A comparison of serum-free media for the support of in vitro mitogen-induced blastogenic expansion of cytolytic lymphocytes

The high cost and potential dangers of including human AB serum in incubation media used to expand lymphocyte populations in vitro for adoptive immunotherapy have stimulated efforts to develop defined media which can support both the expansion and induction of lymphocytes with tumor cytolytic activity in the absence of serum. Lymphocyte proliferation following exposure to either PHA or the combination of phorbol 12,13-dibutyrate (PDBu) and the calcium ionophore, ionomycin, was evaluated. Although the media tested, X-Vivo 10, HB-104, AIM V, and HL-1, supported the generation of comparable levels of LAK activity after 3–5 days incubation with 10³ U human recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2)/ml, there were striking differences in the ability of each medium to support mitogenically stimulated lymphocytes in the absence of serum, with cells in AIM V and X-Vivo 10 showing the highest levels of DNA synthesis. In long-term cultures (17 days) of blood MNC stimulated by PDBu and ionomycin, X-Vivo 10 and HB-104 yielded the greatest numbers of cells. The addition of 2% AB serum greatly enhanced the ability of each medium to support cell proliferation to equivalent maximum levels. The results indicate that while all four serum-free media were suitable for lymphocyte culture and support the development of LAK activity, they differ in their capacity to support expansion of lymphocyte populations in response to polyclonal mitogenic activation. This latter characteristic should be considered before choosing a particular serum-free formulation as its constituents may affect mechanistic interpretations regarding signal transduction events.     

Direct mitogenic effects of human somatomedin on human embryonic lung fibroblasts

The ability of purified basic somatomedin to reinitiate cell division in nondividing cultures of human embryonic lung fibroblasts (WI-38) maintained in serum-free medium was determined in order to assess the direct mitogenic effect of this substance on mammalian tissue. Resting cultures were prepared by incubation of the cells in serum-free medium for 48–72 hours. Addition of partially purified somatomedin resulted in cellular hypertrophy, DNA synthesis and cell division with a time course similar to that seen when serum was added. Although cells divided in response to physiological concentrations of somatomedin, doses up to 100x in excess of this did not produce as much cell division as 10% fetal calf serum. Addition of fresh medium containing somatomedin to cells previously stimulated by somatomedin failed to induce further cell division. A highly purified somatomedin preparation also stimulated cell division.     

Effect of exogenous gangliosides on human neural cell division

Human neural cells in exponential growth phase were transferred to a serum-free medium and maintained for 72 hr without any detectable loss in viability. The two normal fetal cell lines (CH_I and CH_II) showed a serum-dependent cell proliferation, but the glioblastoma multiforme cells (12–18) were able to continue proliferating in this totally synthetic medium. The incorporation of [³H] thymidine into the acid-precipitable fraction of both normal and neoplastic human neural cells was assayed in the presence and the absence of exogenous gangliosides by a convenient new method. In serum-free medium, gangliosides (50 μM) inhibited the thymidine incorporation into the normal fetal cells within 24 hr and, in serum containing medium, reduced their proliferation within 48 hr. No such effects were detectable in the glioma cells. The inhibition of thymidine incorporation in the normal cells was reversible upon removal of the gangliosides. These results indicate a role of gangliosides in the postmitotic phase of normal human neural cells resulting in the regulation of cell proliferation.     

Effect of human plasmalipoproteins on erythropoietic progenitor cells in serum-free cultures

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the influence of human lipoproteins on CFU-e and BFU-e proliferation from human bone marrow in a serum-free system. In our previously described miniaturized agar system the main lipoprotein-density-classes from human plasma, namely very low density lipoproteins (VLDL), intermediate density lipoproteins (IDL), low density lipoproteins (LDL), high density lipoproteins2 (HDL2) and HDL3 and a mixture of all the five lipoproteins were added in rising concentrations (from 1/10 to normal human plasma concentration) to serum-free medium containing delipidated and deionized bovine serum albumin (BSA), iron saturated transferrin and erythropoietin. The results demonstrate that all lipoproteins markedly increased the CFU-e and BFU-e proliferation after 7 and 14 days of incubation, respectively. Moreover, the lipoproteins induced a shift towards a lower threshold concentration of erythropoietin. Serumlike conditions were obtained if LDL and the mixture of lipoproteins were added to serum-free medium. Furthermore, in the serum-free cultures a maturation to the mature erythrocyte could be found.     

