Delay of testicular differentiation in the B6.YDOM ovotestis demonstrated by immunocytochemical staining for müllerian inhibiting substance.

It has been found that when the Y chromosome from Mus musculus domesticus (YDOM) is placed onto the C57BL/6J (B6) mouse background, the XY progeny (B6.YDOM) develop ovaries or ovotestes but not normal testes during fetal life. We examined the ontogeny of the abnormal testicular differentiation in the B6.YDOM ovotestis by immunocytochemical staining for Müllerian inhibiting substance (MIS). We found that the B6.YDOM ovotestis initiated testicular differentiation later in development than did the control B6 testis. When the YDOM was transferred onto the SJL J mouse background by crossing B6.YDOM males with SJL/J females, all XY progeny developed normal testes. The onset of testicular differentiation was at the same developmental stage as in the B6 male fetus. These results suggest that the delay of testicular differentiation is not due to the effect of the YDOM chromosome itself, but due to improper interaction of the testis-determining gene on the YDOM chromosome with autosomal genes of B6. In addition, we found a close correlation between the arrest of germ cells at the prespermatogonia stage and MIS production of adjacent somatic cells in the B6.YDOM ovotestis. This result may support the hypothesis that MIS is involved in the regulation of germ cell differentiation.     

Sex reversal in C57BL/6J XY mice caused by increased expression of ovarian genes and insufficient activation of the testis determining pathway

Sex reversal can occur in XY humans with only a single functional WT1 or SF1 allele or a duplication of the chromosome region containing WNT4. In contrast, XY mice with only a single functional Wt1, Sf1, or Wnt4 allele, or mice that over-express Wnt4 from a transgene, reportedly are not sex-reversed. Because genetic background plays a critical role in testis differentiation, particularly in C57BL/6J (B6) mice, we tested the hypothesis that Wt1, Sf1, and Wnt4 are dosage sensitive in B6 XY mice. We found that reduced Wt1 or Sf1 dosage in B6 XY(B6) mice impaired testis differentiation, but no ovarian tissue developed. If, however, a Y(AKR) chromosome replaced the Y(B6) chromosome, these otherwise genetically identical B6 XY mice developed ovarian tissue. In contrast, reduced Wnt4 dosage increased the amount of testicular tissue present in Sf1+/- B6 XY(AKR), Wt1+/- B6 XY(AKR), B6 XY(POS), and B6 XY(AKR) fetuses. We propose that Wt1(B6) and Sf1(B6) are hypomorphic alleles of testis-determining pathway genes and that Wnt4(B6) is a hypermorphic allele of an ovary-determining pathway gene. The latter hypothesis is supported by the finding that expression of Wnt4 and four other genes in the ovary-determining pathway are elevated in normal B6 XX E12.5 ovaries. We propose that B6 mice are sensitive to XY sex reversal, at least in part, because they carry Wt1(B6) and/or Sf1(B6) alleles that compromise testis differentiation and a Wnt4(B6) allele that promotes ovary differentiation and thereby antagonizes testis differentiation. Addition of a "weak" Sry allele, such as the one on the Y(POS) chromosome, to the sensitized B6 background results in inappropriate development of ovarian tissue. We conclude that Wt1, Sf1, and Wnt4 are dosage-sensitive in mice, this dosage-sensitivity is genetic background-dependant, and the mouse strains described here are good models for the investigation of human dosage-sensitive XY sex reversal.     

C57BL/6J-T-associated sex reversal in mice is caused by reduced expression of a Mus domesticus Sry allele

C57BL/6J-T-associated sex reversal (B6-TAS) in XY mice results in ovarian development and involves (1) hemizygosity for Tas, a gene located in the region of Chromosome 17 deleted in T(hp) and T(Orl), (2) homozygosity for one or more B6-derived autosomal genes, and (3) the presence of the AKR Y chromosome. Here we report results from experiments designed to investigate the Y chromosome component of this sex reversal. Testis development was restored in B6 T(Orl)/+ XY(AKR) mice carrying a Mus musculus Sry transgene. In addition, two functionally different classes of M. domesticus Sry alleles were identified among eight standard and two wild-derived inbred strains. One class, which includes AKR, did not initiate normal testis development in B6 T(Orl)/+ XY mice, whereas the other did. DNA sequence analysis of the Sry ORF and a 5' 800-bp segment divided these inbred strains into the same groups. Finally, we found that Sry is transcribed in B6 T(Orl)/+ XY(AKR) fetal gonads but at a reduced level. These results pinpoint Sry as the Y-linked component of B6-TAS. We hypothesize that the inability of specific M. domesticus Sry alleles to initiate normal testis development in B6 T(Orl)/+ XY(AKR) mice results from a biologically insufficient level of Sry expression, allowing the ovarian development pathway to proceed.     

