The relative contribution of electrostatic interactions to stabilization of collagen fibrils

Electrostatic energies of interaction between type I collagen molecules were calculated, using models developed by Timasheff and Hill. These energies, along with a contribution from hydrophobic forces, were then incorporated into an equation due to Flory that described phase equilibria of rod-like polymers. The Flory formalism in turn permitted a calculation of the overall free energy of fibril formation (delta Ff), and an assessment of the relative contribution of electrostatic and hydrophobic forces to delta Ff. Lastly, delta Ff was used in a nucleation-growth model relating halftimes of fibril formation (t1/2) to ionic strength (I) and temperature. Because the theory provided no basis for setting absolute levels of the energetic contributions, five parameters in the model had to be derived from experimental data. Based on the fit of theory to experimental results both for intact and pepsinized collagen, it was found that very low electrostatic energies (about -1 kcal/mole per collagen molecule) were sufficient to explain experimental t1/2 vs I relationships. This energy is equivalent to 1 close charge-pair interaction per molecule and appears to be lower than the energy assignable to hydrophobic interactions.     

The role of hydrophobic bonding in collagen fibril formation: a quantitative model

A model has been developed for approximating the free energy of collagen fibril formation (ΔF_f) and the equilibrium solubility of collagen under physiological conditions. The model utilizes an expression of Flory for rodlike polymers, with the modification that the “pure” anisotropic phase is defined as a collagen fibril containing about 0.3 g water/g collagen. The model also assumes that χ₁, the polymer–solvent interaction term, is entirely due to hydrophobic effects. χ₁ is estimated from hydrophobic bond energies of amino acid side chains, using the results of Némethy and Scheraga. The temperature dependence of χ₁ is utilized to calculate equilibrium solubilities and ΔF_f as a function of temperature.     

Thermodynamic parameters of fibril formation activation of evolutionary differentiated collagens

Activation parameters of fibril formation of evolutionary differing collagens were investigated. It has been shown that in a heated solution formation of collagen fibrils of different origin proceeds in different temperature regions related with the environmental temperature of species range. Enthalpy and free energy of the activation of fibril formation were measured. The data obtained show that fibril formation is preceded by the conformation of the molecules. Biological significance of the correspondence between the temperature of denaturation and that of the species range is discussed. The above correspondence is the limiting expression of functional dependence of conformational flexibility on temperature. Directed selection realized in the course of evolution is required for maintaining the velocity of collagen synthesis at the constant level.     

Modulation of collagen fibrillogenesis by tenascin-X and type VI collagen

Tenascin-X (TNX) is an extracellular matrix glycoprotein. We previously demonstrated that TNX regulates the expression of type VI collagen. In this study, we investigated the binding of TNX to type I collagen as well as to type VI collagen and the effects of these proteins on fibrillogenesis of type I collagen. Full-length recombinant TNX, which is expressed in and purified from mammalian cell cultures, and type VI collagen purified from bovine placenta were used. Solid-phase assays revealed that TNX or type VI collagen bound to type I collagen, although TNX did not bind to type VI collagen, fibronectin, or laminin. The rate of collagen fibril formation and its quantity, measured as increased turbidity, was markedly increased by the presence of TNX, whereas type VI collagen did not increase the quantity but accelerated the rate of collagen fibril formation. Combined treatment of both had an additive effect on the rate of collagen fibril formation. Furthermore, deletion of the epidermal growth factor-like (EGF) domain or fibrinogen-like domain of TNX attenuated the initial rate of collagen fibril formation. Finally, we observed abnormally large collagen fibrils by electron microscopy in the skin from TNX-deficient (TNX-/-) mice during development. These findings demonstrate a fundamental role for TNX and type VI collagen in regulation of collagen fibrillogenesis in vivo and in vitro.     

Does collagen microunfolding stimulate fibril formation?

The data on the effect of temperature on the kinetics of collagen fibril formation at physiological pH values and ionic strength in the temperature range 26–39°C have been analyzed. The temperature of 35°C optimal for collagen fibril formation has been defined as the point of inflection for half-maximal turbidity and collagen molecule microunfolding values, which corresponds to the temperature of the first transition on the heat absorption curve. The temperature range (32–35°C) in which collagen microunfolding stimulates fibril formation has been determined.     

