Testing the Adaptive Significance of Acclimation: A Strong Inference Approach

Acclimation is a common phenotypic response to environmentalchange. Acclimation is often thought to enhance performanceand thus to be adaptive. This view has recently been formalizedas the "Beneficial Acclimation Hypothesis" and predicts thatindividuals acclimated to one environment perform better inthat environment than do individuals acclimated to a differentenvironment. Although Beneficial Acclimation is appealing andwidely supported, recent studies with E. coli and Drosophilahave challenged its general validity. Although these challengescould be dismissed as mere exceptions, they encourage a re-evaluationof the adaptive significance of acclimation. Our philosophicalapproach differs from that of most previous studies of acclimation,in which the prediction derived from a Beneficial Acclimationperspective (e.g., heat tolerance is positively correlated withacclimation temperature) is tested against the null hypothesis("single hypothesis approach"). Instead, we follow Huey andBerrigan (1996) in advocating a strong inference approach (sensuPlatt, 1964), which recognizes that Beneficial Acclimation isactually one of a set of competing hypotheses that make differentpredictions as to how developmental temperature influences thethermal sensitivity of adults ("developmental acclimation").Using this perspective, Huey and Berrigan proposed a factorialexperimental design (3 developmental by 3 adult temperatures)designed to discriminate among all competing hypotheses. Wenow derive a formal statistical model (ANOVA with orthogonalpolynomial contrasts) for this experimental design and use itto evaluate simultaneously the relative impact of each competinghypothesis. We then apply this model to several case studies(Drosophila, Volvox, Trichogramma), and we review also a recentstudy with E. coli. The influence of Beneficial Acclimationis supported (albeit often weakly) in most cases. Nevertheless,other hypotheses (especially the Optimal Developmental TemperatureHypothesis) often have a greater impact. Even so, however, BeneficialAcclimation usually predicts relative performance at extremetest temperatures. We conclude that, although rumors of itsdeath are premature, Beneficial Acclimation cannot be viewedas the dominant expectation, at least with regard to developmentaltemperature acclimation. Moreover, our findings reinforce theview that a strong inference approach provides a more comprehensiveportrait of complex biological responses than do single-hypothesisapproaches.     

Food limitation in the fungus‐gardening ant,Trachymyrmex septentrionalis

Abstract 1. Most ants are more like plants and marine invertebrates than other insects because the adults are sessile and the immature stages are motile. 2. This paper reported the results from a field experiment that increased food levels on the fungus gardening ant, Trachymyrmex septentrionalis, which has served as a model system for understanding the complexities of these obligate mutualisms. 3. Food supplementation increased the growth of the symbiotic fungus and this led to an increase in the amount of fungal biomass. The amount of fungal biomass was generally more important in determining the amount of ant offspring than colony size. 4. The results indicate that the population is food limited and colonies may compete for relatively rare fungal substrate. However, competition in this species is not obvious.     

Predation on Moose Calves by European Brown Bears

Abstract: In North America, brown bears (Ursus arctos) can be a significant predator on moose (Alces alces) calves. Our study in Sweden is the first in which brown bears are the only predator on moose calves. Bears and moose occurred at densities of about 30/1,000 km² and 920/1,000 km², respectively, and bears killed about 26% of the calves. Ninety-two percent of the predation took place when calves were <1 month old. Bear predation was probably additive to other natural mortality, which was about 10% in areas both with and without bears. Females that lost their calves in spring produced more calves the following year (1.54 calves/F) than females that kept their calves (1.11 calves/F), which reduced the net loss of calves due to predation to about 22%.     

Dinucleotide microsatellite DNA loci from the ant Myrmica scabrinodis

We describe the isolation and characterization of five dinucleotide microsatellite loci in the ant Myrmica scabrinodis, which were obtained using a magnetic bead hybridization selection protocol. The PCR primers were tested on nine to 11 individuals. The number of alleles ranged from two to 13, and the observed heterozygosity from 0.200 to 0.778.     

