Imaging purple membranes in aqueous solutions at sub-nanometer resolution by atomic force microscopy.

Purple membranes adsorbed to mica were imaged in buffer solution using the atomic force microscope. The hexagonal diffraction patterns of topographs from the cytoplasmic and the extracellular surface showed a resolution of 0.7 and 1.2 nm, respectively. On the cytoplasmic surface, individual bacteriorhodopsin molecules consistently exhibited a distinct substructure. Depending on the pH value of the buffer solution, the height of the purple membranes decreased from 5.6 nm (pH 10.5) to 5.1 nm (pH 4). The results are discussed with respect to the structure determined by cryo-electron microscopy.     

Structural determinants of purple membrane assembly

The purple membrane is a two-dimensional crystalline lattice formed by bacteriorhodopsin and lipid molecules in the cytoplasmic membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. High-resolution structural studies, in conjunction with detailed knowledge of the lipid composition, make the purple membrane one of the best models for elucidating the forces that are responsible for the assembly and stability of integral membrane protein complexes. In this review, recent mutational efforts to identify the structural features of bacteriorhodopsin that determine its assembly in the purple membrane are discussed in the context of structural, calorimetric and reconstitution studies. Quantitative evidence is presented that interactions between transmembrane helices of neighboring bacteriorhodopsin molecules contribute to purple membrane assembly. However, other specific interactions, particularly between bacteriorhodopsin and lipid molecules, may provide the major driving force for assembly. Elucidating the molecular basis of protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions in the purple membrane may provide insights into the formation of integral membrane protein complexes in other systems.     

Structure and hydration of purple membranes in different conditions

The unit cell dimension of the bacteriorhodopsin lattice in purple membranes decreases by the same amount (2%) upon drying the membranes at room temperature as when they are cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures. Neutron diffraction experiments with H2O:2H2O exchange, however, show that whereas in the dry membranes the lipid headgroups are dehydrated and the decrease in dimension is due to a smaller area occupied by the lipid molecules, the water of hydration remains in place in the cooled membranes, and the decrease in dimension is due to thermal contraction only. These data suggest a hypothesis that functional bacteriorhodopsin, in the wet state at room temperature, has a relatively soft environment that would allow large amplitude motions of the protein; in the dry membranes at room temperature (which are inactive), the amplitudes of protein motions would be inhibited by a more close-packed environment as they are reduced, due to thermal contraction, in the cold membranes.     

Protein-chromophore interactions in bacteriorhodopsin: the effects of a change in surface potential.

The chromophore retinal is bound to bacteriorhodopsin via a protonated Schiff base linkage. The retinal binding site is reported to be buried in the transmembrane portion of the protein, distant from the membrane surfaces. When bound to bacteriorhodopsin, the absorption maximum of retinal is red-shifted from 366 nm to 568 nm producing a purple color. This color persists across a wide pH range. However, when the pH is raised above 12.0, the membranes become pink in color, while at pH values of 3.0 or below, a blue color is produced. The blue color can also be obtained by removing the divalent cations bound to the surface of the protein. In this study, bacteriorhodopsin was examined by circular dichroism and absorption spectroscopy to determine if protein conformational changes were associated with the color shifts. It was found that although the retinal chromophore can be completely removed by bleaching with hydroxylamine with no significant influence on the secondary structure of the protein, a change in the surface charge of bacteriorhodopsin results in measurable conformational change in the protein, which apparently affects the nature of the retinal binding site.     

The distribution of tetramethylammonium ions on the surface of purple membranes

The two-dimensional distribution of deuterated tetramethylammonium (TMA⁺) ions on the surface of purple membranes of Halobacterium halobium was determined by neutron diffraction. The measurements were performed on stacks of these membranes with a high concentration of TMA⁺ molecules in the water layer between the membranes. A difference Fourier analysis of samples with deuterated and undeuterated ions showed an excess of 8.5 TMA⁺ ions per elementary cell in the lipid areas compared to the protein areas. A total number of 90 ions per elementary cell in the intermembrane space was estimated from the preparation procedure. The excess in the lipid domains may result from the higher affinity of TMA⁺ ions for the lipid head groups and/or from the fact that the protein (bacteriorhodopsin) protrudes slightly out of the lipid surface.Abbreviations BR bacteriorhodopsin - TMA Tetramethylammonium     

Atomic force microscopy of supported planar membrane bilayers.