Time-dependent increase in the stability of collagen fibrils formed in vitro. I. Effects of pH and salt concentration on the dissolution of the fibrils.

The time-dependent increase in stability, as measured in terms of the rate of dissolution, of collagen fibrils formed in vitro from pepsin-treated collagen was significantly affected only by temperature, and not by either ionic strength or pH. This is in contrast with collagen fibril formation, a process which is greatly affected by ionic strength and pH. Within the range of temperature 29-37 degrees C, lower temperature caused slower fibril formation and faster fibril stabilization. These results suggest that the intermolecular interactions involved in stabilizing collagen fibrils are entirely different from those involved in fibril formation. Based on kinetic analysis of the dissolution and stabilization of the fibrils, it is proposed that collagen molecules first form unstable fibrils which become gradually stabilized on prolonged incubation, without necessarily introducing covalent cross-links.     

COMP acts as a catalyst in collagen fibrillogenesis

We have previously reported that COMP (cartilage oligomeric matrix protein) is prominent in cartilage but is also present in tendon and binds to collagens I and II with high affinity. Here we show that COMP influences the fibril formation of these collagens. Fibril formation in the presence of pentameric COMP was much faster, and the amount of collagen in fibrillar form was markedly increased. Monomeric COMP, lacking the N-terminal coiled-coil linker domain, decelerated fibrillogenesis. The data show that stimulation of collagen fibrillogenesis depends on the pentameric nature of COMP and not only on collagen binding. COMP interacts primarily with free collagen I and II molecules, bringing several molecules to close proximity, apparently promoting further assembly. These assemblies further join in discrete steps to a narrow distribution of completed fibril diameters of 149 +/- 16 nm with a banding pattern of 67 nm. COMP is not found associated with the mature fibril and dissociates from the collagen molecules or their early assemblies. However, a few COMP molecules are found bound to more loosely associated molecules at the tip/end of the growing fibril. Thus, COMP appears to catalyze the fibril formation by promoting early association of collagen molecules leading to increased rate of fibrillogenesis and more distinct organization of the fibrils.     

Dynamic behavior of small heat shock protein inhibition on amyloid fibrillization of a small peptide (SSTSAA) from RNase A

Small heat shock proteins, a class of molecular chaperones, are reported to inhibit amyloid fibril formation in vitro, while the mechanism of inhibition remains unknown. In the present study, we investigated the mechanism by which Mj HSP16.5 inhibits amyloid fibril formation of a small peptide (SSTSAA) from RNase A. A model peptide (dansyl-SSTSAA-W) was designed by introducing a pair of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) probes into the peptide, allowing for the monitoring of fibril formation by this experimental model. Mj HSP16.5 completely inhibited fibril formation of the model peptide at a molar ratio of 1:120. The dynamic process of fibril formation, revealed by FRET, circular dichroism, and electron microscopy, showed a lag phase of about 2 h followed by a fast growth period. The effect of Mj HSP16.5 on amyloid fibril formation was investigated by adding it into the incubation solution during different growth phases. Adding Mj HSP16.5 to the incubating peptide before or during the lag phase completely inhibited fibril formation. However, introducing Mj HSP16.5 after the lag phase only slowed down the fibril formation process by adhering to the already formed fibrils. These findings provide insight into the inhibitory roles of small heat shock proteins on amyloid fibril formation at the molecular level.     

Interaction of collagen molecules from the aspect of fibril formation: acid-soluble, alkali-treated, and MMP1-digested fragments of type I collagen.

