Regulatory hurdles for genome editing: process- vs. product-based approaches in different regulatory contexts

Novel plant genome editing techniques call for an updated legislation regulating the use of plants produced by genetic engineering or genome editing, especially in the European Union. Established more than 25 years ago and based on a clear distinction between transgenic and conventionally bred plants, the current EU Directives fail to accommodate the new continuum between genetic engineering and conventional breeding. Despite the fact that the Directive 2001/18/EC contains both process- and product-related terms, it is commonly interpreted as a strictly process-based legislation. In view of several new emerging techniques which are closer to the conventional breeding than common genetic engineering, we argue that it should be actually interpreted more in relation to the resulting product. A legal guidance on how to define plants produced by exploring novel genome editing techniques in relation to the decade-old legislation is urgently needed, as private companies and public researchers are waiting impatiently with products and projects in the pipeline. We here outline the process in the EU to develop a legislation that properly matches the scientific progress. As the process is facing several hurdles, we also compare with existing frameworks in other countries and discuss ideas for an alternative regulatory system.     

Plant genome editing in the European Union—to be or not to be—a GMO

New plant-breeding techniques have been boosting plant breeding, since only a few years but already first promising products are pushing to the market. In contrast to this, in many countries, the current Directives regulating genetically modified organisms have been established more than 25 years ago, especially in the European Union being based on clear differentiation between transgenic plants and conventional breeding. Therefore, the question arises if these Directives are suitable to face the new challenge of genetic engineering or if there is a need for updated regulations.     

Molecularly cloned simian immunodeficiency virus SIVagm3 is highly divergent from other SIVagm isolates and is biologically active in vitro and in vivo.

Simian immunodeficiency viruses have been isolated from African green monkeys originating from Ethiopia. A molecular clone, termed SIVagm3, was found to be highly divergent from SIVagmTYO-1 in terms of its restriction map and partial nucleotide sequence. A premature stop codon present in the transmembrane protein of SIVagm TYO-1 was absent in SIVagm3. SIVagm3 was biologically active in vitro and in vivo and displayed characteristics reminiscent of the wild-type virus. Biological activity was demonstrated by seroconversion of juvenile African green monkeys and Macaca nemestrina after inoculation. In contrast to antibody reactivity mainly directed against env proteins in naturally infected African green monkeys. African green monkeys and M. nemestrina infected with the cloned virus showed antibody reactivity directed against all major proteins as demonstrated by immunoblot analysis. The availability of a biologically fully competent molecular clone of SIVagm allows us now to address various pertinent questions in an animal model system which should help to understand features of human immunodeficiency virus infection in human beings.     

Die Wirkung von niedriger Temperatur,Stickstoffatmosphäre und Entkopplern auf die longitudinale Radioaktivitäts-verteilung nach akropetaler und basipetaler Applikation von [2-14C]ABA in langen Wurzelsegmenten von Phaseolus coccineus L.

Summary Acropetal movement of [2-¹⁴C] abscisic acid (ABA) in long root segments of P. coccineus is drastically reduced by destruction of the tissue, low temperature, anaerobic conditions and pretreatment with CCCP (carbonyl-cyanide-m-chloro-phenylhydrazone) at uncoupling concentrations. Basipetal transport is not affected by destruction of the tissue but markedly inhibited by the other treatments. Consequently polarity of ABA-transport disappears only after the roots have been killed. The importance of using long segments for hormone transport studies is discussed.

---

Abkürzungen ABA Abscisinsäure - CCCP Carbonyl-cyanid-m-chlor-phenylhydrazon - DNP Dinitrophenol - IAA Indolessigsäure - PPO Diphenyloxazol Vorübergchende Anschrift bis zum 31. 3. 1976: Botanisches Institut der Hochschule für Bodenkultur, A-1180 Wien 18, Gregor-Mendel-Straße 33, Austria.     

Substance P: binding properties and studies on cellular responses in guinea pig macrophages

The neuropeptide Substance P (SP) has been recognized to modulate functional activities of inflammatory cells. We have previously shown that it mediates macrophage activation. In this study we examined binding characteristics of SP and searched for additional evidence of heightened metabolic activity of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages upon challenge with this peptide. Radioligand studies indicated the existence of a homogeneous class of specific binding sites with high affinity for SP on macrophages. Scatchard analysis yielded an apparent KD of 1.9 +/- 0.4 X 10(-8) M (range: 1.4 to 2.4 X 10(-8) M), which was confirmed by kinetic studies. Binding was dose related, saturable, reversible, and could be inhibited by the SP antagonist (D-Pro2,D-Phe7,D-Trp9)-SP. Examination of peptide structural requirements revealed that both the COOH- and NH2-terminus contribute to receptor-ligand interaction. Other members of the tachykinin group of peptides were devoid of stimulatory action on macrophages. Cellular responses after engagement of the receptor sites by SP included downregulation of the membrane-associated enzyme 5'-nucleotidase and stimulation of synthesis and release of arachidonic acid metabolites, as well as of the lysosomal enzyme ADGase. These actions were specific as evidenced by immunoabsorption experiments. Our findings demonstrate that macrophage activation afforded by SP is effected through a receptor-mediated mechanism. Liberation of proinflammatory and immunomodulating substances in response to SP may be relevant to the pathogenesis of neuroinflammatory disease.     

