The swapping of terminal arms in ribonucleases: comparison of the solution structure of monomeric bovine seminal and pancreatic ribonucleases

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase), the only dimeric protein among the pancreatic-like ribonucleases, is endowed with special structural features and with biological functions beyond enzymatic activity. In solution, the protein exists as an equilibrium mixture of two forms, with or without exchange (or swapping) of the N-terminal arms. After selective reduction and alkylation of the two intrachain disulfide bridges, the dimeric protein can be transformed into a monomeric derivative that has a ribonuclease activity higher than that of the parent dimeric protein but is devoid of the special biological functions. A detailed investigation of the structural features of this protein in solution, in comparison with those of other monomeric ribonucleases, may help unveil the structural details which induce swapping of the N-terminal arms of BS-RNase. The solution structure of the recombinant monomeric form of BS-RNase, as determined by 3D heteronuclear NMR, shows close similarity with that of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) in all regions characterized by regular elements of secondary structure. However, significant differences are present in the flexible regions, which could account for the different behavior of the two proteins. To characterize in detail these regions, we have measured H/D exchange rate constants, temperature coefficients and heteronuclear NOEs of backbone amides for both RNase A and monomeric BS-RNase. The results indicate a large difference in the backbone flexibility of the hinge peptide segment 16-22 of the two proteins, which could provide the molecular basis to explain the ability of BS-RNase subunits to swap their N-terminal arms.     

Hints on the evolutionary design of a dimeric RNase with special bioactions.

Residues P19, L28, C31, and C32 have been implicated (Di Donato A, Cafaro V, D'Alessio G, 1994, J Biol Chem 269:17394-17396; Mazzarella L, Vitagliano L, Zagari A, 1995, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA: forthcoming) with key roles in determining the dimeric structure and the N-terminal domain swapping of seminal RNase. In an attempt to have a clearer understanding of the structural and functional significance of these residues in seminal RNase, a series of mutants of pancreatic RNase A was constructed in which one or more of the four residues were introduced into RNase A. The RNase mutants were examined for: (1) the ability to form dimers; (2) the capacity to exchange their N-terminal domains; (3) resistance to selective cleavage by subtilisin; and (4) antitumor activity. The experiments demonstrated that: (1) the presence of intersubunit disulfides is both necessary and sufficient for engendering a stably dimeric RNase; (2) all four residues play a role in determining the exchange of N-terminal domains; (3) the exchange is the molecular basis for the RNase antitumor action; and (4) this exchange is not a prerequisite in an evolutionary mechanism for the generation of dimeric RNases.     

RNase A oligomerization through 3D domain swapping is favoured by a residue located far from the swapping domains

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A forms 3D domain-swapped oligomers by lyophilization from 40% acetic acid solutions or if subjected to various thermally-induced denaturation procedures.Considering that the intrinsic swapping propensity of bovine seminal RNase, the only member of the pancreatic-type RNase super-family that is dimeric in nature, is decreased from 70 to 30% if Arg80 is substituted by Ser (the corresponding residue in native RNase A), we introduced the opposite mutation in position 80 of the pancreatic enzyme. Our aim was to detect if the RNase A tendency to aggregate through domain swapping could increase.Aggregation of the S80R-RNase A mutant was induced either through the ‘classic’ acetic acid lyophilization, or through a thermally-induced method. The results indicate that the S80R mutant aggregates to a higher extent than the native protein, and that the increase occurs especially through N-terminal swapping.Additional investigations on the dimeric and multimeric species formed indicate that the S80R mutation increases their stability against regression to monomer, and does not significantly change their structural and functional features.     

Chain termini cross-talk in the swapping process of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease

3D domain swapping is the process by which two or more protein molecules exchange part of their structure to form intertwined dimers or higher oligomers. Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) is able to swap the N-terminal α-helix (residues 1-13) and/or the C-terminal β-strand (residues 116-124), thus forming a variety of oligomers, including two different dimers. Cis-trans isomerization of the Asn113-Pro114 peptide group was observed when the protein formed the C-terminal swapped dimer. To study the effect of the substitution of Pro114 on the swapping process of RNase A, we have prepared and characterized the P114A monomeric and dimeric variants of the enzyme. In contrast with previous reports, the crystal structure and NMR data on the monomer reveals a mixed cis-trans conformation for the Asn113-Ala114 peptide group, whereas the X-ray structure of the C-terminal swapped dimer of the variant is very close to that of the corresponding dimer of RNase A. The mutation at the C-terminus affects the capability of the N-terminal α-helix to swap and the stability of both dimeric forms. The present results underscore the importance of the hydration shell in determining the cross-talk between the chain termini in the swapping process of RNase A.     

