A functional Wood–Ljungdahl pathway devoid of a formate dehydrogenase in the gut acetogens Blautia wexlerae,Blautia luti and beyond

Species of the genus Blautia are typical inhabitants of the human gut and considered as beneficial gut microbes. However, their role in the gut microbiome and their metabolic features are poorly understood. Blautia schinkii was described as an acetogenic bacterium, characterized by a functional Wood–Ljungdahl pathway (WLP) of acetogenesis from H₂ + CO₂. Here we report that two relatives, Blautia luti and Blautia wexlerae do not grow on H₂ + CO₂. Inspection of the genome sequence revealed all genes of the WLP except genes encoding a formate dehydrogenase and an electron-bifurcating hydrogenase. Enzyme assays confirmed this prediction. Accordingly, resting cells neither converted H₂ + CO₂ nor H₂ + HCOOH + CO₂ to acetate. Carbon monoxide is an intermediate of the WLP and substrate for many acetogens. Blautia luti and B. wexlerae had an active CO dehydrogenase and resting cells performed acetogenesis from HCOOH + CO₂ + CO, demonstrating a functional WLP. Bioinformatic analyses revealed that many Blautia strains as well as other gut acetogens lack formate dehydrogenases and hydrogenases. Thus, the use of formate instead of H₂ + CO₂ as an interspecies hydrogen and electron carrier seems to be more common in the gut microbiome.     

One substrate,many fates: different ways of methanol utilization in the acetogen Acetobacterium woodii

Acetogenic bacteria such as Acetobacterium woodii use the Wood–Ljungdahl pathway (WLP) for fixation of CO₂ and energy conservation. This pathway enables conversion of diverse substrates to the main product of acetogenesis, acetate. Methyl group containing substrates such as methanol or methylated compounds, derived from pectin, are abundant in the environment and a source for CO₂. Methyl groups enter the WLP at the level of methyltetrahydrofolic acid (methyl-THF). For methyl transfer from methanol to THF a substrate-specific methyltransferase system is required. In this study, we used genetic methods to identify mtaBC2A (Awo_c22760-Awo_c22740) as the methanol-specific methyltransferase system of A. woodii. After methyl transfer, methyl-THF serves as carbon and/or electron source and the respiratory Rnf complex is required for redox homeostasis if methanol + CO₂ is the substrate. Resting cells fed with methanol + CO₂, indeed converted methanol to acetate in a 4:3 stoichiometry. When methanol was fed in combination with other electron sources such as H₂ + CO₂ or CO, methanol was converted Rnf-independently and the methyl group was condensed with CO to build acetate. When fed in combination with alternative electron sinks such as caffeate methanol was oxidized only and resulting electrons were used for non-acetogenic growth. These different pathways for the conversion of methyl-group containing substrates enable acetogens to adapt to various ecological niches and to syntrophic communities.     

Transient Production of Formate During Chemolithotrophic Growth of Anaerobic Microorganisms on Hydrogen

The homoacetogenic bacteria Acetobacterium woodii, A. carbinolicum, Sporomusa ovata, and Eubacterium limosum, the methanogenic archaeon Methanobacterium formicicum, and the sulfate-reducing bacterium Desulfotomaculum orientis all produced formate as an intermediate when they were growing chemolithoautotrophically with H₂ and CO₂ as sources of energy, electrons, and carbon. The sulfate-reducing bacterium Desulfovibrio vulgaris grew chemolithoheterotrophically with H₂ and CO₂ using acetate as carbon source, but also produced formate when growth was limited by sulfate. All these bacteria were also able to grow on formate as energy source. Formate accumulated transiently while H₂ was consumed. The maximum formate concentrations measured in cultures of A. woodii and A. carbinolicum were proportional to the initial H₂ partial pressure, giving a ratio of about 0.5 mM formate per 10 kPa H₂. The methanogen Methanobacterium bryantii, on the other hand, was unable to grow on formate and did not produce formate during chemolithoautotrophic growth on H₂. The results indicate that the ability to utilize formate, that is, to possess a formate dehydrogenase, was the precondition for the production of formate during chemolithotrophic growth on H₂. Received: 24 November 1998 / Accepted: 30 December 1998     