Movement and compartmentation of abscisic acid in guard cells of Valerianella locusta: Effects of osmotic stress,external H+-concentration and fusicoccin

Epidermal peels of Valerianella locusta were acid-treated for 1 h at pH 3.9 to kill all cells other than guard cells. These guard-cell preparations were used to explore the steady-state one-way fluxes and the cytoplasmic and vacuolar contents of abscisic acid (ABA). The method of compartmental analysis has been applied. The intracellular ABA concentrations were surprisingly high. At an external pH of 5.8 the cytoplasm contained 1.28 mmol·dm^-3 of ABA, twice of the amount which accumulated in the vacuoles (0.57 mmol·dm^-3). The fluxes of ABA at the plasmalemma (_oc=_oc=0.43 fmol · cell ^–1 · h ^–1) were higher than those at the tonoplast (_cv=_vc=0.12 fmol · cell ^–1 · h ^–1). Moderate stress (0.1 and 0.3 mol·dm^-3 sorbitol in the medium) caused a change in the kinetics of ABA movement. The rate constants of the fluxes from the cytoplasm into the vacuole (_cv) and into the apoplast (_co) were increased while the rate constant of the flux from the vacuoles into the cytoplasm (_vc) was decreased. As a consequence the amount of ABA sequestered in the vacuole remained unchanged; the cytoplasmic ABA content, however, was reduced to only 20% of that found in the control treatments (no sorbitol in the medium). Under moderate stress, one Valerianella guard cell released rapidly about 0.36 fmol·cell^-1 to its direct cell-wall space. This surprising result is discussed in regard to rapid stomatal closure under reduced water supply.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - FC fusicoccin     

Random acrocentric bivalent associations in human pachytene spermatocytes. Molecular implications in the occurrence of Robertsonian translocations

Acrocentric bivalent associations were studied in 232 human male germ cells at pachytene in order to understand better the preferential involvement of chromosomes 13, 14, and 21 in Robertsonian translocations. The tendency of each acrocentric bivalent to associate with another was not correlated with NOR activity, as measured by silver staining. Good agreement was noticed between their ability to associate and the amount of satellite DNA in human acrocentric chromosomes. The distribution of two-by-two acrocentric bivalent associations was random. In order to reconcile this result with the nonrandom distribution of Robertsonian translocations, a molecular hypothesis is proposed. The model is based on homology of recombinational sites, interspersed at regular interval in satellite DNA, which could increase the probability of accidental unequal crossing-over between two specific acrocentric chromosomes.     

Effect of short-term energy intake level and exercise on oxygen consumption in men

The influence of short-term energy intake and cycle exercise on oxygen consumption in response to a 1.5 MJ test meal was investigated in ten young, adult men. On the morning after a previous day's "low-energy" intake (LE regimen) of 4.5 MJ, the mean resting oxygen consumption increased by 0.7 ml X kg-1 X min-1 after the test meal (P less than 0.025). After a "high-energy" intake (HE regimen) of 18.1 MJ, the resting measurement was unchanged (+0.4 ml X kg-1 X min-1) after the meal (n.s.). These trends are the reverse of what would be expected if oxygen consumption in response to feeding is a factor in the acute control of body weight. The mean fasting oxygen consumption during cycle exercise at 56% of VO2max (constant work) for both LE and HE prior intakes was not different at 31.1 ml X kg-1 X min-1. Oxygen consumption during exercise increased after feeding by 0.5 ml X kg-1 X min-1 on the LE regimen (n.s.) and decreased by 1.2 ml X kg-1 X min-1 on the HE regimen (n.s.). These results are also the reverse of what would be expected if oxygen consumption in response to exercise is related to short-term energy intake.     

Single ion channels in the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum

Single ion channels with different conductances and gating characteristics were observed in the plasma membrane of the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum by means of the patch-clamp technique in the cell-attached mode. The predominant channel type shows outward current flow, probably carried by K+ ions. The slope conductance of this channel is 9 pS and its probability to be open increases with depolarization of the membrane. The channel is observed from 1 to 8 h after the beginning of starvation.     

Uptake and Release of Abscisic Acid by Isolated Photoautotrophic Mesophyll Cells, Depending on pH Gradients

Uptake and release of abscisic acid (AbA) by isolated mesophyll cells of Papaver somniferum is characterized by the following observations: (a) Uptake rate is a linear function of the external AbA concentration in the range from 10⁻⁶ to 5 × 10⁻⁵ molar, and decreases with increasing pH. At any pH, uptake rate is linearly related to the concentration of undissociated abscisic acid, calculated from the pK = 4.7 according to the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation. At low external pH (5.0), AbA accumulation in the cells is about 10-fold. (b) Uptake of AbA is completely inhibited by salts such as KNO₂ or sodium acetate, which decrease the pH gradient between medium and cells. KCN or m-chlorocarbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone inhibits AbA uptake only after longer incubation periods (20-40 minutes). (c) Uptake rate as well as equilibrium concentration is significantly higher in light than in darkness. (d) At low external pH, release of AbA from preloaded cells is strongly stimulated by KNO₂. It is concluded that AbA is distributed between leaf cells and free space according to pH gradients, with the undissociated abscisic acid being the main penetrating species. Uptake and release occur via diffusion, without participation of a carrier.