Immunoregulation by antigen/antibody complexes. I. Specific immunosuppression induced in vivo with immune complexes formed in antibody excess

Specific immune complexes, prepared at different ratios of antibody to antigen, were examined for their effects on the antibody response of BALB/c mice to the cell wall polysaccharide antigen (PnC) extracted from Streptococcus pneumonia R36a. Mice immunized with complexes formed in antigen excess developed a PnC-specific antibody response that was equivalent to that in mice injected with free antigen. On the other hand, mice injected with complexes formed in antibody excess developed very little PnC-specific antibody. Furthermore, administration of immune complexes (formed in antibody excess) resulted in suppression of the response to an immunogenic dose of PnC given concurrently or 1 day after injection of immune complexes but not when the antigen was given 1 day before injection of the immune complexes. Injections of free antibody (TEPC-15) also resulted in suppression of the response to antigenic challenge; however, suppression was greatest when the antibody was injected concurrently with the antigen, suggesting that the suppression was mediated through the formation of immune complexes in vivo. The suppression appears to be specific for the antigen (PnC), since in mice injected with TEPC-15/PnC complexes (formed in antibody excess) and challenged with PnC coupled to sheep RBC, only the response to PnC was suppressed.     

Inhibition of the immune response by membrane-bound antibody.

Cells from the spleens of "normal" swine, which were pretreated with pronase to remove surface membrane-bound immunoglobulin, gave an enhanced hemolytic plaque-forming cell response to sheep red blood cells in vitro in comparison with untreated controls. The enhancement could be abrogated by preincubating pronase-treated spleeen cells in preparations containing antibody to sheep red blood cells. This effect was demonstrated by autologous sera, immune sera, and all three known classes of porcine serum immunoglobulins, including IgM, IgA, and IgG and could be removed by absorption with sheep red blood cells. Surface membrane-bound antibody exerted its effect by binding to the nonadherent cell population. The response of normal spleen cells was unaffected by antibody treatment. Pronase-treatment was not mitogenic, did not function as a polyclonal B cell activator, and did not selectively eliminate T or B cells. The results indicate that removal of antibody from the surface of lymphoid cells enhanced the humoral immune response invitro and confirm that membrane-bound antibody can inhibit response to antigen.     

Mathematical modeling of humoral immune response suppression by passively administered antibodies in mice

Although passively administered antibodies are known to suppress the humoral immune response, the mechanism is not fully understood. Here, we developed a mathematical model to better understand the suppression phenomena in mice. Using this model, we tested the generally accepted but difficult to prove "epitope masking hypothesis." To simulate the hypothesis and clearly observe masking of epitopes, we modeled epitope-antibody and epitope-B-cell receptor interactions at the epitope level. To validate this model, we simulated the effect of the antibody affinity and quantity as well as the timing of administration on the suppression, and we compared the results with experimental observations reported in the literature. We then developed a simulation to determine whether the epitope-masking hypothesis alone can explain known immune suppression phenomena, especially the conflicting results on F(ab')2 fragment-induced suppression, which has been shown to be no suppression, or similar to or up to 1000-fold weaker than the suppression by intact antibody. We found that suppression was caused by a synergistic effect of both epitope masking and rapid antigen clearance. Although the latter hypothesis has lost support because FcgammaRI/III mutant mice show antibody-mediated suppression, our simulations predict that, even in FcgammaRI/III mutant mice, the immune response can be suppressed according to the antibody affinity. Our model also effectively reproduced the conflicting results obtained using F(ab')2 fragments. Thus, in contrast to the idea that the F(ab')2 results prove the FcgammaRIIb involvement in suppression, our mathematical model suggests that the epitope-masking hypothesis together with rapid antigen clearance explains the conflicting results.     

