Gene centres,a source for genetic variants in symbiotic nitrogen fixation: The symbiotic response of the cultivated pea toRhizobium leguminosarum strains from Europe and the Middle East

Summary Soil samples from several European countries; Sweden, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Greece, contained rhizobial populations capable of forming an effective symbiosis with the cultivated pea cv. Rondo from the Netherlands. The range of variation among the European Rhizobium strains, as expressed on pea cv. Rondo, was not so large and almost the same variation could be found within the rhizobial population within each country. Superior Rhizobium strains for the Dutch pea were not restricted to soils from the Netherlands but were also found in those from Sweden and Italy.Soils from Turkey and Israel also contained Rhizobium strains capable of nodulating pea cv. Rondo. However, the genetic variation among these Middle East Rhizobium strains was much larger than that of the European strains. When tested on pea cv. Rondo the majority of the Middle East strains belonged to the medium or low effective classes and only a few strains were comparable with European Rhizobium strains.Dutch Rhizobium strains induced effective nodules on both the Dutch pea cv. Rondo and the Swedish cv. L 110. However, in association with a Turkish Rhizobium strain effective nodules were formed on pea cv. Rondo and ineffective nodules on cv. L 110.We suggest that the genetic uniformity of EuropeanR. leguminosarum strains is the result of selection and domestication of Rhizobium strains originally derived from the gene centres of the pea plant.     

Modification of symbiotic interaction of pea (Pisum sativum L.) andRhizobium leguminosarum by induced mutations

Summary In pea (Pisum sativum L.), mutants could be induced, modified in the symbiotic interaction withRhizobium leguminosarum. Among 250 M₂-families, two nodulation resistant mutants (K₅ and K₉) were obtained. In mutant K₅ the nodulation resistance was monogenic recessive and not Rhizobium strain specific. Out of 220 M₂-families one mutant nod₃ was found which could form nodules at high nitrate concentrations (15 mM KNO₃). This mutant nodulated abundantly with severalRhizobium strains, both in the absence and presence of nitrate. Probably as the result of a pleiotropic effect, its root morphology was also changed. Among 1800 M₂-families, five nitrate reductase deficient mutants were obtained and one of them (mutant E₁) was used to study the inhibitory effect of nitrate on nodulation and nitrogen fixation.The results of the present investigation show that pea mutants which are modified in their symbiosis withRhizobium leguminosarum, can readily be obtained. The significance of such mutants for fundamental studies of the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis and for applications in plant breeding is discussed.     

Rhizobium nodulation genes involved in root hair curling (Hac) are functionally conserved

Summary Five specific transposon-induced nodulation defective (Nod⁻) mutants from different fast-growing species ofRhizobium were used as the recipients for the transfer of each of several endogenous Sym(biosis) plasmids or for recombinant plasmids that encode early nodulation and host-specificity functions. The Nod⁻ mutants were derived fromR. trifolii, R. meliloti and from a broad-host-rangeRhizobium strain which is able to nodulate both cowpea (tropical) legumes and the non-legumeParasponia. These mutants had several common features (a), they were Nod⁻ on all their known plant hosts, (b), they could not induce root hair curling (Hac⁻) and (c), the mutations were all located on the endogenous Sym-plasmid of the respective strain. Transfer to these mutants of Sym plasmids (or recombinant plasmids) encoding heterologous information for clover nodulation (pBR1AN, pRt032, pRt038), for pea nodulation (pJB5JI, pRL1JI::Tn1831), for lucerne nodulation (pRmSL26), or for the nodulation of both tropical legumes and non-legumes (pNM4AN), was able to restore root hair curling capacity and in most cases, nodulation capacity of the original plant host(s). This demonstrated a functional conservation of at least some genes involved in root hair curling. Positive hybridization between Nod DNA sequences fromR. trifolii and from a broad-host-rangeRhizobium strain (ANU240) was obtained to other fast-growingRhizobium strains. These results indicate that at least some of the early nodulation functions are common in a broad spectrum ofRhizobium strains.     