Evaluating habitat effects on population status: influence of habitat restoration on spring-run Chinook salmon

1. A key element of conservation planning is the extremely challenging task of estimating the likely effect of restoration actions on population status. To compare the relative benefits of typical habitat restoration actions on Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.), we modelled the response of an endangered Columbia River Chinook salmon (O. tshawytscha) population to changes in habitat characteristics either targeted for restoration or with the potential to be degraded. 2. We applied a spatially explicit, multiple life stage, Beverton‐Holt model to evaluate how a set of habitat variables with an empirical influence on spring‐run Chinook salmon survivorship influenced fish population abundance, productivity, spatial structure and diversity. Using habitat condition scenarios – historical conditions and future conditions with restoration, no restoration, and degradation – we asked the following questions: (i) how is population status affected by alternative scenarios of habitat change, (ii) which individual habitat characteristics have the potential to substantially influence population status and (iii) which life stages have the largest impact on population status? 3. The difference in population abundance and productivities resulting from changes in modelled habitat variables from the ‘historical’ to ‘current’ scenarios suggests that there is substantial potential for improving population status. Planned restoration actions directed toward modelled variables, however, produced only modest improvements. 4. The model predicted that population status could be improved by additional restoration efforts directed toward further reductions in the percentage of fine sediments in the streambed, a factor that has a large influence on egg survival. Actions reducing fines were predicted to be especially effective outside the national forest that covers most of the basin. Scenarios that increased capacity by opening access to habitat in good condition also had a positive but smaller effect on spawner numbers. 5. Degradation in habitat quality, particularly in percent fine sediments, within stream reaches located in the national forest had great potential to further reduce this population’s viability. This finding supports current forest planning efforts to minimise road density and clear‐cut harvests and to return forest stand structure in dry regions to the historical condition that promoted frequent low‐intensity fires rather than catastrophic stand‐replacing fires, as these landscape factors have been shown to influence percent fine sediment in streams. 6. Together, these results suggest that planning focusing on protecting currently good habitat, reducing fine sediments to promote egg survival and increasing spawner capacity will be beneficial to endangered spring‐run Chinook population status.     

Rising concentrations of atmospheric CO2 have increased growth in natural stands of quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides)

As atmospheric CO₂ levels rise, temperate and boreal forests in the Northern Hemisphere are gaining importance as carbon sinks. Quantification of that role, however, has been difficult due to the confounding effects of climate change. Recent large‐scale experiments with quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides), a dominant species in many northern forest ecosystems, indicate that elevated CO₂ levels can enhance net primary production. Field studies also reveal that droughts contribute to extensive aspen mortality. To complement this work, we analyzed how the growth of wild aspen clones in Wisconsin has responded to historical shifts in CO₂ and climate, accounting for age, genotype (microsatellite heterozygosity), and other factors. Aspen growth has increased an average of 53% over the past five decades, primarily in response to the 19.2% rise in ambient CO₂ levels. CO₂‐induced growth is particularly enhanced during periods of high moisture availability. The analysis accounts for the highly nonlinear changes in growth rate with age, and is unaffected by sex or location sampled. Growth also increases with individual heterozygosity, but this heterozygote advantage has not changed with rising levels of CO₂ or moisture. Thus, increases in future growth predicted from previous large‐scale, common‐garden work are already evident in this abundant and ecologically important tree species. Owing to aspen's role as a foundation species in many North American forest ecosystems, CO₂‐stimulated growth is likely to have repercussions for numerous associated species and ecosystem processes.     

Limnochemical and phytoplankton studies on Nyumba ya Mungu reservoir, Tanzania

This publication reports on the chemical and phytoplankton aspects of a three month biological survey of Nyumba ya Mungu reservoir, Tanzania.
The lake had a total salt concentration of about 8 meq dm^-3 and specific conductivity of 900 μS cm^-1. The main salt in solution was sodium bicarbonate, and when the lake level fell it sometimes formed a crust on the exposed shore. The concentrations of major nutrient ions were probably not limiting to algal growth and good nutrient replenishment was provided by the two inflow rivers.
Nyumba ya Mungu supports a rich phytoplanton dominated by Melosira and blue-green algae. Acetone extractions gave chlorophyll 'a' concentrations ranging from 20–40 mgm^-3 in the vertical profiles, and light and dark bottle experiments indicated a maximum gross photosynthesis of about 800 mg O₂ m^-3h^-1. There was evidence of chemical stratification in the open water and diurnal stratification in the sheltered bays, but discontinuities were short-lived and the Trade Winds ensured regular mixing of the water. The lake appeared to have a higher primary production than the larger Rift Valley lakes and it was considered that this level of production would continue.