A role for the weak DnaA binding sites in bacterial replication origins

DnaA initiates the chromosomal DNA replication in nearly all bacteria, and replication origins are characterized by binding sites for the DnaA protein (DnaA-boxes) along with an 'AT-rich' region. However, great variation in number, spatial organization and specificity of DnaA-boxes is observed between species. In the study by Taylor et al. (2011), new and unexpectedly weak DnaA-boxes were identified within the Caulobacter crescentus origin of replication (Cori). The position of weak and stronger DnaA-boxes follows a pattern seen in Escherichia coli oriC. This raises the possibility that bacterial origins might be more alike than previously thought.     

DnaA boxes are important elements in setting the initiation mass of Escherichia coli

The binding of DnaA protein to its DNA binding sites-DnaA boxes-in the chromosomal oriC region is essential for initiation of chromosome replication. In this report, we show that additional DnaA boxes affect chromosome initiation control, i.e., increase the initiation mass. The cellular DnaA box concentration was increased by introducing pBR322-derived plasmids carrying DnaA boxes from the oriC region into Escherichia coli and by growing the strains at different generation times to obtain different plasmid copy numbers. In fast-growing cells, where the DnaA box plasmid copy number per oriC locus was low, the presence of extra DnaA boxes caused only a moderate increase in the initiation mass. In slowly growing cells, where the DnaA box plasmid copy number per oriC locus was higher, we observed more pronounced increases in the initiation mass. Our data clearly show that the presence of extra DnaA boxes increases the initiation mass, supporting the idea that the initiation mass is determined by the normal complement of DnaA protein binding sites in E. coli cells.     

DnaA protein binding to individual DnaA boxes in the Escherichia coli replication origin, oriC.

The formation of nucleoprotein complexes between the Escherichia coli initiator protein DnaA and the replication origin oriC was analysed in vitro by band-shift assays and electron microscopy. DnaA protein binds equally well to linear and supercoiled oriC substrates as revealed by analysis of the binding preference to individual DnaA boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, and by a competition band-shift assay. DnaA box R4 (oriC positions 260-268) binds DnaA preferentially and in the oriC context with higher affinity than expected from its binding constant. This effect depends on oriC positions 249 to 274, is enhanced by the wild-type sequence in the DnaA box R3 region, but is not dependent on Dam methylation or the curved DNA segment to the right of oriC. DnaA binds randomly to the DnaA boxes R1, M, R2 and R3 in oriC with no apparent cooperativity: the binding preference of DnaA to these sites was not altered for templates with mutated DnaA box R4. In the oriC context, DnaA box R1 binds DnaA with lower affinity than expected from its binding constant, i.e. the affinity is reduced to approximately that of DnaA box R2. Higher protein concentrations were required to observe binding to DnaA box M, making this low-affinity site a novel candidate for a regulatory dnaA box.     

The chromosome origin of Escherichia coli stabilizes DnaA protein during rejuvenation by phospholipids.

DnaA protein (the initiator protein) binds and clusters at the four DnaA boxes of the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin (oriC) to promote the strand opening for DNA replication. DnaA protein activity depends on the tight binding of ATP; the ADP form of DnaA protein, generated by hydrolysis of the bound ATP, is inactive. Rejuvenation of ADP-DnaA protein, by replacement with ATP, is catalyzed by acidic phospholipids in a highly fluid bilayer. We find that interaction of DnaA protein with oriC DNA is needed to stabilize DnaA protein during this rejuvenation process. Whereas DnaA protein bound to oriC DNA responds to phospholipids, free DnaA protein is inactivated by phospholipids and then fails to bind oriC. Furthermore, oriC DNA facilitates the high affinity binding of ATP to DnaA protein during treatment with phospholipids. A significant portion of the DnaA protein associated with oriC DNA can be replaced by the ADP form of the protein, suggesting that all of the DnaA protein bound to oriC DNA need not be rejuvenated between rounds of replication.     