Morphological development of the mouse gonad in tda-1 XY sex reversal

tda-1 XY sex reversal occurs when the Y chromosome of at least some populations of wild Mus musculus domesticus is placed on the C57BL/6J genomic background. Gross anatomical observations have previously revealed morphological similarities among fetal ovotestes of tda-1 and Tas-inherited XY sex reversals and BALB/cWt mosaic hermaphrodites. We studied the histology of tda-1 XY sex-reversed gonads, ranging in age from day 14 of gestation to adult. The obtained data revealed additional similarities with ovotestes of BALB/cWt mosaic hermaphrodites as well as with ovotestes of hermaphrodites found in XXSxr and XX/XY chimeras. It is proposed that ovotestes occurring in these various hermaphroditic conditions may be formed through a common pathway.     

Assays of testis development in the mouse distinguish three classes of domesticus-type Y chromosome

The Y chromosome of Mus musculus poschiavinus interacts with the autosomal recessive gene tda-1b of the C57BL/6J laboratory strain of the house mouse to cause complete or partial sex reversal. Ovaries or ovotestes develop in a substantial proportion of the XY fetuses. Several different Y-specific DNA probes distinguish two major types of Y chromosome in the house mouse and they are represented by M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus. The poschiavinus Y chromosome appears identical to the domesticus Y. The developmental distribution of the gonad types was examined in the first backcross or N2 generation of fetuses in C57BL/6J with six different domesticus-type Y chromosomes and, as controls, three different musculus-type Y chromosomes. Gonadal hermaphrodites were found with three of the six domesticus-type Y chromosomes. Both overall frequency and phenotypic distribution of types of gonadal hermaphrodites identify three classes of domesticus-type Y chromosome by their differential interaction with the C57BL/6J genetic background.     

Sry promoters from domesticus (Tirano) and C57BL/6 mice function similarly in embryos and adult animals.

Introduction of the Y chromosome from a Mus musculus domesticus (Tirano) subspecies into the Mus musculus musculus C57BL/6 (B6) inbred strain background results in sex reversal in XY offspring. It has been hypothesized that the domesticus testis-determining Y (Tdy) locus is misregulated in B6 genome, thereby impairing sex determination in B6.Y(Dom) animals. The identification of a gene in the sex-determining region on the Y chromosome (Sry) as the Tdy has provided a means to experimentally examine this hypothesis. We have generated several lines of B6 transgenic mice harboring a green fluorescent protein gene directed by a Sry promoter from the domesticus (Tirano) Y chromosome. Detailed analysis of the transgene expression was conducted in both fetal and adult tissues of the transgenic mice. The domesticus Sry promoter was capable of directing the expression of the green fluorescent protein gene in a pattern similar, if not identical, to that of the endogenous B6 Sry gene. These observations suggest that the domesticus Sry promoter is not involved in the postulated misregulation of the domesticus (Tirano) Sry gene in the B6 genomic background. These results are discussed with reference to a second hypothesis invoking incompatible protein interaction(s) as a mechanism of aberrant sex determination in B6.Y(Dom) animals.     