Structural versatility of bovine ribonuclease A. Distinct conformers of trimeric and tetrameric aggregates of the enzyme.

Lyophilization of bovine ribonuclease A (RNase A; Sigma, type XII-A) from 40% acetic acid solutions leads to the formation of approximately 14 aggregated species that can be separated by ion-exchange chromatography. Several aggregates were identified, including two variously deamidated dimeric subspecies, two distinct trimeric and two distinct tetrameric RNase A conformers, besides the two forms of dimer characterized previously [Gotte, G. & Libonati, M. (1998) Two different forms of aggregated dimers of ribonuclease A. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1386, 106-112]. We also have possible evidence for the existence of two forms of pentameric RNase A. The two forms of trimers and tetramers are characterized by: (a) slightly different gel filtration patterns; (b) different retention times in ion-exchange chromatography; and (c) different mobilities in cathodic gel electrophoresis under nondenaturing conditions. Therefore, they appear to have distinct structural organizations responsible for a different availability of their positively charged amino acid residues. All RNase A oligomers, in particular the two distinct trimeric and tetrameric conformers, degrade poly(A).poly(U), viral double-stranded RNA and polyadenylate with a catalytic efficiency that is in general higher for the more basic species. On the contrary, the activity of the RNase A oligomers, from dimer to pentamer, on yeast RNA and poly(C) (Kunitz assay) is lower than that of monomeric RNase A.     

A new mutant of bovine seminal ribonuclease with a reversed swapping propensity

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is made up of two identical subunits bridged through two disulfide bonds. In solution, it exists as a 2:1 equilibrium mixture between two forms, with (MxM) and without swapping (M=M) of the N-terminal arms. The swapping endows BS-RNase with some special biological functions, including antitumor activity, since MxM retains a dimeric structure even under reducing conditions, thus evading the cytosolic ribonuclease inhibitor. To investigate the structural basis of domain swapping in BS-RNase, we have obtained several mutants by replacing selected residues with the corresponding ones of its monomeric counterpart, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A). We have already shown that, in contrast with all other cases of swapped proteins, the swapping propensity of BS-RNase does not depend on the specific sequence of the 16-22 hinge loop, which connects the main body to the dislocating arm. In this paper we report the design, the expression, and the structural characterization of two mutants obtained by replacing Arg80 with Ser either in BS-RNase or in the mutant already containing the 16-22 hinge sequence of RNase A. NMR and circular dichroism data indicate that, in the monomeric form of the latter mutant, Ser80 acts as a switch for the conformation of the hinge region. Accordingly, in the dimeric form of the same mutant the MxM:M=M equilibrium ratio is inverted to 1:2. Overall, these data suggest that the presence of Arg80 triggers the swapping of N-terminal ends and plays a relevant role in the stability of the swapped form of BS-RNase.     

Thermodynamic stability of the two isoforms of bovine seminal ribonuclease

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a dimeric protein with two identical subunits linked by two disulfide bridges, each subunit showing 80% of sequence identity with pancreatic RNase A. BS-RNase exists in two different quaternary conformations in solution: the MxM form, in which each subunit exchanges its alpha-helical N-terminal segment with its partner, and the M=M form with no exchange. By differential scanning microcalorimetry (DSC), the denaturation of the two dimeric forms of BS-RNase was found to be more complex than a simple two-state process. Monomeric derivatives of the dimeric protein follow instead a simple two-state mechanism, but are distinctly less stable than RNase A. The three-state N if I if D denaturation process of the two quaternary isoforms was interpreted by identifying in the dimers a central highly structured core, enclosing the covalently bonded subunit interface, which unfolds only after the periphery (mainly the N-terminal peptide) unfolds. Circular dichroism spectra of the two forms in the far-ultraviolet region show large differences between the secondary structure of the isoforms and that of the native BS-RNase mixture at equilibrium. This has been attributed to the presence in the equilibrium mixture of intermediate forms with displaced and disordered N-terminal alpha-helical segments.     

Limited proteolysis of ribonuclease A with thermolysin in trifluoroethanol.

