Circumnutation of rice coleoptiles: its relationships with gravitropism and absence in lazy mutants

Although circumnutation occurs widely in higher plants, its mechanism is little understood. The idea that circumnutation is based on gravitropism has long been investigated, but the reported results have been controversial. We used dark-grown coleoptiles of rice (Oryza sativa L.) to re-investigate this issue. The following results supported the existence of a close relationship between gravitropism and circumnutation: (1) circumnutation disappears on a horizontal clinostat; (2) circumnutation is interrupted by a gravitropic response and re-initiated at a definable phase after gravitropic curvature; (3) circumnutation can be re-established by submergence and a brief gravitropic stimulation in the coleoptiles that have stopped nutating in response to red light; and (4) lazy mutants show no circumnutation. In spite of these results, however, there were cases in which gravitropism and circumnutation could be separated. Firstly, the non-circumnutating lazy coleoptile showed nearly a wild-type level of gravitropic responsiveness in its upper half, although this part was an active site of both gravitropism and circumnutation in wild-type coleoptiles. Secondly, coleoptiles could nutate without overshooting the vertical when developing phototropic curvature. It is concluded that gravitropism influences, but it is not directly involved in the process of circumnutation. It is further suggested that a gravity signal, shared with gravitropism, contributes to the maintenance of circumnutation.     

Circumnutational movement in rice coleoptiles involves the gravitropic response: analysis of an agravitropic mutant and space‐grown seedlings

Plants exhibit helical growth movements known as circumnutation in growing organs. Some studies indicate that circumnutation involves the gravitropic response, but this notion is a matter of debate. Here, using the agravitropic rice mutant lazy1 and space‐grown rice seedlings, we found that circumnutation was reduced or lost during agravitropic growth in coleoptiles. Coleoptiles of wild‐type rice exhibited circumnutation in the dark, with vigorous oscillatory movements during their growth. The gravitropic responses in lazy1 coleoptiles differed depending on the growth stage, with gravitropic responses detected during early growth and agravitropism during later growth. The nutation‐like movements observed in lazy1 coleoptiles at the early stage of growth were no longer detected with the disappearance of the gravitropic response. To verify the relationship between circumnutation and gravitropic responses in rice coleoptiles, we conducted spaceflight experiments in plants under microgravity conditions on the International Space Station. Wild‐type rice seeds were germinated, and the resulting seedlings were grown under microgravity or a centrifuge‐generated 1 g environment in space. We began filming the seedlings 2 days after seed imbibition and obtained images of seedling growth every 15 min. The seed germination rate in space was 92–100% under both microgravity and 1 g conditions. LED‐synchronized flashlight photography induced an attenuation of coleoptile growth and circumnutational movement due to cumulative light exposure. Nevertheless, wild‐type rice coleoptiles still showed circumnutational oscillations under 1 g but not microgravity conditions. These results support the idea that the gravitropic response is involved in plant circumnutation.     

Effects of MAPKK inhibitor PD98059 on the gravitropism of primary roots of maize

Gravity plays a fundamental role in plant growth and development, yet the molecular details of gravitropism is not fully understood. Here, we report the effects of PD98059, a specific inhibitor of mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase kinase, on the gravitropism of primary roots of maize. Unilateral application of PD98059 to horizontal roots led to different gravitropic growth. Placing PD98059-containing agar on the upper side of the root tips accelerated gravitropic curvature, whereas placing the agar on the lower side inhibited gravitropic curvature. However, no effect was detected when asymmetric application of PD98059 to vertical roots. Global application of maize primary root with PD98059 suppressed root gravitropism. Furthermore, the effects of H₂O₂ on horizontal root gravitropism and vertical root bending were compromised by pretreatment with PD98059. These results suggest an involvement of MAP kinase pathway(s) in gravitropism of maize roots.     

