Efficient ligation of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme from Schistosoma mansoni is the best characterized of the natural hammerhead ribozymes. Biophysical, biochemical, and structural studies have shown that the formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction between stems I and II alters the global folding, cleavage kinetics, and conformation of the catalytic core of this hammerhead, leading to a ribozyme that is readily cleaved under physiological conditions. This study investigates the ligation kinetics and the internal equilibrium between cleavage and ligation for the Schistosoma hammerhead. Single turnover kinetic studies on a construct where the ribozyme cleaves and ligates substrate(s) in trans showed up to 23% ligation when starting from fully cleaved products. This was achieved by an approximately 2000-fold increase in the rate of ligation compared to a minimal hammerhead without the loop-loop tertiary interaction, yielding an internal equilibrium that ranges from 2 to 3 at physiological Mg2+ ion concentrations (0.1-1 mM). Thus, the natural Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme is almost as efficient at ligation as it is at cleavage. The results here are consistent with a model where formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction leads to a higher population of catalytically active molecules and where formation of this tertiary interaction has a much larger effect on the ligation than the cleavage activity of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme.     

A covalent crosslink converts the hammerhead ribozyme from a ribonuclease to an RNA ligase

The hammerhead ribozyme is a more efficient ribonuclease than an RNA ligase. Under typical reaction conditions, the rate of RNA chain cleavage is approximately 100-fold faster than the rate of the reverse ligation reaction such that virtually all of the hammerhead is in its cleaved form at equilibrium. Here we show that the introduction of a crosslink away from the catalytic core of the hammerhead has little effect on the cleavage rate but dramatically increases the ligation rate, thereby making the hammerhead an efficient RNA ligase. This experiment emphasizes the role of molecular flexibility in defining the properties of a macromolecular catalyst and suggests why other small ribozymes are more efficient ligases than ribonucleases.     

The internal equilibrium of the hairpin ribozyme: temperature, ion and pH effects

The hairpin ribozyme reversibly cleaves phosphodiesters of RNA substrates to generate products with 5' hydroxyl and 2',3'-cyclic phosphate termini. We previously found that the rate constant for ligation is tenfold faster than the rate constant for cleavage under standard conditions. The hammerhead ribozyme catalyzes the same reactions but is reported to favor cleavage relative to ligation by more than 100-fold under the same conditions. To explore the basis for this difference, we examined the influence of temperature, ions and pH on the hairpin ribozyme internal equilibrium. Under the same conditions, the loss of entropy associated with ligation is less for the hairpin than for the hammerhead ribozyme, consistent with the notion that a more rigid hairpin structure undergoes a smaller decrease in dynamics upon ligation than the more flexible hammerhead structure. Increased salt and reduced temperature shift the equilibrium toward ligation while pH has little effect, suggesting that conditions that stabilize RNA structure tend to promote ligation. The hairpin ribozyme appears to take up at least one tri- or divalent cation or two monovalent cations upon ligation. The efficiency with which different cations promote ligation depends strongly on valence and, less strongly, on ionic radius or electronegativity. This pattern of cation selectivity suggests that cations promote ligation through delocalized electrostatic shielding, perhaps interacting with a region of especially high charge density in the ligated ribozyme. Changes in ionic conditions produce large but compensating changes in enthalpy and entropy for cleavage and ligation. Thus, in addition to any increase in ribozyme dynamics associated with cleavage, re-organization of associated cations contributes significantly to hairpin ribozyme thermodynamics.     

Structure and function of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme belongs to the family of small catalytic RNAs that cleave RNA substrates in a reversible reaction that generates 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. The hairpin catalytic motif was discovered in the negative strand of the tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA, where hairpin ribozyme-mediated self-cleavage and ligation reactions participate in processing RNA replication intermediates. The self-cleaving hairpin, hammerhead, hepatitis delta and Neurospora VS RNAs each adopt unique structures and exploit distinct kinetic and catalytic mechanisms despite catalyzing the same chemical reactions. Mechanistic studies of hairpin ribozyme reactions provided early evidence that, like protein enzymes, RNA enzymes are able to exploit a variety of catalytic strategies. In contrast to the hammerhead and Tetrahymena ribozyme reactions, hairpin-mediated cleavage and ligation proceed through a catalytic mechanism that does not require direct coordination of metal cations to phosphate or water oxygens. The hairpin ribozyme is a better ligase than it is a nuclease while the hammerhead reaction favors cleavage over ligation of bound products by nearly 200-fold. Recent structure-function studies have begun to yield insights into the molecular bases of these unique features of the hairpin ribozyme.     