We have examined the proteolysis of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase) by thermolysin when dissolved in aqueous buffer, pH 7.0, in the presence of 50% (v/v) trifluoroethanol (TFE). Under these solvent conditions, RNase acquires a conformational state characterized by an enhanced content of secondary structure (helix) and reduced tertiary structure, as given by CD measurements. It was found that the TFE-resistant thermolysin, despite its broad substrate specificity, selectively cleaves the 124-residue chain of RNase in its TFE state (20-42 degrees C, 6-24 h) at peptide bond Asn 34-Leu 35, followed by a slower cleavage at peptide bond Thr 45-Phe 46. In the absence of TFE, native RNase is resistant to proteolysis by thermolysin. Two nicked RNase species, resulting from cleavages at one or two peptide bonds and thus constituted by two (1-34 and 35-124) (RNase Th1) or three (1-34, 35-45 and 46-124) (RNase Th2) fragments linked covalently by the four disulfide bonds of the protein, were isolated to homogeneity by chromatography and characterized. CD measurements provided evidence that RNase Th1 maintains the overall conformational features of the native protein, but shows a reduced thermal stability with respect to that of the intact species (-delta Tm 16 degrees C); RNase Th2 instead is fully unfolded at room temperature. That the structure of RNase Th1 is closely similar to that of the intact protein was confirmed unambiguously by two-dimensional NMR measurements. Structural differences between the two protein species are located only at the level of the chain segment 30-41, i.e., at residues nearby the cleaved Asn 34-Leu 35 peptide bond. RNase Th1 retained about 20% of the catalytic activity of the native enzyme, whereas RNase Th2 was inactive. The 31-39 segment of the polypeptide chain in native RNase forms an exposed and highly flexible loop, whereas the 41-48 region forms a beta-strand secondary structure containing active site residues. Thus, the conformational, stability, and functional properties of nicked RNase Th1 and Th2 are in line with the concept that proteins appear to tolerate extensive structural variations only at their flexible or loose parts exposed to solvent. We discuss the conformational features of RNase in its TFE-state that likely dictate the selective proteolysis phenomenon by thermolysin.     

Binding of a substrate analog to a domain swapping protein: X-ray structure of the complex of bovine seminal ribonuclease with uridylyl(2',5')adenosine

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a unique member of the pancreatic-like ribonuclease superfamily. The native enzyme is a mixture of two dimeric forms with distinct structural features. The most abundant form is characterized by the swapping of N-terminal fragments. In this paper, the crystal structure of the complex between the swapping dimer and uridylyl(2',5')adenosine is reported at 2.06 A resolution. The refined model has a crystallographic R-factor of 0.184 and good stereochemistry. The quality of the electron density maps enables the structure of both the inhibitor and active site residues to be unambiguously determined. The overall architecture of the active site is similar to that of RNase A. The dinucleotide adopts an extended conformation with the pyrimidine and purine base interacting with Thr45 and Asn71, respectively. Several residues (Gln11, His12, Lys41, His119, and Phe120) bind the oxygens of the phosphate group. The structural similarity of the active sites of BS-RNase and RNase A includes some specific water molecules believed to be relevant to catalytic activity. Upon binding of the dinucleotide, small but significant modifications of the tertiary and quaternary structure of the protein are observed. The ensuing correlation of these modifications with the catalytic activity of the enzyme is discussed.     

Structures of the two 3D domain-swapped RNase A trimers

When concentrated in mildly acidic solutions, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) forms long-lived oligomers including two types of dimer, two types of trimer, and higher oligomers. In previous crystallographic work, we found that the major dimeric component forms by a swapping of the C-terminal beta-strands between the monomers, and that the minor dimeric component forms by swapping the N-terminal alpha-helices of the monomers. On the basis of these structures, we proposed that a linear RNase A trimer can form from a central molecule that simultaneously swaps its N-terminal helix with a second RNase A molecule and its C-terminal strand with a third molecule. Studies by dissociation are consistent with this model for the major trimeric component: the major trimer dissociates into both the major and the minor dimers, as well as monomers. In contrast, the minor trimer component dissociates into the monomer and the major dimer. This suggests that the minor trimer is cyclic, formed from three monomers that swap their C-terminal beta-strands into identical molecules. These conclusions are supported by cross-linking of lysyl residues, showing that the major trimer swaps its N-terminal helix, and the minor trimer does not. We verified by X-ray crystallography the proposed cyclic structure for the minor trimer, with swapping of the C-terminal beta-strands. This study thus expands the variety of domain-swapped oligomers by revealing the first example of a protein that can form both a linear and a cyclic domain-swapped oligomer. These structures permit interpretation of the enzymatic activities of the RNase A oligomers on double-stranded RNA.     

