Not Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Howard Temin’s Provirus Hypothesis Revisited

During the 1960s, Howard M. Temin (1934–1994), dared to advocate a “heretical” hypothesis that appeared to be at variance with the central dogma of molecular biology, understood by many to imply that information transfer in nature occurred only from DNA to RNA. Temin’s provirus hypothesis offered a simple explanation of both virus replication and viral-induced cancer and stated that Rous sarcoma virus, an RNA virus, is replicated via a DNA intermediate. Popular accounts of this scientific episode, written after the discovery of an RNA-directed DNA polymerase in 1970, tend to describe the reaction to his proposition as ardent opposition. Typically these accounts use a ‹molecular biology’ standpoint emphasizing the central dogma’s part in its rejection. In this article, however, this episode will be examined from a joint perspective of virology and experimental cancer research. From this perspective it is clear that Temin’s work was well within the epistemological and methodological boundaries of virology and cancer research. Still, scientists did have␣reasons to doubt the provirus hypothesis, but these do not seem to be good enough to either justify an account that portrays Temin as a renegade or his ideas as heretical.     

Heterogeneity of the coumarin anticoagulant targeted vitamin K epoxide reduction system. Study of kinetic parameters in susceptible and resistant mice (Mus musculus domesticus)

Vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR) activity in liver microsomes from a susceptible and a genetically warfarin-resistant strain of mice (Mus Musculus domesticus) was analyzed to determine the mechanism of resistance to this 4-hydroxycoumarin derivative. Kinetic parameters for VKOR were calculated for each strain by incubating liver microsomes with vitamin K epoxide +/- warfarin. In susceptible mice, an Eadie-Hofstee plot of the data was not linear and suggested the involvement of at least two different components. Apparent kinetic parameters were obtained by nonlinear regression using a Michaelis--Menten model, which takes into account two enzymatic components. Component A presents a high Km and a high Vm, and as a consequence only an enzymatic efficiency Vm/Km was obtained (0.0024 mL/min/mg). Estimated warfarin Ki was 0.17 microM. Component B presented an apparent Km of 12.73 microM, an apparent Vm of 0.32 nmol/min/mg, and an apparent Ki for warfarin of 6.0 microM. In resistant mice, the enzymatic efficiency corresponding to component A was highly decreased (0.0003-0.00066 mL/min/mg) while the Ki for warfarin was not modified. The apparent Vm of component B was poorly modified between susceptible and resistant mice. The apparent Km of component B observed in resistant mice was similar to the Km observed in susceptible mice. These modifications of the catalytic properties are associated with a single nucleotide polymorphism (T175G) in the VKOR-C1 gene, which corresponds to a Trp59Gly mutation in the protein.     

Influence of bromodeoxyuridine on the stability and function of polytene chromosomes

Polytene chromosomes of Drosophila hydei have been employed to study the effect of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) on chromosome function and structure. Two media have been tested for their capacity to permit substitution of thymidine by BrdU in larval salivary glands. In medium L up to 80% of the polytene DNA is replicated with maximum substitution of 80% of the thymidine in one strand by BrdU. The degree of substitution achieved with this medium is uniform within individual nuclei but varies between nuclei. An alternate medium (S) results in more complete substitution but less total DNA synthesis. Autoradiographic analyses reveal that extensive BrdU substitution is correlated with an inhibition of chromosomal RNA synthesis. Nucleolar RNA synthesis is almost totally suppressed by exposure to BrdU. Chromosomes which exhibit extensive BrdU incorporation produce puffs in response to a temperature shock or in vitro incubation. Preliminary studies suggest that puffing at some loci is anomalous. The data, therefore, indicate that moderate BrdU incorporation completely suppresses nucleolar RNA synthesis and reduces chromosomal RNA synthesis but does not generally prevent the induction of new puffs. — Exposure of larvae to BrdU also stabilizes the morphology of their polytene chromosomes in the presence of high pH and high ionic strength. Chromosome morphology that is lost at 0.6 M NaCl is regained at 0.15 M NaCl in isolated nuclei derived from BrdU-fed larvae. No recovery is observed in chromosomes of unsubstituted control larvae.     

Characterization of 20 microsatellites marker loci in the golden-crowned sifaka (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Propithecus tattersalli)</Emphasis>

The golden-crowned sifaka (Propithecus tattersalli) is one of the most critically endangered species of Propithecus endemic to a limited area in the Daraina region of north-eastern Madagascar. This species is endangered due to habitat loss and fragmentation, a consequence of deforestation. Twenty nuclear microsatellite loci were isolated from genomic DNA derived from a Propithecus tattersalli from the Daraina area in north-eastern Madagascar. Population genetic parameters were estimated on 20 individuals from two Daraina forest fragments to determine the potential utility of this marker suite for future studies on the golden-crowned sifaka.     