Hammerheads derived from sTRSV show enhanced cleavage and ligation rate constants

The catalytic properties of the hammerhead ribozyme embedded in the (+) strand of the satellite tobacco ringspot viral genome are analyzed with the goal of obtaining the elemental rate constants of the cleavage (k(2)) and ligation (k(-)(2)) steps. Two different chimeras combining the sTRSV (+) hammerhead and the well-characterized hammerhead 16 were used to measure the cleavage rate constant (k(2)), the rate of approach to equilibrium (k(obs) = k(2) + k(-)(2)), and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium (k(-)(2)/k(2) + k(-)(2)). When compared to minimal hammerheads that lack the recently discovered loop I-loop II interaction, an extended format hammerhead derived from sTRSV studied here shows at least a 20-fold faster k(2) and a 1300-fold faster k(-)(2) at 10 mM MgCl(2). However, the magnesium dependence of the cleavage rate is not significantly changed. Thus, the enhanced cleavage of this hammerhead observed in vivo is due to its higher intrinsic rate and not due to its tighter binding of magnesium ions. The faster k(-)(2) of this hammerhead suggests that ligation may be used to form circular RNA genomes. This in vitro system will be valuable for experiments directed at understanding the hammerhead mechanism and the role of the loop I-loop II interaction.     

Catalytic diversity of extended hammerhead ribozymes

Chimeras of the well-characterized minimal hammerhead 16 and nine extended hammerheads derived from natural viroids and satellite RNAs were constructed with the goal of assessing whether their very different peripheral tertiary interactions modulate their catalytic properties. For each chimera, three different assays were used to determine the rate of cleavage and the fraction of full-length hammerhead at equilibrium and thereby deduce the elemental cleavage ( k 2) and ligation ( k -2) rate constants. The nine chimeras were all more active than minimal hammerheads and exhibited a very broad range of catalytic properties, with values of k 2 varying by 750-fold and k -2 by 100-fold. At least two of the hammerheads exhibited an altered dependence of k obs on magnesium concentration. Since much less catalytic diversity is observed among minimal hammerheads that lack the tertiary interactions, a possible role for the different tertiary interaction is to modulate the hammerhead cleavage properties in viroids. For example, differing hammerhead cleavage and ligation rates could affect the steady state concentrations of linear, circular, and polymeric genomes in infected cells.     

A Y form of hammerhead ribozyme trapped by photo-cross-links retains full cleavage activity.

The conformation in solution of a small bipartite I-III hammerhead ribozyme has been deduced from the photo-crosslinks formed between cleavable ribo-deoxysubstrates appropriately substituted with the probe deoxy-4-thiouridine and ribozyme residues. The ribozyme-substrate complex is able to adopt a Y-like structure with stems I and II in close proximity in the presence of 400 mM Na+ only. Indeed, a cross-link joining stem I (1.6) to loop II (AL2.4) forms in significant amount under these conditions. This cross-linked complex furthermore elicits, upon Mg2+ addition, a catalytic activity similar to that exhibited by the complexes cross-linked at the distal ends of either stem I or stem III or of the non-substituted bipartite complex. This shows that the reaction mechanism is fully compatible with a strong structural constraint between stems I and II and that sodium ions at high concentration (400 mM) are able to promote a proper folding of hammerhead ribozymes. None of the multiple cross-links formed within the ribozyme core (probe in position 16.1 or 1.1) was found catalytically active. The cross-link patterns nevertheless indicate a higher flexibility of the core in Na+ than in Mg2+. While most of the cross-links can be accommodated by the Y solution structure, some of them (16.1 to U4 and 2.1) definitely can not, suggesting that additional alternative inactive conformations exist in solution.     

Oligoribonucleotide circularization by 'template-mediated' ligation with T4 RNA ligase: synthesis of circular hammerhead ribozymes.

Circular hammerhead ribozymes were synthesized from linear oligoribonucleotides using T4 RNA ligase. Some of the precursors could not be efficiently circularized under standard conditions. For these molecules, the use of a DNA template allowed their efficient circularization. The template was designed to prevent the precursor from folding into an unsuitable structure. The template allowed circular ribozymes as small as 15 nucleotides in length to be efficiently synthesized at concentrations as high as 50 microM in the ligation reaction. The circular products retained their biological activity.     

