QALYs, age and fairness

... We can therefore conclude that either we should go for equality; and in that case QALYs are unfair because they haven't got enough of an ageist bias. Or we should accept consequentialism; and in that case QALYs have just the right sort of ageist bias. No plausible case can, however, be made for the claim that QALYs have an unfair bias against old people. Other things being equal we ought when distributing resources essential for survival favour the young. This ethical claim can be supported both by reference to equality (the life-time-view) and by reference to consequentialism (and the premises that resources generally will be more useful when given to young people).     

The problem of natural antibodies, 1894–1905

As we have seen, natural antibodies first emerged as an experimental phenomenon without a plausible theoretical explanation. They were originally denied the status of antibody; then, adjustments to the side-chain theory transformed them from a curiosity into a foundation of the theory. However, in accommodating natural antibodies, Ehrlich had opened several holes in his mechanism of antibody formation.Thus, by 1905, natural antibodies were clearly established as problematic. From the practical standpoint, it seemed unwise to maintain an identity between normal and immune antibodies, given the therapeutic differences in their avidity. With the decline of Ehrlich's theory of antibody formation and the spread of Landsteiner's hapten technique for the production of antibodies against artificial antigens after World War I, the theoretical possibility of their existence as other than anomaly seemed more remote than ever. However, outside the theory and despite clinical considerations, natural antibodies remained a perplexing experimental phenomenon.⁴⁹     

Carrier-Mediated Uptake of Abscisic Acid by Suspension-Cultured Amaranthus tricolor Cells

Abscisic acid (ABA) uptake by Amaranthus tricolor cell suspensions was found to include both a nonsaturable component and a saturable part with K_m of 3.74 ± 0.43 micromolar and an apparent V_max of 1.5 ± 0.12 nanomoles per gram per minute. These kinetic parameters as well as the uptake by intact cells at 0°C or by frozen and thawed cells, are consistent with operation of a saturable carrier. This carrier-mediated ABA uptake was partially energized by ΔpH: it increased as the external pH was lowered to pH 4.0; it decreased after the lowering of the ΔpH by the proton ionophore carbonylcyanide-m-chlorophenylhydrazone or after the altering of metabolically maintained pH gradient by metabolic inhibitors (KCN, oligomycin). The carrier is specific for ABA among the plant growth regulators tested, is unaffected by (RS)-trans-ABA and was inhibited by (S)-ABA, (R)-ABA, and also by the ABA analog LAB 173711.     

Oxidation of spermine by an amine oxidase from lentil seedlings

Spermine is a substrate of lentil (Lens culinaris) seedling amine oxidase and the oxidation products are reversible inactivators of the enzyme. The spermine is oxidized at the terminal amino groups to a dialdehyde: 2 moles of hydrogen peroxide and 2 moles of ammonia per mole of spermine are formed. The pH optimum of the enzyme with spermine is 7.9 in TI-HCI buffer; the K_m value is 4.4·10⁻⁴ molar, similar to that found with other substrates (putrescine and spermidine).     

Growth and Photosynthetic Characteristics of Solanum tuberosum Plantlets Cultivated in Vitro in Different Conditions of Aeration, Sucrose Supply, and CO(2) Enrichment

Growth characteristics, oxygen exchange, and carbohydrate and chlorophyll contents were determined 30 days after subculturing of single node-derived plantlets of Solanum tuberosum cv Haig cultivated in vitro. Cultivation conditions were: (a) photomixotrophy in closed vessel, (b) photomixotrophy in closed vessel on medium supplemented with silver thiosulfate, (c) photomixotrophy in aerated vessel, (d) photoautotrophy in air, (e) photoautotrophy in CO₂-enriched air. In photomixotrophic conditions, aeration of the vessel enhanced sucrose utilization and had a positive effect on plantlet growth. In photoautotrophic conditions, growth of the plantlets was slow in air and was strongly enhanced by CO₂ enrichment of the atmosphere. Starch to sucrose ratios were higher in plants grown photoautotrophically than in plants grown with sucrose in the medium. Oxygen exchange characteristics on a chlorophyll basis were similar between the plantlets when measured under moderate light, and resembled those of greenhouse plant leaves. In high light, however, plantlets grown photoautotrophically in a CO₂-enriched atmosphere had higher oxygen exchange rates. We concluded from these results that potato plantlets in vitro in conditions (c), (d), and (e) developed C3-plant photosynthetic characteristics, which were in photoautotrophically grown plantlets comparable to those of field-grown plants.     