Patterns of vegetative growth and gene flow in Rhizopogon vinicolor and R. vesiculosus (Boletales, Basidiomycota)

We have collected sporocarps and tuberculate ectomycorrhizae of both Rhizopogon vinicolor and Rhizopogon vesiculosus from three 50 x 100 m plots located at Mary's Peak in the Oregon Coast Range (USA); linear map distances between plots ranged from c. 1 km to c. 5.5 km. Six and seven previously developed microsatellite markers were used to map the approximate size and distribution of R. vinicolor and R. vesiculosus genets, respectively. Genetic structure within plots was analysed using spatial autocorrelation analyses. No significant clustering of similar genotypes was detected in either species when redundant samples from the same genets were culled from the data sets. In contrast, strong clustering was detected in R. vesiculosus when all samples were analysed, but not in R. vinicolor. These results demonstrate that isolation by distance does not occur in either species at the intraplot sampling scale and that clonal propagation (vegetative growth) is significantly more prevalent in R. vesiculosus than in R. vinicolor. Significant genetic differentiation was detected between some of the plots and appeared greater in the more clonal species R. vesiculosus with Phi(ST) values ranging from 0.010 to 0.078*** than in R. vinicolor with Phi(ST) values ranging from -0.002 to 0.022** (*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001). When tested against the null hypothesis of no relationship between individuals, parentage analysis detected seven likely parent/offspring pairs in R. vinicolor and four in R. vesiculosus (alpha = 0.001). Of these 11 possible parent/offspring pairs, only two R. vinicolor pairs were still supported as parent/offspring when tested against the alternative hypothesis of being full siblings (alpha = 0.05). In the latter two cases, parent and offspring were located at approximately 45 m and 28 m from each other. Challenges to parentage analysis in ectomycorrhizal fungi are discussed.     

Concordant preferences for opposite-sex signals? Human pheromones and facial characteristics.

We have investigated whether preferences for masculine and feminine characteristics are correlated across two modalities, olfaction and vision. In study 1, subjects rated the pleasantness of putative male (4,16-androstadien-3-one; 5alpha-androst-16-en-3-one) and female (1,3,5 (10),16-estratetraen-3-ol) pheromones, and chose the most attractive face shape from a masculine-feminine continuum for a long- and a short-term relationship. Study 2 replicated study 1 and further explored the effects of relationship context on pheromone ratings. For long-term relationships, women's preferences for masculine face shapes correlated with ratings of 4,16-androstadien-3-one and men's preferences for feminine face shapes correlated with ratings of 1,3,5(10),16-estratetraen-3-ol. These studies link sex-specific preferences for putative human sex pheromones and sexually dimorphic facial characteristics. Our findings suggest that putative sex pheromones and sexually dimorphic facial characteristics convey common information about the quality of potential mates.     

A sheep cannulation model for evaluation of nasal vaccine delivery

We have developed and validated a novel model to investigate the efficacy of nasal vaccine delivery. Based on lymphatic cannulation of the tracheal lymph trunk of sheep, the model allows collection of lymph draining from the Nasal Associated Lymphoid Tissue. The model is suitable for determining both the amount of material that is absorbed into the lymphatic system, following intra-nasal delivery and the immune response that occurs following vaccination into the nasal area. The cell populations that track in this duct were phenotyped and found to be similar to those previously reported to be present in efferent lymph draining from peripheral lymph nodes. Following intra-nasal spray, we demonstrated that the amount of material recovered in draining lymph is only a very small fraction of the total delivered. Nevertheless, intra-nasal spraying of a vaccine could activate local immune cells. The method described will be invaluable for optimising intra-nasal delivery systems by allowing a separate optimisation of vaccine uptake and immune responses induction.     

Golgi Disruption and Early Embryonic Lethality in Mice Lacking USO1

Golgins are a family of long rod-like proteins characterized by the presence of central coiled-coil domains. Members of the golgin family have important roles in membrane trafficking, where they function as tethering factors that capture transport vesicles and facilitate membrane fusion. Golgin family members also have essential roles in maintaining the organization of the Golgi apparatus. Knockdown of individual golgins in cultured cells resulted in the disruption of the Golgi structure and the dispersal of Golgi marker proteins throughout the cytoplasm. However, these cellular phenotypes have not always been recapitulated in vivo. For example, embryonic development proceeds much further than expected and Golgi disruption was observed in only a subset of cell types in mice lacking the ubiquitously expressed golgin GMAP-210. Cell-type specific functional compensation among golgins may explain the absence of global cell lethality when a ubiquitously expressed golgin is missing. In this study we show that functional compensation does not occur for the golgin USO1. Mice lacking this ubiquitously expressed protein exhibit disruption of Golgi structure and early embryonic lethality, indicating that USO1 is indispensable for early embryonic development.