Effect of fetal and adult bovine albumins on human lymphocyte proliferation in vitro

Fetal and adult bovine albumins were isolated and compared with the commercially obtained fraction V of Cohn, in terms of their ability to support cell proliferation, when added as a supplement to serum-free lymphocyte cultures activated with phytohemagglutinin. It was found that fetal albumin is the least efficient of the three proteins in permitting lymphoproliferation. A difference between the kinetics of proliferation of lymphocyte cultures supplemented with albumin and with serum was also observed.     

Embryonic bone matrix formation is increased after exposure to a low-amplitude capacitively coupled electric field, in vitro

In order to investigate the mechanism(s) of electric field-stimulated osteogenesis, we have developed an in vitro model in which embryonic chick tibiae have consistently demonstrated increased bone matrix formation in response to a low amplitude (estimated 10(-5) V/m in the serum-free culture medium), capacitively coupled, 10 Hz sinusoidal electric field. Initial applications of this model revealed that 72 h of continuous exposure to the electric field increased tibial collagen production by 29% compared to untreated controls, P less than 0.01. Additional studies further revealed: (a) that when electric field exposure was limited to 30 min/day during the 72 h in vitro incubation, embryonic bone matrix formation was increased by 83%, compared to non-treated controls (P less than 0.001), suggesting an inductive mechanism; (b) that the osteogenic response to electric field exposure in vitro was not unique to embryonic chick tibiae, since a similar response was also seen with newborn mouse calvaria (+133%, P less than 0.02); (c) that electric field-exposure-stimulated chick bone matrix formation was associated with increased bone cell proliferation; and (d) that this mitogenic response to in vitro electric field exposure could also be observed with embryonic chick calvarial cells in monolayer, serum-free cultures.     

Paradoxical production of mouse thymocyte activating factor by ouabain-treated human mononuclear cells

At concentrations as low as 10(-7) M, the cardiotonic glycosteroid ouabain, a specific inhibitor of the membrane Na+, K+-ATPase, is known to inhibit in vitro human lymphocyte proliferation produced in mixed lymphocyte cultures or induced by various stimulating agents (PHA, Con A, PWM, soluble antigens), while mouse lymphocyte proliferation is unaffected at this concentration. Ouabain inhibits most of proliferative response parameters at all stages of the transformation. This observation prompted us to suggest that ouabain could also act through inhibition of interleukin production which is known to occur during the first hours after T-cell stimulation in the presence of monocytes. In order to check the possible influence of ouabain on interleukin production, conditioned media from stimulated human mononuclear cells, prepared in the presence or in the absence of inhibitor, were tested for their ability to promote a mouse thymocyte response to PHA. Instead of the expected inhibition, we found that ouabain, even at high concentrations (2 X 10(-6) M) enhanced the stimulatory effect and/or the production of murine thymocyte activating factor(s). Moreover conditioned media from serum-free cultures of unstimulated human mononuclear cells exposed for 24 hr to low ouabain concentrations (10(-8) to 10(-7) M) showed a high activating effect on the response of murine thymocytes to PHA. This soluble factor produced upon ouabain treatment is produced by adherent cells and appears to be functionally similar to interleukin 1.     

Primary culture in chemically defined medium of human fetal mammary epithelial cells within reconstituted matrix]

A serum-free primary culture system has been developed which allows for three-dimensional growth and differentiation of normal human fetal mammary epithelial cells within an extracellular matrix preparation. Human fetal mammary epithelial cells were isolated from the mammary glands of human female fetuses, 17 to 39 weeks-old. The "organoids" were embedded within a reconstituted basement membrane matrix prepared from the Engelbreth-Holm-Swarm (EHS) sarcoma according to the method of Hahm and Ip. "Organoids" were grown in either serum-free medium or in medium with fetal calf serum (FCS). The "organoid" proliferated over a 2 to 3 weeks culture period and remained viable for 1 or 2 months within the basement membrane matrix in serum free medium. Several types of colonies were observed; including alveolar-like budding clusters obtained from cultures of mammary gland from fetuses of over 20 weeks age, units with ductule-like projections and stellate-type colonies. Cell proliferation was dependent on the culture medium (with FCS no proliferation was obtained) and on the substratum (without matrix, significantly less growth and development occurred). These types of colonies are obtained when a glandular differentiation of cells budding from the malpighian epithelium is observed. Light microscopic and transmission electron microscopic studies were undertaken at the time of culture. This unique system using normal fetal mammary epithelial cells thus provides a model in which the regulation of human mammary development can be investigated.     