Hammerhead cleavage of the phosphorodithioate linkage

Under standard reaction conditions, a hammerhead ribozyme with a phosphorodithioate linkage at the cleavage site cleaved to the expected products with a rate about 500-fold slower than the corresponding phosphodiester linkage. When the greater stability of the dithioate linkage to nonenzymatic nucleophilic attack is taken into account, the hammerhead is remarkably effective at cleaving the dithioate linkage considering that the R(P)-phosphoromonothioate linkage is virtually inactive. On the basis of experiments determining the Mg(2+) concentration dependence of the cleavage rate and the stimulation of cleavage by thiophilic Cd(2+) ion, the lesser catalytic rate enhancement of the dithioate linkage is primarily due to the loss of a single Mg(2+) ion bound near the cleavage site. These results are qualitatively similar to, but quantitatively different from, similar experiments examining the hammerhead cleavage properties of the R(P)-phosphoromonothioate linkage. The dithioate linkage thus promises to be a valuable alternative phosphate analogue to the monothioate linkage in studying the mechanisms of RNA catalysis.     

A re-investigation of the thio effect at the hammerhead cleavage site.

The effect of introducing a phosphorothioate at the hammerhead cleavage site was investigated using a kinetically well-characterized hammerhead. In buffers containing Mg ion, the RP-phosphorothioate isomer cleaved 2000- to 80 000-fold slower than the SPisomer or the unmodified RNA substrate. Addition of low concentrations of several thiophilic metal ions, especially Cd2+, to these reactions is sufficient to fully restore the cleavage rate of the RPsubstrate without affecting cleavage rate of the all-oxygen or SPsubstrate. Thus, a model proposing coordination of a divalent metal ion to the pro-R oxygen at the hammerhead cleavage site appears justified.     

Studies on the hammerhead RNA self-cleaving domain

Nine different hammerhead RNA self-cleaving domains consistent with the consensus secondary structure proposed by Keese and Symons (1987) were prepared and tested for cleavage. Each hammerhead was constructed from two oligoribonucleotides in two different configurations. Although cleavage was observed in all nine cases, the rates of cleavage varied by more than a thousand fold. The presence of RNA secondary structure incompatible with hammerhead formation in the individual oligos may be responsible for the large rate differences. We have also examined the degree of participation of a proposed dimer hammerhead intermediate in one case and conclude that, while such a four-stranded structure can form, it is not the preferred reaction intermediate.     

Morphing the minimal and full-length hammerhead ribozymes: implications for the cleavage mechanism

The hammerhead ribozyme is a small, intensively studied catalytic RNA, and has been used as a prototype for understanding how RNA catalysis works. In 2003, the importance of a set of tertiary contacts that appear in natural sequences of the hammerhead RNA was finally understood. The presence of these contact regions in stems I and II in 'full-length hammerhead ribozymes' is accompanied by an up to 1000-fold catalytic rate enhancement, indicating a profound structural effect upon the active site. Although the new structure resolved most of what appeared to be irreconcilable differences with mechanistic studies in solution, it did so in a way that is simultaneously reconcilable with earlier crystallographic mechanistic studies, within the limits imposed by the truncated sequence of the minimal hammerhead. Here we present an analysis of the correspondence between the full-length and minimal hammerhead crystal structures, using adiabatic morphing calculations that for the first time test the hypothesis that the minimal hammerhead structure occasionally visits the active conformation, both in solution and in the crystalline state in a sterically allowed manner, and argue that this is the simplest hypothesis that consistently explains all of the experimental observations.     

Configurationally defined phosphorothioate-containing oligoribonucleotides in the study of the mechanism of cleavage of hammerhead ribozymes.

The chemical synthesis is described of oligoribonucleotides containing a single phosphorothioate linkage of defined Rp and Sp configuration. The oligoribonucleotides were used as substrates in the study of the mechanism of cleavage of an RNA hammerhead domain having the phosphorothioate group at the cleavage site. Whereas the Rp isomer was cleaved only very slowly in the presence of magnesium ion, the rate of cleavage of the Sp isomer was only slightly reduced from that of the unmodified phosphodiester. This finding gives further evidence for the hypothesis that the magnesium ion is bound to the pro-R oxygen in the transition state of the hammerhead cleavage reaction. Also, inversion of configuration at phosphorus is confirmed for a two-stranded hammerhead.     

An extra nucleotide in the consensus catalytic core of a viroid hammerhead ribozyme: implications for the design of more efficient ribozymes.

