research and innovation is characterized by a broad range of methods and awkward variation in the wording of objectives. Better comparability of PIAs might improve the translation of PIA findings into further policy development. PIA-specific reporting guidelines would help in this regard. The modest level of translation efforts is another pointer to the “deliberation to policy gap”. The results of this review could inform the design of new PIAs and future efforts to improve PIA comparability and outcome translation.     

Vertical distribution and cyst production of Peridiniella catenata (Dinophyceae) during a spring bloom in the Baltic Sea

Vertical distribution and cyst production of the chain-forming,spring dinoflagellate Peridiniella catenata were studied throughoutthe spring season of 2000 in the coastal Gulf of Finland. Numbersof cells were monitored in the water column, and cyst sedimentationwas recorded using multiple sediment traps moored at three discretedepths. At the onset of the spring bloom, most of the populationwas situated in the euphotic zone. When the bloom progressed,the population was more evenly dispersed throughout the watercolumn. Coinciding with the decline of the spring bloom, afternitrogen depletion, a general reduction of cell size of P. catenataand a break-up of chains were observed. Resting cysts startedto appear shortly after the peak of the bloom, in sedimentationtraps moored at 30 and 40 m depth. Cysts were only retrievedfrom the uppermost sediment trap on three of the six samplingoccasions, constituting only a small proportion of all cystsproduced by P. catenata during spring. Our results suggest thatcyst production of this vertically migrating organism takesplace to a large extent in deep water layers and emphasizesthe necessity of whole water column monitoring in studies aimingto understand in situ life-cycle transformations of verticallymigrating dinoflagellates.     

Future land use effects on the connectivity of protected area networks in southeastern Spain

Land-use change is a major driver of the global biodiversity crisis, mainly via the fragmentation and loss of natural habitat. Although land-use changes will accelerate to meet humankind's growing demand for agricultural products, conservation planning rarely considers future land uses and how they may affect the connectivity of ecological networks. Here, we integrate land-use models with landscape fragmentation and connectivity analyses, to assess the effects of past and future land-use changes on the connectivity of protected area networks for a highly dynamic region in southeast Spain. Our results show a continued geographical polarisation of land use, with agricultural intensification and urban development in the coastal areas, and the abandonment of traditional land use in the mountains (e.g., 1100 km² of natural vegetation are projected to be lost in coastal areas whereas 32 km² of natural vegetation would recover in interior areas from 1991 to 2015). As a result, coastal protected areas will experience increasing isolation. The connectivity analyses reveal that the two protected area networks in place in the study area, the European “Natura 2000” and the Andalusian “RENPA” networks, include many landscape connectors. However, we identify two areas that currently lack protection but contain several important patches for maintaining the region's habitat connectivity: the northwestern and the southwestern slopes of the Sierra Cabrera and Bédar protected area. Our results highlight the importance of considering future land-use trajectories in conservation planning to maintain connectivity at the regional scale, and to improve the resilience of conservation networks.     

Deconstructing the electron transfer chain in a complex molybdoenzyme: Assimilatory nitrate reductase from Neurospora crassa

Nitrate reductase (NR) from the fungus Neurospora crassa is a complex homodimeric metallo-flavoenzyme, where each protomer contains three distinct domains; the catalytically active terminal molybdopterin cofactor, a central heme-containing domain, and an FAD domain which binds with the natural electron donor NADPH. Here, we demonstrate the catalytic voltammetry of variants of N. crassa NRs on a modified Au electrode with the electrochemically reduced forms of benzyl viologen (BV²⁺) and anthraquinone sulfonate (AQS^?) acting as artificial electron donors. The biopolymer chitosan used to entrap NR on the electrode non-covalently and the enzyme film was both stable and highly active. Electrochemistry was conducted on two distinct forms; one lacking the FAD cofactor and the other lacking both the FAD and heme cofactors. While both enzymes showed catalytic nitrate reductase activity, removal of the heme cofactor resulted in a more significant effect on the rate of nitrate reduction. Electrochemical simulation was carried out to enable kinetic characterisation of both the NR:nitrate and NR:mediator reactions.     

An ancient look at UCP1

Brown adipose tissue serves as a thermogenic organ in placental mammals to defend body temperature in the cold by nonshivering thermogenesis. The thermogenic function of brown adipose tissue is enabled by several specialised features on the organ as well as on the cellular level, including dense sympathetic innervation and vascularisation, high lipolytic capacity and mitochondrial density and the unique expression of uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1). This mitochondrial carrier protein is inserted into the inner mitochondrial membrane and stimulates maximum mitochondrial respiration by dissipating proton-motive force as heat. Studies in knockout mice have clearly demonstrated that UCP1 is essential for nonshivering thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue. For a long time it had been presumed that brown adipose tissue and UCP1 emerged in placental mammals providing them with a unique advantage to survive in the cold. Our subsequent discoveries of UCP1 orthologues in ectotherm vertebrates and marsupials clearly refute this presumption. We can now initiate comparative studies on the structure-function relationships in UCP1 orthologues from different vertebrates to elucidate when during vertebrate evolution UCP1 gained the biochemical properties required for nonshivering thermogenesis.     