A gravitropic stimulation-induced growth inhibitor, β-(isoxazolin-5-on-2yl)-alanine,is a possible mediator of negative gravitropic bending of epicotyls in etiolated <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pisum sativum</Emphasis> seedlings

Negative gravitropic bending and its possible mediator in etiolated Alaska pea seedlings were intensively studied in comparison with seedlings of an agravitropic mutant, ageotropum. When 3.5-day-old etiolated Alaska seedlings were horizontally placed, the growth suppression at the upper side of the epicotyls began 10 min after the onset of the gravitropic stimulation, whereas the growth acceleration at the lower side began at 30 min, resulting in negative gravitropic bending. In contrast, no gravitropic bending was observed in the etiolated ageotropum seedlings, for which the epicotyls show an automorphogenesis-like growth. Strenuous efforts to identify a possible mediator that induces the gravitropic bending resulted in successfully identifying β-(isoxazolin-5-on-2yl)-alanine (βIA). The unilateral application of βIA to the etiolated Alaska epicotyls substantially induced epicotyl bending toward the application site, indicating that βIA could act as a growth inhibitor. Analyses of the distribution of βIA in the upper and lower flanks of the etiolated Alaska epicotyls revealed that its content rapidly increased twice in the upper flanks compared with that in the lower ones in response to gravitropic stimulation, whereas its content in the lower flanks was almost equal to that in the vertical control. In etiolated ageotropum epicotyls, an almost equal amount of βIA was distributed in the upper and lower flanks of epicotyls. These results suggest that a gravitropic stimulation increases βIA in the upper flank, resulting in the negative gravitropic bending of epicotyls via the suppression of the growth rate at the upper side of epicotyls in the etiolated Alaska pea seedlings.     

Gravitropic response plays an important role in the nutational movements of the shoots of Pharbitis nil and Arabidopsis thaliana

The shoots of a Japanese strain of morning glory ( Pharbitis nil  ) called 'Shidare-asagao' display agravitropic and weeping growth. It has been shown that this shoot agravitropism may be due to the defective differentiation of endodermal cells that contain statoliths. Roots of the weeping morning glory show normal responsiveness to gravity and the shoots are positively phototropic. Shoots of the morning glory cultivar Violet used as a wild type exhibited distinct circumnutation with circular movements that increase as the plants grow. In weeping morning glory, however, nutation was limited to slight back and forth or side to side movements. To determine whether endodermal cells participate in circumnutation through a function that is independent of their role in gravitropism, the nutational movements of various gravitropic mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana were compared. The inflorescences of wild-type Arabidopsis showed relatively large circular movements. Inflorescences of the pgm-1 mutant, which is defective in starch synthesis, showed reduced nutation. Even more seriously affected were the sgr1-1 / scr-3 and sgr7-1 / shr-2 mutants, which are defective in endodermal cell differentiation, and the auxin-resistant axr2-1 mutant showed no significant nutational movements at all. 1- N -naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) could inhibit Violet circumnutation, supporting the notion that auxin participates in circumnutation. Thus, the gravitropic response is an essential component in plant shoot circumnutation. Endodermal cells are involved in such circumnutation possibly because of their role in inducing the gravitropic response.     

Circumnutation of rice coleoptiles: its occurrence, regulation by phytochrome, and relationship with gravitropism

It has been found that coleoptiles of dark-grown rice (Oryza sativa L.) seedlings undergo regular circumnutation in circular orbits with periods of about 180 min. Both clockwise and counter-clockwise movements were observed, but individual coleoptiles continued to rotate only in one direction. Light-grown seedlings did not show circumnutation. In fact, dark-grown seedlings were found to cease circumnutating in response to a pulse of red light (R). This light-induced inhibition of circumnutation was demonstrated to involve both a FR-inducible very-low-fluence response, solely mediated by phytochrome A, and a FR-reversible low-fluence response, mediated by phytochrome B and/or C. The R-induced inhibition of circumnutation showed temporal agreement with the R-induced inhibition of coleoptile growth, suggesting that the former results from the latter. However, about 25% of growth activity remained after R treatment, indicating that circumnutation is more specifically regulated by phytochrome. The R-treated coleoptile showed gravitropism. Investigation of the growth differential for gravitropic curvature revealed that gravitropic responsiveness was rather enhanced by R. The results suggested that gravitropism is not a cause of circumnutation. It remained probable, however, that gravity perception is a part of the mechanism of circumnutation. It is speculated that the circumnutation investigated aids the seedling shoot in growing through the soil.     