Intracellular protein degradation in serum-deprived human fibroblasts.

IMR90 human fibroblasts were labelled by incubation of cells for 48 h in medium containing 10% serum and [3H]leucine. The labelled protein was degraded at a rate of 1%/h during a subsequent incubation in medium with 10% serum. Incubation in medium without serum caused a transient enhancement of the degradation of endogenous protein, which was also found in cells labelled in medium without serum. The degradation of micro-injected haemoglobin was enhanced by serum deprivation in a non-transient manner. These results suggest that enhanced degradation in serum-free medium occurs only for a subpopulation of cell proteins and that it appears transient because the major part of the pool of susceptible endogenous proteins is being degraded during the first 20-30 h in serum-free unlabelled medium. Protein turnover in various cell compartments was measured by a double-labelling technique. Most of the enhanced degradation in serum-deprived cultures (73-83%) was due to breakdown of cytosolic proteins. The enhanced degradation of cytosolic proteins seemed to affect several proteins irrespective of their molecular mass or metabolic stability.     

Depression of lymphocyte reactivity to phytohemagglutinin by serum from patients with liver disease

The influence of serum from patients with a variety of liver abnormalities on the in vitro response of normal human peripheral blood lymphocytes to stimulation with phytohemagglutinin was studied. These experiments demonstrate that serum from patients with acute viral hepatitis, chronic Australia antigenemia, common bile duct obstruction, primary biliary cirrhosis, hepatic necrosis secondary to halothane, and alcoholic cirrhosis suppresses DNA synthesis by stimulated normal lymphocytes. Sera obtained from two patients 1 week after surgical correction of their common duct obstruction no longer demonstrated lymphocyte suppression. Dilution of normal serum with serum from either of three patients resulted in more rapid decrease of thymidine uptake by stimulated lymphocytes than when normal serum was diluted with culture medium. This indicates the presence of an inhibitory factor (s) in the patients' sera. No correlation was shown between the extent of thymidine uptake by stimulated lymphocytes and the bilirubin, transaminase, or alkaline phosphatase levels in the serum in which they were cultured. The addition of bile salts to stimulated lymphocyte cultures did result in suppression of the response but only at concentrations much higher than would be expected in serum of the patients studied. Cell death after 72-hr incubation was 42% in normal serum and only 50% in serum from a patient who had demonstrated prominent suppression of DNA synthesis.     

Human glioma cell culture: two FCS-free media could be recommended for clinical use in immunotherapy

Immunotherapy, particularly active vaccination, may be developed as an effective and safe treatment modality for malignant gliomas, which continue to have a poor prognosis, despite advances in surgical techniques and adjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Since no glioma-specific tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) have been discovered, autologous tumor cells or well-established glioma cell lines could be used in future vaccination protocols to induce antitumour immunity against unknown TAAs. One obstacle for clinical use of these tumour cell vaccines is related to foetal calf serum (FCS). Efforts are currently being directed toward developing FCS-free media and serum-free alternatives to culture these cell vaccines. In this study, a medium containing human serum and one serum-free medium (UltraCulture), supplemented or not with epidermal growth factor, were tested on morphology, survival, DNA content and TAA expression of human glioma cell lines and glioma biopsy primary cultures. Their effects were compared on FCS-containing medium. Results show that, whatever the medium used, no significant variations in morphology and survival were observed. Furthermore, human serum-containing medium or UltraCulture preserved at early passage cultures the cell population of interest present in the biopsies before culture. In addition, the expression profile of eight TAAs was similar between these media. These data indicate that human serum-containing medium and UltraCulture serum-free medium could be promising candidates to produce tumour-cell vaccines.     

