Systematics as science: A response to Cronquist

Our reply to the commentary on cladistics presented by Cronquist (1987) is aimed at four issues:

1. the application of scientific principles in systematics;
2. the recognition that the analysis of pattern is a vital precursor to any consideration of evolutionary process. A priori judgements of evolutionary process are unnecessary for the generation of informative systematic hypotheses which are chosen for their ability to explain the patterns of character distributions rather than for compatibility with any particular preconceived ideas about evolution;
3. that phenetic concepts such as overall similarity, grades, gaps, and degree of divergence, if included in methods of phylogenetic inference, will give erroneous results. Paraphyletic and polyphyletic groups must, consequently, be rejected from systematics since they have no rational empirical basis for recognition;
4. the fact that many of the problems of phylogenetic analysis attributed by Cronquist to cladistics are common to all systematic methods but that these can be dealt with by the application of such principles as parsimony, synapomorphy, and strict monophyly.

     

Collagen can modulate cell interactions with fibronectin

We have examined the effects of soluble collagen on the function of fibronectin in baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells. Collagen and its purified alpha1(l) chain noncompetitively inhibited cell spreading on substrates precoated with fibronectin or a 75,000-D cell-binding fragment of fibronectin. Neither preincubation of cells with collagen followed by washing nor the addition of collagen to previously spread cells had any inhibitory effect on cell spreading, which indicates a requirement for the concurrent presence of collagen during the process of spreading. Treatment of collagen or alpha1(l) chain with collagenase abolished the inhibitory effect on fibronectin-mediated cell spreading. However, direct attachment of BHK cells to fibronectin-coated or 75,000-D fragment-coated substrates was not inhibited by collagen or by the alpha1(l) chain. Moreover, the binding of [3H]fibronectin or the 3'-75,000-D fragment to cell surfaces was not inhibited by the presence of soluble collagen, whereas soluble fibronectin inhibited binding. Although the binding of [3H]fibronectin-coated beads to BHK cell surfaces was also not inhibited by collagen, the phagocytosis of such beads was inhibited by the presence of collagen. On the other hand, soluble fibronectin partially inhibited the binding of fibronectin-coated beads but did not inhibit phagocytosis of the beads that did bind. The mechanism of the inhibition of fibronectin function by collagen and the possible interactions of two different kinds of receptors on the cell surface are discussed.     

Identification of a deletion in the low density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor gene in a patient with familial hypercholesterolaemia

Summary DNA samples from 60 unrelated UK patients with familial hypercholesterolaemia (FH) were screened by Southern blot hybridisation to detect gross alterations in the low density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor gene. One patient was found to have a 2kb deletion in the 3 part of the gene. The deletion cosegregates with the FH phenotype in his family. This finding is compatible with the deletion being the cause of FH in this case and makes a presymptomatic test based on DNA analysis available for this family. The defects in most of the other patients are likely to be due to point mutations.     

Cholesterol-free phospholipid domains may be the membrane feature selected by N epsilon-dansyl-L-lysine and merocyanine 540

We have used N epsilon-dansyl-L-lysine as a fluorescent membrane probe, to study cells taken from tissues concerned with immune function. There is a striking similarity between the staining selectivity of this compound and that reported by others for merocyanine 540. Both compounds stain leukemic, human, peripheral leukocytes, an erythroleukemia line, and some mouse bone marrow cells, suggesting common selectivity for a membrane feature of hemopoietic cells. Both compounds fail to stain red blood cells, normal human leukocytes, mouse spleen and thymus cells. We have recently reported that dansyl-lysine apparently selects for cholesterol-free phospholipid domains in liposomes and now report similar selectivity for merocyanine 540 staining of liposomes.     

Dansyl lysine: a structure-selective fluorescent membrane stain?

Dansyl lysine (DL) is a fluorescent compound that has significantly higher solubility in synthetic phosphatidylcholine (PC) membranes with a low cholesterol content than it does in water or in membranes having a high cholesterol content. Its fluorescence intensity is enhanced at least 50-fold when dissolved in PC membranes. Therefore, membranes with mole fractions of cholesterol (Xch) less than or equal to 0.5-0.3 are stained by aqueous solutions of DL: those with a higher cholesterol content, 0.3-0.4 less than or equal to Xch less than or equal to 0.5, are not. It is proposed that DL selects for a structural feature of membranes: cholesterol-free domains. The phenomenon has provided evidence for long-lived compositional heterogeneity in large multilamellar PC-cholesterol liposomes having Xch less than or equal to 0.2. This is not consistent with a model in which the homogeneous state is thermodynamically favored and both intermembrane transfer and transmembrane transfer (flip-flop) of cholesterol are fast. These studies are of potential importance for understanding cell membrane structure, in particular lipid-phase equilibria and the maintenance of compositional heterogeneity between the different membranes of cells.     

Photosynthesis in sugar beet depends on root growth

Summary Sugar-beet plants, germinated in growth cabinets at 20°C and transplanted into the field after 3 weeks, developed much larger roots than plants grown from seed drilled directly into the soil. At the end of the season, the roots of transplants were 39% greater than from drilled seed—an increase of 14 m tons per hectare. The increased yield was mainly due to a sustained increase in photosynthesis because of the larger sink for carbohydrates provided by plants from the growth cabinets.     

Experimental Infection of the Cotton Rat Sigmodon hispidus with Rickettsia rickettsii

Studies of experimental infection of the cotton rat, Sigmodon hispidus, with the virulent Sheila Smith (R type) and the avirulent Si 7 (U type) strains of Rickettsia rickettsii were undertaken to evaluate the role of this native wild mammal in the ecology of Rocky Mountain spotted fever. The Sheila Smith strain, which was highly lethal for guinea pigs, was nonpathogenic for cotton rats. Serial passage of the R-type strain in the cotton rat did not alter the virulence of the agent for cotton rats or guinea pigs. The U-type strain, which was originally recovered from a wild cotton rat, could not be maintained beyond the first passage in this animal host. Rickettsemia in the cotton rat occurred over a 24-hr period after inoculation of the virulent strain but was detected only 1 hr after inoculation of the avirulent strain. The short period of rickettsemia suggests that the cotton rat probably is not an important reservoir of R. rickettsii. Specific complement-fixing antibodies developed rapidly after infection with either strain, but the antibodies evoked by the R strain attained higher titers and persisted longer. Cotton rats previously infected with the Sheila Smith strain developed rickettsemia after reinfection with the same strain, even though relatively high levels of antibody were still present.     

SYSTEMATICS AND BIOGEOGRAPHY OF THE AUSTRALIAN "GREEN ASH" EUCALYPTS (MONOCALYPTUS)

Abstract— A cladistic analysis of the "green ash" eucalypts, informal subgenus " Monocalyptus ", is presented- As a first step, ordination methods of principal coordinates analysis and multidimensional scaling delineated some terminal taxa. The cladistic analysis, applying parsimony methods to the unweighted data set, yielded 25 equally parsimonious trees, each with a consistency index of 0.57.
Farris' successive approximations approach to character weighting produced one tree with a consistency index of 0.74.
An informal classification of the group, superseries Eucalyptus , is based on that cladogram. The biogeographic history of superseries Eucalyptus is interpreted from the cladogram as having been caused by lour vicariant events in southeastern Australia, in combination with a suite of ecological features that overlie the biogeographic area-pattern.