Root-gel interactions and the root waving behavior of Arabidopsis

Arabidopsis roots grown on inclined agarose gels exhibit a sinusoidal growth pattern known as root waving. While root waving has been attributed to both intrinsic factors (e.g. circumnutation) and growth responses to external signals such as gravity, the potential for physical interactions between the root and its substrate to influence the development of this complex phenotype has been generally ignored. Using a rotating stage microscope and time-lapse digital imaging, we show that (1) root tip mobility is impeded by the gel surface, (2) this impedance causes root tip deflections by amplifying curvature in the elongation zone in a way that is distinctly nontropic, and (3) root tip impedance is augmented by normal gravitropic pressure applied by the root tip against the gel surface. Thus, both lateral corrective bending near the root apex and root tip impedance could be due to different vector components of the same graviresponse. Furthermore, we speculate that coupling between root twisting and bending is a mechanical effect resulting from root tip impedance.     

Circumnutation and distribution of phytohormones in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Vigna angularis</Emphasis> epicotyls

Circumnutation is a plant growth movement in which the tips of axial organs draw a circular orbit. Although it has been studied since the nineteenth century, its mechanism and significance are still unclear. Greened adzuki bean (Vigna angularis) epicotyls exhibited a clockwise circumnutation in the top view with a constant period of 60 min under continuous white light. The bending zone of circumnutation on the epicotyls was always located in the region 1–3 cm below the tip, and its basal end was almost identical to the apical end of the region where the epicotyl had completely elongated. Therefore, epidermal cells that construct the bending zone are constantly turning over with their elongation growth. Since exogenously applied auxin transport inhibitors and indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) impaired circumnutation without any effect on the elongation rate of epicotyls, we attempted to identify the distribution pattern of endogenous auxin. Taking advantage of its large size, we separated the bending zone of epicotyls into two halves along the longitudinal axis, either convex/concave pairs in the plane of curvature of circumnutation or pre-convex/pre-concave pairs perpendicular to the plane. By liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry, we found, for the first time, that IAA and gibberellin A₁ were asymmetrically distributed in the pre-convex part in the region 1–2 cm below the tip. This region of epicotyl sections exhibited the highest responsiveness to exogenously applied hormones, and the latent period between the hormone application and the detection of a significant enhancement in elongation was 15 min. Our results suggest that circumnutation in adzuki bean epicotyls with a 60 min period is maintained by differential growth in the bending zone, which reflects the hormonal status 15 min before and which is shifting sequentially in a circumferential direction. Cortical microtubules do not seem to be involved in this regulation.     

Travelling Pattern of Acidity in the Epidermis of Tulip Leaves

Many growing leaves of tulips show subtle undulations of their surface, oriented mostly transversely to the leaf axis. The undulations move acropetally with respect to cells. The epidermal peels from the leaves with the undulations placed on agar plates containing a pH indicator dye produce band patterns of more acid and less acid zones. Similar patterns also appear when the agar-indicator is applied to the abraded leaf surface. This indicates that there is spatially variable H⁺ efflux from the epidermis into agar. No variation of the colour appears when the agar-indicator is applied to the mesophyll surface formed by peeling off the epidermis, which indicates that the pH pattern is a feature of the epidermis only. The pattern of pH bands correlates closely with the pattern of undulation; more acid bands correspond to the convex zones of the surface. The movement of the undulations also indicates that the pH pattern moves, which means that in the epidermal apoplast the pH oscillates at a particular location.     

Distribution of mechanical stress is not involved in regulating stipe gravitropism in Coprinus cinereus

Removal of large segments of the apical part of the stipe of Coprinus cinereus (extending to about half its length) affected neither the ability of the stipe to show gravitropic bending nor its ability to compensate the curvature so induced and adjust to the vertical. However, gravitropic reaction time was directly proportional to the amount of stipe removed. Application of lateral loads of up to 20 g had no adverse effects on adjustment of the stipe to the vertical and continued vertical growth. It is concluded that sensing the distribution of extracellular mass and/or mechanical stress is unlikely to be a component of the control of gravitropic bending in C. cinereus stipes.     