Induction of CD4 suppressor T cells with anti-Leu-8 antibody

To characterize the conditions under which CD4 T cells suppress polyclonal immunoglobulin synthesis, we investigated the capacity of CD4 T cells that coexpress the surface antigen recognized by the monoclonal antibody anti-Leu-8 to mediate suppression. In an in vitro system devoid of CD8 T cells, CD4, Leu-8+ T cells suppressed pokeweed mitogen-induced immunoglobulin synthesis. Similarly, suppressor function was induced in unfractionated CD4 T cell populations after incubation with anti-Leu-8 antibody under cross-linking conditions. This induction of suppressor function by anti-Leu-8 antibody was not due to expansion of the CD4, Leu-8+ T cell population because CD4 T cells did not proliferate in response to anti-Leu-8 antibody. However, CD4, Leu-8+ T cell-mediated suppression was radiosensitive. Finally, CD4, Leu-8+ T cells do not inhibit immunoglobulin synthesis when T cell lymphokines were used in place of helper CD4 T cells (CD4, Leu-8- T cells), suggesting that CD4 T cell-mediated suppression occurs at the T cell level. We conclude that CD4 T cells can be induced to suppress immunoglobulin synthesis by modulation of the membrane antigen recognized by anti-Leu-8 antibody.     

Effect of tolerance and of antibody mediated immune suppression on the avidity of the cellular and humoral immune response

Partial tolerance induction in adult rabbits although resulting in a marked depression of circulating antibody concentration, had no effect on either the avidity of the antibody synthesized at 2 weeks after immunization or the magnitude of the response of lymph node cells to stimulation by antigen in culture. A modest depression in the avidity of the cells responding to antigen in culture by an increase in thymidine incorporation was observed. Partial antibody mediated immune suppression was found to result in an increase in avidity of the residual circulating antibody and had no effect on the magnitude of the proliferative response induced by antigen in culture. Thus suppression appears to affect predominantly B-lymphocytes.     

Immune Response to Listeria monocytogenes in Rabbits and Humans

Rabbits were immunized with listeria antigens, staphylococcus antigen, or with both, and the course of their immune response was monitored. Antibodies to Listeria and Staphylococcus were produced in both immunoglobulin M (IgM) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) classes in response to inoculation with the specific antigen. Cross-responses occurred in rabbits injected only with Listeria or only with Staphylococcus, as well as in rabbits injected with both antigens. L. monocytogenes serotype 4d appeared to be immunologically distinct from L. monocytogenes serotype 2 and its cross-reaction with S. aureus. Human sera from bacteriologically confirmed cases of listeriosis were examined to determine the nature of the immunological response of man to Listeria. In the sera studied, IgM was the predominant antibody produced to Listeria, whereas cross-reactions with Staphylococcus were observed in both the IgM and the IgG antibody classes.     

From cell biology to immunology--a short trip

Immunologic memory and immunoglobulin allotype suppression are discussed as problems in Cell Biology. Memory, the ability of an animal after a first antigenic exposure to give a heightened and faster immune response upon a second exposure to the same antigen, is shown to be a property of bone marrow-derived cell lines. Expression of this memory depends on interaction with thymus-derived cells from either non-immunized or immunized mice. Chronic allotype suppression is described for the first time. It is initiated by in utero or neonatal exposure of (SJL × BALB/c)F₁ mice, allotype a/b, to anti b antibody. Suppression lasts for long periods and continues in irradiated recipients which have received lymphoid cells from suppressed donors. Selection against b allotype producing cell precursors can explain suppression.     

Reversible Blocking Effect of Anti-mouse Immunoglobulin Serum on the Induction of Immunity and Tolerance <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis>

THE induction of blast transformation by incubating lymphocytes with anti-immunoglobulin¹ and anti-allotype² sera has suggested that these cells have immunoglobulin on their surface. This hypothesis was directly verified by the demonstration of immunoglobulin on living mouse lymphoid cells by Raff et al.³. There is much evidence to indicate that immunocompetent cells have surface receptors for antigen. This idea is based on the finding that lymphocytes can bind radioactively labelled antigen to their surface^4,5 and that specific immune unresponsiveness occurs if lymphoid cells are exposed to either highly radioactive antigen⁶ or haptens capable of forming covalent bonds with proteins^7,8. The immunoglobulin nature of these antigen receptors is suggested by recent work showing that the binding of radioactively labelled antigen can be blocked by anti-immunoglobulin sera^5,9. Reports that the adoptive immune response of mouse spleen cells can be inhibited by anti-mouse immunoglobulin sera (AMS)^9,10 suggest that the interaction of antigen with the immunoglobulin receptor sites is a crucial step in the induction of the antibody response. We report here that the inhibitory action of AMS on the immune response is potentially reversible and that the induction of immune tolerance to polymerized flagellin (POL) in vitro may be blocked in the presence of AMS.     

