Competence Mutant of Haemophilus influenzae with Abnormal Ratios of Marker Efficiencies in Transformation

In studies of competence-deficient mutants of Haemophilus influenzae which absorb deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) but fail to produce transformants, it was observed that in some mutants the residual transforming activity for different markers varied widely, i.e., produced a ratio effect. One of these mutants, com⁻⁵⁶, was studied intensively to determine the cause of the residual efficiency of transformation and the reason for the ratio effect. The residual frequency of transformation was higher for markers considered single-site mutations (like naladixic acid resistance), whereas the least efficient markers tested were those conferring resistance to high levels of streptomycin or novobiocin which are more complex than single-site mutations. Measurement of frequencies of cotransformation indicated that overall genetic linkage was reduced. Transfection was fairly efficient with phage S2 DNA, but not prophage DNA. Donor marker activity could be detected in transformed cell lysates, but not linked to recipient markers in recombinant molecules. Sucrose gradient analysis of such lysates revealed that donor material was associated with recipient DNA in at least normal quantities, but lacked detectable genetic activity. Material from donor DNA labeled with heavy isotopes was incorporated into recipient chromosomal fragments having a density indistinguishable from normal density, unlike the hybrid density recombinant material found in normal cells. No excessive solubilization or nicking of unincorporated donor was detected. It is postulated that this strain contains a hyperactive nuclease, which reduces the effective size of the input DNA during the integration process.     

Restriction of DNA encoding selectable markers decreases the transformation efficiency of Helicobacter pylori

Helicobacter pylori populations recovered from the human stomach display extensive recombination and quasispecies development, and this suggests frequent exchange of DNA between different strains in vivo. In vitro, however, most H. pylori strains display restriction to the uptake of non-self DNA, as measured using selectable markers, regardless of their competency for transformation with self DNA. We have examined the effect of different selectable markers on double-crossover recombination efficiencies in three reference strains (1061, 26695 & SS1) and one clinical isolate (CHP1) of H. pylori. All strains were efficiently transformable to kanamycin or chloramphenicol resistance by using self-genomic DNA from isogenic mutants bearing the aphA3 or cat cassettes, respectively. However, strains 26695 and CHP1 showed a 3-5-log reduction in transformation efficiency by non-self recombinant DNA containing aphA3, when compared to cat. Strain 1061 readily accepted either cassette, and strain SS1 was poorly tolerant of any non-self DNA. Genome-wide random mutagenesis of these strains was only achievable with a selectable marker that allowed high transformation efficiency. Digestion of 32P-labelled cassettes by H. pylori lysates mirrored the transformation results and indicated that in some strains these cassettes are the targets of enzymatic restriction.     

Integration Efficiency in DNA-Induced Transformation of Pneumococcus. I. a Method of Transformation in Solid Medium and Its Use for Isolation of Transformation-Deficient and Recombination-Modified Mutants

A method of transformation on solid medium especially adapted for pneumococcus has been developed. Under specific conditions, all colonies that are allowed to grow in the presence of transforming DNA for six hours give rise to transformed bacteria. Combined with replica plating this technique has been used to isolate mutants modified with regard to recombination. Most of the mutants found are transformation-defective and show a large diversity in their response to ultraviolet light. Some of these mutants have lost their ability to take up transforming DNA. One shows a reduced yield of transformants for a given quantity of DNA taken up. Mutants that manifest altered behavior with regard to marker efficiencies have also been isolated. One of these exhibits a decrease in the transformation efficiency of only the high efficiency markers and two mutants show a decrease in the transformation efficiency of the low efficiency markers.     

Interspecific transformation of Bacillus subtilis competent cells by chromosomal DNA in lysates of protoplasts of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens

Competent cells of Bacillus subtilis were transformed with chromosomal DNA in lysates of protoplasts of B. subtilis or B. amyloliquefaciens. The interspecific transformation frequency of B. subtilis by cysA in a conserved region was 3.1 x 10(4) transformants per microg DNA, 60 times higher than that for conventional transformation using purified DNA. Increased interspecific transformation frequencies of B. subtilis were also observed for arg-1, lys-1, leuB, aroG, thr-5, hisH, or metC markers outside the conserved region (3.1 x 10 approximately 5.2 x 10(2) transformants per microg DNA). An interspecific cotransformation ratio (33-50%) as high as an intraspecific one (46%) using purified DNA was also detected between cysA and rpsL markers, which are separated by 16 kb on the B. subtilis chromosome. Interspecific double transformation of the cysA-arg-1 or cysA-metC marker was observed, which have not been detected for conventional transformation. The involvement of mutS in the interspecific transformation was not significant.     