Hammerhead ribozymes catalyze self-cleavage of oligomeric RNAs generated in replication of certain viroid and viroid-like RNAs. Previous studies have defined a catalytic core conserved in most natural hammerheads, but it is still unknown why some present deviations from the consensus. We have addressed this issue in chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid (CChMVd), whose (+) hammerhead has an extra A (A10) between the conserved A9 and the quasi-conserved G10.1. Effects of insertions at this position on hammerhead kinetics have not hitherto been examined. A10 caused a moderate decrease of the trans-cleaving rate constant with respect to the CChMVd (+) hammerhead without this residue, whereas A10-->C and A10-->G substitutions had major detrimental effects, likely because they favor catalytically inactive foldings. By contrast, A10-->U substitution induced a 3-4-fold increase of the rate constant, providing an explanation for the extra U10 present in two natural hammerheads. Because A10 also occupies a singular and indispensable position in the global CChMVd conformation, as revealed by bioassays, these results show that some hammerheads deviate from the consensus due to the involvement of certain residues in critical function(s) other than self-cleavage. Incorporation of the extra U10 into a model hammerhead also caused a similar increase in the rate constant, providing data for a deeper understanding of the hammerhead structural requirements and for designing more efficient ribozymes.     

Functional groups on the cleavage site pyrimidine nucleotide are required for stabilization of the hammerhead transition state.

The role of individual functional groups on cytidine 17 in the hammerhead ribozyme was assessed by introducing modified pyrimidines into two kinetically well-characterized hammerheads. As long as the pyrimide ring size was maintained, the modifications had no effect on substrate binding, suggesting that the C17-C3 hydrogen bond observed in the X-ray structure is energetically neutral. However, modification of the exocyclic amino group and the carbonyl of C17 reduced the cleavage rate significantly, indicating that these groups are important in stabilizing the transition-state structure. C17 modifications did not affect the ratio of the forward and reverse reaction rates. Thus, unlike that believed previously, C17 is another one of many hammerhead residues critical in maintaining its active structure.     

Surface structure of in vitro assembled bacteriophage lambda polyheads.

Interstrand cross-links induced by psoralen-plus-light are removed from the DNA of Escherichia coli, and this reaction is effected by the uvrA, uvrB, uvrC and polA (5′ → 3′ exonuclease) gene products. During cross-link removal, cellular DNA strands are cut so that, upon denaturation, the DNA dissociates into segments having an average molecular weight about equal to twice the average distance between cross-links. These strand cuts are persistent in cells, having a half-life of more than 20 minutes.The structure of cross-linked DNA undergoing repair was further investigated by use of density and radioactively labeled isotopes. These experiments demonstrate that two strand cuts are made in one DNA strand near each cross-link, one on each side of one arm of the cross-link. A mechanism is proposed for cross-link removal. The endonuclease coded for by the uvrA and B genes makes an incision on the 5′ side of one arm of a cross-link. Polymerase I (5′ → 3′ exonuclease) then makes a second cut on the 3′ side, in the same strand. This allows the strands to be separated during denaturation, but would leave the second arm of the cross-linking structure still attached to the uncut strand. The persistence of strand cuts at cross-links suggests that rejoining, dependent upon repair polymerization and ligation, is blocked by such a partially excised cross-linking residue. Initial stages of cross-link removal appear to be similar to pyrimidine dimer excision, but intermediates generated by these processes differ substantially in structure and repair must be completed by different mechanisms.     

Sequence requirements of the hammerhead RNA self-cleavage reaction.

A previously well-characterized hammerhead catalytic RNA consisting of a 24-nucleotide substrate and a 19-nucleotide ribozyme was used to perform an extensive mutagenesis study. The cleavage rates of 21 different substrate mutations and 24 different ribozyme mutations were determined. Only one of the three phylogenetically conserved base pairs but all nine of the conserved single-stranded residues in the central core are needed for self cleavage. In most cases the mutations did not alter the ability of the hammerhead to assemble into a bimolecular complex. In the few cases where mutant hammerheads did not assemble, it appeared to be the result of the mutation stabilizing an alternate substrate or ribozyme secondary structure. All combinations of mutant substrate and mutant ribozyme were less active than the corresponding single mutations, suggesting that the hammerhead contains few, if any, replaceable tertiary interactions as are found in tRNA. The refined consensus hammerhead resulting from this work was used to identify potential hammerheads present in a variety of Escherichia coli gene sequences.