Membrane bilayers of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and dipalmitoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DPPE) adsorbed to a freshly cleaved mica substrate have been imaged by Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). The membranes were mounted for imaging by two methods: (a) by dialysis of a detergent solution of the lipid in the presence of the substrate material, and (b) by adsorption of lipid vesicles onto the substrate surface from a vesicle suspension. The images were taken in air, and show lipid bilayers adhering to the surface either in isolated patches or in continuous sheets, depending on the deposition conditions. Epifluorescence light-microscopy shows that the lipid is distributed on the substrate surfaces as seen in the AFM images. In some instances, when DPPE was used, whole, unfused vesicles, which were bound to the substrate, could be imaged by the AFM. Such membranes should be capable of acting as natural anchors for imaging membrane proteins by AFM.     

Water molecules and exchangeable hydrogen ions at the active centre of bacteriorhodopsin localized by neutron diffraction. Elements of the proton pathway?

Neutron diffraction is used to localize water molecules and/or exchangeable hydrogen ions in the purple membrane by H2O/2H2O exchange experiments at different values of relative humidity. At 100% relative humidity, differences in the hydration between protein and lipid areas are observed, accounting for an excess amount of about 100 molecules of water in the lipid domains per unit cell. A pronounced isotope effect was observed, reproducibly showing an increase in the lamellar spacing from 60 A in 2H2O to 68 A in H2O. At 15% relative humidity, the positions of exchangeable protons became visible. A dominant difference density peak corresponding to 11 +/- 2 exchangeable protons was detected in the central part of the projected structure of bacteriorhodopsin at the Schiff's base end of the chromophore. A difference density map obtained from data on purple membrane films at 15% relative humidity in 2H2O, and the same sample after complete drying in vacuum, revealed that about eight of these protons belong to four water molecules. This is direct evidence for tightly bound water molecules close to the chromophore binding site of bacteriorhodopsin, which could participate in the active steps of H+ translocation as well as in the proton pathway across this membrane protein.     

Effect of fluorescamine modification of purple membranes on exciton coupling and light-to-dark adaptation

Purple membranes of $\text{Halobacterium}\text{,}\text{halobium}$ were modified with fluorescamine. At pH 8.8, with a molar ratio of fluorescamine to bacteriorhodopsin of 170, about 6 residues of lysine were modified while the arginines were not affected at all. Except for the appearance of the fluorescamine peak at 394 nm and some broadening of the chromophore peak at 570 nm, the absorption spectrum of bacteriorhodopsin was not significantly changed after modification. After fluorescamine modification, circular dichroism studies indicated loss of exciton coupling between bacteriorhodopsin molecules in the purple membrane. Rotational diffusion studies suggested enhanced mobility of the chromophore after modification. However, the spectral changes accompanying the light-to-dark adaptation of purple membranes were not prevented by fluorescamine modification. The implications of these findings are that exciton coupling between neighboring bacteriorhodopsin molecules in the purple membrane is not required for light-to-dark adaptation.     

Localization of the lipopolysaccharide-binding protein in phospholipid membranes by atomic force microscopy

Lipopolysaccharides (LPS; endotoxin) activate immunocompetent cells of the host via a transmembrane signaling process. In this study, we investigated the function of the LPS-binding protein (LBP) in this process. The cytoplasmic membrane of the cells was mimicked by lipid liposomes adsorbed on mica, and the lateral organization of LBP in these membranes and its interaction with LPS aggregates were characterized by atomic force microscopy. Using cantilever tips functionalized with anti-LBP antibodies, single LBP molecules were localized in the membrane at low concentrations. At higher concentrations, LBP formed clusters of several molecules and caused cross-linking of lipid bilayers. The addition of LPS to LBP-containing liposomes led to the formation of LPS domains in the membranes, which could be inhibited by anti-LBP antibodies. Thus, LBP mediates the fusion of lipid membranes and LPS aggregates.     