Structural and functional relationships of natural and artificial dimeric bovine ribonucleases: New scaffolds for potential antitumor drugs

Protein aggregation via 3D domain swapping is a complex mechanism which can lead to the acquisition of new biological, benign or also malignant functions, such as amyloid deposits. In this context, RNase A represents a fascinating model system, since by dislocating different polypeptide chain regions, it forms many diverse oligomers. No other protein displays such a large number of different quaternary structures. Here we report a comparative structural analysis between natural and artificial RNase A dimers and bovine seminal ribonuclease, a natively dimeric RNase with antitumor activity, with the aim to design RNase A derivatives with improved pharmacological potential.     

NMR studies on structure and dynamics of the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase: new insights for 3D domain swapping

Three-dimensional domain swapping is a common phenomenon in pancreatic-like ribonucleases. In the aggregated state, these proteins acquire new biological functions, including selective cytotoxicity against tumour cells. RNase A is able to dislocate both N- and C-termini, but usually this process requires denaturing conditions. In contrast, bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase), which is a homo-dimeric protein sharing 80% of sequence identity with RNase A, occurs natively as a mixture of swapped and unswapped isoforms. The presence of two disulfides bridging the subunits, indeed, ensures a dimeric structure also to the unswapped molecule. In vitro, the two BS-RNase isoforms interconvert under physiological conditions. Since the tendency to swap is often related to the instability of the monomeric proteins, in these paper we have analysed in detail the stability in solution of the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase (mBS) by a combination of NMR studies and Molecular Dynamics Simulations. The refinement of NMR structure and relaxation data indicate a close similarity with RNase A, without any evidence of aggregation or partial opening. The high compactness of mBS structure is confirmed also by H/D exchange, urea denaturation, and TEMPOL mapping of the protein surface. The present extensive structural and dynamic investigation of (monomeric) mBS did not show any experimental evidence that could explain the known differences in swapping between BS-RNase and RNase A. Hence, we conclude that the swapping in BS-RNase must be influenced by the distinct features of the dimers, suggesting a prominent role for the interchain disulfide bridges.     

Inhibition of functional activity of macrophages in vitro by dimer RNase Bacillus intermedius

The influence of cross-linked by dimethylsuberimidate dimeric RNAse from Bacillus intermedius on peritoneal rat macrophages has been investigated in vitro. It has been shown that dimeric RNase with concentrations of 0.5-40.0 mg/ml decreases the functional activities of macrophages. This is manifested in the inhibition of the phagocyte function of macrophages and suppression of the fusion of phagosomes with lysosomes. The change in the cytoplasmatic membrane surface structure induced by the dimers, which is stronger than that induced by monomers, has been demonstrated using atomic force microscopy. The role of membrane properties modification in the inhibition effect of RNase dimers on the functional activities of macrophages is discussed.     

Structural basis for recognition of 2',5'-linked oligoadenylates by human ribonuclease L

An interferon-induced endoribonuclease, ribonuclease L (RNase L), is implicated in both the molecular mechanism of action of interferon and the fundamental control of RNA stability in mammalian cells. RNase L is catalytically active only after binding to an unusual activator molecule containing a 5'-phosphorylated 2',5'-linked oligoadenylate (2-5A), in the N-terminal half. Here, we report the crystal structure of the N-terminal ankyrin repeat domain (ANK) of human RNase L complexed with the activator 2-5A. This is the first structural view of an ankyrin repeat structure directly interacting with a nucleic acid, rather than with a protein. The ANK domain folds into eight ankyrin repeat elements and forms an extended curved structure with a concave surface. The 2-5A molecule is accommodated at a concave site and directly interacts with ankyrin repeats 2-4. Interestingly, two structurally equivalent 2-5A binding motifs are found at repeats 2 and 4. The structural basis for 2-5A recognition by ANK is essential for designing stable 2-5As with a high likelihood of activating RNase L.     

On the thermal stability of the two dimeric forms of ribonuclease A

The thermal stability of the two dimers of RNase A with N- or C-terminal swapped ends is investigated by means of dissociation kinetics, differential scanning calorimetry, and circular dichroism measurements. The data indicate that the dimer characterized by the swapping of the N-terminal alpha-helices is less prone to monomerize when compared to the dimer characterized by the swapping of the C-terminal beta-strands. This finding is correlated to the structural features of the so-called open interface of the dimeric forms.     

