Comparative accuracy of methods for protein sequence similarity search

MOTIVATION: Searching a protein sequence database for homologs is a powerful tool for discovering the structure and function of a sequence. Two new methods for searching sequence databases have recently been described: Probabilistic Smith-Waterman (PSW), which is based on Hidden Markov models for a single sequence using a standard scoring matrix, and a new version of BLAST (WU-BLAST2), which uses Sum statistics for gapped alignments. RESULTS: This paper compares and contrasts the effectiveness of these methods with three older methods (Smith- Waterman: SSEARCH, FASTA and BLASTP). The analysis indicates that the new methods are useful, and often offer improved accuracy. These tools are compared using a curated (by Bill Pearson) version of the annotated portion of PIR 39. Three different statistical criteria are utilized: equivalence number, minimum errors and the receiver operating characteristic. For complete-length protein query sequences from large families, PSW's accuracy is superior to that of the other methods, but its accuracy is poor when used with partial-length query sequences. False negatives are twice as common as false positives irrespective of the search methods if a family-specific threshold score that minimizes the total number of errors (i.e. the most favorable threshold score possible) is used. Thus, sensitivity, not selectivity, is the major problem. Among the analyzed methods using default parameters, the best accuracy was obtained from SSEARCH and PSW for complete-length proteins, and the two BLAST programs, plus SSEARCH, for partial-length proteins.      

Phylogeny and Phytogeography of Eupatorium (Eupatorieae, Asteraceae): Insights from Sequence Data of the nrDNA ITS Regions and cpDNA RFLP

Eupatorium were examined by sequencing the internal transcribed spacers (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA and restriction site analysis of chloroplast DNA. Molecular data provided strong evidence that (1) this genus originated in North America, (2) the genus diverged into three morphological species groups, Eutrochium, Traganthes and Uncasia in North America, and (3) one of the North American Uncasia lineages migrated into temperate Europe and eastern Asia over the Bering land bridge. The estimated divergence times support a late Miocene to early Pliocene migration from North America to Eurasia via the Bering land bridge. A European species was sister to all of the eastern Asian species examined. The disjunct distribution pattern of the genus Eupatorium is incongruent with the classical Arcto-Tertiary geoflora concept. Received 13 September 1999/ Accepted in revised form 4 January 2000     

Ultrastructural localization of amiloride-sensitive sodium channels and Na+,K(+)-ATPase in the rat's olfactory epithelial surface

Several studies have indicated that olfactory responses are impeded by amiloride. Therefore, it was of interest to see whether, and if so which, olfactory epithelial cellular compartments have amiloride- sensitive structures. Using ultrastructural methods that involved rapid freezing, freeze-substitution and low temperature embedding of olfactory epithelia, this study shows that, in the rat, this tissue is immunoreactive to antibodies against amiloride sensitive Na(+)- channels. However, microvilli of olfactory supporting cells, as opposed to receptor cilia, contained most of the immunoreactive sites. Apices from which the microvilli sprout and receptor cell dendritic knobs had much less if any of the amiloride-antibody binding sites. Using a direct ligand-binding cytochemical method, this study also confirms earlier ones that showed that olfactory receptor cell cilia have Na+, K(+)-ATPase. It is proposed that supporting cell microvilli and the receptor cilia themselves have mechanisms, different but likely complementary, that participate in regulating the salt concentration around the receptor cell cilia. In this way, both structures help to provide the ambient mucous environment for receptor cells to function properly. This regulation of the salt concentration of an ambient fluid environment is a function that the olfactory epithelium shares with cells of transporting epithelia, such as those of kidney.      

Clonal variants of a melanoma cell line sensitive to growth inhibition by dexamethasone

We have isolated and characterized two clones of the RPMI 3460 Syrian hamster melanoma cell line which exhibit different responses to the synthetic glucocorticoid dexamethasone. In the presence of 10 nM dexamethasone, one clone (clone 6) exhibits the growth inhibition, morphological alterations, and reduction in final cell density observed in the parental RPMI 3460 cell line. In contrast, the other clone (clone 5), although exhibiting a reduction in final cell density, fails to exhibit the growth inhibition and morphological alterations. Thus, the effect of dexamethasone on growth and morphology can be expressed separately from the effect of dexamethasone on final cell density in these cells. This observation suggests that the two sets of responses can be controlled separately and that glucocorticoids may exert their influence through different or divergent biological pathways.In vitro receptor assays suggest that the different phenotypes of clone 5 compared with clone 6 cells cannot be explained by an absence of or reduction in cytosolic glucocorticoid receptor, in clone 5 cells. Additional receptor characterization suggests that the different responses to dexamethasone of clone 5 and clone 6 cells do not reflect changes in the ability of receptor to exist in a stably activated form. Differences in the accumulation or depletion of extracellular components in the growth medium also do not seem to be responsible for the altered phenotype of clone 5 vis-à-vis clone 6 cells.     

Commentary on Gressel's review

Transgenic Research -