Loss of activity of transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by Haemophilus influenzae

Voll, Mary Jane (University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia), and Sol H. Goodgal. Loss of activity of transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by Haemophilus influenzae. J. Bacteriol. 90:873-883. 1965.-Transforming deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) which has been irreversibly removed from solution by competent cells undergoes a progressive loss in marker activity when tested by lysis of the cells and exposure to new recipient cells. The loss of activity is limited and marker-specific, with greater inactivation of those markers with lower efficiencies of transformation. Recipient factors or donor factors which have undergone recombination, as measured by the appearance of linked markers, do not undergo inactivation. The efficiency of transformation can be correlated with the sensitivity of a marker to inactivation after DNA uptake. A mutation which affects the efficiency of transformation is found to increase sensitivity to postuptake inactivation. The rate of inactivation is temperature-dependent. At temperatures of 20 and 45 C, marker inactivation can occur without concomitant recombination. During the uptake process, DNA is retained in an acid-insoluble form, indicating that the fate of Haemophilus influenzae DNA differs from the fate of transforming DNA in pneumococcus.     

Destruction of low efficiency markers is a slow process occurring at a heteroduplex stage of transformation

Summary Direct evidence is presented that the mechanism which discriminates against low efficiency markers in transformation of Diplococcus pneumoniae of genotype hex ⁺ acts on them after the formation of donor-recipient heteroduplexes. This conclusion is based on assays of the transforming activity of donor markers in lysates made after various times of incubation of recipient cells following exposure to DNA. The activity of a low efficiency marker rises substantially, indicating formation of native-like heteroduplex structures, and then falls. At 37° C the process is essentially completed 10 minutes after entry, and the apparent half life of a susceptible heteroduplex is 1.5 to 2 minutes. Data from these and other experiments imply that about as many of the surviving low efficiency markers have simply escaped attack as have been inserted into both strands by the excision-repair process suggested by Ephrussi-Taylor.     

Heterospecific transformation of Pneumococcus and Streptococcus

Summary Transformations of two linked ribosomal loci (str and ery) were carried out between the SIII-1 strain of pneumococcus and the Challis and SBE strains of group H streptococcus. Transfer of markers between the Challis and SBE strains is as efficient as in the corresponding intrastrain transformations. Transfer between either of these strains and the pneumococcus, however, is less efficient than in the corresponding intrastrain transformation, and is referred to as heterospecific transformation. The inefficiency of the heterospecific transformation is due neither to specific lethality nor reduced uptake of heterologous DNA.When DNA was extracted from the hybrid resulting from a heterospecific cross and used to transform the original donor and recipient species, we found: (a) no donor material in the hybrid DNA responsible for the markedly low efficiency of integration into the recipient species; (b) donor material, in addition to the transforming marker itself, detectable by the higher efficiency with which hybrid DNA transforms the original donor species than does DNA from the original recipient species.DNA was extracted from each of 36 independently derived, doubly marked transformants resulting from the cross: Challis str-s ery-sxSIII-1 str-r53 ery-r2 DNA. Variability was observed between the different hybrid DNAs when the integration efficiency of the str marker in each DNA was compared with that of the ery marker. Variability of as great a magnitude was not observed when the same hybrid DNA was tested in repeated experiments, or when different DNA preparations were extracted from the same hybrid strain, or when several DNA preparations were obtained from a number of independent homospecific transformants. It is concluded that different kinds of donor material are present in the various hybrids, and that the nature of this extra-marker material affects the integration of the marker.Linkage of the str and ery markers was reduced in heterospecific transformations. The kind of donor DNA in the hybrid genome did not affect the linkage reduction observed when the str and ery markers were transferred back to the donor species in which they originated. Indeed, this linkage reduction was the same as that observed when the markers were originally transferred from the SIII-1 to the Challis strain. Specific factors reducing linkage in heterologous crosses must, therefore, be distinct from other factors which affect integration efficiency. The former, however, may be primarily responsible for the inefficiency of heterospecific transformation.One of the hybrid DNAs was used to obtain a second generation of hybrids by passing it through each of the original parental strains. Tests of the DNAs extracted from 24 independently produced, second-generation hybrids showed that hybrid DNA is subject to further alteration by a second integration involving some heterologous confrontation. The probability of such alteration appears to be increased if the second integration is accompanied by linkage reduction.Supported by NIH grant AI-00917.     