Collagen type I extracted with acid or digested with pepsin forms fibrils under physiological conditions, but this ability is lost when the collagen is treated with alkaline solution or digested with matrix metalloproteinase 1 (MMP1). When acid-soluble collagen was incubated with alkali-treated collagen, the fibril formation of acid-soluble collagen was inhibited. At 37 degrees C, at which alkali-treated collagen is denatured, the lag time was prolonged but the growth rate of fibrils was not affected. At 30 degrees C, at which the triple helical conformation of alkali-treated collagen is retained, the lag time was prolonged and the growth rate reduced. Heat-denatured alkali-treated collagen and MMP1-digested fragments have no inhibitory effect on the fibril formation of acid-soluble collagen. This means that the triple helical conformation and the molecular length are important factors in the interaction of collagen molecules and that alkali-treated collagen acts as a competitive inhibitor for fibril formation of collagen. We found that alkali-treated collagen and MMP1-digested fragments form fibrils that lack the D periodic banding pattern and twisted morphology under acidic conditions at the appropriate ionic strength. We also calculated the relative strengths of hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions between collagen molecules. When the hydrophobic interaction between linear collagen molecules was considered, we found a pattern of periodic maximization of the interactive force including the D period. On the other hand, the electrostatic interaction did not show the periodic pattern, but the overall interaction score affected fibril formation.     

The effect of acid mucopolysaccharides and acid mucopolysaccharide–proteins on fibril formation from collagen solutions

1. The effects of acid mucopolysaccharides and acid mucopolysaccharide-proteins on the size and rate of formation of fibril aggregates from collagen solutions in pH7.6 buffers were studied by turbidimetric and light-scattering methods. 2. Serum albumin, orosomucoid, methylated cellulose, chondroitin sulphate A and chondroitin sulphate C of molecular weight less than 20000, and hyaluronate of molecular weight less than 40000 did not influence rates of fibril formation. Chondroitin sulphate A, chondroitin sulphate C and hyaluronate of high molecular weight retarded the rate of fibril formation. This effect of high-molecular-weight chondroitin sulphate C decreased with increasing ionic strength. Heparin, though of low molecular weight (13000), was highly effective, as was also heparitin sulphate. The chondroitin sulphate-proteins of very high molecular weight were highly effective, despite the fact that for some preparations the component chondroitin sulphate chains had molecular weights much less than 20000. 3. Agents that had delayed fibril formation were also effective in producing an increase in degree of aggregation of fibrillar collagen, as indicated by dissymmetry changes observed in light-scattering experiments at low collagen concentrations. Methylated cellulose and heparin at 2.5mug./ml. were unusual in decreasing aggregation, but heparin at 0.25mug./ml. increased aggregation. Electron microscopy of gels showed fibrils and fibril aggregates with ;normal' collagen spacing and dimensions consistent with the light-scattering results. 4. The rates of electrical transport of agents and of solvent (electro-osmosis) through collagen gels indicated a contribution of molecular entanglement that increased with increase in molecular size of the agents. Electrostatic binding of heparin to collagen was noted. Binding to collagen during fibril formation was also found for heparitin sulphate and a chondroitin sulphate with extra sulphate groups. 5. Electrostatic binding of acid mucopolysaccharide-proteins to collagen may be an important factor in the organization and functioning of connective tissues at all stages of growth and development. Excluded-volume (molecular-entanglement) effects may also be important. These factors operate simultaneously and interact mutually so that precise assessment of their relative importance is difficult.     

The C-terminal extrahelical peptide of type I collagen and its role in fibrillogenesis in vitro: effects of ethylurea

Ethylurea was used to weaken hydrophobic interactions during collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro. Intact and enzyme-digested type I collagen was studied. In all preparations, ethylurea decreased the extent and rate of fibril formation, inhibition being greatest in the enzyme-digested collagens. With intact collagen (and probably also with carboxypeptidasedigested collagen), there was no evidence the ethylurea altered the mechanism of fibril growth; in pepsin-digested collagen, however, the growth mechanism was altered by ethylurea, possibly reflecting a conformational change of the “hydrophobic cluster” in the C-terminal peptide. Such a structural change could occur in a hydrophobic environment once the distal portion of the C-terminal peptide (presumed to be essential for its structural stability) is removed by pepsin. The results further emphasize the importance of hydrophobic interactions in collagen fibril nucleation and growth in vitro.     