Serum suppresses the expression of hormonally induced functions in cultured granulosa cells

Growth and function of primary cultures of granulosa cells obtained from immature, hypophysectomized, estrogen-treated rats were compared in serum-containing and serum-free media. In serum-free medium (1:1 mixture of DMEM:F-12) supplemented with insulin, hydrocortisone, transferrin and fibronectin (4F medium), the cells remained healthy and steroidogenically responsive for at least 60 days in culture. The growth profile of the granulosa cells in 4F medium was similar to that obtained in serum-containing medium. In both media cell proliferation did not exceed more than one cell doubling. DMEM:F-12 alone did not support the cell viability. Upon FSH stimulation, the cells produced 25 fold more progestin and estrogen per cell in 4F medium than in medium supplemented with 5% serum. This effect was not directly related to serum proteins which mediate cell adhesion since cells cultured in dishes precoated with serum remained steroidogenically responsive to FSH. Cholera toxin and Bt₂-cAMP readily stimulated progestin production in the presence of serum. The inhibitory effect of serum was not reversed by adding the four factors to serum-containing medium. The factors were essential for the FSH-induced steroidogenesis in serum-free medium. After four days of incubation in 4F medium, the cells showed a transient loss of their ability to produce progestin in response to FSH. In both 4F medium as well as in serum-containing medium, the cells regained their hormonal responsiveness after 35 days in culture. Since the loss of hormonal responsiveness occurred at the same time as growth was initiated in the cultures, it is suggested that the FSH-induced steroidogenesis is negatively controlled by growth-related processes.     

Regulation of B-lymphocyte production in the bone marrow: role of macrophages and the spleen in mediating responses to exogenous agents

B-Lymphocyte production in mouse bone marrow can be stimulated by administering a variety of foreign materials in vivo. The nature and location of cells mediating this effect have now been studied, using assays of lymphocyte renewal and pre-B-cell proliferation. Pretreatment of mice with silica, to depress macrophage function, abolished the stimulation of small lymphocyte renewal produced by administering either sheep red blood cells (SRBC) or mineral oil and reduced the response to bovine serum albumin. The response was still abolished when silica was given 6 or 24 hr, but not 48 hr, after SRBC. Splenectomy prevented the stimulation of marrow lymphocyte renewal when performed either 4 weeks before or up to 72 hr after SRBC injection. The stimulation of pre-B-cell proliferation was similarly prevented by pretreatment with either silica or splenectomy. The results indicate that the wave of increased B-lymphocyte production after SRBC injection depends for the first 2-3 days upon silica-sensitive, spleen-dependent mechanisms, suggesting an early mediation by splenic macrophages. Primary B-lymphocyte production in vivo may thus normally be stimulated by exposure to external environmental agents acting indirectly on bone marrow B-cell progenitors via cellular reactions in peripheral lymphoid tissues.     

Anchorage-independent colony formation of SV40 transformed BALB/c-3T3 cells in serum-free medium: role of cell- and serum-derived factors

The colony-forming response of SV40 transformed BALB/c-3T3 cells in agarose suspension culture was studied in a serum-free medium (with insulin, transferrin and serum albumin as the only macromolecular supplements) that was optimized for colony formation of fibronectin-attached monolayer cultures. In this serum-free medium, the SV3T3 cells fail to form colonies in agarose suspension. However, they can be induced to anchorage-independent colony formation by the growth factors that are additionally required by their untransformed counterparts for proliferation in monolayer culture. The SV3T3 cells are also rendered anchorage-independent for colony formation in serum-free medium by conditioned medium from dense monolayer serum-free SV3T3 cultures. These experiments suggest that it is the cell-substrate interaction that is responsible for the growth factor autonomy of fibronectin-attached transformed cells.     