Interspecies transformation in Bacillus: sequence heterology as the major barrier.

The relative contribution of DNA restriction and of sequence heterology as barriers to interspecies transfer of DNA was studied in the heterologous transformation of Bacillus subtilis recipients by DNA was studied in the heterologous transformation of Bacillus subtilis recipients by DNA isolated from B. globigii. Transformants were obtained at very low frequencies in the evolutionarily nonconserved aromatic region; high cotransfer of linked markers was observed. New mutations were introduced into the B. globigii intergenote sequence in the resulting hybrids; these markers could be transformed with high efficiency by both B. globigii and B. subtilis DNA, representing a 10(5)-fold increase in heterologous transforming efficiency. A restriction activity in B. globigii crude extracts inactivated the biological activity of B. subtilis and hybrid DNA but not B. globigii DNA in vitro, demonstrating different sites for restriction and modification between these species. In vivo, however, B. globigii and hybrid DNA transformed the B. globigii sequence in a hybrid recipient with the same efficiency. These results show that sequence heterology is the major barrier to interspecies transformation and that, in this system, enzymatic restriction does not prevent interspecies transformation.     

Restriction-like phenomena in transformation of Bacillus subtilis recA.

Genetic transformation in recA1 strains of Bacillus subtilis was studied to test the hypothesis that, in these strains, a major pathway of recombination is missing, leaving only residual transformation via a pathway specific for transduction. The two putative recombinational pathways have been hypothesized to differ in either length of synapsed regions or specificity for nucleotide sequence homology. It was found that the efficiency of transformation of recA1 cells by deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) from the heterologous strain W23 was much lower than when a homologous donor DNA was used, the relative efficiency being different for different genetic markers. Because the frequency of recombination between linked markers is only slightly changed in recA1 recipients, and because markers of heterologous origin in DNA from intergenotic strains are not discriminated against strongly by recA1 recipients, it is concluded that neither a difference in length of synapsed DNA nor a difference in specificity for nucleotide sequence homology accounts for reduced transformation in recA1 cells. It is proposed that at some time between uptake and integration, heterologous DNA is inactivated by restriction, and that aberrant restriction of repaired regions may account for reduced transformation by homologous DNA.     

UV stimulation of DNA-mediated transformation of human cells.

Irradiation of dominant marker DNA with UV light (150 to 1,000 J/m2) was found to stimulate the transformation of human cells by this marker from two- to more than fourfold. This phenomenon is also displayed by xeroderma pigmentosum cells (complementation groups A and F), which are deficient in the excision repair of UV-induced pyrimidine dimers in the DNA. Also, exposure to UV of the transfected (xeroderma pigmentosum) cells enhanced the transfection efficiency. Removal of the pyrimidine dimers from the DNA by photoreactivating enzyme before transfection completely abolished the stimulatory effect, indicating that dimer lesions are mainly responsible for the observed enhancement. A similar stimulation of the transformation efficiency is exerted by 2-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene modification of the DNA. No stimulation was found after damaging vector DNA by treatment with DNase or gamma rays. These findings suggest that lesions which are targets for the excision repair pathway induce the increase in transformation frequency. The stimulation was found to be independent of sequence homology between the irradiated DNA and the host chromosomal DNA. Therefore, the increase of the transformation frequency is not caused by a mechanism inducing homologous recombination between these two DNAs. UV treatment of DNA before transfection did not have a significant effect on the amount of DNA integrated into the xeroderma pigmentosum genome.     

Transformation of a Bacillus subtilis L-form with bacteriophage deoxyribonucleic acid.

