Suppression of the Tumorous State in Crown Gall Teratomas of Tobacco A Clonal Analysis

Two types of experimental approaches designed to test the possible involvement of chimeras in the persistent but readily reversible suppression of the tumorous state and in a recovery from that state in crown gall teratomas of tobacco were investigated. These studies showed that the tumorous state was suppressed in specialized cells present in the different tissues derived from each of the three layers of the apical meristem of teratoma-derived shoots of clonal origin. Although differences existed in the exogenous requirements needed for the reestablishment of the tumorous state in the different specialized cell types present in the different tissues, all again acquired a capacity for autonomous growth when appropriately stimulated. No evidence was found for the existence of periclinal or sectoral chimeras in teratoma-derived shoots of a single cell origin. Chimerism was, however, found to exist in one noncloned teratoma-derived shoot. Analysis of more than 500 clones derived from leaf mesophyll cells of cloned teratoma shoots showed that the vast majority of them (> 99%) were tumorous, while all of the 144 seed-grown plants from these shoots had completely recovered from the tumorous state. The results of these studies suggest that (a) a teratoma shoot does not depend for its development on the presence of significant numbers, if any, of cells that had recovered from the tumorous state; (b) the tumorous state may be suppressed in even the most highly specialized cells; (c) some special mechanism exists in the meiotic process for the elimination of all or most of the foreign DNA from transformed cells.