Temperature-dependent root-nodule formation in pea cv. Iran

Summary Pea cv. Iran was found to be ‘resistant’ to a large number of Rhizobium strains, when growing at 20°C, but nodulation is normal at 26°C. An exceptional Rhizobium strain was found which forms nodules on this pea cultivar both at 20°C and 26°C.     

nodT,a positively-acting cultivar specificity determinant controlling nodulation of Trifolium subterraneum by Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar trifolii

Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar trifolii strain TA1 nodulates a range of Trifolium plants including red, white and subterranean clovers. Nitrogen-fixing nodules are promptly initiated on the tap roots of these plants at the site of inoculation. In contrast to these associations, strain TA1 has a Nod^- phenotype on a particular cultivar of subterranean clover called Woogenellup (A.H. Gibson, Aust J Agric Sci 19: (1968) 907–918) where it induces rare, poorly developed, slow-to-appear and ineffective lateral root nodules. By comparing the nodulation gene region of strain TA1 with that of another R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain ANU843, which is capable of efficiently nodulating cv. Woogenellup, we have shown that the nodT gene (B.P. Surin et al., Mol Microbiol 4: (1990) 245–252) is essential for nodulation on cv. Woogenellup. The nodT gene is naturally absent in strain TA1. A cosmid clone spanning the entire nodulation gene region of strain TA1 was capable of conferring nodulation ability to R.l. bv. trifolii strains deleted for nodulation genes, but only on cultivars of subterranean clovers nodulated by strain TA1. This shows that cultivar recognition events are, in part, determined by genes in the nodulation region of strain TA1. Complementation studies also indicated that strain TA1 contains negatively-acting genes located on the Sym plasmid and elsewhere, which specifically block nodulation of cv. Woogenellup.     

Inoculation of pea by application of Rhizobium in the planting furrow

Summary Selected streptomycin resistant strains ofRhizobium leguminosarum suspended in nutrient broth were added to the planting furrow immediately before the sowing of pea. The nodule occupancy by a strain isolated from Risø soil (Risø la) was increased from 74 to 90%, when the inoculum rate was increased from 3.7×10⁶ to 3.7×10⁸ cells per cm row. The experimental soil contained 10³ to 10⁴ cells ofR. leguminosarum per gram. An almost inefficient strain isolated from Risø soil (SV10) was less competitive with respect to nodulation on two pea cultivars than an efficient Risø strain (SV15) and an efficient non-Risø strain (R1045). The nodule occupancy by the introduced strains varied between pea cultivars.Irrespective of the generally high nodulation by the efficient strains introduced to the soil, the pea seed yield, compared to pea nodulated by the indigenous population, was not significantly increased. Neither were two commercial inoculants, applied in rates corresponding to 3 times the recommended rate, able to increase the yield. This suggests that the indigenous populations ofR. leguminosarum were sufficient in number and nitrogen fixing capacity to ensure an optimal pea crop. However, some inoculation treatments slightly increased the seed N concentration and total N accumulation, indicating that it may be possible to select or develop bacterial strains that may increase the yield.     

Sym plasmid transfer to various symbiotic mutants of Rhizobium trifolii, R. leguminosarum, and R. meliloti.

Two self-transmissible Sym(biosis) plasmids, one encoding pea-specific nodulation and nitrogen-fixation functions (plasmid pJB5JI) and the other encoding clover-specific nodulation and nitrogen-fixation functions (plasmid pBR1AN) were used to determine whether the symbiotic genes encoded on these plasmids are expressed in various members of the Rhizobiaceae. The host specificity of Rhizobium trifolii and R. leguminosarum Sym plasmid-cured strains could be directly determined by the transfer to these strains of the appropriate Sym plasmid. The nodulation of white clovers was restored by either plasmid pJB5JI or pBR1AN when these plasmids were transferred to two transposon Tn5-induced hair-curling (Hac-) R. trifolii mutants. In addition, lucerne nodulation was restored to a Hac- R. meliloti mutant when either plasmid pBR1AN or pJB5JI was transferred to this strain. The phenotype of nonmucoid (Muc-) Rhizobium mutants, which had altered cell surfaces, was not influenced by the transfer to these strains of plasmid pBR1AN or plasmid pJB5JI.     