Growth requirements and long-term subcultivation of bovine granulosa cells cultured in a serum-free medium

Summary We have developed an improved serum-free medium to optimize the cell growth of bovine granulosa cells. The cells on collagen-coated culture plates proliferated extensively in a nutrient medium supplemented with insulin, heparin binding growth factor-2 (HBGF-2), lipoprotein, and bovine serum albumin (BSA). The cell doubling time at logarithmic phase and final cell density at confluent cultures were equal to those of cultures grown in the presence of medium supplemented with optimal concentration (10%) of fetal bovine serum (FBS). Whereas HBGF-2 or insulin alone had a small mitogenic effect of granulosa cells, lipoprotein or BSA did not. When lipoprotein, BSA, or insulin was added together with HBGF-2, synergistic cell proliferation was observed in all combinations. Insulin or lipoprotein had an additive mitogenic stimulation of these cells in the presence of BSA. After granulosa cells were subcultivated in a serum-containing medium until three generations [8.5 cumulative population doubling level (CPDL)], subsequent subcultivation of the cells in a complete serum-free medium could be achieved up to six generations (14.4 CPDL). These results demonstrate that this serum-free medium can support the optimal cell growth and long-term subcultivation of bovine granulosa cells.     

Increased glucocorticoid responsiveness of CD4+ T-cell clonal lines grown in serum-free media

Summary CEM-C7, a human leukemic CD4+ T-lymphocyte cell line and three of its subclones, CEM-4R4, CEM-3R43, and ICR-27, previously cultured in a medium supplemented with 5 to 10% fetal bovine serum, have been adapted to serum-free media. The best medium of those tested was RPMI 1640 supplemented with 5 μg/ml each transferrin and insulin + 5 ng/ml sodium selinite ± 0.1% bovine serum albumin. While growing either with or without albumin, the several clonal lines of CEM cells displayed growth similar to serum-supplemented cultures. Cell proliferation of CEM-C7 cells cultured in both serum-free media has been sustained for 3 mo, with culture doubling times of about 25 h for both serum-supplemented and serum-free cultures (viability ≥ 90%). Cell morphology remained essentially the same in serum-free or serum containing media. The expression of CD4, a marker for T-derived lymphoid cells, was not significantly different in serum-free medium. When grown in serum-free medium, CEM-C7 cells exhibited increased steroid responsiveness as evidenced by increased glucocorticoid receptor binding sites, increased induction of glutamine synthetase, and cell lysis at lower concentrations of steroid. Receptor mutant subclones of CEM-C7, which are proven to be completely unresponsive to micromolar concentrations of dexamethasone when grown in serum-supplemented medium, become partially sensitive to the hormone after growth in defined medium. The increased sensitivity of CEM-C7 cells and its subclones to dexamethasone in serum-free medium returned to previous levels when these cells were recultured in serum-containing medium. Our results suggest that substances in serum influence steroid effects on these cells and that the molecular details of glucocorticoid hormone action may be pursued more precisely in a clearly defined culture medium. This work was conducted in conjunction with the Walls Medical Research Foundation.     

Effects of neuraminidase on DNA synthesis, proliferation and endocytosis of cultivated arterial smooth muscle cells

Growth-arrested cultures of rat arterial smooth muscle cells were treated with neuraminidase in order to study the role of sialic acid-containing cell surface components in the control of cell proliferation. The enzyme markedly reduced the number of anionic sites on the plasma membrane, as demonstrated electron microscopically. A distinct stimulatory effect on DNA synthesis was observed in confluent cultures and in serum-free medium, as well as in medium supplemented with 10% plasma-derived serum or 10% whole blood serum. In the last-mentioned cultures, which showed a high basal mitotic rate, the enzyme further produced a distinct increase in cell number. A possible explanation to these results is that removal of sialic acid increases the availability and affinity of cell surface receptors for serum growth factors. The stimulatory effect observed in serum-free medium indicates that a more direct effect also exists. It could be due to a change in plasma membrane permeability and ion concentrations in the microenvironment of the cells. Neuraminidase was further shown to have a weak inhibitory effect on cellular uptake of horse-radish peroxidase, a soluble protein that is ingested without prior adsorption to the cell surface. This finding suggests that no strict coupling exists between cell proliferation and fluid-phase endocytosis.     