Effect of environmental factors on the kinetics of insulin fibril formation: elucidation of the molecular mechanism

In the search for the molecular mechanism of insulin fibrillation, the kinetics of insulin fibril formation were studied under different conditions using the fluorescent dye thioflavin T (ThT). The effect of insulin concentration, agitation, pH, ionic strength, anions, seeding, and addition of 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonic acid (ANS), urea, TMAO, sucrose, and ThT on the kinetics of fibrillation was investigated. The kinetics of the fibrillation process could be described by the lag time for formation of stable nuclei (nucleation) and the apparent rate constant for the growth of fibrils (elongation). The addition of seeds eliminated the lag phase. An increase in insulin concentration resulted in shorter lag times and faster growth of fibrils. Shorter lag times and faster growth of fibrils were seen at acidic pH versus neutral pH, whereas an increase in ionic strength resulted in shorter lag times and slower growth of fibrils. There was no clear correlation between the rate of fibril elongation and ionic strength. Agitation during fibril formation attenuated the effects of insulin concentration and ionic strength on both lag times and fibril growth. The addition of ANS increased the lag time and decreased the apparent growth rate for insulin fibril formation. The ANS-induced inhibition appears to reflect the formation of amorphous aggregates. The denaturant, urea, decreased the lag time, whereas the stabilizers, trimethylamine N-oxide dihydrate (TMAO) and sucrose, increased the lag times. The results indicated that both nucleation and fibril growth were controlled by hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions. A kinetic model, involving the association of monomeric partially folded intermediates, whose concentration is stimulated by the air-water interface, leading to formation of the critical nucleus and thence fibrils, is proposed.     

Assembly of type I collagen: fusion of fibril subunits and the influence of fibril diameter on mechanical properties.

Structural stability of the extracellular matrix is primarily a consequence of fibrillar collagen and the extent of cross-linking. The relationship between collagen self-assembly, consequent fibrillar shape and mechanical properties remains unclear. Our laboratory developed a model system for the preparation of self-assembled type I collagen fibers with fibrillar substructure mimicking the hierarchical structures of tendon. The present study evaluates the effects of pH and temperature during self-assembly on fibrillar structure, and relates the structural effects of these treatments on the uniaxial tensile mechanical properties of self-assembled collagen fibers. Results of the analysis of fibril diameter distributions and mechanical properties of the fibers formed under the different incubation conditions indicate that fibril diameters grow via the lateral fusion of discrete approximately 4 nm subunits, and that fibril diameter correlates positively with the low strain modulus. Fibril diameter did not correlate with either the ultimate tensile strength or the high strain elastic modulus, which suggests that lateral aggregation and consequently fibril diameter influences mechanical properties during small strain mechanical deformation. We hypothesize that self-assembly is mediated by the formation of fibrillar subunits that laterally and linearly fuse resulting in fibrillar growth. Lateral fusion appears important in generating resistance to deformation at low strain, while linear fusion leading to longer fibrils appears important in the ultimate mechanical properties at high strain.     

Collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro: comparison of types I, II, and III

The self-assembly of pepsin-extracted types I, II, and III collagen was studied to determine how differences in the triple-helical structure between collagen types influence in vitro collagen fibrillogenesis. Collagen types I, II, and III were extracted and purified from bovine sources, and were studied in solution by laser light scattering, pH titration, and determination of turbidity-time curves. The molecular weights were between 280,000 and 289,000, while the translational diffusion coefficients and particle scattering factors at 175.5 degrees were consistent with those expected for single collagen molecules. Titration of collagen types I, II, and III between pH 7.0 and 2.0 using HCl indicated that type I collagen had the most titratable carboxylic groups with type II and III having significantly fewer titratable groups. The self-assembly of these collagens was studied in vitro in phosphate-buffered saline. The time course and extent of fibril formation were studied turbidimetrically, and were found to be dependent on collagen type. Apparent rate constants were determined for both the lag and growth phases of fibril formation. The rates of both phases were greater for type III than for type I collagen, with the rates for type II collagen being intermediate. The extent of fibril formation was based on the turbidity per unit concentration (specific turbidity) extrapolated to zero concentration (intrinsic turbidity), which was found to be greater for type I than for type III collagen. Type II collagen had the smallest intrinsic turbidity. The specific and intrinsic turbidity values were consistent with the relative fibril diameters seen in dermis and cartilage by transmission electron microscopy. These observations indicate that helix-helix interactions are important in the regulation of the rate and extent of collagen fibrillogenesis and may be involved in the determination of fibril structure.     