The agony of choice: Impact of the host animal species on the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay performance for host cell protein quantification

Host cell proteins (HCPs) are inevitable process-related impurities in biotherapeutics commonly monitored by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs). Of particular importance for their reliable detection are the anti-HCP polyclonal antibodies (pAbs), supposed to detect a broad range of HCPs. The present study focuses on the identification of suitable host animal species for the development of high-performance CHO-HCP ELISAs, assuming the generation of pAbs with adequate coverage and specificity. Hence, antibodies derived from immunization of sheep, goats, donkeys, rabbits, and chickens were compared concerning their amount of HCP-specific antibodies, coverage, and performance in a sandwich ELISA. Immunization of sheep, goats, donkeys, and rabbits met all test criteria, whereas the antibodies from chickens cannot be recommended based on the results of this study. Additionally, a mixture of antibodies from the five host species was prepared to assess if coverage and ELISA performance can be improved by a multispecies approach. Comparable results were obtained for the single- and multispecies ELISAs in different in-process samples, indicating no substantial improvement for the latter in ELISA performance while raising ethical and financial concerns.     

Design,synthesis and evaluation of potent and selective inhibitors of mono-(ADP-ribosyl)transferases PARP10 and PARP14

A series of diaryl ethers were designed and synthesized to discern the structure activity relationships against the two closely related mono-(ADP-ribosyl)transferases PARP10 and PARP14. Structure activity studies identified 8b as a sub-micromolar inhibitor of PARP10 with?～15-fold selectivity over PARP14. In addition, 8k and 8m were discovered to have sub-micromolar potency against PARP14 and demonstrated moderate selectivity over PARP10. A crystal structure of the complex of PARP14 and 8b shows binding of the compound in a novel hydrophobic pocket and explains both potency and selectivity over other PARP family members. In addition, 8b, 8k and 8m also demonstrate selectivity over PARP1. Together, this study identified novel, potent and metabolically stable derivatives to use as chemical probes for these biologically interesting therapeutic targets.     

The effect of intrinsic curvature on supercoiling: Predictions of elasticity theory

Elasticity theory of naturally curved rods is employed to study the effects of intrinsic curvature on the properties of the equilibrium conformations of supercoiled DNA. The results stand in sharp contrast to those obtained when the molecule is viewed as being straight in its relaxed form. Starting from very fundamental principles of the theory, we show that the torsion of an open segment with a curved duplex axis can vary when the temperature, and along with it, the intrinsic twist is changed. Conversely, an imposed helicity, such as might be associated with binding to a histone, can change the intrinsic twist. It is also shown that another consequence of the presence of naturally curved sequences is that the twist density will, in general, vary with position along the chain in all equilibrium states. Then portions of the molecule will be more or less susceptible to interaction with other agents sensitive to such a variation. Finally, some closed equilibrium global structures uniquely associated with intrinsic curvature are discussed. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

RIP2 regulates growth and differentiation of normal myoblasts and of rhabdomyosarcoma cells

RIP2 is an important regulator of myoblast proliferation and differentiation. We have previously demonstrated that in the myoblast cell line C2C12 and in primary myoblasts, downregulation of rip2 gene expression is a prerequisite for differentiation. To further study the role of rip genes in myogenesis, we compared expression patterns of rip1–4 in two myoblast cell lines, C2C12 and C2F3, after the induction of differentiation. These two cell lines are derived from the same clonal origin, but differ with respect to their differentiation behaviour: specifically, the differentiation process is slower and more incomplete in C2F3 cells. When analyzing cells up to 4 days after the induction of differentiation, we found no downregulation of rip2 gene expression in C2F3 cells, which might be linked to the low differentiation potential of these cells. In addition, in contrast to C2C12 cells, the rip3 gene was not expressed in C2F3 cells. To further study the role of rip genes in the regulation of myoblast growth and differentiation, we analyzed expression patterns of rip1–4 in rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines. We found that in these cells, rip2 expression was not downregulated after the induction of differentiation. Furthermore, in contrast to normal myoblasts, they did not express the rip3 and rip4 genes. Thus, we focused on the functional role of RIP2 in rhabdomyosarcoma cells. Inhibition of rip2 gene expression in C2C12 and in rhabdomyosarcoma cells using specific siRNAs led to decreased proliferation and promoted the differentiation process of these cells. These data indicate that differential expression of rip genes can be associated with abnormal growth and differentiation behaviour of skeletal myoblasts.