PRODUCT TESTING 2: MODELING VERSUS MAPPING AND THEIR INTEGRATION

Evaluations of multiple products in a category proceed with two different, unstated objectives, and two distinct analytic approaches. The first objective is to "map" the category - viz., to put the products in a category onto some type of geometrical map with the property that products lying close to each other on the map share aspects in common. Researchers use mapping to identify which products compete with each other, as well as to discover whether or not there exist in the category unfilled "holes" that have promise. Researchers use modeling, in contrast, to identify the salient dimensions along which consumers differentiate products in the category. Modeling assumes that the researcher will create a relation between two or more attributes in the category. The analysis generates equations (or even only correlations) rather than maps. Mapping and modeling are complementary, yet often one approach is used to the exclusion of the other because of internal biases and points of view held by the researcher. This paper shows how the two are used, and how they can be integrated to create a more powerful analytic approach.     

The functional morphology and palaeoecology of the Dinantian brachiopod Levitusia

The functional morphology of Levitusia , based principally upon the type-species L. humerosa (J. Sowerby), is described and compared with living brachiopods. It is concluded that Levitusia species lived in tropical Dinantian seas with agitated waters and at shallow depths, perhaps no more than 50 m. The lithologies in which specimens are found support this view and indicate the need for some revision in our interpretations of some Dinantian sedimentary environments. Further evidence for the synonymy of L. christiani (de Koninck) in L. humerosa is presented.     

Can the progressive increase of C4 bundle sheath leakiness at low PFD be explained by incomplete suppression of photorespiration?

The ability to concentrate CO₂ around Rubisco allows C₄ crops to suppress photorespiration. However, as phosphoenolpyruvate regeneration requires ATP, the energetic efficiency of the C₄ pathway at low photosynthetic flux densities (PFD) becomes a balancing act between primary fixation and concentration of CO₂ in mesophyll (M) cells, and CO₂ reduction in bundle sheath (BS) cells. At low PFD, retro‐diffusion of CO₂ from BS cells, relative to the rate of bicarbonate fixation in M cells (termed leakiness φ), is known to increase. This paper investigates whether this increase in ? could be explained by incomplete inhibition of photorespiration. The PFD response of φ was measured at various O₂ partial pressures in young Zea mays plants grown at 250 (LL) and 750 µmol m^?2 s^?1 PFD (HL). φ increased at low PFD and was positively correlated with O₂ partial pressure. Low PFD during growth caused BS conductance and interveinal distance to be lower in the LL plants, compared to the HL plants, which correlated with lower φ. Model analysis showed that incomplete inhibition of photorespiration, especially in the HL plants, and an increase in the relative contribution of mitochondrial respiration at low PFD could explain the observed increases in φ.     

Spatial heterogeneity of tundra vegetation response to recent temperature changes

The spatial heterogeneity of recent decadal dynamics in vegetation greenness and biomass in response to changes in summer warmth index (SWI) was investigated along spatial gradients on the Arctic Slope of Alaska. Image spatial analysis was used to examine the spatial pattern of greenness dynamics from 1991 to 2000 as indicated by variations of the maximum normalized difference vegetation index (Peak NDVI) and time‐integrated NDVI (TI‐NDVI) along latitudinal gradients. Spatial gradients for both the means and temporal variances of the NDVI indices for 0.1° latitude intervals crossing three bioclimate subzones were analyzed along two north–south Arctic transects. NDVI indices were generally highly variable over the decade, with great heterogeneity across the transects. The greatest variance in TI‐NDVI was found in low shrub vegetation to the south (68.7–68.8°N) and corresponded to high fractional cover of shrub tundra and moist acidic tundra (MAT), while the greatest variance in Peak‐NDVI predominately occurred in areas dominated by wet tundra (WT) and moist nonacidic tundra (MNT). Relatively high NDVI temporal variances were also related to specific transitional areas between dominant vegetation types. The regional temporal variances of NDVI from 1991 to 2000 were largely driven by meso‐scale climate dynamics. The spatial heterogeneity of the NDVI variance was mostly explained by the fractional land cover composition, different responses of each vegetation type to climate change, and patterned ground features. Aboveground plant biomass exhibited similar spatial heterogeneity as TI‐NDVI; however, spatial patterns are slightly different from NDVI because of their nonlinear relationship.     