Engineered Smooth Muscle Tissues: Regulating Cell Phenotype with the Scaffold

Culturing cells on three-dimensional, biodegradable scaffolds may create tissues suitable either for reconstructive surgery applications or as novel in vitro model systems. In this study, we have tested the hypothesis that the phenotype of smooth muscle cells (SMCs) in three-dimensional, engineered tissues is regulated by the chemistry of the scaffold material. Specifically, we have directly compared cell growth and patterns of extracellular matrix (ECM) (e.g. , elastin and collagen) gene expression on two types of synthetic polymer scaffolds and type I collagen scaffolds. The growth rates of SMCs on the synthetic polymer scaffolds were significantly higher than on type I collagen sponges. The rate of elastin production by SMCs on polyglycolic acid (PGA) scaffolds was 3.5 +/- 1.1-fold higher than that on type I collagen sponges on Day 11 of culture. In contrast, the collagen production rate on type I collagen sponges was 3.3 +/- 1.1-fold higher than that on PGA scaffolds. This scaffold-dependent switching between elastin and collagen gene expression was confirmed by Northern blot analysis. The finding that the scaffold chemistry regulates the phenotype of SMCs independent of the scaffold physical form was confirmed by culturing SMCs on two-dimensional films of the scaffold materials. It is likely that cells adhere to these scaffolds via different ligands, as the major protein adsorbed from the serum onto synthetic polymers was vitronectin, whereas fibronectin and vitronectin were present at high density on type I collagen sponges. In summary, this study demonstrates that three-dimensional smooth muscle-like tissues can be created by culturing SMCs on three-dimensional scaffolds, and that the phenotype of the SMCs is strongly regulated by the scaffold chemistry. These engineered tissues provide novel, three-dimensional models to study cellular interaction with ECM in vitro.     

Self-association of collagen triple helic peptides into higher order structures

Interest in self-association of peptides and proteins is motivated by an interest in the mechanism of physiologically higher order assembly of proteins such as collagen as well as the mechanism of pathological aggregation such as beta-amyloid formation. The triple helical form of (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(10), a peptide that has proved a useful model for molecular features of collagen, was found to self-associate, and its association properties are reported here. Turbidity experiments indicate that the triple helical peptide self-assembles at neutral pH via a nucleation-growth mechanism, with a critical concentration near 1 mM. The associated form is more stable than individual molecules by about 25 degrees C, and the association is reversible. The rate of self-association increases with temperature, supporting an entropically favored process. After self-association, (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(10) forms branched filamentous structures, in contrast with the highly ordered axially periodic structure of collagen fibrils. Yet a number of characteristics of triple helix assembly for the peptide resemble those of collagen fibril formation. These include promotion of fibril formation by neutral pH and increasing temperature; inhibition by sugars; and a requirement for hydroxyproline. It is suggested that these similar features for peptide and collagen self-association are based on common lateral underlying interactions between triple helical molecules mediated by hydrogen-bonded hydration networks involving hydroxyproline.     

Chondroitin sulfate perlecan enhances collagen fibril formation. Implications for perlecan chondrodysplasias

Inactivation of the perlecan gene leads to perinatal lethal chondrodysplasia. The similarity to the phenotypes of the Col2A1 knock-out and the disproportionate micromelia mutation suggests perlecan involvement in cartilage collagen matrix assembly. We now present a mechanism for the defect in collagen type II fibril assembly by perlecan-null chondrocytes. Cartilage perlecan is a heparin sulfate or a mixed heparan sulfate/chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan. The latter form binds collagen and accelerates fibril formation in vitro, with more defined fibril morphology and increased fibril diameters produced in the presence of perlecan. Interestingly, the enhancement of collagen fibril formation is independent on the core protein and is mimicked by chondroitin sulfate E but neither by chondroitin sulfate D nor dextran sulfate. Furthermore, perlecan chondroitin sulfate contains the 4,6-disulfated disaccharides typical for chondroitin sulfate E. Indeed, purified glycosaminoglycans from perlecan-enriched fractions of cartilage extracts contain elevated levels of 4,6-disulfated chondroitin sulfate disaccharides and enhance collagen fibril formation. The effect on collagen assembly is proportional to the content of the 4,6-disulfated disaccharide in the different cartilage extracts, with growth plate cartilage glycosaminoglycan being the most efficient enhancer. These findings demonstrate a role for perlecan chondroitin sulfate side chains in cartilage extracellular matrix assembly and provide an explanation for the perlecan-null chondrodysplasia.     