Natural variation in host-specific nodulation of pea is associated with a haplotype of the SYM37 LysM-type receptor-like kinase

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae, which nodulates pea and vetch, makes a mixture of secreted nodulation signals (Nod factors) carrying either a C18:4 or a C18:1 N-linked acyl chain. Mutation of nodE blocks the formation of the C18:4 acyl chain, and nodE mutants, which produce only C18:1-containing Nod factors, are less efficient at nodulating pea. However, there is significant natural variation in the levels of nodulation of different pea cultivars by a nodE mutant of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae. Using recombinant inbred lines from two pea cultivars, one which nodulated relatively well and one very poorly by the nodE mutant, we mapped the nodE-dependent nodulation phenotype to a locus on pea linkage group I. This was close to Sym37 and PsK1, predicted to encode LysM-domain Nod-factor receptor-like proteins; the Sym2 locus that confers Nod-factor-specific nodulation is also in this region. We confirmed the map location using an introgression line carrying this region. Our data indicate that the nodE-dependent nodulation is not determined by the Sym2 locus. We identified several pea lines that are nodulated very poorly by the R. leguminosarum bv. viciae nodE mutant, sequenced the DNA of the predicted LysM-receptor domains of Sym37 and PsK1, and compared the sequences with those derived from pea cultivars that were relatively well nodulated by the nodE mutant. This revealed that one haplotype (encoding six conserved polymorphisms) of Sym37 is associated with very poor nodulation by the nodE mutant. There was no such correlation with polymorphisms at the PsK1 locus. We conclude that the natural variation in nodE-dependent nodulation in pea is most probably determined by the Sym37 haplotype.     

Co-evolution of the legume-Rhizobium association

Summary A number of examples is given demonstrating the co-existence of pea genotypes and their specific Rhizobium, strains isolated within the same region.R. leguminosarum strains compatible with the cultivated pea have a narrow symbiotic range and they are widely distributed in European soils. This is presumably due to the narrow genetic base of the cultivated pea and its wide-spread cultivation in European soils. Rhizobium strains capable of nodulating a primitive pea line from Afghanistan were only found in soils of the Middle East and Central Asia. A more restricted distribution of specific Rhizobium strains was found for fulvum peas from Israel. Rhizobium strains effective with the fulvum pea were found in Israeli soils. A good example of co-evolution due to geographical isolation was found in south Turkey. Here a pea line was found which can form an effective symbiosis with local Rhizobium strains but not with strains from other parts of Turkey.     

Strain selection for pigeon pea Rhizobium under greenhouse conditions

Pigeon pea obtains N for growth by N₂ fixation although yield generally is not improved by either the inoculation of Rhizobium or by the application of N fertilizer in Puerto Rico. Sixteen strains ofRhizobium spp., different in geographical origin, were tested for N-fixing effectiveness, determined from comparisons with uninoculated controls, N controls and the standard strain 176A22. Inoculated treatments showed significant differences in nodulation, plant dry weight and %N. Several strain x plant combinations had higher N content than the N treatment, reflecting the ubiquity of effective strains and the possible lack of response of pigeon pea to inoculation or N fertilization. Strains superior in N₂ fixation were selected for testing for symbiotic effectiveness under field conditions.     

Competitive nodulation blocking of Afghanistan pea is determined by nodDABC and nodFE alleles in Rhizobium leguminosarum

Summary One well-defined competitive interaction amongst rhizobia is that between compatible and non-compatible strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum with respect to the nodulation of some primitive pea genotypes. The Middle Eastern pea cv Afghanistan is nodulated effectively can R. leguminosarum TOM, but its capacity to nodulate can be blocked if a mixed inoculation is made with R. leguminosarum PF₂. This PF₂ phenotype (Cnb) is encoded by its symbiotic plasmid and cosmid clones thereof. We found that Cnb is also encoded by the well-characterized Sym plasmid pRL1JI of R. leguminosarum strain 248. We have isolated and characterized a 6.9 kb HindIII fragment of pSymPF₂ which confers the Cnb⁺ phentoype on other (Cnb^–) rhizobia. A Tn5 site-directed Cnb^– mutant was constructed by homogenotization and was also found to be Nod^– on the European pea cv Rondo. DNA hybridization and complementation analysis indicated that the 6.9 kb Cnb⁺ fragment contained the nodD, nodABC and nodFE operons. Analysis of the Cnb phenotype of nod::Tn5 alleles of pRL1JI showed that mutations of nodC, nodD or nodE all abolished Cnb activity whereas mutants in nodI and nodJ reduced activity to 50% of the wild-type level.     

Mobilization of a Sym plasmid from a fast-growing cowpea Rhizobium strain.

