COMMENTARY ON ZOHAR'S “PROSPECTS FOR‘GENETIC THERAPY’- CAN A PERSON BENEFIT FROM BEING ALTERED?”

In his paper on the effects of Prenatal Genetic Intervention (PGI) on personal identity, Noam Zohar comes to a conclusion about genetic makeup and the uses of gene therapy quite different from the one I reach in another piece in this issue. Zohar's argument rests on the contention that personal identity changes with alteration of the genome, following what I have identified as the "constitutive" view. To see that this is the pillar supporting the weight of his argument, consider the following. Questions of identity aside, how can it be that altering the genome of children suffering from Lesch-Nyhan syndrome or Tay-Sachs disease so that they now produce the enzyme that they formerly lacked does not benefit them? Clearly, if their identities were not changed, such individuals would in fact realize great benefit from PGI, since the devastating bad effects of the genetic flaw would be avoided. Such a change would certainly make the altered individuals better off, that is, it would benefit them. On this, Zohar and I do not disagree. Persistence of identity through such genetic change is the sticking point.     

Formation of the transverse nerve in moth embryos : I. A scaffold of nonneuronal cells prefigures the nerve

We have studied the embryonic development of the transverse nerve (TN), an unpaired segmental nerve of the moth Manduca sexta. Two identified motor neurons and 16 identified neuroendocrine neurons project axons within the larval TN; therefore, the TN is both a peripheral nerve and a neurohaemal organ. At 33% of embryogenesis, and prior to the arrival of any neuronal growth cones, the position, shape, and trajectory of the TN are anticipated by two groups of nonneuronal cells that we call the strap and the bridge. At this time the strap and the bridge together consist of approximately 100 cells, all of which express a cell surface epitope recognized by the monoclonal antibody TN-1. As development proceeds, both the number of nonneuronal cells within the strap and the bridge and the fraction that expresses the TN-1 antigen(s) decrease. Moreover, individual cells within the strap become morphologically identifiable before the arrival of the neuronal growth cones. Most of the axons that project to the TN also express the TN-1 antigen(s) during their period of outgrowth. The two motor neuron growth cones are the first to reach the environment of the strap and the bridge, doing so at approximately 37%; having encountered these cellular structures, the growth cones restrict their navigation to this preexisting scaffolding, until they reach their muscle target. The neuroendocrine growth cones arrive later and also grow within the confines of the strap and the bridge (J.N. Carr and P.H. Taghert, 1988, Dev. Biol, 130, 500-512). In this first paper we describe the development of the strap and the bridge, and the interactions of the motor neuron growth cones with these structures. The observations are novel in documenting the extent and precision to which a peripheral nerve pathway is prefigured by a contiguous assemblage of nonneuronal cells.     

Distribution of Alginate Lyase Activity among Strains of Bacillus circulans

Strains from four different DNA relatedness groups of Bacillus circulans showed apparent alginate lyase activity; the activity of three strains examined had mannuronidase specificity. A representative strain of group 4 also produced apparent inducible unsulfated chrondroitin lyase activity.     

Arthrin: a new actin-like protein in insect flight muscle

There are one or more proteins of 50,000 to 60,000 Mr in the thin filaments of insect flight muscle. A protein of 55,000 Mr has been isolated from insect fibrillar flight muscle and called arthrin. Despite its higher molecular weight, arthrin is in many ways like actin. The amino acid composition of arthrin was similar to that of actin. There were similarities in the peptides produced by digesting the denatured proteins and mild digestion of polymerized proteins cleaved similar-sized fragments from arthrin and actin. Polymerized arthrin activated the Mg2+ ATPase of myosin to the same extent as actin and the ATPase was regulated by rabbit or Lethocerus troponin and tropomyosin. Arthrin did not itself act as troponin-T. Electron microscopy of negatively stained specimens showed that arthrin and actin filaments were similar in structure and that arthrin could be decorated by rabbit subfragment-1 to form normal-looking arrowheads. Arthrin formed paracrystals at an optimum concentration of MgCl2 (25 mM) that was somewhat lower than the optimum for actin paracrystals. Optical diffraction showed that the structure of the paracrystals was similar to those formed from actin. The mass of arthrin and actin filaments relative to phage fd was measured by scanning transmission electron microscopy; the relative mass of arthrin and actin was 1.33, in agreement with molecular weight estimations. Therefore arthrin has the properties of a heavy form of actin. The proportion of actin, arthrin and troponin-T in Lethocerus myofibrils was six moles of actin to one mole of arthrin and one mole of troponin-T. The function of arthrin is not known.     

Enzyme kinetics of a highly purified mitochondrial creatine kinase in comparison with cytosolic forms

Summary Mitochondrial creatine kinase (CK) purified from canine myocardium showed a single protein band on SDS-PAGE and was free of MMCK. Its amino acid composition was different than MMCK or BBCK and did not react to antiserum to MMCK or BBCK. Using purified mitochondrial, MM and BBCK, the velocity of reaction (V) was estimated for creatine phosphate (CP), creatine (C), adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and adenosine diphosphate (ADP) over a wide range of concentrations including those at V_max. The values for K_m (mM/L) derived from Lineweaver-Burke plots are shown: The affinity of mitochondrial CK for C is much greater than MMCK which is compatible with the energy shuttle hypothesis, namely ATP is converted by mitochondrial CK to CP, and then diffuses to the myofibril for conversion to ATP for utilization.     

Cross-linked collagen surface for cell culture that is stable,uniform, and optically superior to conventional surfaces

Summary A new type of collagen surface for use with cultures of peripheral nervous system cells is described. Collagen is derivatized to plastic culture dishes by a cross-linking reagent, 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl)-carbodiimide-metho-p-toluenesulfonate (carbodiimide), to form a uniform and durable surface for cell attachment and growth that allows dry storage, long-term culture, and improved microscopy. Surfaces of collagen derivatized to plastic were compared to surfaces of adsorbed or ammonia-polymerized collagen in terms of collagen binding and detachment, growth by dorsal root ganglion cells, and electron microscopy appearances. Derivatized collagen surfaces retained more collagen and showed much less evidence of degradation and cellular damage over periods of many weeks than did conventional adsorbed surfaces. Long-term survival of cells on derivatized collagen was far superior to that on the other surfaces, with almost 90% of cultures still viable after 10 wk. Transmission electron microscopy showed an organized layer of single fibrils that supported cell growth well, and scanning electron microscopy demonstrated an increased uniformity of derivatized collagen surfaces compared to ammoniated collagen surfaces. Applications for this improved substrate surface are discussed. This work was supported by the Leopold Schepp Foundation, the Dysautonomia Foundation, National Institutes of Health Grants NS14768 and NS11237, and Institutional Core Grant HD06276.