Effect of molecular hydrogen and carbon dioxide on chemo-organotrophic growth of Acetobacterium woodii and Clostridium aceticum

During growth of Acetobacterium woodii on fructose, glucose or lactate in a medium containing less than 0.04% bicarbonate, molecular hydrogen was evolved up to 0.1 mol per mol of substrate. Under an H₂-atmosphere growth of A. woodii with organic substrates was completely inhibited whereas under an H₂/CO₂-atmosphere rapid growth occurred. Under these conditions H₂+CO₂ and the organic substrate were utilized simultaneously indicating that A. woodii was able to grow mixotrophically. Clostridium aceticum differed from A. woodii in that H₂ was only evolved in the stationary phase, that the inhibition by H₂ was observed at pH 8.5 but not at pH 7.5, anf that in the presence of fructose and H₂+CO₂ only fructose was utilized.The hydrogenase activity of fructose-grown cells of C. aceticum amounted to only 12% of that of H₂+CO₂-grown cells. With A. woodii a corresponding decrease of the activity of this enzyme was not observed.     

Novel synthetic co-culture of Acetobacterium woodii and Clostridium drakei using CO2 and in situ generated H2 for the production of caproic acid via lactic acid

Acetobacterium woodii is known to produce mainly acetate from CO₂ and H₂, but the production of higher value chemicals is desired for the bioeconomy. Using chain-elongating bacteria, synthetic co-cultures have the potential to produce longer-chained products such as caproic acid. In this study, we present first results for a successful autotrophic co-cultivation of A. woodii mutants and a Clostridium drakei wild-type strain in a stirred-tank bioreactor for the production of caproic acid from CO₂ and H₂ via the intermediate lactic acid. For autotrophic lactate production, a recombinant A. woodii strain with a deleted Lct-dehydrogenase complex, which is encoded by the lctBCD genes, and an inserted D-lactate dehydrogenase (LdhD) originating from Leuconostoc mesenteroides, was used. Hydrogen for the process was supplied using an All-in-One electrode for in situ water electrolysis. Lactate concentrations as high as 0.5 g L^–1 were achieved with the AiO-electrode, whereas 8.1 g L^–1 lactate were produced with direct H₂ sparging in a stirred-tank bioreactor. Hydrogen limitation was identified in the AiO process. However, with cathode surface area enlargement or numbering-up of the electrode and on-demand hydrogen generation, this process has great potential for a true carbon-negative production of value chemicals from CO₂.     

CO Metabolism in the Acetogen Acetobacterium woodii

The Wood-Ljungdahl pathway allows acetogenic bacteria to grow on a number of one-carbon substrates, such as carbon dioxide, formate, methyl groups, or even carbon monoxide. Since carbon monoxide alone or in combination with hydrogen and carbon dioxide (synthesis gas) is an increasingly important feedstock for third-generation biotechnology, we studied CO metabolism in the model acetogen Acetobacterium woodii. When cells grew on H₂-CO₂, addition of 5 to 15% CO led to higher final optical densities, indicating the utilization of CO as a cosubstrate. However, the growth rate was decreased by the presence of small amounts of CO, which correlated with an inhibition of H₂ consumption. Experiments with resting cells revealed that the degree of inhibition of H₂ consumption was a function of the CO concentration. Since the hydrogen-dependent CO₂ reductase (HDCR) of A. woodii is known to be very sensitive to CO, we speculated that cells may be more tolerant toward CO when growing on formate, the product of the HDCR reaction. Indeed, addition of up to 25% CO did not influence growth rates on formate, while the final optical densities and the production of acetate increased. Higher concentrations (75 and 100%) led to a slight inhibition of growth and to decreasing rates of formate and CO consumption. Experiments with resting cells revealed that the HDCR is a site of CO inhibition. In contrast, A. woodii was not able to grow on CO as a sole carbon and energy source, and growth on fructose-CO or methanol-CO was not observed.     