A large Sym plasmid from a fast-growing cowpea Rhizobium species was made mobilizable by cointegration with plasmid pSUP1011, which carries the oriT region of RP4. This mobilizable Sym plasmid was transferred to a number of Rhizobium strains, in which nodulation and nitrogen fixation functions for symbiosis with plants of the cowpea group were expressed.     

Symbiotic nitrogen fixation under stress conditions

Summary An outline is given of the possibility selecting Rhizobium strains capable of performing a relatively good symbiosis with leguminous plants, growing under stress conditions. A Rhizobium strain capable of nodulating pea plants in acid soils is described. A pea cultivar, resistant to the majority of Rhizobium strains when growing at 20°C, is found to require a short period of a higher temperature for successful nodulation. The effect of non-photosynthetic light and its possible significance under natural conditions is discussed.     

Distribution of O-acetyl groups in the exopolysaccharide synthesized by Rhizobium leguminosarum strains is not determined by the Sym plasmid

The patterns of O-acetylation of the exopolysaccharide (EPS) from the Sym plasmid-cured derivatives of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain LPR5, R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain ANU843 and R. leguminosarum bv. viciae strain 248 were determined by 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy. Beside a site indicative of the chromosomal background, these strains have one site of O-acetylation in common, namely residue b of the repeating unit. The O-acetyl esterification pattern of EPS of the Sym plasmid-cured derivatives of strains LPR5, ANU843, and 248 was not altered by the introduction of a R. leguminosarum bv. viciae Sym plasmid or a R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii Sym plasmid. The induction of nod gene expression by growth of the bacteria in the presence of Vicia sativa plants or by the presence of the flavonoid naringenin, produced no significant changes in either amount or sites of O-acetyl substitution. Furthermore, no such changes were found in the EPS from a Rhizobium strain in which the nod genes are constitutively expressed. The substitution pattern of the exopolysaccharide from R. leguminosarum is, therefore, determined by the bacterial genome and is not influenced by genes present on the Sym plasmid. This conclusion is inconsistent with the suggestion of Philip-Hollingsworth et al. (Philip-Hollingsworth, S., Hollingsworth, R. I., Dazzo, F. B., Djordjevic, M. A., and Rolfe, B. G. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 5710-5714) that nod genes of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii, by influencing the acetylation pattern of EPS, determine the host specificity of nodulation.     

In Bradyrhizobium japonicum the common nodulation genes, nodABC, are linked to nifA and fixA

Summary Using cloned Rhizobium phaseoli nodulation (nod) genes as hybridization probes homologous restriction fragments were detected in the genome of the slow-growing soybean symbiont, Bradyrhizobium japonicum strain 110. These fragments were isolated from a cosmid library, and were shown to lie 10 kilobasepairs (kb) upstream from the nifA and fixA genes. Specific nod probes from Rhizobium leguminosarum were used to identify nodA-, nodB-, and nodC-like sequences clustered within a 4.5 kb PstI fragment. A mutant was constructed in which the kanamycin resistance gene from Tn5 was inserted into the nodA homologous B. japonicum region. This insertion was precisely located, by DNA sequencing, to near the middle of the nodA gene. B. japonicum mutants carrying this insertion were completely nodulation deficient (Nod^-).     

Competitive nodulation blocking of cv. Afghanistan pea is related to high levels of nodulation factors made by some strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae

Cultivar Afghanistan peas are resistant to nodulation by many strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae but are nodulated by strain TOM, which carries the host specificity gene nodX. Some strains that lack nodX can inhibit nodulation of cv. Afghanistan by strain TOM. We present evidence that this "competitive nodulation-blocking" (Cnb) phenotype may result from high levels of Nod factors inhibiting nodulation of cv. Afghanistan peas. The TOM nod gene region (including nodX) is cloned on pIJ1095, and strains (including TOM itself) carrying pIJ1095 nodulate cv. Afghanistan peas very poorly but can nodulate other varieties normally. The presence of pIJ1095, which causes increased levels of Nod factor production, correlates with Cnb. Nodulation of cv. Afghanistan by TOM is also inhibited by a cloned nodD gene that increases nod gene expression and Nod factor production. Nodulation of cv. Afghanistan can be stimulated if nodD on pIJ1095 is mutated, thus severely reducing the level of Nod factor produced. Repression of nod gene expression by nolR eliminates the Cnb phenotype and can stimulate nodulation of cv. Afghanistan. Addition of Nod factors to cv. Afghanistan roots strongly inhibits nodulation. The Cnb+ strains and added Nod factors inhibit infection thread initiation by strain TOM. The sym2A allele determines resistance of cv. Afghanistan to nodulation by strains of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae lacking nodX. We tested whether sym2A is involved in Cnb by using a pea line carrying the sym2A region introgressed from cv. Afghanistan; nodulation in the introgressed line was inhibited by Cnb+ strains. Therefore, the sym2A region has an effect on Cnb, although another locus (or loci) may contribute to the stronger Cnb seen in cv. Afghanistan.     

