On the multivariate analysis of avian vocalizations

In a recent paper in this journal, Sparling & Williams (1978) demonstrated several multivariate techniques by applying them to measurements of albatross calls. Their paper contains a useful summary of the literature, but includes several misleading interpretations of the analyses. Since the stated purpose of that article was to familiarize biologists with proper uses of the statistical methods, it is important to clarify the problems, some of which I discuss below. I then mention how such techniques are likely to be particularly valuable in the near future, when coupled with real-time sound spectrum analysis.     

Bacterial productivity in the water column and sediments of the Georgia (USA) coastal zone: Estimates via direct counting and parallel measurement of thymidine incorporation

Three methods of estimating bacterial productivity were compared using parallel samples of Atlantic Ocean water (within 0.25–15 km of the Georgia coast). The frequency-of-dividing cells (FDC) method and the [³H]thymidine incorporation method gave results which were strongly correlated (r=0.97), but the FDC estimates were always higher (X2 to X7) than the [³H]thymidine estimates. Estimates of bacterial productivity ranged from 2–4×10⁸ cells·l^–1·h^–1 at 0.25 km from shore to 1–9×10⁷cells·l^–1·h^–1 at 15 km. A method involving incubation of 3-m filtrates and direct counting gave results that could not be easily translated into estimates of bacterial productivity. Application of the FDC method to sediment samples gave high productivity estimates, which could be not reconciled with productivity estimates based on sediment oxygen uptake.     

Isolation of an aggregation inhibitory factor from non-adhesive mouse teratoma cells

An aggregation inhibitory factor (AIF) has been extracted from mouse ascites teratoma cells (that do not aggregate in culture) that retards adhesion of cultured teratoma cells of the same cell line (that do aggregate). Preliminary characterization of AIF on polyacrylamide gels suggests that AIF is a protein composed of four subunits. Extraction of AIF from ascites teratoma cells was accomplished without significant loss of viability by a technique involving the application of an electric field to large numbers of whole cells suspended in a hypertonic electrode buffer. In tests of adhesion, AIF consistently and immediately inhibited aggregation of cultured teratoma cells after 5, 10, 15, and 30 min of incubation. Furthermore, a reduced concentration of AIF resulted in a corresponding decrease in inhibition, suggesting a concentration-dependent action. AIF may help explain how cultured teratoma cells adhere, whereas ascites teratoma cells of the same subline do not adhere.     

Individual variation of nucleoside triphosphate pyrophosphohydrolase activity in human erythrocytes,granulocytes, lymphocytes,and platelets

Analysis of the nucleoside triphosphate pyrophosphohydrolase specific activity of red cells obtained from a random Caucasian population indicated at least two subclasses. The specific activity of 18% of the population ranged from undetectable activity to 27.5 nmol ITP cleaved/20 min/mg hemoglobin. The remainder of the population had higher activity, 27.5–125 nmoles ITP cleaved/20 min/mg hemoglobin. The variation of NTPH activity evident in the red cells of an individual is reflected in granulocytes, lymphocytes, and platelets of that individual. Erythrocyte activity ranges from 0.7 to 21 units (nmol of ITP cleaved in 20 min)/10⁷ cells, granulocytes have 17–201 units/10⁷ cells, lymphocytes have 91–462 units/10⁷ cells, and platelets have 1.1–7.1 units/10⁷ platelets. These cell differences are discussed with respect to the hypothesis that NTPH prevents incorporation of ITP or dITP into nucleic acids.This work was supported by funds allocated by the Agricultural Experiment Station, Michigan State University. Michigan Agricultural Experiment Station Journal No. 8727.     

Heritability of Quasi-Continuous Skeletal Traits in a Randombred Population of House Mice

Heritabilities of 11 quasi-continuous skeletal traits were estimated in randombred house mice of three separate ages (1, 3, and 5 months). Three separate methods—regression, maximum likelihood correlation, and Falconer's Method—were used to obtain heritabilities for each of the separate age groups. Significant differences in the incidences of seven of the skeletal traits were found among ages, but they did not affect the heritability estimates, these estimates being pooled over ages. Heritabilities calculated from female parents were consistently higher (by about 13%) than those from male parents, indicating the presence of maternal effects. Mid-parent estimates made by all three methods gave very similar mean levels (0.17 — 0.20). Although low, this level compared favorably with that expected on the basis of previously estimated rates of accumulation of genetic variance. Maternal effects estimated from full sib correlations averaged 0.08.     

Pentobarbital anesthesia: Lack of effect on venous prostaglandins in dogs

Venous prostaglandins A, E, and F were determined by radioimmunoassay in 10 dogs before and one hour after administration of sodium pentobarbital (35 mg/Kg, iv). In the conscious state, PGA was 0.34 ± 0.04 ng/ml (mean ± SE), PGE 0.20 ± 0.01 ng/ml, and PGF 0.25 ± 0.03 ng/ml. During pentobarbital anesthesia, these levels were unchanged (p >0.05). Thus, pentobarbital anesthesia had no effect on peripheral venous prostaglandin levels.     

Quantitative aspects of hormone-receptor interactions of high affinity: Effect of receptor concentration and measurement of dissociation constants of labeled and unlabeled hormones

It is demonstrated that because of limitations in the magnitude of the specific activity of radiolabeled hormone derivatives, direct binding studies of hormone-receptor interactions of high affinity (10^?9–10^?11 M, depending on whether ³H- or ¹²³I-labeled hormones are used) will be subject to artifactual distortions due to the need to utilize high concentrations of the receptor. If the concentration of the receptor is not ten times lower than the true affinity constant, the apparent dissociation constant obtained from direct concentration binding curves will vary as a linear function of the receptor concentration. In addition, at high receptor concentrations saturability becomes difficult to demonstrate experimentally and the binding data yield apparently non-hyperbolic, sigmoidal curves which can be mistakenly interpreted to depict cooperative interactions. Similar artifacts related to receptor concentration are predicted for measurements of the hormone concentration dependence of biological processes (e.g. activation of adenylate cyclase, transport processes, etc.). Methods for detecting these effects, and correctly measuring affinities for labeled and unlabeled hormones under these conditions, are described. The implications for measuring the binding properties of hormone-receptor interactions are discussed, especially in reference to studies of the comparative analysis of receptor function in altered metabolic states and to studies relating the biological and binding properties of hormones.