Lysyl Oxidase Activity Is Required for Ordered Collagen Fibrillogenesis by Tendon Cells

Lysyl oxidases (LOXs) are a family of copper-dependent oxido-deaminases that can modify the side chain of lysyl residues in collagen and elastin, thereby leading to the spontaneous formation of non-reducible aldehyde-derived interpolypeptide chain cross-links. The consequences of LOX inhibition in producing lathyrism are well documented, but the consequences on collagen fibril formation are less clear. Here we used β-aminoproprionitrile (BAPN) to inhibit LOX in tendon-like constructs (prepared from human tenocytes), which are an experimental model of cell-mediated collagen fibril formation. The improvement in structure and strength seen with time in control constructs was absent in constructs treated with BAPN. As expected, BAPN inhibited the formation of aldimine-derived cross-links in collagen, and the constructs were mechanically weak. However, an unexpected finding was that BAPN treatment led to structurally abnormal collagen fibrils with irregular profiles and widely dispersed diameters. Of special interest, the abnormal fibril profiles resembled those seen in some Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome phenotypes. Importantly, the total collagen content developed normally, and there was no difference in COL1A1 gene expression. Collagen type V, decorin, fibromodulin, and tenascin-X proteins were unaffected by the cross-link inhibition, suggesting that LOX regulates fibrillogenesis independently of these molecules. Collectively, the data show the importance of LOX for the mechanical development of early collagenous tissues and that LOX is essential for correct collagen fibril shape formation.     

The retrogradation of waxy maize starch extrudates: effects of storage temperature and water content

The effects of water content and storage temperature on the kinetics of the retrogradation of nonexpanded waxy maize starch extrudates were studied using (1)H pulsed NMR and wide-angle X-ray diffraction. The increase in crystallinity observed by XRD was accompanied by a decrease in the relaxation times of the solid-like component of the NMR free induction and the spin-echo decays, and an increase in the contribution of the solid-like component to the total signal. The dependence of the rate of starch retrogradation on the storage temperature showed the typical "bell-shaped" behavior, which was successfully modeled using the Lauritzen-Hoffman theory of crystallization of chain-folded polymers. This theory was extended to model the effect of water content on the rate of isothermal crystallization by exploiting the ten-Brinke and Karasz, and the Flory equations to describe the dependence of the glass-transition and the melting temperatures on water content.     

The mammalian chitinase-like lectin, YKL-40, binds specifically to type I collagen and modulates the rate of type I collagen fibril formation

YKL-40 is expressed in arthritic cartilage and produced in large amounts by cultured chondrocytes, but its exact role is unclear, and the identities of its physiological ligands remain unknown. Purification of YKL-40 from resorbing bovine nasal cartilage and chondrocyte monolayers demonstrated the existence of three isoforms, a major and minor form from resorbing cartilage and a third species from chondrocytes. Affinity chromatography experiments with purified YKL-40 demonstrated specific binding of all three forms to collagen types I, II, and III, thus identifying collagens as potential YKL-40 ligands. Binding to immobilized type I collagen was inhibited by soluble native ligand, but not heat-denatured ligand, confirming a specific interaction. Binding of the chondrocyte-derived species to type I collagen was also demonstrated by surface plasmon resonance analysis, and the dissociation rate constant was calculated (3.42 x 10(-3) to 4.50 x 10(-3) s(-1)). The chondrocyte-derived species was found to prevent collagenolytic cleavage of type I collagen and to stimulate the rate of type I collagen fibril formation in a concentration-dependent manner. By contrast, the cartilage major form had an inhibitory effect on type I collagen fibrillogenesis. Digestion with N-glycosidase F, endoglycosidase H and lectin blotting did not reveal any difference in the carbohydrate component of these two YKL-40 species, indicating that this does not account for the opposing effects on fibril formation rate.