A stable L-form, sal-1, of Bacillus subtilis was transformed with deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) from bacteriophages phi 25 and phi 29 to determine whether exogenous DNA can be introduced into this organism. The viral transformation (transfection) was successful with the use of polyethylene glycol. In the presence of the fusogen, bacteriophage phi 25 DNA initiated a single cycle of infection. When compared with transfection of competent cells of Bacillus subtilis, the appearance of viral particles was delayed and their production occurred over a longer time period. L-form cells were best able to support intracellular replication of phi 25 viral particles when in balanced growth in a rich medium. The addition of polyethylene glycol also induced infection of sal-1 with whole bacteriophage phi 25 particles which could not otherwise infect the L-form and enhanced infection by intact phi 29 particles. Primary recombination was shown to be required for polyethylene glycol-mediated phi 25 transfection, but not phi 29 transfection or for whole bacteriophage phi 25 infection mediated by polyethylene glycol. Successful transfection of sal-1 suggests that the L-form may be amenable to genetic modification with exogenous DNA.     

Genetic Studies Relating to the Production of Transformed Clones Diploid in the Tryptophan Region of the Bacillus subtilis Genome

Transformation experiments with Bacillus subtilis strains carrying trpE26 (the marker responsible for the detection of merodiploid clones after transformation or transduction) have established the precise position of this marker on the "aromatic region" of the chromosome, at the distal end of the anthranilate synthetase locus. Integration efficiency of the mutant allele (trpE26) seems to be very low. Co-transfer of markers situated on either side of it is almost nil when both donor and recipient carry this mutation. The "exclusion" of trpE26 does not, however, affect recombination frequencies for nearby markers. To explain these facts we considered the hypothesis of a preferential breakage of the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) at the trpE26 site or that of an insertion mutation. These studies have also demonstrated the establishment of physical linkage of a marker from the exogenote (hisH2) to a resident marker (tyrA1) in stable and unstable merodiploid clones, thus confirming integration of the donor DNA segment into a genetic structure of the recipient. Furthermore, duplication was shown in merodiploid clones (through reversion and transformation) for a locus of the recipient (tyrA) which was not involved in the initial transformation. This suggests that the diploid condition in this region extends beyond the transformed area. Interpretation of the genetic constitution of these partial diploids calls for postulation of the existence of long duplications, a second (incomplete) chromosome, or an episome-like element.     

Ultraviolet inactivation and excision-repair in Bacillus subtilis. I. Construction and characterization of a transformable eightfold auxotrophic strain and two ultraviolet-sensitive derivatives

An eightfold auxotrophic strain of Bacillus subtilis was constructed. It was about equally well transformable for all markers. When this strain was used as recipient in transformation, single marker transformation frequencies of 0.5–2.0% were obtained. The markers were located relatively to each other using marker frequency analysis. Two UV-sensitive derivatives, equally well transformable as the parental multiple auxotroph, were isolated. One was highly sensitive to UV irradiation, was host cell reactivation-negative and did not show DNA breakdown or recovery of DNA synthesis after exposure to UV. Using UV-inactivated transforming DNA, this strain's transformability was strongly reduced as compared with both the UV-resistant parental strain and the other, moderately UV-sensitive, strain.     

Chromosomal Basis of the Merozygosity in a Partially Diploid Mutant of Pneumococcus

A sulfonamide-resistant mutant of pneumococcus, sulr-c, displays a genetic instability, regularly segregating to wild type. DNA extracts of derivatives of the strain possess transforming activities for both the mutant and wild-type alleles, establishing that the strain is a partial diploid. The linkage of sulr-c to strr-61, a stable chromosomal marker, was established, thus defining a chromosomal locus for sulr-c. DNA isolated from sulr-c cells transforms two mutant recipient strains at the same low efficiency as it does a wild-type recipient, although the mutant property of these strains makes them capable of integrating classical "low-efficiency" donor markers equally as efficiently as "high efficiency" markers. Hence sulr-c must have a different basis for its low efficiency than do classical low efficiency point mutations. We suggest that the DNA in the region of the sulr-c mutation has a structural abnormality which leads both to its frequent segregation during growth and its difficulty in efficiently mediating genetic transformation.     

The variation in frequency with which markers are transduced by phage P1 is primarily a result of discrimination during recombination

Summary The efficiency of recovery of P1 transductants is marker dependent and normally varies over a 25-fold range. UV irradiation of either transducing lysates or recipient cells results in a selective stimulation of the transduction of markers which are normally transduced poorly. As a result the range in frequency of transduction is reduced to about 3-fold and resembles the gene frequency distribution expected in the donor cells. We conclude that P1 transducing lysates are likely to contain a random sample of donor DNA but that the recombination system of the recipient cell exhibits a preference for the DNA of some regions over that of others. Damage to DNA presumably overrides this specificity.     

