Debates: The Aggressive Spillover Hypothesis: Existing Ailments and Putative Remedies

The aggressive spillover hypothesis posits that precopulatory sexual cannibalism could evolve as a byproduct of directional selection on aggressiveness in a foraging context. In this debates piece we consider the critique of Kralj‐Fi?er and collaborators on the existing evidence in favor of the aggressive spillover hypothesis. Like Kralj‐Fi?er et al., we are of the opinion that the evidence in favor of the aggressive spillover hypothesis is still fairly weak. Despite this fact, the hypothesis remains one of the most widely celebrated examples of how behavioral syndromes can generate adaptive trade‐offs. We describe herein several opportunities to build upon the existing data in favor of the aggressive spillover hypothesis and more critically evaluate its assumptions and predictions.     

Urinary kallikrein in hypertensive animal models.

Urinary kallikrein excretion was studied in a number of animal models of hypertension. Kallikrein excretion was subnormal in spontaneously hypertensive rats as compared to Wistar/Kyoto rats and in rats made hypertensive by a clip on one renal artery. Kallikrein excretion was supranormal in rats made hypertensive by desoxycorticosterone and salt and in rats receiving desoxycorticosterone alone. It was subnormal after bilateral adrenalectomy. Kallikrein excretion increased in normotensive rats fed a low-sodium diet but was unchanged by a high-sodium diet. Thus, kallikrein excretion responded to changes in activity of sodium-retaining steroids and was not correlated with excretion of salt or water. In studies in dogs with stenosis of one renal artery kallikrein excretion was decreased on the stenoic side and the decrease correlated highly with the reduction in renal blood flow. While the role of the kallikrein-kinin system is still unclear the data indicate that the kidney may modify the initiation or maintenance of hypertension via this potent vasodilator system.     

Immunodiffusion studies of the tryptic fragments of bovine nasal-cartilage proteoglycan monomer of high buoyant density

Tryptic fragments of bovine nasal-cartilage proteoglycan, fractionated by dissociative density-gradient ultracentrifugation, were made to react by immunodiffusion against antiserum to a hyaluronidase-digest subfraction of cartilage proteoglycan monomer. This reaction produced two families of partly superimposed precipitin lines. One family was restricted to gradient fractions of medium or low buoyant density and included the immunoprecipitation reaction attributed to the hyaluronic acid-binding region of the cartilage proteoglycan monomer. The second family of precipitin lines was present alone in gradient fractions of high buoyant density. Immunodiffusion studies with antisera to relatively homogeneous keratan sulphate-rich and chondroitin sulphate-bearing fragment subfractions isolated from the gradient fraction of highest density indicated that both subfractions contained the antigenic determinants responsible for the second family of precipitin lines. Additional immunodiffusion studies, with the use of multispecific antisera to chondroitinase ABC digest and hyaluronidase digest of proteoglycan monomer, confirmed that the two subfractions shared antigenic determinants, and, in addition, indicated that these determinants were on one molecular species in the keratan sulphate-rich fragment subfraction and divided among at least three in the chondroitin sulphate-bearing fragment subfraction. Although an unprecedentedly large number of cartilage proteoglycan antigens could be recognized with the antisera employed in this cartilage proteoglycan antigens could be recognized with the antisera employed in this study, it was not possible to identify antigenic determinants unambiguously specific for the three structurally and functionally distinct regions of the cartilage proteoglycan monomer.