Reconciling international human rights and cultural relativism: the case of female circumcision

How can we reconcile, in a non-ethnocentric fashion, the enforcement of international, universal human rights standards with the protection of cultural diversity? Examining this question, taking the controversy over female circumcision as a case study, this article will try to bridge the gap between the traditional anthropological view that human rights are non-existent -- or completely relativised to particular cultures -- and the view of Western naturalistic philosophers (including Lockeian philosophers in the natural rights tradition, and Aquinas and neo-Thomists in the natural law tradition) that they are universal -- simply derived from a basic human nature we all share. After briefly defending a universalist conception of human rights, the article will provide a critique of female circumcision as a human rights violation by three principal means: by an internal critique of the practice using the condoning cultures' own functionalist criteria; by identifying supra-national norms the cultures subscribe to which conflict with the practice; and by the identification of traditional and novel values in the cultures, conducive to those norms. Through this analysis, it will be seen that cultural survival, diversity and flourishing need not be incompatible with upholding international, universal human rights standards.     

IL-1α and TNFα act synergistically to stimulate production of myeloid colony-stimulating factors by cultured human bone marrow stromal cells and cloned stromal cell strains

Human bone marrow stromal cells repond to stimulation by the monokines IL-1 and TNF by producing colony-stimulating factors such as GM-CSF and G-CSF. In this study we show that IL-1α and TNFα act synergistically to stimulate GM-CSF and G-CSF production by cultured marrow stromal cells. We further show that IL-1α and TNFα synergistically stimulate production of GM-CSF and G-CSF by a clonal stroma-derived cell strain. Although IL-1 and TNF share many of the same biological activities, we show that IL-1α and TNFα have an unequal ability to induce myeloid-CSF production by both cultures, with IL-1α being the more potent inducer. We found that induction by IL-1α and TNFα was independent of cell proliferation. The effect of IL-1α and TNFα on production of the two myeloid-CSFs by the clonal cells was significantly greater than the unfractionated passaged stromal cultures, having the greater effect on G-CSF production. The clonally derived stromal cells constitutively produced colony-stimulating activity, in particular GM-CSF, at levels easily detected by ELISA. These findings show that, in addition to the overlapping and additive activities of IL-1α and TNFα, they can interact synergistically. Our findings further suggest that a small subpopulation of stroma cells may be the major producer of G-CSF in the marrow microenvironment during immune response. © 1994 wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Genomic structure,expression and evolution of the alfalfa aspartate aminotransferase genes

Genomic clones encoding two isozymes of aspartate aminotransferase (AAT) were isolated from an alfalfa genomic library and their DNA sequences were determined. The AAT1 gene contains 12 exons that encode a cytosolic protein expressed at similar levels in roots, stems and nodules. In nodules, the amount of AAT1 mRNA was similar at all stages of development, and was slightly reduced in nodules incapable of fixing nitrogen. The AAT1 mRNA is polyadenylated at multiple sites differing by more than 250 bp. The AAT2 gene contains 11 exons, with 5 introns located in positions identical to those found in animal AAT genes, and encodes a plastid-localized isozyme. The AAT2 mRNA is polyadenylated at a very limited range of sites. The transit peptide of AAT2 is encoded by the first two and part of the third exon. AAT2 mRNA is much more abundant in nodules than in other organs, and increases dramatically during the course of nodule development. Unlike AAT1, expression of AAT2 is significantly reduced in nodules incapable of fixing nitrogen. Phylogenetic analysis of deduced AAT proteins revealed 4 separate but related groups of AAT proteins; the animal cytosolic AATs, the plant cytosolic AATs, the plant plastid AATs, and the mitochondrial AATs.     

Intraprotoplasmic feruloylation of arabinoxylans in Festuca arundinacea cell cultures

Graminaceous primary cell walls contain polysaccharides to which are esterified feruloyl residues. Ester biosynthesis is highly specific and the present experiments were performed to ascertain the likely site of feruloylation in living grass cell cultures. Cell cultures of tall fescue grass (Festuca arundinacea Schreber) incorporated exogenous l-[1-³H]arabinose into polymers at a linear rate after a short lag of approx. 1–3 min. Radiolabelled polymers did not start to accumulate in the culture medium until 20–35 min after [³H]arabinose was supplied. However, polymer-bound feruloyl-arabinose residues began to accumulate ³H after a lag of 1–3 min. Assuming that the onset of secretion of radiolabelled polymers into the medium indicates the time before which essentially all the radiolabel was internal to the plasma membrane, the results show that the polysaccharide-bound [³H]arabinose residues must have been feruloylated within the protoplast.Abbreviations AIR alcohol-insoluble residue - BAW butan1-ol/acetic acid/water (12:3:5 by volume) - BEW butan-1-ol/ ethanol/water (20:5:11 by volume) - EPW ethyl acetate/pyridine/ water (8:2:1 by volume) - R_Ara Chromatographic mobility relative to that of l-arabinose We are very grateful to Mr. Gundolf Wende for assistance with the characterisation of the feruloyl esters. K.E.M. is funded by a studentship from the Science and Engineering Research Council in collaboration with Zeneca Agrochemicals.     

Jasmonic acid spraying does not induce tuberisation in short-day-requiring potato species kept in non-inducing conditions

The potato species Solanum andigena (Juz. and Buk.) and Solanum demissum (Lindl.) that both require short days for tuberisation were kept in either long days (16 h light), or short days (8 h light) with a 30-min night break mid-way through the dark period. Tuberisation of these species was inhibited under both conditions. Repeated spraying of these plants with up to 100 μM jasmonic acid did not induce them to tuberise even though jasmonic acid was shown to be taken up and transported within the plant. This result argues against jasmonic acid itself being the transported tuber-inducing signal, although it does not exclude a role for jasmonic acid later in tuber formation and development once induction has taken place.     