The immunoregulatory role of bone marrow. I. Suppression of the induction of antibody responses to T-dependent and T-independent antigens by cells in the bone marrow.

Bone marrow cells (BMC) from normal mice suppressed the in vitro IgM, but not the IgG, antibody (Ab) response of spleen cells. BMC were inhibitory only when added during the first 24 hr of culture, and inhibition was not due to an induced shift in the kinetics of the response. Addition of specifically activated T cells or nonspecific T-cell-replacing factors to normal or T-depleted spleen cell cultures did not abrogate suppression while the response to the T-independent antigen DNP-polymerized flagellin or lipopolysaccharide was also suppressed. BMC did not inhibit background Ab synthesis by normal or primed cells in the absence of antigen and did not inhibit, but stimulated, DNA synthesis in normal spleen cell cultures. In addition, high-avidity Ab synthesis was preferentially suppressed. A possible role for the bone marrow suppressor cell in the induction of B cell tolerance is discussed.     

The influence of TRPM8 ion channel activation on immune response at different temperature conditions

In experiments on rats it was shown that it is possible to modulate the immune response in a whole organism by activating cold-sensitive TRPM8 ion channel by its agonist menthol. The most pronounced changes in the conditions without external temperature stimulation were related to immune parameters for the spleen cells and immunoglobulin level in blood: the activation of TRPM8 ion channel by menthol enhances antigen binding and inhibits antibody formation in spleen, significantly reduces the level of IgG in blood. Activation of TRPM8 ion channel changes the effect of subsequent temperature exposure—cooling or heating. Preliminary application of menthol eliminates the inhibitory effect of deep cooling on immune response. Stimulation of the antigen binding in spleen at deep heating is inversed to suppression in case of heating on the background of TRPM8 activation by menthol. On the contrary, suppression of antibody formation caused by deep heating is eliminated if heating is carried out on the background of TRPM8 stimulation.     

The suppressive effect of circulating specific antibody on the response to oral immunisation with Vibrio cholerae

Species IgG antibody given intravenously 3-4 hours prior to oral immunisation with Vibrio cholerae led to a specific depression of both the systemic and loca limmune response. One vibriocidal unit of IgG antibody, which itself would given undetectable levels of circulating specific antibody, was significantly immunosuppressive. The suppression is considered to be due to central repression of the antigen-reactive lymphocyte, rather than to antigen exclusion at the gut mucosal surface. The repression appeared less pronounced in some immunoglobulin classes than in others.     

In vitro evidence indicating a role for the Fc region of IgG in the mechanism for the long-term maintenance and regulation of antibody levels in vivo

The synthesis of anti-human serum albumin (HSA) antibody was induced spontaneously in cell cultures prepared from the draining lymph nodes of rabbits immunized months earlier with polymerized HSA. Serum from HSA-immunized rabbits suppressed this response. Removal of specific antibody from immune serum eliminated suppression and the addition of specific IgG restored suppression, indicating that the feedback phenomenon may be explained by an effect of specific IgG antibody. Fab and F(ab′)₂ fragments masked antigen as effectively as IgG; however, they were markedly inferior to IgG in mediating suppression. Furthermore, Fab competed with IgG and interfered with IgG mediated suppression. The addition of small amounts of antigen to antibody-suppressed cultures induced an antibody response. The level of induction was proportional to the antigen-antibody ratio. However, 80 to 100 times the antibody concentration needed to mask all antigenic determinants was needed in order to eliminate induction of antibody synthesis. High concentrations of antigen-antibody complexes at equivalence also suppressed the spontaneous response. This suppression was similar to antibody mediated suppression at the spontaneous response in that the Fc region of IgG was required.     

