Mechanisms of human minisatellite mutation in yeast

Minisatellites are tandem repeat loci, with repeat units ranging in size from 5 bp to 100 bp. The total lengths of repeat arrays vary from about 0.5 kb to 30 kb, and excessive variability in allele length at human minisatellite loci is the result of germline-specific complex recombination events generating new length alleles. Minisatellite alleles also mutate to new lengths in somatic cells, but this occurs at a much lower rate than in the germline. Since recombination is involved in minisatellite mutation, the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is a suitable model organism that has been employed to further dissect the molecular basis of mutation events at human minisatellites. These studies have shown that the mutational behaviour of a minisatellite in meiosis is not determined by the intrinsic properties of the repeat array, but are highly dependent on the position of the minisatellite in the genome. The processes for minisatellite mutation in yeast and humans are identical in the sense that mutation is indeed driven by meiotic recombination, but differ with regard to the types of structural changes that are generated by the recombination events. Tetrad analyses showed that inter-allelic transfers of repeats occur by conversion and not crossing over, and that several chromatids can be involved in successive recombination events in one meiosis, resulting in mutant alleles in several spores. It has been demonstrated that the genes SPO11 and RAD50, involved in the initiation of recombination events, are required for human minisatellite mutation in yeast meiosis. Intrinsic properties of the repeat array appear to determine the stability of human minisatellites in yeast mitosis, since mitotic mutation rates in yeast are highly variable between minisatellites. The repair genes RAD27 and DNA2 stabilise human minisatellites in yeast mitosis, while RAD5 has no effect on mitotic stability. MSH2 depresses human minisatellite frequency in meiotic cells of yeast.     

Mutations at the human minisatellite MS32 integrated in yeast occur with high frequency in meiosis and involve complex recombination events

Minisatellites are composed of tandem repetitive DNA sequences and are present at many positions in the human genome. They frequently mutate to new length alleles in the germline, by complex and incompletely understood recombination mechanisms which may operate during meiosis. In several minisatellites the mutation events are restricted to one end of the repeat array, indicating a possible association with elements that act in cis. Mutant alleles do not show exchange of flanking regions. To construct a model system suitable for further investigations of the mutation process, we have integrated the human minisatellite MS32, flanked by synthetic markers, in the vicinity of a meiotic recombination hot spot upstream of the LEU2 locus in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here we provide direct evidence for a meiotic origin of MS32 mutations. Mutation events were polarised towards both ends of the minisatellite and varied from simple duplications and deletions to complex intra- and interallelic events. Interallelic events were frequently accompanied by exchange of regions flanking the minisatellite. The results also support the notion that cis-acting elements are involved in the mutational process. The fact that MS32 mutant structures are similar in yeast and human shows that meiotic recombination plays a crucial role in both organisms and emphasises the usefulness of yeast strains harbouring minisatellites as a model system for the study of minisatellite mutation. Received: 1 March 1997 / Accepted: 16 May 1997     

Hypermutable minisatellites,a human affair?

Minisatellites are a class of highly polymorphic GC-rich tandem repeats. They include some of the most variable loci in the human genome, with mutation rates ranging from 0.5% to >20% per generation. Structurally, they consist of 10- to 100-bp intermingled variant repeats, making them ideal tools for dissecting mechanisms of instability at tandem repeats. Distinct mutation processes generate rare intra-allelic somatic events and frequent complex conversion-like germline mutations in these repeats. Furthermore, turnover of repeats at human minisatellites is controlled by intense recombinational activity in DNA flanking the repeat array. Surprisingly, whereas other mammalian genomes possess minisatellite-like sequences, hypermutable loci have not been identified that suggest human-specific turnover processes at minisatellite arrays. Attempts to transfer minisatellite germline instability to the mouse have failed. However, yeast models are now revealing valuable information regarding the mechanisms regulating instability at these tandem repeats. Finally, minisatellites and tandem repeats provide exquisitely sensitive molecular tools to detect genomic insults such as ionizing radiation exposure. Surprisingly, by a mechanism that remains elusive, there are transgenerational increases in minisatellite instability.     

