Although there is a consensus that mitochondrial function is somehow linked to the aging process, the exact role played by mitochondria in this process remains unresolved. The discovery that reduced activity of the mitochondrial enzyme CLK-1/MCLK1 (also known as COQ7) extends lifespan in both
Caenorhabditis elegans and mice has provided a genetic model to test mitochondrial theories of aging. We have recently shown that the mitochondria of young, long-lived,
Mclk1
+/− mice are dysfunctional, exhibiting reduced energy metabolism and a substantial increase in oxidative stress. Here we demonstrate that this altered mitochondrial condition in young animals paradoxically results in an almost complete protection from the age-de pend ent loss of mitochondrial function as well as in a significant attenuation of the rate of development of oxidative biomarkers of aging. Moreover, we show that reduction in MCLK1 levels can also gradually prevent the deterioration of mitochondrial function and associated increase of global oxidative stress that is normally observed in
Sod2+/− mutants. We hypothesize that the mitochondrial dysfunction observed in young
Mclk1+/− mutants induces a physiological state that ultimately allows for their slow rate of aging. Thus, our study provides for a unique vertebrate model in which an initial alteration in a specific mitochondrial function is linked to long term beneficial effects on biomarkers of aging and, furthermore, provides for new evidence which indicates that mitochondrial oxidative stress is not causal to aging.Because it is well known that the aging process is characterized by declines in basal metabolic rate and in the general performance of energy-dependent processes, many aging studies have focused on mitochondria because of their central role in producing chemical energy (ATP) by oxidative phosphorylation (
1). Among the various theories of aging that have been proposed, the mitochondrial oxidative stress theory of aging is the most widely acknowledged and studied (
2–
4). It is based on the observation that mitochondrial energy metabolism produces reactive oxygen species (ROS),
2 that mitochondrial components are damaged by ROS, that mitochondrial function is progressively lost during aging, and that the progressive accumulation of global oxidative damage is strongly correlated with the aged phenotype. However, the crucial question of whether these facts mean that mitochondrial dysfunction and the related ROS production cause aging remains unproven (
5–
7). Furthermore, recent observations made in various species, including mammals, have begun to directly challenge this hypothesis, notably by relating oxidative stress to long (
8) or increased (
9) lifespans, by demonstrating that overexpression of the main antioxidant enzymes does not extend lifespan (
10) as well as by showing that mitochondrial dysfunction could protect against age-related diseases (
11).A direct and powerful approach to attempt to clarify this major question and to test the theory is to characterize the mitochondrial function of long-lived mutants (
12). CLK-1/MCLK1 is an evolutionary conserved protein (
13) and has been found to be located in the mitochondria of yeast (
14), worms (
15), and mice (
16). The inactivation of the
Caenorhabditis elegans gene
clk-1 substantially increases lifespan (
17). Moreover, the elimination of one functional allele of its murine orthologue also resulted in an extended longevity for
Mclk1+/− mice in three distinct genetic backgrounds (
18). These findings have provided for an evolutionarily conserved pathways of animal aging that is affected by the function of a mitochondrial protein (
19,
20). In mitochondria CLK1/MCLK1 acts as an hydroxylase and is implicated in the biosynthesis of ubiquinone (coenzyme Q or UQ), a lipid-like molecule primarily known as an electron carrier in the mitochondrial respiratory chain and as a membrane antioxidant but which is also associated with an increasing number of different aspects of cellular metabolism (
20,
21). Taken together, these observations indicate that the long-lived
Mclk1+/− mouse is a model of choice for the understanding of the links between mitochondrial energy metabolism, oxidative stress, and the aging process in mammals.Previous analysis of
Mclk1+/− mice, which show the expected reduction of MCLK1 protein levels (
22), have revealed that their tissues as well as their mitochondria contain normal levels of UQ at 3 months of age (
23). Yet the same study also revealed a host of phenotypes induced by
Mclk1 heterozygosity (see below). Thus, it appears that MCLK1 has an additional function that is unrelated to UQ biosynthesis but responsible for the phenotypes observed in young
Mclk1+/− mutants. This is consistent with several results from nematodes which also strongly suggest that CLK-1 has other functions (
24,
25).In depth characterization of the phenotype of young
Mclk1+/− mutants has revealed that the reduction of MCLK1 levels in these animals profoundly alters their mitochondrial function despite the fact that UQ production is unaffected (
23). In fact, we have shown that
Mclk1 heterozygosity induces a severe impairment of mitochondrial energy metabolism as revealed by a reduction in the rates of mitochondrial electron transport and oxygen consumption as well as in ATP synthesis and ATP levels in both the mitochondria and the whole cell. ATP levels in several organs were surprisingly strongly affected with, for example, a 50% reduction of overall cellular ATP levels in the livers of
Mclk1+/− mutants (
23). Moreover, we have found that the
Mclk1+/− mice sustain high mitochondrial oxidative stress by a variety of measurements, including aconitase activity, protein carbonylation, and ROS production (
23). Additionally, we have shown that this early mitochondrial dysfunction is associated with a reduction in some aspects of cytosolic oxidative damage and global oxidative stress that can be measured via recognized plasma biomarkers such as 8-isoprostanes and 8-hydroxy-2-deoxyguanosine (8-OHdG). Considering that the accumulation of global oxidative damage is known to be tightly linked to the aging process (
26), this latter result suggests that the anti-aging effect triggered by low MCLK1 levels might already act at a young age.To further investigate the
clk-1/Mclk1-dependent mechanism of aging as well as to try to elucidate the still unclear relation between mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, and aging, we have now carefully analyzed the evolution of the phenotype of
Mclk1+/− mutants over time. We have also studied the effects of reduced MCLK1 levels on the phenotype of mice heterozygous for the mitochondrial superoxide dismutase (
Sod2), which represent a well known model of mitochondrial oxidative stress (
27). In addition of confirming the long lifespan phenotype of the
Mclk1+/− mutants in a mixed background (129S6 x BALB/c), we also report here a study of mutants and controls on a completely isogenic background where we find that the condition of
Mclk1+/− mutants unexpectedly results in protection against the age-dependent loss of mitochondrial function. Moreover, we found that the mutants are characterized by a significant attenuation of the age-associated increase in global oxidative stress normally observed in mammals. We also show that the
Mclk1+/− condition can gradually reverse the deterioration of mitochondrial function and the associated increase of global oxidative stress that is normally observed in
Sod2+/− mutants. Thus, this study provides for a unique vertebrate model in which reduced levels of a specific mitochondrial protein causes early mitochondrial dysfunction but has long term beneficial effects that slow down the rate of aging, as established with appropriate biomarkers, and can ultimately prolong lifespan in mice. Furthermore, in line with recent studies that have raised doubts about the validity of the mitochondrial oxidative stress theory of aging (
4,
8,
10), our results, which relate to a recognized long-lived mice model, represent a novel and crucial indication that mitochondrial oxidative stress might not by itself be causal to aging.
相似文献