Antibody enhances lymphocyte proliferation in guinea pigs immunized to express cutaneous basophil hypersensitivity

Lymphocytes from HSA-sensitized guinea pigs expressing cutaneous basophil hypersensitivity (CBH) proliferate in the presence of specific antigen. We report that this proliferative response is enhanced by the addition of anti-HSA antibody, either in the form of whole immune serum or as purified antibody. The enhancement was characterized as a marked shift of the antigen dose-response curve such that significant [3H]thymidine incorporation was observed at antigen concentrations much lower than those eliciting a comparable response in the absence of immune serum. Enhancement was antigen specific and required an intact immunoglobulin molecule. Antibodies capable of enhancing antigen-specific lymphocyte proliferation could be isolated from serum by affinity chromatography as early as 7 days after sensitization and were also evident in sera obtained at later intervals. It is unlikely that such antibodies account for the progressive decline of CBH reactivity and they may actually influence its initial expression.     

Studies on the control of antibody synthesis. IX. Effect of boosting on antibody affinity.

The effect of boosting on antibody affinity was studied in a haptenic system. Generally, boosting results in the prompt synthesis of high affinity anti-hapten antibody. However, repeated boosting frequently leads to a decrease in the amount and affinity of the serum antibody. Repeated boosting with hapten on a carrier different from that used for priming selectively stimulates synthesis of the highest affinity anti-hapten antibody and does not result in a decrease in affinity. Priming with soluble antigen without adjuvants results in the synthesis of low affinity antibody. After such priming, boosting stimulates low affinity antibody synthesis and repeated boosting leads to a moderate increase in antibody affinity.     

Regulation of immune response in allogeneic mixed spleen cell cultures. I. Influence of I-region on the generation of suppressor cells

The immune responses of allogeneic mixed spleen cell cultures (MLC) to the T-dependent antigen, SRBC, and to the T-independent antigen, DNP-PAA, were investigated. The immune response to DNP-PAA in MLC with certain strain combinations was always suppressed as compared with the expected PFC response calculated from the PFC responses of the individual strains. This suppression was eliminated by treating the spleen cells with RAMB antiserum plus complement before the incubation of the MLC with DNP-PAA. It can be concluded that the suppression in the PFC response to the T-independent antigen DNP-PAA in MLC is due to the generation of suppressor T-cells. The PFC response to the T-dependent antigen, SRBC, in MLC showed either suppression, no change, or rarely augmenation, suggesting that the allogeneic mixed spleen cell cultures can generate both suppressor and helper T cells and that the balance between helper and suppressor activity regulates the PFC response to a T-dependent antigen. Suppressor activity was also generated in a one-way MLC, but the degree of suppression depended upon which of the two strains was responding. Similar amounts of thymidine were incorporated in the one-way MLR irrespective of which strains was responding. Thus, the extent of proliferation in one-way MLR is not related to the degree of suppressor activity generated. The results further indicate that a difference between two strains in the I-C, S, and G regions of the major histocompatibility complex is required to generate suppressor activitiy that can depress the response to a T-independent antigen, MLC between strains differing in K, I-A, I-B, I-J, I-E, and D regions generate little or no suppressor activity in this system.     

Humoral immune response of asymptomatic cats naturally infected with feline leukemia virus

The humoral immune response of cats that were naturally infected with the feline leukemia virus (FeLV) was examined after antigenic stimulation with the synthetic antigen poly(L-Tyr, L-Glu)-poly(DL-Ala)-poly(L-Lys). The primary humoral antibody response in FeLV-infected cats was both delayed and greatly reduced, compared with that seen in uninfected control cats. A similar discordance was observed after secondary stimulation with the antigen, in the FeLV-infected cats had both a delayed response and a reduced response, compared with uninfected cats. The levels of total immunoglobulins of the immunoglobulin G and immunoglobulin M classes in the sera of FeLV-infected cats were significantly higher (two- and threefold, respectively) than were those of the uninfected control animals. The presence of an impaired humoral immune response to newly presented antigens in the presence of elevated immunoglobulin levels has been thoroughly documented in the case of people with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. This further emphasizes the potential value of FeLV-infected cats as a model for human acquired immunodeficiency syndrome.     