Revealing formate production from carbon monoxide in wild type and mutants of Rnf- and Ech-containing acetogens,Acetobacterium woodii and Thermoanaerobacter kivui

Acetogenic bacteria have gained much attraction in recent years as they can produce different biofuels and biochemicals from H₂ plus CO₂ or even CO alone, therefore opening a promising alternative route for the production of biofuels from renewable sources compared to existing sugar-based routes. However, CO metabolism still raises questions concerning the biochemistry and bioenergetics in many acetogens. In this study, we focused on the two acetogenic bacteria Acetobacterium woodii and Thermoanaerobacter kivui which, so far, are the only identified acetogens harbouring a H₂-dependent CO₂ reductase and furthermore belong to different classes of ‘Rnf’- and ‘Ech-acetogens’. Both strains catalysed the conversion of CO into the bulk chemical acetate and formate. Formate production was stimulated by uncoupling the energy metabolism from the Wood–Ljungdahl pathway, and specific rates of 1.44 and 1.34 mmol g⁻¹ h⁻¹ for A. woodii ∆rnf and T. kivui wild type were reached. The demonstrated CO-based formate production rates are, to the best of our knowledge, among the highest rates ever reported. Using mutants of ∆hdcr, ∆cooS, ∆hydBA, ∆rnf and ∆ech2 with deficiencies in key enzyme activities of the central metabolism enabled us to postulate two different CO utilization pathways in these two model organisms.     

Differential effects of sodium ions on motility in the homoacetogenic bacteriaAcetobacterium woodii andSporomusa sphaeroides

The strictly anaerobic homoacetogenic bacteria Acetobacterium woodii and Sporomusa sphaeroides differ with respect to their energy metabolism. Since growth as well as acetate and ATP formation of A. woodii is strictly dependent on Na⁺, but that of S. sphaeroides is not, the question arose whether these organisms also use different coupling ions for mechanical work, i.e. flagellar rotation. During growth on fructose in the presence of Na⁺ (50 mM), cells of A. woodii were vigorously motile, as judged by light microscopy. At low Na⁺ concentrations (0.3 mM), the growth rate decreased by only 15%, but the cells were completely non-motile. Addition of Na⁺ to such cultures restored motility instantaneously. Motility, as determined in swarm agar tubes, was strictly dependent on Na⁺; Li⁺, but not K⁺ partly substituted for Na⁺. Of the amilorides tested, phenamil proved to be a specific inhibitor of the flagellar motor of A. woodii. Growth and motility of S. sphaeroides was neither dependent on Na⁺ nor inhibited by amiloride derivatives. These results indicate that flagellar rotation is driven by Δμ_Na ⁺ in A. woodii, but by Δμ_H ⁺ in S. sphaeroides. Received: 30 May 1995 / Accepted: 31 August 1995     

Complete degradation of carbohydrate to carbon dioxide and methane by syntrophic cultures of Acetobacterium woodii and Methanosarcina barkeri

Methanosarcina barkeri (strain MS) grew and converted acetate to CO₂ and methane after an adaption period of 20 days. Growth and metabolism were rapid with gas production being comparable to that of cells grown on H₂ and CO₂. After an intermediary growth cycle under a H₂ and CO₂ atmosphere acetateadapted cells were capable of growth on acetate with formation of methane and CO₂. When acetate-adapted Methanosarcina barkeri was co-cultered with Acetobacterium woodii on fructose or glucose as substrate, a complete conversion of the carbohydrate to gases (CO₂ and CH₄) was observed.Abbreviation CMC carboxymethyl cellulose     

Deciphering mixotrophic Clostridium formicoaceticum metabolism and energy conservation: Genomic analysis and experimental studies