Distribution of the molossinus allele of Sry, the testis-determining gene, in wild mice

When the Y chromosome of the laboratory inbred mouse strain C57BL/6 (B6) is replaced by the Y of certain strains of Mus musculus domesticus, testis determination fails and all XY fetuses develop either as hermaphrodites or XY females (XY sex reversal). This suggests the presence of at least two alleles of Sry, the male-determining gene on the Y:M. m. domesticus and B6. The B6 Y chromosome is derived from the Japanese house mouse, M. m. molossinus and therefore carries a molossinus Sry allele. As a first step to determine how the molossinus Sry allele evolved, its distribution pattern was determined in wild mice. The cumulative data of 96 M. musculus samples obtained from 58 geographical locations in Europe, North Africa, and Asia show the molossinus Sry allele is restricted to Japan and the neighboring Asian mainland and confirm that Japanese M. m. molossinus mice were derived in part from a race of M. m. musculus from Korea or Manchuria. Sry polymorphisms, as illustrated by the molossinus Sry allele, can serve as molecular markers for studies on the evolution of wild M. musculus populations and can help determine the role sex determination plays in speciation.      

Defective mesonephric cell migration is associated with abnormal testis cord development in C57BL/6J XY(Mus domesticus) mice

During the critical period of mouse sex determination, mesenchymal cells migrate from the mesonephros into the adjacent developing testis. This process is thought to initiate cord development and is dependent on Sry. The presence of Sry, however, does not always guarantee normal testis development. For example, transfer of certain Mus domesticus-derived Y chromosomes, i.e., M. domesticus Sry alleles, onto the C57BL/6J (B6) inbred mouse strain results in abnormal testis development. We tested the hypothesis that mesonephric cell migration was impaired in three cases representing a range of aberrant testis development: B6 XY(AKR), B6 XY(POS), and (BXD-21 x B6-Y(POS))F1 XY(POS). In each case, mesonephric cell migration was abnormal. Furthermore, the timing, extent, and position of migrating cells in vitro and cord development in vivo were coincident, supporting the hypothesis that mesonephric cells are critical for cord development. Additional experiments indicated that aberrant testis development results from the inability of Sry(M. domesticus) to initiate normal cell migration, but that downstream signal transduction mechanisms are intact. These experiments provide new insight into the mechanism of C57BL/6J-Y(M. domesticus) sex reversal. We present a model incorporating these findings as they relate to mammalian sex determination.     

Inheritance of T-associated sex reversal in mice

We previously identified a primary sex-determining locus, Tas, on mouse Chr 17 that causes ovarian tissue development in C57BL/6J Thp/+ and TOrl/+ individuals if the AKR/JY chromosome is present. We hypothesized that Tas is located within the region of Chr 17 deleted by Thp and TOrl and that C57BL/6J carries a diagnostic Tas allele, based on the observation that ovarian tissue develops in XY mice when Thp is on a C57BL/6J inbred strain background, whereas normal testicular development occurs when Thp is on a C3H/HeSnJ inbred strain background. To test this hypothesis, we mated (C57BL/6J x C3H/HeSnJ)F1 females to C57BL/6J Thp/+ hermaphrodites. As expected, half of the XY Thp/+ offspring developed ovarian and testicular tissue while half developed exclusively testicular tissue. Unexpectedly, the inheritance of selected Chr 17 molecular loci was independent of gonadal development, as half of the male and hermaphroditic offspring inherited C3H/HeSnJ-derived Chr 17 loci and half inherited C57BL/6J-derived Chr 17 loci. We conclude that for ovarian tissue to develop in an XY Thp/+ or XY TOrl/+ individual (1) Tas must be present in a hemizygous state, which is accomplished by heterozygosity for the Thp or TOrl deletions; (2) the AKR/J-derived Y chromosome must be present; and (3) an additional locus involved in primary sex determination must be present in a homozygous C57BL/6J state. This newly identified gene may be one of the previously defined loci, tda-1 or tda-2.     

A DNA polymorphism from five inbred strains of the mouse identifies a functional class of domesticus-type Y chromosome that produces the same phenotypic distribution of gonadal hermaphrodites