Cytotoxicity of polyspermine-ribonuclease A and polyspermine-dimeric ribonuclease A

Polyspermine-ribonuclease A (PS-RNase A) and polyspermine-dimeric ribonuclease A (PS-dimeric RNase A) were prepared by cross-linking ribonuclease A or its covalently linked dimer to polyspermine (PS) using dimethyl suberimidate. The two RNase A derivatives were tested for a possible antitumor action. The in vitro and in vivo cytotoxic activity of PS-RNase A, although strong, is not higher than that known for free polyspermine. PS-dimeric RNase A, which was characterized by mass spectroscopy, titration of free amine groups, and enzymatic assays, proved instead to be a definitely more efficient antitumor agent, both in vitro and in vivo. This result could tentatively be explained in view of the importance of positive charges for ribonuclease activity, considering the higher basicity of PS-dimeric RNase A compared to that of PS-(monomeric)RNase A. It must be also taken into account that the dimeric RNase A moiety of PS-dimeric RNase A could evade the cytoplasmic ribonuclease inhibitor, which instead could trap the monomeric RNase A moiety of the other derivative. The two RNase A derivatives degrade poly(A).poly(U) under conditions where native RNase A is inactive. The results of this work demonstrate once again the importance of positive charges for the functions of mammalian pancreatic type ribonucleases in general, in particular for RNase A derivatives, and the potential therapeutic use of the ribonuclease A derivatives.     

Oligomerization of ribonuclease A: two novel three-dimensional domain-swapped tetramers

By lyophilization from 40% acetic acid solutions, bovine ribonuclease A forms several types of three-dimensional domain-swapped oligomers: dimers, trimers, tetramers, and higher order multimers. Each oligomeric species comprehends at least two conformers: one less basic and one more basic. The structures of the two dimers and one trimer have been solved. Plausible models have been proposed for the other oligomers. Among them, all chromatographic patterns show the constant presence of minority species, and we focused our attention on two of them. The first oligomer (named X) elutes between the two trimeric conformers; the second (named Y) elutes as a shoulder in the ascending limb of the more basic trimer. After purification with cation-exchange chromatography, on the basis of (a) gel filtration analyses, (b) gel electrophoreses under nondenaturing conditions, (c) SDS-PAGE, (d) cross-linking experiments with divinylsulfone and 1,5-difluoro 2,4-dinitrobenzene, (e) enzymatic activity assays, (f) identification of the products of their spontaneous dissociation, and (g) controlled proteolysis with subtilisin, we propose that the X and Y oligomeric species contain two novel three-dimensional domain-swapped tetrameric conformers of RNase A, differing from each other as well as from the two tetramers already identified. For the two novel tetramers we showed tentative structural models. X(TT) could be a circular NCNC-tetramer; Y(TT) could be a propeller-like C-trimer with an attached N-swapping monomer (NCCC(TT)), identical to a model proposed by Liu and Eisenberg (Liu, Y., and Eisenberg, D. (2002) Protein Sci. 11, 1285-1299).     

Role of the hinge peptide and the intersubunit interface in the swapping of N-termini in dimeric bovine seminal RNase.

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is the only known dimeric enzyme characterized by an equilibrium between two different 3D structures: MxM, with exchange (or swapping) of the N-terminal 1-20 residues, and M=M, without exchange. As a consequence, the hinge region 16-22 has a different tertiary structure in the two forms. In the native protein, the equilibrium ratio between MxM and M=M is about 7 : 3. Kinetic analysis of the swapping process for a recombinant sample shows that it folds mainly in the M=M form, then undergoes interconversion into the MxM form, reaching the same 7 : 3 equilibrium ratio. To investigate the role of the regions that are most affected structurally by the swapping, we expressed variant proteins by replacing two crucial residues with the corresponding ones from RNase A: Pro19, within the hinge peptide, and Leu28, located at the interface between subunits. We compared the structural properties of the monomeric forms of P19A-BS-RNase, L28Q-BS-RNase and P19A/L28Q-BS-RNase variants with those of the parent protein, and investigated the exchange kinetics of the corresponding dimers. The P19A mutation slightly increases the thermal stability of the monomer, but it does not alter the swapping tendency of the dimer. In contrast, the L28Q mutation significantly affects both the dimerization and swapping processes but not the thermal stability of the monomer. Overall, these results suggest that the structural determinants that control the exchange of N-terminal arms in BS-RNase may not be located within the hinge peptide, and point to a crucial role of the interface residues.