The purple to blue transition of bacteriorhodopsin is accompanied by a loss of the hexagonal lattice and a conformational change

X-ray diffraction measurements show that in contrast to the purple membrane, the bacteriorhodopsin molecules are not organized in a hexagonal lattice in the deionized blue membrane. Addition of Ca2+ restores both the purple color and the normal (63 A) hexagonal protein lattice. In the blue state, the circular dichroism spectrum in the visible has the typical exciton features indicating that a trimeric structure is retained. Time-resolved linear dichroism measurements show that the blue patch rotates in aqueous suspension with a mean correlation time of 11 ms and provide no evidence for rotational mobility of bacteriorhodopsin within the membrane. The circular dichroism spectra of the blue and the Ca2+-regenerated purple state in the far-UV are different, indicating a small change in secondary structure. The thermal stability of the blue membrane is much smaller than that of the purple membrane. At pH 5.0, the irreversible denaturation transition of the blue form has a midpoint at 61 degrees C. The photocycle of the blue membrane (lambda ex 590 nm) has an L intermediate around 540 nm whose decay is slowed down into the millisecond time range (5 ms). Light-dark adaptation in the blue membrane is rapid with an exponential decay time of 38 s at 25 degrees C. The purple to blue transition apparently involves a conformational change in the protein leading to a change in the aggregation state from a highly ordered and stable hexagonal lattice to a disordered array of thermally more labile trimers.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Single bacteriorhodopsin molecules revealed on both surfaces of freeze- dried and heavy metal-decorated purple membranes

The flat sheets of the purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium contain only a single protein (bacteriorhodopsin) arranged in a hexagonal lattice. After freeze-drying at -80 degrees C (a method that is superior to air-drying), shadowing with tantalum/tungsten, and image processing, structural details on both surfaces are portrayed in the range of 2 nm. One surface is rough and lattice lines are clearly visible, whereas the other is smooth and the hexagonal order seems to be absent. The optical diffraction patterns, however, indicate a hexagonal lattice for both surfaces. In addition, these diffraction patterns are characteristic and easily distinguished. The orientation of the two surfaces was identified by silver decoration: partial condensation of silver on purple membranes enabled the smooth surface to be identified as the plasmatic and the rough surface as the exoplasmic surface. After image processing, the exoplasmic surface shows a triplet structure which exactly fits the projected structure determined by Unwin and Henderson (1975. Nature(Lond.). 257:28-32) at molecular resolution, whereas, on the plasmatic surface, four image details per unit cell are visible. Three of them match the arrangement of bacteriorhodopsin, whereas the fourth must be located over a lipidic array. Summarizing these results, it is possible to show the part of each single bacteriorhodopsin protein that is present in the surfaces of the purple membrane. By "shadowing" the membranes perpendicularly, we prove that these components of the surfaces are mainly portrayed by a decoration effect of the tantalum/tungsten condensate.     

Protein structural change at the cytoplasmic surface as the cause of cooperativity in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The effects of excitation light intensity on the kinetics of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle were investigated. The earlier reported intensity-dependent changes at 410 and 570 nm are explained by parallel increases in two of the rate constants, for proton transfers to D96 from the Schiff base and from the cytoplasmic surface, without changes in the others, as the photoexcited fraction is increased. Thus, it appears that the pKa of D96 is raised by a cooperative effect within the purple membrane. This interpretation of the wild-type kinetics was confirmed by results with several mutant proteins, where the rates are well separated in time and a model-dependent analysis is unnecessary. Based on earlier results that demonstrated a structural change of the protein after deprotonation of the Schiff base that increases the area of the cytoplasmic surface, and the effects of high hydrostatic pressure and lowered water activity on the photocycle steps in question, we suggest that the pKa of D96 is raised by a lateral pressure that develops when other bacteriorhodopsin molecules are photoexcited within the two-dimensional lattice of the purple membrane. Expulsion of no more than a few water molecules bound near D96 by this pressure would account for the calculated increase of 0.6 units in the pKa.     