Memory in the B-cell compartment: antibody affinity maturation

In the humoral arm of the immune system, the memory response is not only more quickly elicited and of greater magnitude than the primary response, but it is also different in quality. In the recall response to antigen, the antibodies produced are of higher affinity and of different isotype (typically immunoglobulin G rather than immunoglobulin M). This maturation rests on the antigen dependence of B-cell maturation and is effected by programmed genetic modifications of the immunoglobulin gene loci. Here we consider how the B-cell response to antigen depends on the affinity of the antigen receptor interaction. We also compare and draw parallels between the two processes, which underpin the generation of secondary-response antibodies: V gene somatic hypermutation and immunoglobulin heavy-chain class switching.     

On the control between cell-mediated, IgM and IgG immunity

An hypothesis is proposed here describing some of the conditions that determine the type of response an antigen will induce, and explaining how the induction of one type of immunity affects the induction of other types of immunity. In more detail, the hypothesis attempts to account for the following observations: Some antigens induce only cell-mediated immunity, whereas others can, under different conditions, induce either cell-mediated or humoral immunity. The humoral response to most antigens consists of an initial period of IgM antibody synthesis, followed by a period of IgG synthesis. Some polymeric antigens induce the synthesis of only IgM antibody. There is a tendency for the immune response to an antigen, at a particular time, to be exclusively of the cell-mediated, IgM or IgG type.The hypothesis may also be relevant to some observations that, I believe, have been incorrectly interpreted to mean that “tolerance” to some antigens requires the presence of T (thymus-derived) cells specific for these antigens. The hypothesis suggests teleological reasons for the existence of the different types of immunity. It also suggests ways of controlling the type of response an antigen induces.     

Antibody formation in young rabbits immunized with heterologous serum proteins

Rabbits were immunized with human or bovine albumin at different intervals after birth and antibody formation was studied by haemagglutination of red cells sensitized with the relevant antigen. The intraperitoneal injection of antigen in amounts of 5 mg. induced antibody formation in some litters 16–20 days after immunization, if the animals were over three days old when immunized. In younger rabbits the same dose induced tolerance. Even when different methods of enhancing the effect of the antigen (Freund’s adjuvant, Al (OH)₃, antigen-conjugated red cells, immune precipitates) or very small doses of antigen were used, antibody formation was still not detected before the 20th day of life. The use of¹³¹I-BSA did not demonstrate the immune phase of elimination of the antigen during 17 days after administration of the antigen, even in rabbits immunized 14 days after birth. The relationship of antibody formation to the induction of tolerance and the difference in the response of newborn rabbits to immunization with the different types of antigen is discussed.     

Class, amounts, and affinities of anti-dinitrophenyl antibodies in chickens. II. Production of a restricted population of high affinity 7S antibodies by injection of antigen emulsified in adjuvant.

The response of chickens given a single intramuscular injection of maximally coupled dinitrophenylated-gamma-bovine beta-globulin in either Freund's complete (FCA) or incomplete (FIA) adjuvants was characterized by an initial synthesis of 7S and 17S antibodies followed by the exclusive and persistent production of 7S antibodies. The 17S antibodies were not detected either 3 to 4 weeks after a single injection or after an intravenous boost 16 months later. Injections of low doses of antigen in FCA induced the synthesis of 7S antibodies of high affinity at least by 4 months. Analyses of the Sips plots generated from equilibrium dialysis data indicated that a shift in the distribution of 7S antibody affinities occurred because of the production of a restricted population of high affinity antibodies. The changes in the binding properties of antibody during the immune response from chickens given antigen in FIA were less apparent, although qualitatively similar, to those found in birds given antigen in FCA. Three possibilities were presented to explain the effect of adjuvant on the class and affinity of the antibody: a) the requirement of a second signal for B cell differentiation, b) the presence of subpopulation of B cells, and c) somatic mutation events.