Isolation and Characterization of Mouse Minisatellites

Minisatellites provide the most informative system for analyzing processes of tandem repeat turnover in humans. However, little is known about minisatellites and the mechanisms by which they mutate in other species. To this end, we have isolated and characterized 76 endogenous mouse VNTRs. Fifty-one loci have been localized on mouse chromosomes and, unlike in humans, show no clustering in proterminal regions. Sequence analysis of 25 loci revealed the majority to be authentic minisatellites with GC-rich repeat units ranging from 14 to 47 bp in length. We have further characterized 3 of the most polymorphic loci both inMus musculussubspecies and in inbred strains by using minisatellite variant repeat mapping (MVR) by PCR to gain insight into allelic diversity and turnover processes. MVR data suggest that mouse minisatellites mutate mainly by intra-allelic nonpolar events at a rate well below 10⁻³per gamete, in contrast to the high-frequency complex meiotic gene conversion-like events seen in humans. These results may indicate a fundamental difference in mechanisms of minisatellite mutation and genome turnover between mice and humans.     

Minisatellites show rare and simple intra-allelic instability in the mouse germ line

Minisatellites provide very informative systems for analyzing processes of tandem repeat DNA turnover in humans. The mouse genome also contains authentic minisatellites, but none has yet been found to show high levels of instability. Indirect evidence using minisatellite variant repeat mapping by PCR in Mus musculus subspecies suggested that mouse minisatellites mutate at a rate below 10(-3) per gamete and mainly by intra-allelic events. This is in sharp contrast to the complex interallelic mutations observed at high frequency at some human loci. To define more directly the turnover mechanisms and rates of instability at one of the most variable mouse minisatellites (MMS80), we used size-enrichment small-pool PCR (SESP-PCR) to recover de novo mutant alleles from sperm DNA from homozygous BALB/cJ mice and from strain DHA heterozygotes. The sperm mutation rate at MMS80 was extremely low, at or below 5 x 10(-6) per sperm. Comparison of progenitor and mutant allele structures showed that these rare mutants had arisen by simple and primarily, if not exclusively, intra-allelic mutation events. These results suggest a fundamental difference in turnover mechanisms at minisatellites between mice and human.     

Tetrad analysis shows that gene conversion is the major mechanism involved in mutation at the human minisatellite MS1 integrated in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Minisatellites are arrays of tandemly repeated DNA sequences which occur at thousands of locations in the human genome. They are frequently hypervariable with respect to allele length as a result of high rates of complex and incompletely understood recombination-based germline mutation events that alter the repeat copy number. MS1 is one of the most variable minisatellites so far isolated from the human genome. We have integrated MS1, flanked by synthetic markers, in the vicinity of a hot spot for meiotic double-strand breaks upstream of the LEU2 locus in chromosome III of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here we present the first tetrad analysis of mutations at a human minisatellite locus. The data showed that mutant alleles occur as single mutants in one of the spores in a tetrad, also when the mutant structure was the result of a combination of intra- and inter-allelic rearrangements. The conversional transfer of repeat units from one allele to the other was associated with flanking marker conversion which always involved the same flank of the minisatellite. The results demonstrate that conversion is the predominant mechanism by which minisatellite alleles mutate to new lengths, and also support the assumption that cis-acting elements are involved in the regulation of the mutational process in humans.     

Meiotic interallelic conversion at the human minisatellite MS32 in yeast triggers recombination in several chromatids

Tandem repetitive DNA sequences such as minisatellites include the most polymorphic loci yet identified in the human genome. The high mutation rates at many of these loci are driven by incompletely understood recombination-based mechanisms that operate in the germline. To analyse aspects of minisatellite mutation processes and general eukaryotic recombination in meiosis that cannot be studied in humans or other mammals, including crosstalk and interplay between all four chromatids, we have previously constructed a eukaryotic model system, enabling the analysis of all four products of meiosis. In this system we have integrated alleles of the human minisatellite MS32, flanked by synthetic markers, in the vicinity of a meiotic recombination hot spot in chromosome III of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In the present study, tetrad analysis showed that gene conversion is the predominant and possibly the universal pathway leading to interallelic transfer of repeats, with or without exchange of flanking regions. The data also suggest a hyper-recombinogenic state, triggered by interallelic mutation processes which generate a cascade of mutant alleles in the same meiosis. A number of tetrads contained identical mutant alleles of meiotic origin. Several tetrads could not be explained by the current models for minisatellite mutation. Accordingly, we here present a modified model based on the successive repair of multiple double-strand breaks.     