THE ATOMIC FORCE MICROSCOPE DETECTS ATP-SENSITIVE PROTEIN CLUSTERS IN THE PLASMA MEMBRANE OF TRANSFORMED MDCK CELLS

Plasma membrane proteins are supposed to form clusters that allow ‘functional cross-talk’ between individual molecules within nanometre distance. However, such hypothetical protein clusters have not yet been shown directly in native plasma membranes. Therefore, we developed a technique to get access to the inner face of the plasma membrane of cultured transformed kidney (MDCK) cells. The authors applied atomic force microscopy (AFM) to visualize clusters of native proteins protruding from the cytoplasmic membrane surface. We used the K⁺channel blocker iberiotoxin (IBTX), a positively charged toxin molecule, that binds with high affinity to plasma membrane potassium channels and to atomically flat mica. Thus, apical plasma membranes could be ‘glued’ with IBTX to the mica surface with the cytosolic side of the membrane accessible to the scanning AFM tip. The topography of these native inside-out membrane patches was imaged with AFM in electrolyte solution mimicking the cytosol. The plasma membrane could be clearly identified as a lipid bilayer with the characteristic height of 4.9±0.02nm. Multiple proteins protruded from the lipid bilayer into the cytosolic space with molecule heights between 1 and 20nm. Large protrusions were most likely protein clusters. Addition of the proteolytic enzyme pronase to the bath solution led to the disappearance of the proteins within minutes. The metabolic substrate ATP induced a shape-change of the protein clusters and smaller subunits became visible. ADP or the non-hydrolysable ATP analogue, ATP-γ-S, could not exert similar effects. It is concluded that plasma membrane proteins (and/or membrane associated proteins) form ‘functional clusters’ in their native environment. The ‘physiological’ arrangement of the protein molecules within a cluster requires ATP.     

Structural comparison of native and deoxycholate-treated purple membrane.

Lipid-depleted purple membrane prepared by extraction with deoxycholate has been compared with the native structure. X-ray and electron diffraction photographs show a reduction in cell dimension from 62.4 to 57.3 A, and a substantial change in the distribution of diffraction intensity compared with the native specimens. Low-dose electron microscopy has been used to obtain a projected density map of lipid-depleted membranes. The projected structure shows that the deoxycholate treatment removes a boundary layer of lipid, which in the native form separates adjacent trimers of bacteriorhodopsin. The map also provides an improved estimate of the molecular envelope of the protein. A plausible arrangement for the lipid molecules in both the native and the lipid-depleted membranes is proposed, but the precise positions of individual molecules cannot yet be specified.     

Atomic force microscopy of hydrated phosphatidylethanolamine bilayers.

We present images of the polar or headgroup regions of bilayers of dimyristoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (DMPE), deposited by Langmuir-Blodgett deposition onto mica substrates at high surface pressures and imaged under water at room temperature with the optical lever atomic force microscope. The lattice structure of DMPE is visualized with sufficient resolution that the location of individual headgroups can be determined. The forces are sufficiently small that the same area can be repeatedly imaged with a minimum of damage. The DMPE molecules in the bilayer appear to have relatively good long-range orientational order, but rather short-range and poor positional order. These results are in good agreement with x-ray measurements of unsupported lipid monolayers on the water surface, and with electron diffraction of adsorbed monolayers.     

Bacteriorhodospin: a trans-membrane pump containing alpha-helix.

The probable arrangement of the bacteriorhodopsin molecules in the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium is in clusters of three, with a 3-fold axis at the centre of each cluster; the axis is at right angles to the plane of the membrane. The proposed arrangement and the results of model calculations together indicate that each protein molecule spans the entire thickness of the membrane. An earlier proposal for the structure had the protein molecules in two layers, and it was symmetric in projection onto the profile-axis. This model is now rejected since it would be difficult to account for the recently discovered function of pumping protons. There remains a discrepancy in that the calculated number of protein molecules in the unit-cell is 3.4 compared to the three expected.The X-ray diffraction patterns from dispersions of the lipids extracted from the red and purple membranes of H. halobium are described.Model calculations are reported, which are based on the bilayer profile calculated for the extracted lipids and on two simple profiles for the protein. The calculations favour a structure for the purple membrane having the lipid molecules in two layers, as in a bilayer, although there may be more of the lipid on one side of the membrane than on the other. Assuming bilayer structure, the diffraction nearest the centre of the oriented pattern suggests that the lipid molecules may be located mainly in a few discrete regions, roughly 20 Å across, between the protein molecules. An uninterrupted monolayer of the lipid on one surface of a sheet of the protein molecules gives poor agreement with the observed profile-diffraction.The X-ray diffraction pattern from the oriented membranes suggested α-helix in the bacteriorhodopsin, and this has been confirmed by recording a 1.5 Å-reflection oriented on the profile-axis. There appear to be at least two segments of α-helix, which are somewhat inclined to one another, and the two may be packed together. Prominent diffraction on the in-plane axis near 10 Å is consistent with the segments lying more or less perpendicular to the plane of the membrane.     