Acidic phospholipids inhibit the DNA-binding activity of DnaA protein,the initiator of chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli

In order to initiate chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli, the DnaA protein must bind to both ATP and the origin of replication (oriC). Acidic phospholipids are known to inhibit DnaA binding to ATP, and here we examine the effects of various phospholipids on DnaA binding to oriC. Among the phospholipids in E. coli membrane, cardiolipin showed the strongest inhibition of DnaA binding to oriC. Synthetic phosphatidylglycerol containing unsaturated fatty acids inhibited binding more potently than did synthetic phosphatidylglycerol containing saturated fatty acids, suggesting that membrane fluidity is important. Thus, acidic phospholipids seem to inhibit DnaA binding to both oriC and adenine nucleotides in the same manner. Adenine nucleotides bound to DnaA did not affect the inhibitory effect of cardiolipin on DnaA binding to oriC. A mobility-shift assay re-vealed that acidic phospholipids inhibited formation of a DnaA-oriC complex containing several DnaA molecules. DNase I footprinting of DnaA binding to oriC showed that two DnaA binding sites (R2 and R3) were more sensitive to cardiolipin than other DnaA binding sites. Based on these in vitro data, the physiological relevance of this inhibitory effect of acidic phospholipids on DnaA binding to oriC is discussed.     

The FIS protein fails to block the binding of DnaA protein to oriC, the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin.

The Escherichia coli chromosomal origin contains several bindings sites for factor for inversion stimulation (FIS), a protein originally identified to be required for DNA inversion by the Hin and Gin recombinases. The primary FIS binding site is close to two central DnaA boxes that are bound by DnaA protein to initiate chromosomal replication. Because of the close proximity of this FIS site to the two DnaA boxes, we performed in situ footprinting with 1, 10-phenanthroline-copper of complexes formed with FIS and DnaA protein that were separated by native gel electrophoresis. These studies show that the binding of FIS to the primary FIS site did not block the binding of DnaA protein to DnaA boxes R2 and R3. Also, FIS appeared to be bound more stably to oriC than DnaA protein, as deduced by its reduced rate of dissociation from a restriction fragment containing oriC . Under conditions in which FIS was stably bound to the primary FIS site, it did not inhibit oriC plasmid replication in reconstituted replication systems. Inhibition, observed only at high levels of FIS, was due to absorption by FIS binding of the negative superhelicity of the oriC plasmid that is essential for the initiation process.     

Stoichiometry of DnaA and DnaB protein in initiation at the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin

Initiation of DNA replication at the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin, oriC, occurs through an ordered series of events that depend first on the binding of DnaA protein, the replication initiator, to DnaA box sequences within oriC followed by unwinding of an AT-rich region near the left border. The prepriming complex then forms, involving the binding of DnaB helicase at oriC so that it is properly positioned at each replication fork. We assembled and isolated the prepriming complexes on an oriC plasmid, then determined the stoichiometries of proteins in these complexes by quantitative immunoblot analysis. DnaA protein alone binds to oriC with a stoichiometry of 4-5 monomers per oriC DNA. In the prepriming complex, the stoichiometries are 10 DnaA monomers and 2 DnaB hexamers per oriC plasmid. That only two DnaB hexamers are bound, one for each replication fork, suggests that the binding of additional molecules of DnaA in forming the prepriming complex restricts the loading of additional DnaB hexamers that can bind at oriC.     

Identification of the chromosomal replication origin from Thermus thermophilus and its interaction with the replication initiator DnaA

The chromosomal replication origin oriC and the gene encoding the replication initiator protein DnaA from Thermus thermophilus have been identified and cloned into an Escherichia coli vector system. The replication origin is composed of 13 characteristically arranged DnaA boxes, binding sites for the DnaA protein, and an AT-rich stretch, followed by the dnaN gene. The dnaA gene is located upstream of the origin and expresses a typical DnaA protein that follows the division into four domains, as with other members of the DnaA protein family. Here, we report the purification of Thermus-DnaA (Tth-DnaA) and characterize the interaction of the purified protein with the replication origin, with regard to the binding kinetics and stoichiometry of this interaction. Using gel retardation assays, surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and electron microscopy, we show that, unlike the E. coli DnaA, Tth-DnaA does not recognize a single DnaA box, instead a cluster of three tandemly repeated DnaA boxes is the minimal requirement for specific binding. The highest binding affinities are observed with full-length oriC or six clustered, tandemly repeated DnaA boxes. Furthermore, high-affinity DNA-binding of Tth-DnaA is dependent on the presence of ATP. The Thermus DnaA/oriC interaction will be compared with oriC complex formation generated by other DnaA proteins.     