Clostridium formicoaceticum, a Gram-negative mixotrophic homoacetogen, produces acetic acid as the sole metabolic product from various carbon sources, including fructose, glycerol, formate, and CO₂. Its genome of 4.59-Mbp contains a highly conserved Wood-Ljungdahl pathway gene cluster with the same layout as that in other mixotrophic acetogens, including Clostridium aceticum, Clostridium carboxidivorans, and Clostridium ljungdahlii. For energy conservation, C. formicoaceticum does not have all the genes required for the synthesis of cytochrome or quinone used for generating proton gradient in H⁺-dependent acetogens such as Moorella thermoacetica; instead, it has the Rnf system and a Na⁺-translocating ATPase similar to the one in Acetobacterium woodii. Its growth in both heterotrophic and autotrophic media were dependent on the sodium concentration. C. formicoaceticum has genes encoding acetaldehyde dehydrogenases, alcohol dehydrogenases, and aldehyde oxidoreductases, which could convert acetyl-CoA and acetate to ethanol and butyrate to butanol under excessive reducing equivalent conditions.     

A genome-guided analysis of energy conservation in the thermophilic,cytochrome-free acetogenic bacterium Thermoanaerobacter?kivui

Background

Acetogenic bacteria are able to use CO₂ as terminal electron acceptor of an anaerobic respiration, thereby producing acetate with electrons coming from H₂. Due to this feature, acetogens came into focus as platforms to produce biocommodities from waste gases such as H₂ + CO₂ and/or CO. A prerequisite for metabolic engineering is a detailed understanding of the mechanisms of ATP synthesis and electron-transfer reactions to ensure redox homeostasis. Acetogenesis involves the reduction of CO₂ to acetate via soluble enzymes and is coupled to energy conservation by a chemiosmotic mechanism. The membrane-bound module, acting as an ion pump, was of special interest for decades and recently, an Rnf complex was shown to couple electron flow from reduced ferredoxin to NAD⁺ with the export of Na⁺ in Acetobacterium woodii. However, not all acetogens have rnf genes in their genome. In order to gain further insights into energy conservation of non-Rnf-containing, thermophilic acetogens, we sequenced the genome of Thermoanaerobacter kivui.

Results

The genome of Thermoanaerobacter kivui comprises 2.9 Mbp with a G + C content of 35% and 2,378 protein encoding orfs. Neither autotrophic growth nor acetate formation from H₂ + CO₂ was dependent on Na⁺ and acetate formation was inhibited by a protonophore, indicating that H⁺ is used as coupling ion for primary bioenergetics. This is consistent with the finding that the c subunit of the F₁F_O ATP synthase does not have the conserved Na⁺ binding motif. A search for potential H⁺-translocating, membrane-bound protein complexes revealed genes potentially encoding two different proton-reducing, energy-conserving hydrogenases (Ech).

Conclusions

The thermophilic acetogen T. kivui does not use Na⁺ but H⁺ for chemiosmotic ATP synthesis. It does not contain cytochromes and the electrochemical proton gradient is most likely established by an energy-conserving hydrogenase (Ech). Its thermophilic nature and the efficient conversion of H₂ + CO₂ make T. kivui an interesting acetogen to be used for the production of biocommodities in industrial micobiology. Furthermore, our experimental data as well as the increasing number of sequenced genomes of acetogenic bacteria supported the new classification of acetogens into two groups: Rnf- and Ech-containing acetogens.     

