The surface layers (S layers) of those bacteria and archaea that elaborate these crystalline structures have been studied for 40 years. However, most structural analysis has been based on electron microscopy of negatively stained S-layer fragments separated from cells, which can introduce staining artifacts and allow rearrangement of structures prone to self-assemble. We present a quantitative analysis of the structure and organization of the S layer on intact growing cells of the Gram-negative bacterium
Caulobacter crescentus using cryo-electron tomography (CET) and statistical image processing. Instead of the expected long-range order, we observed different regions with hexagonally organized subunits exhibiting short-range order and a broad distribution of periodicities. Also, areas of stacked double layers were found, and these increased in extent when the S-layer protein (RsaA) expression level was elevated by addition of multiple
rsaA copies. Finally, we combined high-resolution amino acid residue-specific Nanogold labeling and subtomogram averaging of CET volumes to improve our understanding of the correlation between the linear protein sequence and the structure at the 2-nm level of resolution that is presently available. The results support the view that the U-shaped RsaA monomer predicted from negative-stain tomography proceeds from the N terminus at one vertex, corresponding to the axis of 3-fold symmetry, to the C terminus at the opposite vertex, which forms the prominent 6-fold symmetry axis. Such information will help future efforts to analyze subunit interactions and guide selection of internal sites for display of heterologous protein segments.Surface layers (S layers) are the outermost cell wall component in many archaea and bacteria (
6,
44). Most S layers are composed of a single protein or glycoprotein species that self-organizes into two-dimensional (2D) lattices of various sizes, usually with square or hexagonal symmetry (
7,
14,
43). This geometrical arrangement is almost the only commonality among species, since sequence homology between S-layer proteins is low and functionality differs in many cases. In many archaea, the S layer is the only cell wall component, so it may have a role in shape determination. However, in bacteria such as
Caulobacter crescentus, the role is more likely related to protection against a variety of predatorial assaults (
8).One interest in understanding S layers comes from their potential applications in nanotechnology (
46) and therapeutic applications, such as anti-HIV microbicide development (
37) and cancer therapy (
9). The concept is to display heterologous proteins from within the S-layer structure in order to create dense arrays of foreign insertions. Resolving the S-layer organization and structure at high resolution in cells as close to a native state as possible is crucial to understand or predict where proteins are displayed in the array, particularly when more than one foreign peptide is being displayed simultaneously.A significant limitation has been the difficulty in obtaining an atomic resolution structural analysis for any S layer with standard structural methods, such as X-ray crystallography. It has been assumed that the difficulty in obtaining three-dimensional crystals is the consequence of the propensity for two-dimensional assembly, which prevents the proteins from being sufficiently well behaved for crystallization. Despite that, there are a few examples of limited success for portions of S layers (
38,
39). Moreover, many studies have been conducted on isolated
in vitro S-layer sheets using negative-stain electron microscopy. This approach removes the interaction of the S layer with other cell wall components, which makes it more difficult to understand how a crystalline structure develops on a growing bacterium. Defects in structure that occur during the introduction of newly secreted subunits or to accommodate covering areas of strong curvature may well not be appreciated in isolated fragments, where rearrangements of the two-dimensional array are likely to occur. This may result in a more regular structure and even assist image analysis methods but does not represent what is occurring on the dynamic cell surface. Quoting Engelhardt (
17): “Functional aspects have usually been investigated with isolated S-layer sheets or proteins, which disregards the interactions between S-layers and the underlying cell envelope components.”Imaging technologies such as freeze-etch and negative-stain microscopy of whole cells (
48) can obtain quality images of the S layer directly on the cell. However, each of these techniques presents drawbacks, which would make impossible to extract the conclusions summarized in this paper. For example, it is very difficult to combine freeze-etching with site-specific labeling methods and is impossible with any label in the size range of Nanogold (NG). Moreover, freeze-etch images do not contain three-dimensional (3D) information. Negative staining of S layers on intact cells is difficult and generally can be imaged only on lysed (eviscerated) cells (
48). In this case, resolution is hampered by overlying double S layers, membrane debris, and the stain itself. Labeling with the typical 5- to 10-nm colloidal gold probes with either approach is not amenable to averaging techniques designed to localize the labels.Prior work has shown that
C. crescentus, a Gram-negative bacterium, has an S-layer subunit composed of a single highly expressed (
27) protein (RsaA), secreted by a type I mechanism, such that there is no cleaved N-terminal signal leader but there is an uncleaved C-terminal secretion signal (
4,
11). Six RsaA monomers (
12) form the characteristic hexagonal core with p6 symmetry seen by image analysis (
47,
48), and the 2D lattice is completed by hexagonal cores connected at junction points with p3 symmetry (Fig. A). Secretion and subsequent self-assembly require calcium (
35), and it is assumed that the RTX repeat domain (characteristic of type I secreted proteins) that is located adjacent to the C-terminal secretion signal is responsible for at least some of the calcium interaction; whether there is a second domain to complete subunit-subunit interactions is unknown. The S layer is attached to the outer membrane (OM) surface by interaction of an N-terminal attachment domain of approximately 200 amino acids (
18) with the fraction of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) that is modified with an O-polysaccharide (
3,
52).
Open in a separate window(A) Schematic from a previous publication (
12) showing how six RsaA monomers build a hexagonal S-layer subunit in
C. crescentus. The six-point star shows the center of 6-fold symmetry, and the triangle indicates the center of 3-fold symmetry. The figure is based on results presented previously (
35). (B) Cross section of a
C. crescentus tomogram to show the cell wall components. The effect of the missing wedge blurring the features on the top and bottom of the cell is obvious.In this paper, we present a quantitative analysis of the
C. crescentus S layer that sheds light on the overall S-layer organization as well as improves our understanding of the structure within the RsaA monomer, in advance of achieving true atomic resolution, by combining cryo-electron tomography (CET) of intact cells with statistical image-processing algorithms. CET is an ideal imaging technology with which to obtain a view of intact prokaryotic cells at molecular resolution (
28,
29,
30). This technology allows the visualization of S-layer architecture directly as it exists on the dynamic, growing cell surface. The sample in the microscope is kept close to the native state without staining artifacts, while projections are obtained from different tilt angles to reconstruct a 3D density map of the sample. However, due to low contrast and a generally high sample thickness, CET images have a low signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR). In particular,
C. crescentus has a diameter of approximately 600 nm, which is considered close to the thickness limit of CET imaging for these kinds of samples. Statistical image-processing techniques and target samples as thin as possible are needed to overcome the low SNR and to perform quantitative analysis of the S-layer characteristics
in situ.To obtain structural information from within the RsaA monomer, we introduced unique cysteine residues at locations ranging from the N terminus to as close as possible to the C terminus (without disrupting the secretion signal), followed by labeling with maleimide-coupled Nanogold particles. At 1 to 2 nm in size, the Nanogold is not visible in individual CET images of intact cells. However, it is possible to extract thousands of small volumes containing S-layer subunits from CET images and combine them using subtomogram averaging techniques to produce higher-resolution structures. In these averages, we identified locations of high-density areas representing the Nanogold, effectively using the regularity of the S-layer structure to increase the resolution of CET imaging.In short, we found that the long-range order is substantially lower than we had expected and that there were areas of double layers, especially when RsaA was overexpressed. By comparing the site-specific Nanogold labeling to the 2-nm-resolution structure that is available (
47), we have begun to correlate the primary sequence to positions within the averaged hexagonal structure, which represents a significant step toward having a rational basis for site selection for heterologous protein insertions in nanotechnology applications.
相似文献