Asymmetric reproductive isolation among polymorphic salamanders

The study of reproductive isolation (RI) as a prerequisite to sympatric speciation has been limited by a focus on species that have already experienced isolation. However, a complete understanding of speciation depends on observing taxa before they complete the speciation process. We estimated RI in field populations of the polyphenic mole salamander, Ambystoma talpoideum, by capturing paedomorphic (aquatic) and metamorphic (terrestrial) adults during the breeding season from two natural populations. We found evidence for asymmetric RI between morphs, such that paedomorphic males and metamorphic females had functionally zero RI, whereas metamorphic males and paedomorphic females had substantial RI. Evidence suggests that ecological factors such as the abundance of each morph, timing of rainfall, and water depth of the breeding habitat play a large role in the production of these asymmetries. Spatial aspects of RI had a greater relative impact on overall isolation than temporal differences, in part because metamorphic adults were often captured in shallower water than paedomorphic adults. However, morph separation varied across populations and year, suggesting that environmental heterogeneity likely plays a large role in the potential for RI, particularly between metamorphic males and paedomorphic females. In addition, body‐size variation and behavioural differences could also influence the RI estimates presented here. Although facultative paedomorphosis appears to have played a large role in macroevolutionary change via allopatric speciation in some taxa, our results suggest that there is little potential for sympatric speciation in the future within these populations. However, asymmetric RI creates the opportunity for fitness differences between morphs and sexes that would directly affect the maintenance of this polymorphism. Our results suggest that further studies on this and other polyphenisms may provide valuable insight into the evolution of RI and the role of environmental heterogeneity in the production and maintenance of biological diversity. © 2005 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2005, 86 , 265?281.     

Breeding for resistance to the white potato cyst-nematode, Heterodera pallida

Progenies bred from material derived from the wild potato, Solanum vernei and from the cultivated potato, S. tuberosum ssp. andigena, clone CPC 2775, were compared for their resistance to Heterodera pallida, pathotype E. The influence of additional resistance derived from the wild species, S. multidissectum, was also investigated. Both S. vernei and CPC 2775 gave progenies with variable levels of resistance and there was often no clear segregation into resistant and susceptible categories. Incorporation of gene H₂ derived from S. multidissectum increased resistance to pathotype E of H. pallida for resistant material bred from both S. vernei and clone CPC 2775. The results indicate that adequate resistance to all British populations of potato cyst-nematodes can best be obtained by combining the factors for resistance from the two Andigena clones, CPC 1673 (gene H₁) and CPC 2775 (gene H₃), and from S. multidissectum (gene H₂).     

Acclimation to low light by C4 maize: implications for bundle sheath leakiness

C4 plants have a biochemical carbon concentrating mechanism (CCM) that increases CO₂ concentration around ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase (Rubisco) in the bundle sheath (BS). Under limiting light, the activity of the CCM generally decreases, causing an increase in leakiness, (Φ), the ratio of CO₂ retrodiffusing from the BS relative to C4 carboxylation processes. Maize plants were grown under high and low light regimes (respectively HL, 600 versus LL, 100 μE m^?2 s^?1). Short‐term acclimation of Φ was compared from isotopic discrimination (Δ), gas exchange and photochemistry. Direct measurement of respiration in the light, and ATP production rate (J_ATP), allowed us use a novel approach to derive Φ, compared with the conventional fitting of measured and predicted Δ. HL grown plants responded to decreasing light intensities with the well‐documented increase in Φ. Conversely, LL plants showed a constant Φ, which has not been observed previously. We explain the pattern by two contrasting acclimation strategies: HL plants maintained a high CCM activity at LL, resulting in high CO₂ overcycling and increased Φ; LL plants acclimated by down‐regulating the CCM, effectively optimizing scarce ATP supply. This surprising plasticity may limit the impact of Φ‐dependent carbon losses in leaves becoming shaded within developing canopies.