Two modes of germline instability at human minisatellite MS1 (locus D1S7): complex rearrangements and paradoxical hyperdeletion

Minisatellite MS1 (locus D1S7) is one of the most unstable minisatellites identified in humans. It is unusual in having a short repeat unit of 9 bp and in showing somatic instability in colorectal carcinomas, suggesting that mitotic replication or repair errors may contribute to repeat-DNA mutation. We have therefore used single-molecule polymerase chain reaction to characterize mutation events in sperm and somatic DNA. As with other minisatellites, high levels of instability are seen only in the germline and generate two distinct classes of structural change. The first involves large and frequently complex rearrangements that most likely arise by recombinational processes, as is seen at other minisatellites. The second pathway generates primarily, if not exclusively, single-repeat changes restricted to sequence-homogeneous regions of alleles. Their frequency is dependent on the length of uninterrupted repeats, with evidence of a hyperinstability threshold similar in length to that observed at triplet-repeat loci showing expansions driven by dynamic mutation. In contrast to triplet loci, however, the single-repeat changes at MS1 exclusively involve repeat deletion, and can be so frequent--as many as 0.7-1.3 mutation events per sperm cell for the longest homogeneous arrays--that alleles harboring these long arrays must be extremely ephemeral in human populations. The apparently impossible existence of alleles with deletion-prone uninterrupted repeats therefore presents a paradox with no obvious explanation.     

Variable germline and embryonic instability of the human minisatellite MS32 (D1S8) in transgenic mice.

Tandem repeat loci such as minisatellites and trinucleotide repeats frequently show instability. We have investigated mutation at human minisatellite MS32 (locus D1S8) transferred to transgenic mice. Three lines of hemizygous transgenic mice were studied. A single-copy line (110D) was seen to be relatively stable, whilst two multicopy lines showed structural instability of the transgene in pedigrees (lines 109 and 110A). For both these lines, mutant structures were detected as a result of mutation events having occurred in the germline or early embryo. Structural changes seen included gain or loss of minisatellite repeat units (110A and 109), alteration of DNA flanking the minisatellite repeat array (109 only) or deletion of the entire transgene (109 only). This work demonstrates that tandem repeat transgenes can show instability and thus provide additional systems for the analysis of repetitive DNA structural change in mice.     

Minisatellite variants generated in yeast meiosis involve DNA removal during gene conversion

Two yeast minisatellite alleles were cloned and inserted into a genetically defined interval in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Analysis of flanking markers in combination with sequencing allowed the determination of the meiotic events that produced minisatellites with altered lengths. Tetrad analysis revealed that gene conversions, deletions, or complex combinations of both were involved in producing minisatellite variants. Similar changes were obtained following selection for nearby gene conversions or crossovers among random spores. The largest class of events involving the minisatellite was a 3:1 segregation of parental-size alleles, a class that would have been missed in all previous studies of minisatellites. Comparison of the sequences of the parental and novel alleles revealed that DNA must have been removed from the recipient array while a newly synthesized copy of donor array sequences was inserted. The length of inserted sequences did not appear to be constrained by the length of DNA that was removed. In cases where one or both sides of the insertion could be determined, the insertion endpoints were consistent with the suggestion that the event was mediated by alignment of homologous stretches of donor/recipient DNA.     

Influences of array size and homogeneity on minisatellite mutation.

Unstable minisatellites display high frequencies of spontaneous gain and loss of repeats in the human germline. Most length changes arise through complex recombination events including intra-allelic duplications/deletions and inter-allelic transfers of repeats. Definition of the factors modulating instability requires both measurement of mutation rate and detailed analysis of mutant structures at the level of individual alleles. We have measured mutation rates in sperm for a wide range of alleles of the highly unstable human minisatellite CEB1. Instability varies by three orders of magnitude between alleles and increases steadily with the size of the tandem array. Structural analysis of mutant molecules derived from six alleles revealed that it is the rate of intra-allelic rearrangements which increases with array size and that intra-allelic duplication events tend to cluster within homogeneous segments of alleles; both phenomena resemble features of trinucleotide repeat instability. In contrast, inter-allelic transfers occur at a fairly constant rate, irrespective of array length, and show a mild polarity towards one end of the minisatellite, suggesting the possible influence of flanking DNA on these conversion-like events.     