Relationship between osmoprotection and the structure and intracellular accumulation of betaines by Escherichia coli

Abstract Naturally occuring betaines, especially glycine betaine and proline betaine, were accumulated by Escherichia coli from urine. In synthetic hyperosmotic medium, with an homologous series of added betaines, (CH₃)₃N⁺-(CH₂) _n -COO⁻, osmoprotective activity and intracellular accumulation decreased monotonically as n increased from 1 to 5. In contrast, α -substituted glycine betaines were accumulated in a similar manner to glycine betaine, but with different osmoprotective activities. Arsenobetaine, with a quaternary arsonium group, was also accumulated but amino acids which can become negatively charged in a chemically basic environment were not.     

The Effects of Surfactants on Lipase-Catalysed Hydrolysis of Esters: Activities and Stereoselectivity

The effect of surfactants on the hydrolysis of prochiral and chiral substrates by crude and purified porcine pancreatic lipase (PPL, EC 3.1.1.3)) has been studied. Rather than accelerating the reactions, surfactants slowed down (“inhibited”) the reactions relative to the rate in the absence of surfactant. Surfactants varied in the extent to which the reaction was inhibited. With the crude enzyme there was a correlation between degree of inhibition and the optical purity of the product of hydrolysis of an achiral diester substrate 1. There was no special effect associated with use of surfactants in the concentration range corresponding to critical micelle formation, nor was there any increase in rate of reaction when stable emulsions were formed by using mixtures of surfactants to generate an appropriate hydrophile-lipophile (HLB) balance. A study of the effect of sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) on the hydrolysis of the diester 1 by crude PPL showed that the rate of the reaction steadily decreased with increasing surfactant concentration, but that the optical purity of the product first fell and then rose gain, an effect attributed to the differential denaturing action of the surfactant on at least three hydrolytic enzymes. In general, there would seem to be no advantage to be gained from the use of surfactants in the hydrolysis by PPL of compounds of low water solubility; the use of an immiscible co-solvent is more effective.     

Altered free calcium transients in pig kidney cells (LLC-PK1) cultured with penicillin/streptomycin

Summary The effect of a conventional antibiotic (penicillin/streptomycin) mixture on the widely used kidney epithelial cell line, LLC-PK₁, was investigated by measuring growth and intracellular free calcium. Free calcium concentration was the same in cells cultured for 3 to 7 wk with (“plus”) and without (“minus”) antibiotics both at rest and when challenged with high (14 mM) external calcium. When exposed to vasopressin, minus cells exhibited significantly smaller calcium transients than plus cells. A similar difference existed for transients elicited by a calcium ionophore, 4-br-A23187. After longer periods of culture (>20 wk), minus cells grew slower than plus cells but on reaching confluence (minus cells took 1 day longer) the morphologies and viabilities were indistinguishable. The finding that culture with penicillin/streptomycin reversibly modified some properties of LLC-PK₁ cells, at least partly through altered calcium homeostasis, is of importance for workers using this cell model to study drug effects and raises the general possibility of similar effects on other cultured cells.     

Simple electromyographic biofeedback treatment for chronic pediatric constipation/encopresis: Preliminary report

Pediatric constipation/encopresis is thought to be due, in part, to paradoxical constriction of the external anal sphincter (EAS) muscle during attempted defecation. This inappropriate contraction can lead to delayed, impacted, painful, and infrequent bowel movements. Standard Medical Care (SMC) involves disimpaction with enemas, followed by laxative therapy and diet modification, to maintain frequent soft stools. Using the case control method, the efficacy of SMC alone was compared with SMC plus EAS electromyographic biofeedback aimed at eliminating paradoxical contraction. Thirteen consecutive chronically constipated children received SMC plus biofeedback, and were compared with 13 age- and sex-matched children who received only SMC. Biofeedback subjects demonstrated post-treatment elimination of EAS paradoxical constriction. At 16 months follow-up parents of biofeedback children reported significantly greater improvement in constipation, encopresis, laxative use, and painful bowel movements compared to SMC.This research report was supported by the NIH under grant No. RO1 HD 28160.     

Effect of Inhibitors of Eicosanoid Metabolism on Release of [3H]Noradrenaline from the Human Neuroblastoma, SH-SY5Y

Abstract: Nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA; a lipoxygenase inhibitor), LY-270766 (an inhibitor of 5-lipoxygenase), and the diacylglycerol lipase inhibitor RG 80267 completely eliminated potassium-evoked release of [³H]noradrenaline ([³H]NA) from the human neuroblastoma clone SH-SY5Y with IC₅₀ values of 10, 15, and 30 μ M , respectively. In contrast, these inhibitors only partially inhibited carbachol-evoked release and had little effect on the calcium ionophore A23187-evoked release of NA in this cell line. Arachidonic acid partially inhibited potassium- and A23187-evoked release but did not reverse the inhibition of potassium-evoked release observed in the presence of RG 80267. These studies suggest that arachidonic acid (or its lipoxygenase products) are not important intermediates in the regulation of exocytosis in SH-SY5Y. This conclusion is strengthened by our studies in which SH-SY5Y cells were grown in medium supplemented with bovine serum albumin-linoleic acid (50 μ M ). Under these conditions there was a selective increase in content of membrane polyunsaturated fatty acids of the ω6 series, including arachidonic acid; however, these changes did not effect potassium-, veratridine-, carbachol-, or calcium ionophoreevoked release of [³H]NA.