Safety of Microorganisms Intended for Pest and Plant Disease Control: A Framework for Scientific Evaluation

Microorganisms are enormous but largely untapped natural resources for biological control of pests and diseases. There are two primary reasons for their underployment for pest or disease control: (1) the technical difficulties of using microorganisms for biological control, owing to a lack of fundamental information on them and their ecology, and (2) the costs of product development and regulatory approvals required for each strain, formulation, and use. Agriculture and forestry benefit greatly from the resident communities of microorganisms responsible for naturally occurring biological control of pest species, but additional benefits are achieved by introducing/applying them when or where needed. This can be done as (1) an inoculative release, (2) an augmentative application, or (3) an inundative application. Because of their specificity, different microbial biocontrol agents typically are needed to control different pests or the same pest in different environments. Four potential adverse effects are identified as safety issues (hazards) associated with the use of microorganisms for the biological control of plant pests and diseases. These are: (1) displacement of nontarget microorganisms, (2) allergenicity to humans and other animals, (3) toxigenicity to nontarget organisms, and (4) pathogenicity to nontarget organisms. Except for allergenicity, these are the same attributes that contribute to the efficacy of microbial biocontrol agents toward the target pest species. The probability of occurrence of a particular adverse nontarget effect of a microbial biocontrol agent may be a function of geographic origin or a specific trait genetically added or modified, but the safety issues are the still the same, including whether the microorganism intended for pest or disease control is indigenous, nonindigenous (imported and released), or genetically modified by traditional or recombinant DNA (rDNA) technology. Likewise, the probability of occurrence of a particular adverse nontarget effect may vary with method of application, e.g., whether as an aerosol, soil treatment, baits, or seed treatment, and may increase with increased scale of use, but the safety issues are still the same, including whether the microorganism is used for an inoculative release or augmentative or inundative application. Existing practices for managing microorganisms in the environment (e.g., plant pathogens,Rhizobium,plant inoculants) provide experience and options for managing the risks of microorganisms applied for pest and disease control. Moreover, experience to date indicates that any adverse nontarget effects, should they occur, are likely to be short-term or transitory effects that can, if significant, be eliminated by terminating use of the microbial biocontrol agent. In contrast, production agriculture as currently practiced, such as the use of tillage and crop rotations, has significant and long-term effects on nontarget organisms, including the intentional and unintentional displacement of microorganisms. Even the decision to leave plant pests and diseases unmanaged could have significant long-term environmental effects on nontarget organisms. Potential safety issues associated with the use of microbial biocontrol must therefore be properly identified and compared with the impact of other options for managing the pest or leaving the pest unmanaged. This paper provides a scientific framework for this process.     

Interactions of Gliocladium virens with Rhizoctonia solani and Pythium ultimum in Non-sterile Potting Medium

Interactions of Gliocladium virens with Pythium ultimum and Rhizoctonia solani under simulated in vivo conditions were observed microscopically. Different types of propagules of the three fungi were paired on nitrocellulose membranes and incubated at 25°C in non-sterile potting medium in Petri dishes for 1-5 days. Alginate-wheat bran prill were used as carriers for G. virens. Prill inoculated with G. virens and pre-incubated in potting medium for 3-5 days before placement on membranes did not inhibit the germination of Pythium sporangia, but subsequent Pythium growth was markedly stunted and distorted, with some hyphal collapse and cytoplasmic leakage. G. virens had no visible effect on older Pythium mycelium. Two to 5 days' growth of G. virens caused cytoplasmic leakage of Rhizoctonia mycelium, prevented secondary branching of hyphae and occasionally coiled around Rhizoctonia hyphae. Prill that were newly colonized by G. virens, but not prill pre-incubated for 3 or 5 days, stimulated the growth of Pythium mycelium and sporangia, Rhizoctonia mycelium and unprimed monilioid cells, probably by supplying nutrients. The timing of the interactions and their specificity for the different pathogen propagules were consistent with the production of gliotoxin by G. virens. This view was supported by in vitro experiments, in which pathogen propagules were incubated in a range of concentrations of gliotoxin in potato dextrose broth. Pythium sporangia and mycelium were inhibited by 1 or 2 μmg ml^-1, but Rhizoctonia monilioid cells and mycelium required 3-5 μmg ml^-1 for inhibition. At the lowest effective concentrations the inhibition was sometimes reversible, but propagules were killed at high concentrations of gliotoxin.     

Inertial vestibular coding of motion: concepts and evidence

Central processing of inertial sensory information about head attitude and motion in space is crucial for motor control. Vestibular signals are coded relative to a non-inertial system, the head, that is virtually continuously in motion. Evidence for transformation of vestibular signals from head-fixed sensory coordinates to gravity-centered coordinates have been provided by studies of the vestibulo-ocular reflex. The underlying central processing depends on otolith afferent information that needs to be resolved in terms of head translation related inertial forces and head attitude dependent pull of gravity. Theoretical solutions have been suggested, but experimental evidence is still scarce. It appears, along these lines, that gaze control systems are intimately linked to motor control of head attitude and posture.     

Large-bowel Perforations in Patients Undergoing Sigmoidoscopy and Barium Enema

Perforation of the large bowel can occur as a complication of sigmoidoscopy, rectal or sigmoid biopsy, and even of a simple cleansing enema. If the perforation is extraperitoneal there may be no early symptoms and consequently there may be delay in diagnosis. The risk of perforation during these procedures is small but it should not be ignored. The performance of a barium enema shortly after a rectal or sigmoid biopsy may slightly increase the risk by converting a partial perforation into a complete one. Precautions can be taken to minimize the hazard.     

Fine filaments in lymphatic endothelial cells

Several and various types of cells contain fine cytoplasmic filaments closely resembling the myofilaments of muscle cells (2, 18, 23, 24). In many of these cells and especially when cultured, it has been demonstrated that some of these filaments react with heavy meromyosin (HMM) in the same way as do the actin filaments of muscle cells (3, 6 7). This suggests that these filaments may be actinoid and form part of a contractile system. As fine intracytoplasmic filaments do occur in lymphatic endothelial cells (2, 14), we undertook an electron microscope investigation of their fine structure and their reaction on incubation with HMM and EDTA. We postulated that lymphatic endothelial cells possess a contractile filamentous system to which these filaments belong.     

The immunological response of CBA mice to Trypanosoma musculi: mechanisms of protective immunity

CBA mice which had recovered from infection with Trypanosoma musculi were immune to challenge with all strains of the homologous species that were tested but were still full susceptible to challenge with T. cruzi, T. brucei or T. evansi. A heavy challenge inoculum of T. musculi was cleared rapidly from the blood of mice which had recently recovered from infection but, in mice which had recovered 11 months earlier, the parasitaemia changed very little for 3–4 days but then fell abruptly within a few hours. Immunization with a parasite extract in multiple emulsion conferred a strong though not complete protection against homologous challenge.Serum from mice which had recovered from infection had a marked neutralizing effect in vitro on the infectivity of the homologous parasites although the numbers of live organisms were not reduced during the period of in vitro incubation. The test did not reveal antigenic differences among three isolates of the parasite.A summary is given of the sequence of events that is thought to make up the immune response of mice to T. musculi.