Formation of an ATP-DnaA-specific initiation complex requires DnaA Arginine 285, a conserved motif in the AAA+ protein family

Escherichia coli DnaA protein, a member of the AAA+ superfamily, initiates replication from the chromosomal origin oriC in an ATP-dependent manner. Nucleoprotein complex formed on oriC with the ATP-DnaA multimer but not the ADP-DnaA multimer is competent to unwind the oriC duplex. The oriC region contains ATP-DnaA-specific binding sites termed I2 and I3, which stimulate ATP-DnaA-dependent oriC unwinding. In this study, we show that the DnaA R285A mutant is inactive for oriC replication in vivo and in vitro and that the mutation is associated with specific defects in oriC unwinding. In contrast, activities of DnaA R285A are sustained in binding to the typical DnaA boxes and to ATP and ADP, formation of multimeric complexes on oriC, and loading of the DnaB helicase onto single-stranded DNA. Footprint analysis of the DnaA-oriC complex reveals that the ATP form of DnaA R285A does not interact with ATP-DnaA-specific binding sites such as the I sites. A subgroup of DnaA molecules in the oriC complex must contain the Arg-285 residue for initiation. Sequence and structural analyses suggest that the DnaA Arg-285 residue is an arginine finger, an AAA+ family-specific motif that recognizes ATP bound to an adjacent subunit in a multimeric complex. In the context of these and previous results, the DnaA Arg-285 residue is proposed to play a unique role in the ATP-dependent conformational activation of an initial complex by recognizing ATP bound to DnaA and by modulating the structure of the DnaA multimer to allow interaction with ATP-DnaA-specific binding sites in the complex.     

Insights into the quality of DnaA boxes and their cooperativity

Plasmids carrying the mioC promoter region with its two DnaA boxes are as efficient in titration of DnaA protein as plasmids carrying a replication-inactivated oriC region with its five DnaA boxes. The two DnaA boxes upstream of the mioC promoter were mutated in various ways to study the cooperativity between the DnaA boxes, and to study in vivo the in vitro-defined 9mer DnaA box consensus sequence (TT(A)/(T)TNCACA). The quality and cooperativity of the DnaA boxes were determined in two complementary ways: as titration of DnaA protein leading to derepression of the dnaA promoter, and as repression of the mioC promoter caused by the DnaA protein binding to the DnaA boxes. Titration of DnaA protein correlated with repression of the mioC promoter. The level of titration and repression with the normal promoter-proximal box (TTTTCCACA) depends strongly on the presence and the quality of a DnaA box in the promoter-distal position, whereas a promoter-proximal DnaA box with the sequence TTATCCACA titrated DnaA protein and caused significant repression of the mioC promoter without a promoter-distal DnaA box. The quality of the eight different consensus DnaA boxes located in the promoter-proximal position was determined: TTATCCACA had the highest affinity for DnaA protein. In the third position, A was better than T, and the four possibilities in the fifth position could be ranked as C >A >or=G >T. Parallel in vitro experiments using a purified DNA-binding domain of DnaA protein gave the same ranking of the binding affinities of the eight DnaA boxes.     

The Escherichia coli SeqA protein binds specifically and co-operatively to two sites in hemimethylated and fully methylated oriC

The Escherichia coli SeqA protein has been found to affect initiation of replication negatively, both in vivo and in vitro. The mechanism of inhibition is, however, not known. SeqA has been suggested to affect the formation and activity of the initiation complex at oriC, either by binding to DNA or by interacting with the DnaA protein. We have investigated the binding of SeqA to oriC by electron microscopy and found that SeqA binds specifically to two sites in oriC, one on each side of the DnaA binding site R1. Specific binding was found for fully and hemimethylated but not unmethylated oriC in good agreement with earlier mobility shift studies. The affinity of SeqA for hemi-methylated oriC was higher than for fully methylated oriC. The binding was in both cases strongly cooperative. We suggest that SeqA binds to two nucleation sites in oriC, and by the aid of protein-protein interaction spreads to adjacent regions in the same oriC as well as recruiting additional oriC molecules and/or complexes into larger aggregates.     

