WHEN DOES POTENTIALITY COUNT? A COMMENT ON LOCKWOOD

Michael Lockwood's essay, "Warnock v. Powell (and Harradine): when does potentiality count?," and Hare's response are two of three articles in this issue of Bioethics discussing potentiality and its implications for experimentation with human embryos. (See also Stephen Buckle's "Arguing from potential.") Hare responds to Lockwood's arguments on potential, an embryo's "interests," and what obligations these interests entail. In Hare's view, the interests are those of the grown person the embryo (or fetus or neonate) will become. In formulating regulations on embryo research, legislators ought to be concerned chiefly with the interests of the persons who may come into existence, grading harms differently for gametes, embryos, fetuses, and neonates, and balancing these against the expected good from the experiments.     

Developmental expression of 44-kDa bone phosphoprotein (osteopontin) and bone γ-carboxyglutamic acid (Gla)-containing protein (osteocalcin) in calcifying tissues of rat

New aspects of the distribution and developmental appearance of the 44-kDa bone phosphoprotein (44K BPP, also called sialoprotein I or osteopontin) and bone gamma-carboxyglutamic acid (Gla)-containing protein (BGP, also called osteocalcin) during osteogenesis and dentinogenesis were investigated with immunocytochemical techniques using monospecific, affinity-purified polyclonal antibodies. Sections from newborn rat incisors and from various bone anlagen of newborn animals and fetuses were processed for detection of 44K BPP or BGP antigenicity. In addition, histochemical reactions for detection of alkaline phosphatase or calcium salts were performed on a number of the sections. The 44K BPP appears to be synthesized and secreted by chondrocytes only in the areas of cartilage-to-bone transition; these cells could participate indirectly in the process of bone formation by providing a suitable scaffold onto which primary marrow osteoblasts attach and spread. During osteogenesis, 44K BPP is found in bone-forming cells almost concomitantly with the appearance of alkaline phosphatase and before osteoid deposition, whereas BGP is still absent during early stages of mineralization. We hypothesize that this dramatic difference between the developmental appearance of 44K BPP and BGP reflects the delayed expression of the BGP gene relative to that of 44K BPP. In long-term cultures of bone marrow from adult mice, some fibroblastic cells expressed the 44K BPP phenotype; these cells could represent early osteogenic progenitor cells. Some experiments also suggested that, as with BGP, 44K BPP or an immunologically related protein is synthesized by some odontoblasts and secreted into predentin, prior to the onset of mineralization.     

Segmental release of amino acid neurotransmitters from transcranial stimulation

The present study used microdialysis techniques in an intact rabbit model to measure the release of amino acids within the lumbar spinal cord in response to transcranial electrical stimulation. Dialysis samples from the extracellular space were obtained over a stimulation period of 90 minutes and were examined using high pressure liquid chromatography. Neuronal excitation was verified by recerding corticomotor evoked potentials (CMEPs) from the spinal cord. A significant increase in the release of glycine and taurine compared to sham animals was measured after 90 minutes of transcranial stimulation. Glutamate and aspartate release was not significantly elevated. GABA concentrations were consistently low. CMEP components repeatedly showed adequate activation of descending fiber pathways and segmental interneuron pools during dialysis sampling. Since glycine, and to a lesser extent taurine, have been shown to inhibit motor neuron activity and are closely associated with segmental interneuron pools, suprasegmental modulation of motor activity may be, in part, through these inhibitory amino acid neurotransmitters in the rabbit lumbar spinal cord.     

Margaret Mead and Samoa: Coming of Age in Fact and Fiction

Derek Freeman's 1983 critique of Margaret Mead's Coming of Age in Samoa has prompted one of the most heated debates in recent anthropological memory. Yet even Mead's defenders have generally accepted the view that she saw Samoa as a romantic paradise. Here I argue that a careful reading of Coming of Age shows quite a different picture. In my reanalysis, Mead's work emerges as complex and somewhat enigmatic, with facile conclusions standing in contrast to much rich and sensitive ethnography. My goal in this article is to highlight what Mead actually said, pointing up the notable discrepancy between the popular perception and her actual account.     

On the Divergence of Alleles in Nested Subsamples from Finite Populations

Within-population variation at the DNA level will rarely be studied by sequencing of loci of randomly chosen individuals. Instead, individuals will usually be chosen for sequencing based on some knowledge of their genotype. Data collected in this way require new sampling theory. Motivated by these observations, we have examined the sampling properties of a finite population model with two mutation processes and with no selection or recombination. One mutation process generates new alleles according to an infinite-alleles model, and the other generates polymorphisms at sites according to an infinite-sites model. A sample of n genes is considered. The stationary distribution of the number of segregating sites in a subsample from one of the allelic classes in the sample conditional on the allelic configuration of the sample is studied. A recursive scheme is developed to compute the moments of this distribution, and it is shown that the distribution is functionally independent of the number of additional alleles in the sample and their respective frequencies in the sample. For the case in which the sample contains only two alleles, the distribution of the number of segregating sites in a subsample containing both alleles conditional on the sample frequencies of the alleles is studied. The results are applied to the analysis of DNA sequences of two alleles found at the Adh locus of Drosophila melanogaster. No significant departure from the neutral model is detected.