Perspectives from early career researchers on the publication process in ecology – a response to Statzner & Resh (2010)

1. Two senior ecologists summarised their experience of the scientific publication process ( Statzner & Resh, Freshwater Biology, 2010 ; 55 , 2639) to generate discussion, particularly among early career researchers (ECRs). As a group of eight ECRs, we comment on the six trends they described. 2. We generally agree with most of the trends identified by Statzner & Resh (2010) , but also highlight a number of divergent perspectives and provide recommendations for change. Trends of particular concern are the use of inappropriate metrics to evaluate research quality (e.g. impact factor) and the salami slicing of papers to increase paper count. We advocate a transparent and comprehensive system for evaluating the research. 3. We stress the importance of impartiality and independence in the peer review process. We therefore suggest implementation of double‐blind review and quality control measures for reviewers and possibly editors. Besides such structural changes, editors should be confident to overrule biased reviewer recommendations, while reviewers should provide helpful reviews but be explicit if a submission does not meet quality standards. Authors should always conduct a thorough literature search and acknowledge historical scientific ideas and methods. Additionally, authors should report low‐quality copy editing and reviews to the editors. 4. Both early and late career researchers should jointly implement these recommendations to reverse the negative trends identified by Statzner & Resh (2010) . However, more senior scientists will always have to take the lead with respect to structural changes in the publication system given that they occupy the majority of decision‐making positions.     

Microsatellite DNA markers for Lysiphlebus testaceipes

Microsatellite loci were isolated from the aphid parasitoid Lysiphlebus testaceipes (Hymenoptera: Braconidae). Ten loci were obtained from an enriched partial genomic library. Genetic diversity was analysed at seven of these loci and two natural populations, one on oleander and one on citrus. The observed number of alleles ranged from one to 17, and the observed heterozygosity ranged from 0.37 to 0.82. In both populations, no departure from Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium was detected except for one locus. The differentiation between the two populations was characterized by an F_ST of 0.09.     

Effects of accumulation of 3-O-methylglucose on levels of endogenous osmotic solutes in Chlorella emersonii

Abstract. Regulation of the concentration of osmotic solutes was studied in Chlorella emersonii grown at external osmotic pressures (II) ranging between 0.08 and 1.64MPa. NaCl was used as osmoticum. The total solute content of the cells was manipulated by applying 2 mol m⁻³ 3- O -methylglucose (MG), which was not metabolized, and accumulated at concentrations ranging between 60 and 230 mol m⁻³ within 4 h after its addition to the medium. Methylglucose uptake resulted in decreases in concentrations of proline and sucrose, the two solutes mainly responsible for osmotic adaptation of C. emersonii to high external II. The responses were consistent with the hypothesis that proline and sucrose concentrations are controlled by a system of osmotic regulation, with turgor and/or volume as a primary signal. Short-term experiments showed that even very small increases in turgor and/or volume, due to accumulation of methylglucose, resulted in large decreases in proline and sucrose. Over the first 30-60 min the total solute concentration in the cells increased by at most 15 osmol m⁻³ which would represent an increase in turgor pressure of at most 0.04 M Pa. Yet, the decreases in proline and sucrose were as fast as those in cells exposed to a sudden decrease of 0.25 MPa in external II, when the turgor pressure would have increased by at least 0.15 MPa. High concentrations of methylglucose in cells grown at high II did not affect the rapid synthesis of proline and sucrose which started when the cells were transferred to yet higher II. Thus, methylglucose had no direct effects on proline and sucrose metabolism, and it has been assumed that it acted solely as an inert osmotic solute within the cell.     

Assessment of ecological status in U.K. rivers using diatoms

1. The European Union's Water Framework Directive requires all water bodies to achieve ‘good ecological status’ by 2015 and this paper describes a rationale for defining ‘good ecological status’ based on diatoms, a significant component of the biological quality element ‘macrophyte and phytobenthos’. 2. A database of benthic diatom samples collected over the past 20 years was assembled. New sampling, specifically for this project, was undertaken during 2004 to supplement these data. In total 1051 samples were included in the database with matching environmental data. 3. ‘Reference sites’, relatively unimpacted by human activity, were selected from this database by a series of screening steps and these sites were used to develop a site‐specific reference typology. 4. Environmental variables not related to the pressure gradient were used to predict the ‘expected’ Trophic Diatom Index (TDI) values at each site. Site‐specific TDI predictions were used to generate ecological quality ratios (EQRs) ranging from ≥1, where the diatom assemblage showed no impact, to (theoretically) 0, when the diatom assemblage was indicative of major anthropogenic activities. 5. The boundary between ‘high’ and ‘good’ status was defined as the 25th percentile of EQRs of all reference sites. The boundary between ‘good’ and ‘moderate’ status was set at the point at which nutrient‐sensitive and nutrient‐tolerant taxa were present in equal relative abundance. An ecological rationale for this threshold is outlined in the paper.     

Instream habitat use by blue duck (Hymenolaimus malacorhynchos) in a New Zealand river

1. The feeding habitat of a river specialist, blue duck (Hymenolaimus malacorhynchos (Gmelin 1789): Anatidae), was characterized in terms of water depth and velocity on eight occasions over a 13-month period in a river in the central North Island of New Zealand using video to record activity and relocate feeding sites. 2. Of the five feeding activities identified (‘pecking’, ‘grazing’, ‘head-dipping’, up-ending’ and ‘diving’), adult blue duck used mostly head-dipping (> 60% of feeding events on all dates), although diving or grazing from submerged surfaces of exposed boulders comprised major proportions of feeding behaviour (up to 33%) on occasions. Variations in feeding behaviour between dates partly reflected changes in antecedent flow conditions and the annual cycle of the birds. 3. Grazing and diving occurred in significantly faster water (mostly 0.3–0.45 m s^–1) and at significantly different depths (mean = 0.10 and 0.55 m, respectively) than head-dipping (0.20 m depth and 0.28 m s^–1 velocity). Adult feeding depths and velocities at four sites on different dates averaged 0.20 m and 0.31 m s^–1, respectively. Most feeding by 3–4-week-old ducklings occurred over a similar distribution of water velocities to adults but over a wider range of depths. 4. Adult birds fed in significantly shallower and lower velocity water than was available on the two dates that comparisons could be made. Ducklings also fed over a slower range of water velocities but were not selective in terms of water depth. 5. Energetically more expensive search methods were employed at times of high apparent energy demand to access flow microhabitats where larger bodied prey were more likely to be encountered. 6. These data indicate that, like other aquatic organisms, river birds can be influenced by basic hydraulic elements of river flow, but show at the same time that adult blue duck can accommodate variable lotic environments efficiently.