Measuring local surface charge densities in electrolyte solutions with a scanning force microscope

To show that local surface charge densities can be measured with a scanning force microscope purple membranes adsorbed to alumina were imaged in electrolyte solutions. Force versus distance curves were measured on purple membranes and on the bare alumina with standard silicon nitride tips. By comparing the electrostatic force measured on both substances, the surface charge density of purple membranes could be calculated from the known charge density of alumina. The charge density of purple membranes was estimated to be -0.05 C/m².     

The preparation of lipid-depleted bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin, the protein of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium, was freed to the extent of 90–95% from the natural membrane lipids without loss of function. The residual lipid corresponded to less than 1 mol/mol of bacteriorhodopsin. Delipidation was achieved by treatment of the purple membrane with a mixture of the detergent dimethyldodecylamine oxide and sodium chloride. The detergent was removed by dialysis or by sucrose density gradient centrifugation. Analysis of the lipids removed and those still bound to bacteriorhodopsin was facilitated by the use of purple membrane preparations labelled with ³⁵S, ³²P, or ¹⁴C. The composition of the residual lipids associated with bacteriorhodopsin was similar to that of the total lipid in the purple membrane.     

Effects of modification of the tyrosine residues of bacteriorhodopsin with tetranitromethane.

Treatment of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium with tetranitromethane led to modification of tyrosine residues. Modification of more than 3-4 tyrosine residues per bacteriorhodopsin monomer caused a decrease in the light-induced proton-pumping ability of purple membrane in synthetic lipid vesicles, loss of the sharp X-ray-diffraction patterns characteristic of the crystal lattice, loss of the absorbance maximum at 560 nm, and change in the buoyant density of the membrane. No modification of lipid was detected. These changes were interpreted as a gradual denaturation of the protein component such that when 8-9 tyrosine residues are modified, no proton pumping is observed. Modification of less than 3-4 tyrosine residues with tetranitromethane caused an increse in light-induced proton pumping. It was possible to generate partly modified purple membrane which had completely lost the property of diffracting X-rays into the sharp pattern observed with native purple membrane, but which still retained the ability to pump protons in a vectorial manner. Retention of crystal lattice is not essential for proton pumping.     

Chromophore of Bacteriorhodopsin is Closer to the Cytoplasmic Surface of Purple Membrane: Fluorescence Energy Transfer on Oriented Membrane Sheets

Transmembrane location of the retinal chromophore, either native or reduced in situ to a fluorescent derivative, of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium was investigated with fluorescence energy transfer techniques. Single sheets of purple membrane, either native or reduced with borohydride, were adsorbed on polylysine-coated glass; the orientation, whether the exposed surfaces were cytoplasmic or extracellular, was controlled by adjusting the pH of the membrane suspension before the adsorption. On the exposed surface of the reduced membrane, a layer of cytochrome c, hemoglobin, or ferritin was deposited. The rate of excitation energy transfer from the fluorescent chromophore in the membrane to the colored protein was greater when the protein was on the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane than when it was on the extracellular surface. Analysis in which uniform distribution of the protein on the surface was assumed showed that the reduced chromophore is situated at a depth of <1.5 nm from the cytoplasmic surface. The location of the native retinal chromophore was examined by depositing a small amount of tris(2,2′-bipyridyl)ruthenium(II) complex on the native membrane adsorbed on the glass. Energy transfer from the luminescent complex to the retinal chromosphore was more efficient on the cytoplasmic surface than on the extracellular surface, suggesting that the native chromophore is also on the cytoplasmic side. From these and previous results we conclude that the chromophore, whether native or reduced, of bacteriorhodopsin is located at a depth of 1.0 ± 0.3 nm from the cytoplasmic surface of purple membrane.