Replicator Selection and the Extended Phenotype3

Adaptations are often spoken of as ‘for the good of’ some entity, but what is that entity? Groups and species are now rightly unfashionable, so what are we left with? The prevailing answer is Darwin's: ‘the individual’. Individuals clearly do not maximise their own survival so the concept of fitness had to be invented. If fitness is correctly defined in Hamilton's way as ‘inclusive fitness’ it ceases to matter whether we speak of individuals maximising their inclusive fitness or of genes maximising their survival. The two formulations are mutually inter-translatable. Yet some serious mistranslations are quoted from the literature, which have led their authors into actual biological error. The present paper blames the prevailing concentration on the individual for these errors, and advocates a reversion to the replicator as the proper focus of evolutionary attention. A gene is an obvious replicator, but there are others, and the general properties of replicators are discussed. Defenders of the individual as the unit of selection often point to the unity and integration of the genome as expressed phenotypically. This paper ends by attacking even this assumption, not by a reductionist fragmentation of the phenotype, but, on the contrary, by extending it to include more than one individual. Replicators survive by virtue of their effects on the world, and these effects are not restricted to one individual body but constitute a wider ‘extended phenotype’.     

Metabolism of cationized lipoproteins by human fibroblasts: biochemical and morphologic correlations

Human plasma low density lipoprotein (LDL) that had been rendered polycationic by coupling with N, N-dimethyl-1, 3-propanediamine (DMPA) was shown by electron microscopy to bind in clusters to the surface of human fibroblasts. The clusters resembled those formed by polycationic ferritin (DMPA-feritin), a visual probe that binds to anionic site on the plasma membrane. Biochemical studies with (125)I-labeled DMPA-LDL showed that the membrane-bound lipoprotein was internalized and hydrolyzed in lysosomes. The turnover time for cell bound (125)I-DMPA-LDL, i.e., the time in which the amount of (125)I-DMPA-LDL degraded was equal to the steady-state cellular content of the lipoprotein, was about 50 h. Because the DMPA-LDL gained access to fibroblasts by binding nonspecifically to anionic sites on the cell surface rather than by binding to the physiologic LDL receptor, its uptake failed to be regulated under conditions in which the uptake of native LDL was reduced by feedback suppression of the LDL receptor. As a result, unlike the case with native LDL, the DMPA-LDL accumulated progressively within the cell, and this led to a massive increase in the cellular content of both free and esterified cholesterol. Studies with (14)C-oleate showed that at least 20 percent of the accumulated cholesteryl esters represented cholesterol that had been esterified within the cell. After 4 days of incubation with 10 μg/ml of DMPA-LDL, fibroblasts had accumulated so much cholesteryl ester that neutral lipid droplets were visible at the light microscope level with Oil Red O staining. By electron microscopy, these intracellular lipid droplets were observed to lack a tripartite limiting membrane. The ability to cause the overaccumulation of cholesteryl esters within cells by using DMPA-LDL provides a model system for study of the pathologic consequences at the cellular level of massive deposition of cholesteryl ester.     

Extensive genomic and functional polymorphism of the complement control proteins

Using combinations of genomic markers, we describe more than 20 distinct ancestral haplotypes (AH) of complement control proteins (CCPs), located within the regulators of complement activation (RCA) alpha block at 1q32. This extensive polymorphism, including functional sites, is important because CCPs are involved in the regulation of complement activation whilst also serving as self and viral receptors. To identify haplotypes, we used the genomic matching technique (GMT) based on the pragmatic observation that extreme nucleotide polymorphism is packaged with duplicated sequences as polymorphic frozen blocks (PFB). At each PFB, there are many alternative sequences (haplotypes) which are inherited faithfully from very remote ancestors. We have compared frequencies of RCA haplotypes and report differences in recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA) and psoriasis vulgaris (PV).     

Amino Acid Patterns Within Short Consensus Repeats Define Conserved Duplicons Shared by Genes of the RCA Complex

Complement control proteins (CCPs) contain repeated protein domains, short consensus repeats (SCRs), which must be relevant to diverse functions such as complement activation, coagulation, viral binding, fetal implantation, and self-nonself recognition. Although SCRs share some discontinuous and imperfect motifs, there are many variable positions and indels making classification in subfamilies extremely difficult. Using domain-by-domain phylogenetic analysis, we have found that most domains can be classified into only 11 subfamilies, designated a, b, c, d, e, f, g, h, i, j, or k and identified by critical residues. Each particular CCP is characterized by the order of representatives of the subfamilies. Human complement receptor 1 (CR1) has ajefbkd repeated four times and followed by ch. The classification crosses CCPs and indicates that a particular CCP is a function of the mix of SCRs. The aje set is a feature of several CCPs including human CR1 and DAF and murine Crry and appears to be associated with the success or failure of implantation inter alia. This approach facilitates genomic analysis of available sequences and suggests a framework for the evolution of CCPs. Units of duplication range from single SCRs, to septamers such as efbkdaj, to extensive segments such as MCP-CR1L. Imperfections of duplication with subsequent deletion have contributed to diversification.     

Allelic and interlocus comparison of the PERB11 multigene family in the MHC

 The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) contains at least a hundred genes over 4 megabases of DNA. Within the MHC there are several new multigene families which have been recently described. PERB11 is a multigene family which occurs over the class I and central region of the MHC. Two members of the family have been shown to be functional and share domains with members of the supergene family including HLA class I, FcRn, and Zn-α2-glycoprotein molecules. The two functional members are contained within an area of the MHC which has been associated with increased susceptibility to autoimmune diseases such as insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus and also rapid progression to AIDS following HIV-1 infection. Intralocus and interlocus differences between PERB11.1 and PERB11.2 include: (1) several nucleotide substitutions leading to amino acid changes; (2) presence and absence of potential glycosylation sites; (3) insertions and deletions leading to a frame shift resulting in diversity at the amino acid level and an early termination signal. There are ten different alleles of PERB11.1 including one allele which contains a frame shift in the transmembrane region causing a putative truncated molecule lacking the cytoplasmic tail. The significance of this polymorphism in disease associations is under investigation. The most divergent domain is the transmembrane region when PERB11.1 and PERB11.2 are compared. The results suggest that these two molecules may have different functions. Received: 23 July 1996 / Revised: 17 September 1996     

The isolation of nucleic acid from nematodes requires an understanding of the parasite and its cuticular structure

As parasitology increasingly becomes the domain of molecular biologists, it is important to keep in mind that a fundamental understanding of the whole parasite, its structure and behaviour can help to solve complex problems of molecular biology. Hugh Dawkins and Terence Spencer discuss the preparation of DNA from filaform larvae of Trichostrongylus colubriformis and Ostertagia circumcincta and how a detailed knowledge of the morphology and life cycle of each parasite helps in this process.