The influence of sequence divergence between alleles of the human MS205 minisatellite incorporated into the yeast genome on length-mutation rates and lethal recombination events during meiosis

Certain minisatellites exhibit hypervariability with respect to the number of repeat units and, thus, allele length. Such polymorphism is generated by germline-specific recombinational events that occur at high frequencies and lead to the gain or loss of repeat units. In order to elucidate the molecular details of mutagenesis in minisatellites, we have integrated human minisatellites into the yeast genome in the vicinity of a hotspot for meiotic double-strand breaks (DSBs). Here, we describe the results of tetrad analyses of mutations in the human MS205 minisatellite in yeast strains heterozygous for alleles composed of 51 and 31 repeat units, as well as in a strain homozygous for the same 51 repeat unit allele. The length-mutation rate was twice as high in the heterozygous strain as in the homozygous strain, suggesting that sequence divergence between alleles enhances the generation of length mutations. In the case of heterozygotes, the frequency of length mutants resulting from inter-allelic exchange was significantly higher in tetrads with three viable spores than in tetrads with four viable spores, indicating that there is a higher probability for spore mortality in tetrads originating from meioses during which inter-allelic exchange of repeat units occurs. In an attempt to explain these findings, we propose a model for minisatellite mutation involving recombination, in which sequence divergence between alleles results in a heteroduplex containing numerous mismatches. We suggest that convergent mismatch-repair tracts in this heteroduplex give rise to a DSB that may be repaired by an additional round of recombination resulting in mutation of a third allele, or be lethal if such recombination fails. It appears probable that the formation of such additional mutants is the major explanation for the difference in meiotic length-mutation rates between the heterozygous and homozygous yeast strains, and that this phenomenon contributes to high germline length-mutation frequencies at minisatellites in humans.     

Conservation of intronic minisatellite polymorphisms in the SCK1/SHC2 gene of Hominidae

The neuronally expressed Shc adaptor homolog SCK1/SHC2 gene contains an unusually high number of minisatellites. In humans, twelve different minisatellite sequences are located in introns of SCK1/SHC2 and ten of them are highly polymorphic. Here we used primers developed for humans to screen ten intronic loci of SCK1/SHC2 in chimpanzee and gorilla, and undertook a comprehensive analysis of the genomic sequence to address the evolutionary events driving these variable repeats. All ten loci amplified in chimpanzee and gorilla contained hypervariable and low-variability minisatellites. The human polymorphic locus TR1 was monomorphic in chimpanzee and gorilla, but we detected polymorphic alleles in these apes for the human monomorphic TR7 locus. When we examined the repeat size among these hominoids, there was no consistent variation by length from humans to great apes. In spite of the inconsistent evolutionary dynamics in repeat length variation, exon 16 was highly conserved between humans and great apes. These results suggest that non-coding intronic minisatellites do not show a consistent evolutionary paradigm but evolved with different patterns among each minisatellite locus. These findings provide important insight for minisatellite conservation during hominoid evolution.     

Nucleotide sequence and genomic organization of bird minisatellites.

Two minisatellite loci from a Eurasian songbird, the willow warbler (Phylloscopus trochilus) were isolated, sequenced and used as probes to detect more than 20 related hypervariable loci. In addition, a sequence flanking one of the minisatellite loci was isolated, and used to study a VNTR locus. The bird minisatellites have a repeat unit of either 12 (AGGGAAGGGCTC) or 17 bp (GGGGACAGGGGACACCC), repeated in tandem 40-100 times per locus, and shows partial similarity to the sequence motifs of human minisatellites. These sequences are among the most variable minisatellites known, with the incidence per gamete of new length alleles estimated from family studies of warblers to about 5.6% per locus. The bird minisatellite alleles show mendelian inheritance and segregation analysis indicates that they are derived from families of sequences with members on several autosomal linkage groups. Some of the warbler core sequences cross-hybridize to hypervariable loci in other species of birds, mammals and fishes.     