Energetics and regulations of formate and hydrogen metabolism by Methanobacterium formicicum

Accumulation of formate to millimolar levels was observed during the growth of Methanobacterium formicicum species on H₂–CO₂. Hydrogen was also produced during formate metabolism by M. formicicum. The amount of formate accumulated in the medium or the amount H₂ released in gas phase was influenced by the bicarbonate concentration. The formate hydrogenlyase system was constitutive but regulated by formate. When methanogenesis was inhibited by addition of 2-bromoethane sulfonate, M. formicicum synthesized formate from H₂ plus HCO _inf3 ^sup- or produced H₂ from formate to a steady-state level at which point the Gibbs free energy (G) available for formate synthesis or H₂ production was approximately -2 to -3 kJ/reaction. Formate conversion to methane was inhibited in the presence of high H₂ pressure. The relative rates of conversion of formate and H₂ were apparently controlled by the G available for formate synthesis, hydrogen production, methane production from formate and methane production from H₂. Results from ¹⁴C-tracer tests indicated that a rapid isotopic exchange between HCOO^- and HCO _inf3 ^sup- occurred during the growth of M. formicicum on H₂–CO₂. Data from metabolism of ¹⁴C-labelled formate to methane suggested that formate was initially split to H₂ and HCO _inf3 ^sup- and then subsequently converted to methane. When molybdate was replaced with tungstate in the growth media, the growth of M. formicicum strain MF on H₂–CO₂ was inhibited although production of methane was not Formate synthesis from H₂ was also inhibited.     

Formate production and utilization by methanogens and by sewage sludge consortia — interference with the concept of interspecies formate transfer

Pure cultures of H₂/CO₂- and formate-utilizing methanogens or mixed consortia of sewage sludge generated some formate from H₂/CO₂ at H₂ partial pressure in the gas phase above 200 kPa. At decreasing H₂ partial pressure the formate was taken up again and converted to methane. If methanogenesis was inhibited by bromoethanesulphonic acid (BESA) or a high redox potential (–180 to –200 mV), formate-utilizing methanogens produced high amounts of formate from H₂/CO₂. No formate was excreted by the species, which could only utilize H₂/CO₂ for methanogenesis. In contrast, H₂ formation from formate was observed in cultures of Methanobacterium thermoformicicum and M. formicicum. Measurable amounts were, however, only formed if its immediate utilization for methane production was inhibited by BESA. In the light of the data on formate formation from H₂/CO₂ and its re-utilization by all formate-utilizing methanogens, the concept of interspecies formate transfer of Thiele and Zeikus should be reconsidered. In pure cultures of methanogens or complex ecosystems with excess H₂, formate formation seemed to serve more as a means of disposal of surplus reducing power than for H₂ transfer. Correspondence to: J. Winter     

Anaerobic biodegradation of methyl esters byAcetobacterium woodii andEubacterium limosum

Summary The ability ofAcetobacterium woodii andEubacterium limosum to degrade methyl esters of acetate, propionate, butyrate, and isobutyrate was examined under growing and resting-cell conditions. Both bacteria hydrolyzed the esters to the corresponding carboxylates and methanol under either condition. Methanol was further oxidized to formate under growing but not resting conditions. Unlike the metabolism of phenylmethylethers, no H₂ requirement was evident for ester biotransformation. The hydrolysis of methyl carboxylates is thermodynamically favorable under standard conditions and the mixotrophic metabolism of ester/CO₂ allowed for bacterial growth. These results suggest that the degradation of methyl carboxylates may be a heretofore unrecognized nutritional option for acetogenic bacteria.     

Growth yield increase linked to caffeate reduction in Acetobacterium woodii

Growth yields were determined with Acetobacterium woodii strain NZva 16 on hydrogen and CO₂, formate, methanol, vanillate, ferulate and fructose in mineral medium in the absence and presence of 0.05% yeast extract. Yeast extract was not essential for growth but enhanced growth yields by 25–100% depending on the substrate fermented. Comparison of yields on formate or methanol allowed calculation of an energy yield in the range of 1.5–2 mol ATP per mol acetate formed during homoacetate fermentation of A. woodii. In the presence of 6 mM caffeate, growth yields were determined with the substrates formate or methanol. Caffeate was reduced to hydrocaffeate and increased growth yields were obtained. An ATP yield of about 1 mol per mol of caffeate reduced was calculated. Cytochromes were not detectable in cell free extracts or membrane preparations.     