Human lymphocyte-eosinophil interactions. I. Modulation of phytohemagglutinin-induced lymphocyte proliferation by eosinophils

Do eosinophils modulate lymphocyte function? This question was studied by examining the effect of purified eosinophils (eos) on lectin-induced human lymphocyte proliferation. Intact resting or zymosan-stimulated eos or their extracts were cocultured with phytohemagglutinin-stimulated mononuclear cells in vitro and [3H]thymidine uptake was measured at 72 hr. Zymosan-stimulated eos consistently suppressed (up to 90%) the lectin-induced proliferative response by a noncytotoxic mechanism. Freeze-thaw extracts from zymosan-stimulated eos also significantly suppressed lymphocyte proliferation to a similar degree. The amount of suppression was directly proportional to the number of eos or the amount of extract added to the lymphocyte cultures. Intact resting eos and their extracts occasionally exhibited suppressive effects (up to 40%) on lymphocyte proliferation; this suppression, however, was always less than that of activated eos or their extracts. Eos pretreated with the protein synthesis inhibitor, pactamycin, exhibited significantly less suppressive activity, suggesting that a protein was responsible in part for the reduction in proliferation. The addition of superoxide dismutase or catalase to the eos-mononuclear cell cocultures did not reduce the amount of suppression observed, thus making it unlikely that active oxygen products were involved in the mechanism of suppression. Heating extracts from stimulated eos to 80 degrees C for 30 min resulted in partial loss of suppressive activity while extensive dialysis of the extracts had no effect. The studies reported here provide evidence that a nondialyzable and heat sensitive factor(s) produced by stimulated eos may exert feedback inhibition of lymphocyte function.     

Human vascular smooth muscle cells in culture: growth characteristics and protein pattern by use of serum-free media supplements

This study demonstrates that cultivation of vascular smooth muscle cells from human artery wall is possible under completely serum-free conditions. The effects of attachment factors on cell spreading and cell proliferation are described in detail as well as routine cultivation methods under serum-free conditions (clone cultures, cell migration, subcultivation by use of an exogenous trypsin inhibitor, cryopreservation and readaptation of cells). After a careful adaptation period, only two (BMS and Ultroser G) of the four commercially available serum-free media supplements tested were used successfully for a routine cultivation of the smooth muscle cells over several passages. With both supplements cell proliferation rates were comparable with those obtained in medium containing 10% fetal calf serum. The addition of platelet-derived growth factor or transferrin to serum-free cultures had no growth-stimulating effect. The addition of endothelial cell growth factor isolated from bovine brain caused a significant increase in proliferative activity of cells cultivated with BMS, but not with Ultroser G. Moreover, we report that under the serum-free culture conditions described here, the gamma-actin content of the cells is largely reduced (51% +/- 13% (means +/- SD) for cells cultivated in Ultroser G, and 12% +/- 4% (means +/- SD) for cells cultivated in BMS) when compared with cells cultivated under serum-containing conditions (gamma-actin content = 100%). The alpha-actin content was observed to be unaltered. Even after a careful readaptation of serum-free cultured cells to serum conditions, the gamma-actin content remained reduced.     

A decrease in sister chromatid exchange frequency during the prolonged cultivation of human lymphocytes

Sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency at different times of fixation was studied in human lymphocyte cultures obtained from 6 donors. No differences were found in the SCE frequency between human lymphocyte cultures fixed at 72 and 96 hours of incubation (10.61 +/- 0.85 and 10.15 +/- 0.81 SCE per cell, respectively). However, a decreased SCE frequency (8.11 +/- 0.36 SCE per cell) was observed in cultures fixed at 120 hours of incubation. For a more detailed studies, one lymphocyte culture was fixed at different times of incubation (from 56 to 128 hours, at each a 8 hours). A slight increase in SCE frequencies was found at the interval between 56 and 88 hours of incubation, while starting from 104 hours of incubation a marked decrease in the SCE frequency was observed. Time-dependent changes in the SCE frequency may be described by the equation y = -1.8614 + 0.3922x - (2.5183 x 10(-3))x2, where y is the number of SCEs per cell, and x--the duration of culture incubation in hours. The observed phenomenon may be associated with changes in proportion of T and B lymphocytes, or with heterochromatization of chromosomes during a prolonged cultivation, or with an early in vitro stimulation of the in vivo long-lived lymphocytes that may be more damaged than the in vivo short-lived and the in vitro late-stimulating ones.