The wild-derived CLA inbred strain of the house mouse contains a domesticus-type Y chromosome that lacks a 2.3-kb TaqI band with fragment 1 of the AC11 probe. The CLA Y chromosome also causes a low frequency of XY gonadal hermaphrodites when backcrossed to the C57BL/6J strain (F. G. Biddle and Y. Nishioka, 1988. Genome, 30:870-878). A similar domesticus-type Y chromosome, lacking the 2.3-kb TaqI band has now been found in the four historical inbred strains AKR/J, MA/MyJ, PL/J, and RF/J. When backcrossed to C57BL/6J, these four Y chromosomes cause low frequencies of gonadal hermaphrodites similar to the CLA Y and phenotypic distribution of types of gonad are indistinguishable from that with the CLA Y. The absence of the 2.3-kb TaqI band appears to be a polymorphism among domesticus-type Y chromosomes that identifies one of the three functional classes that, so far, can be distinguished only by their effects on testis differentiation in backcross test fetuses with the C57BL/6J strain. Three other historical inbred strains, BUB/BnJ, ST/bJ, and SWR/J, with a domesticus-type Y chromosome but containing the 2.3-kb TaqI band, were also assayed. They permit normal testis development in backcross test fetuses with C57BL/6J.     

The Mus musculus domesticus Tdy allele acts later than the Mus musculus musculus Tdy allele: a basis for XY sex-reversal in C57BL/6-YPOS mice.

Consomic C57BL/6 males, carrying either the Mus musculus musculus-derived C57BL/6 Y chromosome or the Mus musculus domesticus-derived Poschiavinus Y chromosome, were outcrossed to females of the inbred strains C3H/Bi and CXBH/By and to females of the random bred strain MF1/Ola. In a study at 12.5 days post coitum, gonads of XYC57 and XYPOS fetuses were assessed for the presence of testicular cords. It was found that XYPOS fetuses had a later onset of testicular development than XYC57 fetuses. Limb development, which was monitored as a measure of overall development, was unaffected by the strain of Y present. These data were supported by a longitudinal study in which the increased growth rate of the testes relative to undifferentiated gonads, was also shown to be delayed in XYPOS fetuses. The extent of the delay was estimated to be approximately 14 h. It is concluded that this delay in the onset of testicular differentiation must be caused by differences between the two Y-chromosome types, most probably allelic differences in the testis determinant Tdy.     

The chromosome 11 region from strain 129 provides protection from sex reversal in XYPOS mice

C57BL/6J (B6) mice containing the Mus domesticus poschiavinus Y chromosome, YPOS, develop ovarian tissue, whereas testicular tissue develops in DBA/2J or 129S1/SvImJ (129) mice containing the YPOS chromosome. To identify genes involved in sex determination, we used a congenic strain approach to determine which chromosomal regions from 129Sl/SvImJ provide protection against sex reversal in XYPOS mice of the C57BL/6J.129-YPOS strain. Genome scans using microsatellite and SNP markers identified a chromosome 11 region of 129 origin in C57BL/6J.129-YPOS mice. To determine if this region influenced testis development in XYPOS mice, two strains of C57BL/6J-YPOS mice were produced and used in genetic experiments. XYPOS adults homozygous for the 129 region had a lower incidence of sex reversal than XYPOS adults homozygous for the B6 region. In addition, many homozygous 129 XYPOS fetuses developed normal-appearing testes, an occurrence never observed in XYPOS mice of the C57BL/6J-YPOS strain. Finally, the amount of testicular tissue observed in ovotestes of heterozygous 129/B6 XYPOS fetuses was greater than the amount observed in ovotestes of homozygous B6 XYPOS fetuses. We conclude that a chromosome 11 locus derived from 129Sl/SvImJ essentially protects against sex reversal in XYPOS mice. A number of genes located in this chromosome 11 region are discussed as potential candidates.     

Fertility of Y(TIR).B6 sex-reversal females with XX orthotopic ovarian transplants

When the Y chromosome of Mus musculus domesticus (Y(TIR)) was introduced onto the C57BL/6J (B6) mouse background, testis development was impaired and half of the XY progeny (Y(TIR).B6) developed a female phenotype. Y(TIR).B6 fetal ovaries showed massive death of medullary oocytes and, after birth, produced abnormal levels of steroid hormones, exhibited irregular estrous cycles, and failed to become fertile. In this study we examined whether alterations during perinatal development observed in Y(TIR).B6 ovaries permanently impaired the establishment of the hypothalamus-pituitary-ovary axis (HPOa). B6 fetal and postnatal ovaries at different stages (fetal, infantile, or adult) were transplanted orthotopically (to the ovarian bursa) to either ovariectomized B6 normal females or Y(TIR).B6 sex-reversal females. Percentage of pregnancy, litter size, and capacity to feed pups were recorded. Reciprocally, XY(TIR).B6 ovaries were orthotopically transplanted into B6 females. After crossing with fertile males, several Y(TIR).B6 sex-reversal females with B6 ovarian transplants at all ages became pregnant, had offspring, and fed their pups. On the other hand, none of the B6 female hosts with XY(TIR) ovaries became pregnant. Results demonstrated that Y(TIR).B6 sex-reversal females maintain a functional HPOa and that their failure to reproduce is primarily due to an ovarian defect.     