Induction of transverse polarity by blue light: An all-or-none response

Phototropic stimulation induces a spatial memory. This was inferred from experiments with maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles involving opposing blue-light pulses, separated by variable time intervals, and rotation on a horizontal clinostat (Nick and Schafer, 1988b, Planta 175, 380-388). In those experiments, individual seedlings either curved towards the first or towards the second pulse, or they remained straight. Bending, if it occurred, seemed to be an all-or-none response. Intermediates, i.e. plants, bending only weakly, were not observed. In the first part of the present study it was attempted to create such intermediates. For this purpose the strength of the first, inducing, and the second, opposing, pulse was varied. The result was complex: (i) Individual seedlings maintained the all-or-none expression of spatial memory. (ii) However, on the level of the whole population, the time intervals at which a given response type dominated depended on the fluence ratio. (iii) Furthermore, the final curvature was determined by the fluence ratio. These results are discussed in terms of a blue-light-induced transverse polarity. This polarity initiates from a labile precursor, which can be reoriented by an opposing stimulation (indicated by the strong bending towards the second pulse). The strong curvatures towards the first pulse over long time intervals reveal that, eventually, the blue-light-induced transverse polarity becomes stabilised and thus immune to the counterpulse. In the second part of the study, the relation between phototropic transduction and transverse polarity was characterised by a phenomenological approach involving the following points: (i) Sensory adaptation for induction of transverse polarity disappears with a time course similar to that for phototropic sensory adaptatation. (ii) The fluence response for induction of transverse polarity is a saturation curve and not bell-shaped like the curve for phototropism (iii) For strong counterpulses and long time intervals the clinostat-elicited nastic response (Nick and Schafer 1989, Planta 179, 123-131) becomes manifest and causes an "aiming error" towards the caryopsis. (iv) Temperature-sensitivity of polarity induction was high in the first 20 min after induction, then dropped sharply and rose again with the approach of polarity fixation. (v) Stimulus-summation experiments indicated that, for different inducing fluences, the actual fixation of polarity happened at about 2 h after induction. These experiments point towards an early separation of the transduction chains mediating phototropism and transverse polarity, possibly before phototrophic asymmetry is formed.     

Level of Abscisic Acid in Integuments, Nucellus, Endosperm, and Embryo of Peach Seeds (Prunus persica L. cv Springcrest) during Development

Free abscisic acid (ABA) in integuments, nucellus, endosperm, and embryo was determined throughout seed development of peach (Prunus persica L. cv Springcrest). Quantification of ABA was performed using combined high performance liquid chromatography-radioimmunoassay based on a monoclonal antibody raised against free (S)-ABA. In the integuments and endosperm, ABA concentration remained constant during the first 100 days after anthesis and rose in the following days when fresh weight was rapidly decreasing. In the nucellus, the ABA concentration variation pattern paralleled that of tissue growth. ABA concentration in the embryo increased constantly with the growth of the tissues to reach a maximum at the last growth stage. The role of ABA in peach seeds is discussed in relation to the development of the different seed tissues.     

Study of glucose starvation in excised maize root tips

Excised maize (Zea mays) root tips were used to follow the effects of a prolonged glucose starvation. Respiration rate began to decrease immediately after excision, reaching 30 to 40% of its initial value after 20 hours, and then declined more slowly until death of the tissues, which occurred after 200 hours of starvation. During the whole process, respiration could be uncoupled by 2,4-dinitrophenol and the energy charge remained high. These results suggest that in excised maize root tips, respiration rate is essentially limited by the rate of biosyntheses (ATP-utilizing processes) rather than mitochondrial number. During starvation the sugar content sharply decreased for the first 20 hours and reached zero at 120 hours. Following root excision, proteins and lipids were continuously degraded and were virtually the only substrates for respiration and biosyntheses after 20 hours of starvation. Over the first 90 hours of starvation, enzymic activities related to sugar metabolic pathways and the Krebs cycle decreased to 20% or less of their initial activity. Starvation was reversible only for the first 80 to 90 hours. Between 80 and 100 hours, there was a sharp fall in intracellular osmolarity and a 25% loss in the dry weight. The irreversibility may be due, as in senescence, to a change in membrane selective permeability.     

Two Apoplastic alpha-Amylases Are Induced in Tobacco by Virus Infection

α-Amylase activity (EC 3.2. 1.1) is greatly increased in leaves of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Samsun NN) infected with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). The kinetics of enzyme induction during the hypersensitive reaction resemble those of other hydrolases known to be pathogenesis-related proteins of tobacco. Two α-amylases were purified from TMV-infected leaves and shown to have features in common with well-characterized pathogenesis-related proteins: they are acidic monomers that can be separated upon electrophoresis on basic native gels, and they are found in the apoplastic compartment of the cell. This extra-cellular localization was demonstrated by comparing the α-amylase partition between the intercellular wash fluid and the cell extract with that of proteins of known cellular compartmentalization. These data indicate an active secretion of both α-amylases produced in tobacco upon TMV infection.