Selection of Competitive Strains of Rhizobium Nodulating Phaseolus Vulgaris and Adapted to Environmental Conditions in Egypt,Using the Gus-Reporter Gene Technique

Two Rhizobium etli strains, EBRI 2 and EBRI 26, isolated from Egypt were tested for nodulation competitiveness on beans using Rhizobium tropici CIAT 899G as the competing strain. The insertion of the gus-reporter transposon mTn5ssgusA30 did not alter the nodulation or nitrogen fixation capacity of mutant strain CIAT 899G compared to the wild type. At neutral pH, R. etli strains EBRI 2 and EBRI 26 were more competitive than CIAT 899G with the bean cultivar Saxa. These two strains gave nodule occupancies of 52.1 and 61.1% competing with equal cell numbers of CIAT 899G. Nodule occupancies from these two native strains increased with the bean cultivar Giza 6 from Egypt to 66 and 67.5%. Based on these results, cultivar Giza 6 was used to select the most competitive strains under stress of salinity or alkalinity as a major problem for a large part of Egyptian soils. Under stress of salinity (0.2% NaCl or 34.2 mM NaCl), the salt-sensitive strain EBRI 2 was more competitive than the salt-resistant strain EBRI 26. Strain EBRI 2 gave 87.4% but strain EBRI 26 gave 63.7% nodule occupancy against CIAT 899G. The same trend of results was observed under stress of alkalinity (pH 8). Strain EBRI 2 occupied 83% while Strain EBRI 26 occupied 53.2%.     

Molecular cloning and expression of Rhizobium fredii USDA 193 nodulation genes: extension of host range for nodulation.

DNA hybridization with the cloned nodulation region of Rhizobium meliloti as a probe revealed DNA homology with four HindIII fragments, 12.5, 6.8, 5.2, and 0.3 kilobases (kb) in size, of the symbiotic plasmid pRjaUSDA193. Both hybridization and complementation studies suggest that the common nodulation genes nodABC and nodD of R. fredii USDA 193 are present on the 5.2-kb HindIII and 2.8-kb EcoRI fragments, respectively, of the Sym plasmid. Both fragments together could confer nodulation ability on soybeans when present in Sym plasmid-cured (Sym-) and wild-type (Sym+) Rhizobium strains or in a Ti plasmid-cured Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain. Furthermore, the 2.8-kb EcoRI fragment alone was able to form nodulelike structures on Glycine max L. cv. "Peking" (soybean). Microscopic examination of these nodules revealed bacterial invasion of the cells, probably via root hair penetration. Bacterial strains harboring plasmids carrying the 5.2- and 2.8-kb nod fragments elicited root-hair-curling responses on infection. These data suggest that the genes responsible for host range determination and some of the early events of nodulation may be coded for by the 5.2-kb HindIII and 2.8-kb EcoRI fragments.     

Host-genetic control of nitrogen fixation in the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis: complication in the genetic analysis due to maternal effects

Summary In pea cv. Afghanistan a recessive gene sym 6 prevents the full expression of nitrogenase activity in root nodules, induced byRhizobium leguminosarum strain F 13. In contrast, nitrogenase activity is fully expressed in pea cv. Iran. A comparison of the reciprocal hybrids of these two plants showed that the size of the plant was determined by the mother plant (maternal effect). Therefore the shoot weight and the total amount of nitrogen fixed are not suitable as parameters for a genetic analysis. The % nitrogen of the shoot and the specific activity of the nodules per gram of nodules are more reliable, but for practical purposes the specific activity of the nodules expressed per gram of shoot tissue can be used.