Pyruvate fermentation in Rhodospirillum rubrum and after transfer from aerobic to anaerobic conditions in the dark

The fermentative metabolism of Rhodospirillum rubrum (strain Ha, F₁, S₁) was studied after transfering the cells from aerobic to anaerobic dark culture conditions. Pyruvate was metabolized mainly to acetate and formate, and to a lesser extent to CO₂ and propionate, by all strains. Therefore, pyruvate formate lyase would appear to be the characteristic key enzyme of the dark anaerobic fermentation metabolism in R. rubrum. Strain F₁ and S₁ metabolized the formate further to H₂ and CO₂. It is concluded that this cleavage was catalysed by a formate hydrogen lyase system. Strain Ha was unable to metabolize formate. The cleavage of formate and the synthesis of poly--hydroxy-butyric acid were increased by a low pH value (6.5). Fermentation equations and schemes of the pyruvate metabolism are discussed.     

Electron availability in CO2, CO and H2 mixtures constrains flux distribution,energy management and product formation in Clostridium ljungdahlii

Acetogens such as Clostridium ljungdahlii can play a crucial role reducing the human CO₂ footprint by converting industrial emissions containing CO₂, CO and H₂ into valuable products such as organic acids or alcohols. The quantitative understanding of cellular metabolism is a prerequisite to exploit the bacterial endowments and to fine-tune the cells by applying metabolic engineering tools. Studying the three gas mixtures CO₂ + H₂, CO and CO + CO₂ + H₂ (syngas) by continuously gassed batch cultivation experiments and applying flux balance analysis, we identified CO as the preferred carbon and electron source for growth and producing alcohols. However, the total yield of moles of carbon (mol-C) per electrons consumed was almost identical in all setups which underlines electron availability as the main factor influencing product formation. The Wood–Ljungdahl pathway (WLP) showed high flexibility by serving as the key NAD⁺ provider for CO₂ + H_2, whereas this function was strongly compensated by the transhydrogenase-like Nfn complex when CO was metabolized. Availability of reduced ferredoxin (Fd_red) can be considered as a key determinant of metabolic control. Oxidation of CO via carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) is the main route of Fd_red formation when CO is used as substrate, whereas Fd_red is mainly regenerated via the methyl branch of WLP and the Nfn complex utilizing CO₂ + H₂. Consequently, doubled growth rates, highest ATP formation rates and highest amounts of reduced products (ethanol, 2,3-butanediol) were observed when CO was the sole carbon and electron source.     

Biosynthesis of the respiratory formate dehydrogenases from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis>: characterization of the FdhE protein

Escherichia coli can perform two modes of formate metabolism. Under respiratory conditions, two periplasmically-located formate dehydrogenase isoenzymes couple formate oxidation to the generation of a transmembrane electrochemical gradient; and under fermentative conditions a third cytoplasmic isoenzyme is involved in the disproportionation of formate to CO₂ and H₂. The respiratory formate dehydrogenases are redox enzymes that comprise three subunits: a molybdenum cofactor- and FeS cluster-containing catalytic subunit; an electron-transferring ferredoxin; and a membrane-integral cytochrome b. The catalytic subunit and its ferredoxin partner are targeted to the periplasm as a complex by the twin-arginine transport (Tat) pathway. Biosynthesis of these enzymes is under control of an accessory protein termed FdhE. In this study, it is shown that E. coli FdhE interacts with the catalytic subunits of the respiratory formate dehydrogenases. Purification of recombinant FdhE demonstrates the protein is an iron-binding rubredoxin that can adopt monomeric and homodimeric forms. Bacterial two-hybrid analysis suggests the homodimer form of FdhE is stabilized by anaerobiosis. Site-directed mutagenesis shows that conserved cysteine motifs are essential for the physiological activity of the FdhE protein and are also involved in iron ligation.