Evidence that the testis determination pathway interacts with a non-dosage compensated, X-linked gene.

In a number of mammals, including mouse and man, it has been shown that at equivalent gestational ages, males are developmentally more advanced than females, even before the gonads form. In mice, although some strains of Y chromosome exert a minor accelerating effect in pre-implantation development, it is a post-implantation effect of the difference in X chromosome constitution that is the major cause of the male/female developmental difference. Thus XX females are retarded in their development by about 1.5 h relative to X(M)O females or XY males; however, they are more advanced than X(P)O females by about 4 h. It has been suggested that this early developmental difference between XX and XY embryos may "weight the dice" in favour of ovarian and testicular development, respectively, although expression of Sry will normally overcome any such bias. Here we test this proposal by comparing the relative frequencies of female, hermaphrodite and male development in X(P)O, XX and X(M)O mice that carry an incompletely penetrant Sry transgene. The results show that testicular tissue develops more frequently in XX,Sry transgenics than in either of the two types of XO transgenics. Thus the incidence of testicular development is affected by X dosage rather than by the developmental hierarchy. This implies there is a non-dosage compensated gene (or genes) on the X chromosome, which interacts with the testis-determining pathway. Since the pseudoautosomal region (PAR) is known to escape X-inactivation, penetrance of the Sry transgene was also assessed in X(M)Y(*X) mice that have two doses of the PAR but have a single dose of all genes proximal to the distal X marker Amel. These mice showed similar levels of testicular development to X(M)O mice with the transgene; thus the non-dosage compensated X gene maps outside the PAR.     

Autosomal genes involved in mammalian primary sex determination

Beginning with findings made during the late 1950s and early 1960s, evidence continues to accumulate in support of the hypothesis that the mammalian Y chromosome carries a gene that induces the undifferentiated foetal gonad in XY individuals to develop as a testis. Recently a DNA sequence has been isolated from the human Y chromosome that appears to be the hypothesized Y-linked testis-determining gene, and advances have also been made toward identifying genes that interact with the Y-linked testis-determining (Tdy) gene to initiate testis formation. These loci have been identified in specific stocks of mice carrying the mutant Thp or TOrl allele at the T locus located on chromosome 17, and in crosses involving the transfer of a Y chromosome from two populations of Mus domesticus into the genomes of specific inbred strains of mice. The data in both cases support the hypothesis that there are several loci involved in testis determination and that abnormal interaction of these loci disrupts initiation of testis determination, resulting in development of ovarian tissue in XY individuals.     

Familial case with sequence variant in the testis-determining region associated with two sex phenotypes.

The human Y chromosome encodes a testis-determining factor (TDF) which is responsible for initiating male sex determination. Recently a region of the Y chromosome (SRY) was identified as part of the TDF gene. We have identified a three-generation family (N) in which all XY individuals have a single base-pair substitution resulting in a conservative amino acid change in the conserved domain of the SRY open reading frame. Three individuals are XY sex-reversed females, and two are XY males. Several models are proposed to explain association between a sequence variant in SRY and two sex phenotypes.     

A genomic clone of Zfy-1 from a YDOM mouse strain detects post-meiotic gene expression of Zfy in testes

In order to obtain a genomic clone of Zfy-1 from a Y chromosome of Mus musculus domesticus (YDOM) origin, we cloned size-fractionated SJL/J DNA in EMBL-4 and selected colonies which hybridized to pDP1007, a human zinc finger Y clone. The specificity of the clone in hybridizations to mouse and human DNA and partial sequencing confirmed that the clone (subcloned as pGZfy1D) was of Zfy-1 origin. Studies on the expression during testicular development of mRNAs hybridizing to the clone suggested that the gene is expressed post-meiotically.