Mutant DnaA proteins defective in duplex opening of oriC, the origin of chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli

We characterized three mutant DnaA proteins with an amino acid substitution of R334H, R342H and E361G that renders chromosomal replication cold (20 degrees C) sensitive. Each mutant DnaA protein was highly purified from overproducers, and replication activities were assayed in in vitro oriC replication systems. At 30 degrees C, all three mutant proteins exhibited specific activity similar to that seen with the wild-type protein, whereas at 20 degrees C, there was much less activity in a replication system using a crude replicative extract. Regarding the affinity for ATP, the dissociation rate of bound ATP and binding to oriC DNA, the three mutant DnaA proteins showed a capacity indistinguishable from that of the wild-type DnaA protein. Activity for oriC DNA unwinding of the two mutant DnaA proteins, R334H and R342H, was more sensitive to low temperature than that of the wild-type DnaA protein. We propose that R334H and R342H have a defect in their potential to unwind oriC DNA at low temperatures, the result being the cold-sensitive phenotype in oriC DNA replication. The two amino acid residues of DnaA protein, located in a motif homologous to that of NtrC protein, may play a role in the formation of the open complex. The E361 residue may be related to interaction with another protein present in a crude cell extract.     

The bacteriophage lambda DNA replication protein P inhibits the oriC DNA- and ATP-binding functions of the DNA replication initiator protein DnaA of Escherichia coli

Under the condition of expression of lambda P protein at lethal level, the oriC DNA-binding activity is significantly affected in wild-type E. coli but not in the rpl mutant. In purified system, the lambda P protein inhibits the binding of both oriC DNA and ATP to the wild-type DnaA protein but not to the rpl DnaA protein. We conclude that the lambda P protein inhibits the binding of oriC DNA and ATP to the wild-type DnaA protein, which causes the inhibition of host DNA synthesis initiation that ultimately leads to bacterial death. A possible beneficial effect of this interaction of lambda P protein with E. coli DNA initiator protein DnaA for phage DNA replication has been proposed.     

Drunken-cell footprints: nuclease treatment of ethanol-permeabilized bacteria reveals an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex in stationary phase replication origins.

The nucleoprotein complex formed on oriC, the Escherichia coli replication origin, is dynamic. During the cell cycle, high levels of the initiator DnaA and a bending protein, IHF, bind to oriC at the time of initiation of DNA replication, while binding of Fis, another bending protein, is reduced. In order to probe the structure of nucleoprotein complexes at oriC in more detail, we have developed an in situ footprinting method, termed drunken-cell footprinting, that allows enzymatic DNA modifying reagents access to intracellular nucleoprotein complexes in E.coli, after a brief exposure to ethanol. With this method, we observed in situ binding of Fis to oriC in exponentially growing cells, and binding of IHF to oriC in stationary cells, using DNase I and Bst NI endonuclease, respectively. Increased binding of DnaA to oriC in stationary phase was also noted. Because binding of DnaA and IHF results in unwinding of oriC in vitro, P1 endonuclease was used to probe for intracellular unwinding of oriC. P1 cleavage sites, localized within the 13mer unwinding region of oriC ', were dramatically enhanced in stationary phase on wild-type origins, but not on mutant versions of oriC unable to unwind. These observations suggest that most oriC copies become unwound during stationary phase, forming an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex.     

A comprehensive set of DnaA-box mutations in the replication origin, oriC, of Escherichia coli

We probed the complex between the replication origin, oriC , and the initiator protein DnaA using different types of mutations in the five binding sites for DnaA, DnaA boxes R1–R4 and M: (i) point mutations in individual DnaA boxes and combinations of them; (ii) replacement of the DnaA boxes by a scrambled 9 bp non-box motif; (iii) positional exchange; and (iv) inversion of the DnaA boxes. For each of the five DnaA boxes we found at least one type of mutation that resulted in a phenotype. This demonstrates that all DnaA boxes in oriC have a function in the initiation process. Most mutants with point mutations retained some origin activity, and the in vitro DnaA-binding capacity of these origins correlated well with their replication proficiency. Inversion or scrambling of DnaA boxes R1 or M inactivated oriC -dependent replication of joint replicons or minichromosomes under all conditions, demonstrating the importance of these sites. In contrast, mutants with inverted or scrambled DnaA boxes R2 or R4 could not replicate in wild-type hosts but gave transformants in host strains with deleted or compromised chromosomal oriC at elevated DnaA concentrations. We conclude that these origins require more DnaA per origin for initiation than does wild-type oriC . Mutants in DnaA box R3 behaved essentially like wild-type oriC , except for those in which the low-affinity box R3 was replaced by the high-affinity box R1. Apparently, initiation is possible without DnaA binding to box R3, but high-affinity DnaA binding to DnaA box R3 upsets the regulation. Taken together, these results demonstrate that there are finely tuned DnaA binding requirements for each of the individual DnaA boxes for optimal build-up of the initiation complex and replication initiation in vivo