Confirmation of protoplast fusion-derived linkages in Staphylococcus aureus by transformation with protoplast DNA

Transformation provided definitive evidence for linkage between tyrB282::Tn551 ermB321 and omega (Chr::Tn551)34, and thus between the separate large linkage groups containing these markers, in Staphylococcus aureus NCTC 8325. Transformation also defined the chromosomal loci for the purC193::Tn551 and omega (Chr::Tn551)42 markers and the linkage of a tetracycline resistance marker (tet-3490) with a fusidic acid resistance marker (fus-149). The use of DNA isolated from protoplasts under conditions that reduced hydrodynamic shear greatly facilitated the demonstration of most of these linkages. These results provide direct evidence confirming several of the linkages predicted by a microcomputer-assisted protoplast fusion analysis in a previous study (M. L. Stahl and P. A. Pattee, J. Bacteriol. 154:395-405, 1983); those markers whose predicted linkages were not confirmed by transformation are probably separated by chromosomal distances that exceed the limits of detection by transformation, even with protoplast DNA.     

Restriction enzymes do not play a significant role in Haemophilus homospecific or heterospecific transformation.

Competent Haemophilus influenzae Rd recipients, either as phage HP1 restricting (r+) or nonrestricting (r-) nonlysogens or defective lysogens, were exposed to deoxyribonucleic acids from various wild-type phage HP1 lysogenic H. influenzae serotype strains (non-encapsulated derivatives of serotypes a,b, c, d, and e), to DNA from lysogenic Haemophilus parahaemolyticus, and to DNA from modified and nonmodified phage HP1. Transformation of antibiotic resistance markers and of prophage markers in homospecific crosses was observed to be unaffected by the recipient restriction phenotype, whereas the transfection response was much reduced in r+ recipients. Heterospecific transformation of prophage markers was reduced by only 80 to 90%, whereas antibiotic resistance marker transformation was 1,000 to 10,000 times lower. Heterspecific transfection was at least 100 times lower than homospecific transfection in both r+ and r- recipients. The general conclusion is that neither class I nor class II restriction enzymes affect significantly the transformation efficiency in homospecific and heterospecific crosses. The efficiency of heterospecific transformation may depend mainly on the deoxyribonucleic acid homology in the genetic marker region.     

Isolation of DNA fragments containing replicating growing forks from both E. coli and B. subtilis

Summary By the use of a restriction enzyme digestion of gently lysed E. coli or B. subtilis cells, it is possible to isolate a minute fraction of the total DNA that has an unusually high sedimentation coefficient. Upon inspection of this DNA in the electron microscope, branched DNA fragments are observed. Single branched DNA fragments were analyzed by restriction enzyme and partial denaturation mapping techniques. The fragments appear to have the properties of growing forks excised from in vivo replicating intermediates. In B. subtilis, the minute fraction of DNA was also investigated by transformation assays and found to be greatly enriched for a marker near the origin and slightly enriched for a terminus marker.     

Plasmid transformation of Azotobacter vinelandii OP

Azotobacter vinelandii OP which had been naturally induced to competence by growth in iron- and molybdenum-limited medium was transformed with the broad-host-range cloning vector pKT210. However, the transformation frequency at nearly saturating levels of DNA was 1000-fold lower for pKT210 than for a single chromosomal DNA marker (nif+). Plasmid- and chromosomal-DNA-mediated transformation events were competitive, magnesium-dependent, 42 degrees C-sensitive processes specific to double-stranded DNA, suggesting a common mechanism of DNA binding and uptake. The low frequency of plasmid transformation was not related to restriction of transforming DNA or to the growth period allowed for phenotypic expression. Covalently-closed-circular and open-circular forms of pKT210 transformed cells equally well whereas EcoRI- or HindIII-linearized pKT210 transformed cells with two to three times greater efficiency. Genetic transformation was enhanced 10- to 50-fold when pKT210 contained an insert fragment of A. vinelandii nif DNA, indicating that A. vinelandii possessed a homology-facilitated transformation system. However, all transformants failed to maintain the plasmid-encoded antibiotic resistance determinants, and extrachromosomal plasmid DNA was not recovered from these cells. Flush-ended pKT210 was not active in transformation; however, competent cells were transformed to Nif+ by HincII-digested plasmid DNA containing the cloned A. vinelandii nif-10 marker.