Evolutionary transience of hypervariable minisatellites in man and the primates.

Using PCR, two minisatellite loci showing extreme repeat-unit copy-number variation in humans have been characterized in great apes and monkeys. In contrast to humans, minisatellite locus MS32 is monomorphic with only 3-4 diverged repeat units in great apes, Old World and New World monkeys, this organization presumably representing the relatively stable ancestral precursor state of the human hypervariable locus. Similarly, minisatellite MS1 shows extreme repeat-copy-number variability in man compared with low copy number and minimal variability in great apes. Analysis of variant repeat units shows that the 5' and 3' regions of MS1 are relatively stable in great apes and man, and that variability in man is confined to the central region of the minisatellite. In contrast to the great apes, MS1 is highly variable in Old World monkeys. These results, as well as computer simulations of minisatellite evolution based on known mutation rates, show that short minisatellites are stable within the genome, and that the degree of polymorphism at a given locus can change dramatically over a short period of evolutionary time. The ability of hypervariable minisatellites to detect highly informative loci by cross-species hybridization is therefore largely unpredictable.     

Somatic versus germline mutation processes at minisatellite CEB1 (D2S90) in humans and transgenic mice

The most variable human minisatellites show extreme germline instability dominated by complex intra-allelic rearrangements plus a lower frequency of inter-allelic transfers of repeat units. In contrast, little is known about somatic instability at such loci. We have therefore used single-molecule PCR to analyze mutation at minisatellite CEB1 (D2S90) in human blood DNA. Somatic mutants were rare and involved only relatively simple intra-allelic events, with no bias toward expansions, in sharp contrast to the complex gain-biased rearrangements seen in sperm. Somatic and germline mutation processes were further analyzed in mice transgenic for a cosmid insert containing CEB1. Mutant molecules in transgenic sperm and blood were detected but only at the low frequencies seen in human blood and arose mainly by simple duplications and deletions as seen for somatic mutations in human. These data suggest distinct pathways for germline and somatic CEB1 mutations with germline instability involving recombination-based repair of meiotic double-strand breaks and somatic mutation arising by replication slippage or mitotic recombination. The problem of transferring germline-specific features of minisatellite instability from human to mouse suggests, with other recent observations, that long-range chromatin conformation may be required for the recombination-based mode of germline instability at human minisatellites.     

Amplification of human minisatellites by the polymerase chain reaction: towards DNA fingerprinting of single cells.

Hypervariable minisatellites can be amplified from human DNA by the polymerase chain reaction, using primers from DNA flanking the minisatellite to amplify the entire block of tandem repeat units. Minisatellite alleles up to 5-10 kb long can be faithfully amplified. At least six minisatellite loci can be co-amplified from the same DNA sample and simultaneously detected to provide a reproducible and highly variable DNA fingerprint which can be obtained from nanogram quantities of human DNA. The polymerase chain reaction can also be used to analyse single target minisatellite molecules and single human cells, despite the appearance of spurious PCR products from some hypervariable loci. DNA fingerprinting at the level of one or a few cells therefore appears possible.     

Tandemly repeated transgenes of the human minisatellite MS32 (D1S8), with novel mouse gamma satellite integration.

The human hypervariable minisatellite MS32 has a well characterised internal repeat unit array and high mutation rates have been observed at this locus. Analysis of MS32 mutants has shown that male germline mutations are polarised to one end of the array and frequently involve complex gene conversion-like events, suggesting that tandem repeat instability may be modulated by cis-acting sequences flanking the locus. In order to investigate the processes affecting MS32 mutation rate and mechanism, we have created transgenic mice harbouring an MS32 allele. Here we describe the organisation of eight transgenic insertions. Analysis of these transgenic loci by MVR-PCR and structural analysis of the junctions between mouse flanking DNA and the transgenic loci has shed light on mechanisms of integration and rearrangement of the tandem repeated transgenes. Sequence analysis of the mouse DNA flanking these transgenes has shown that 5 of the 8 insertions have integrated into mouse gamma satellite repeated sequence. This suggests a non-random integration of the MS32 transgene construct into the mouse genome.