A major factor in gravitropism in radish hypocotyls is the suppression of growth on the upper side of hypocotyls

The changes in length on the two opposite sides of etiolated radish (Raphanus sativus) hypocotyls prior to, and following gravitropic stimulation, were measured using an infrared-imaging system. It was observed that the growth suppression on the upper side began first at least 10 min after the onset of gravitropic stimulation, and after 30 min the acceleration in growth on the lower side started. The gravitropic curvature was steadily induced from 10 min. When radish hypocotyls were switched from a vertical to horizontal position for different durations and then replaced to the vertical position, the growth suppression on the gravity-stimulated (upper) side was observed in all cases, but the acceleration in growth on the opposite (lower) side appeared only in continuously gravity-stimulated seedlings, although it occurred later than the growth suppression on the upper side. These results suggest that the suppression in growth on the upper side of the hypocotyls is a direct effect of gravitropic stimulation, but not the acceleration on the lower side. When 4-methylthio-3-butenyl isothiocyanate (4-MTBI), which has an inhibitory activity against radish hypocotyl growth, was applied on the one side of radish hypocotyls and then the 4-MTBI-applied side or opposite side was placed in a horizontal position, the former showed greater bending than the control, suggesting that the growth suppression on the upper side is enhanced and maintained with MTBI application there. In the latter case, the seedlings showed less bending than the control, suggesting a decrease in growth on the lower side with MTBI application. All the results suggest that gravitropism of radish hypocotyls may be caused by an increase in growth-inhibiting substance(s) induced with gravitropic stimulation in the upper side, inducing growth inhibition there.     

Effects of submergence on development and gravitropism in the coleoptile of Oryza sativa L.

Caryopses of rice (Oryza sativa L. cv. Sasanishiki) were germinated in air or under water. In submerged seedlings a twofold increase in coleoptile growth rate and an inhibition of root growth was observed. The amount of starch in the amyloplasts of submerged coleoptiles was substantially reduced compared to the air-grown control plants and plastids had a proplastidic character. During the rapid elongation of coleoptiles under water, the osmotic concentration of the press sap remained constant, whereas in air-grown coleoptiles a decrease was measured. Determination of curvature of gravistimulated air-grown and submerged shoots was carried out by placing the coleoptiles horizontally in air of 98% relative humidity. Air-grown coleoptiles reached a vertical orientation within 5 h after onset of gravistimulation. In coleoptiles germinated under water the first signs of consistent negative gravitropic bending occurred after 4–5 h and curvature was complete after 24 h. During the first 5 h of gravistimulation the water-grown coleoptiles grew at an average rate of 0.39 mm·h^–1, whereas in air-grown coleoptiles a rate of 0.27 mm·h^–1 was measured. Concomitant with the delayed onset of gravitropic bending of the water-grown coleoptiles, a change in plastid ultrastructure and an increase in starch content was observed. We conclude that the gravitropic responsiveness of the rice coleoptile depends on the presence of starch-filled amyloplasts.We wish to thank H.-J. Ensikat for technical assistance with the scanning electron microscopy. Supported by the Bundesminister für Forschung und Technologie and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.     

Computer-based video digitizer analysis of surface extension in maize roots

We used a video digitizer system to measure surface extension and curvature in gravistimulated primary roots of maize (Zea mays L.). Downward curvature began about 25 +/- 7 min after gravistimulation and resulted from a combination of enhanced growth along the upper surface and reduced growth along the lower surface relative to growth in vertically oriented controls. The roots curved at a rate of 1.4 +/- 0.5 degrees min-1 but the pattern of curvature varied somewhat. In about 35% of the samples the roots curved steadily downward and the rate of curvature slowed as the root neared 90 degrees. A final angle of about 90 degrees was reached 110 +/- 35 min after the start of gravistimulation. In about 65% of the samples there was a period of backward curvature (partial reversal of curvature) during the response. In some cases (about 15% of those showing a period of reverse bending) this period of backward curvature occurred before the root reached 90 degrees. Following transient backward curvature, downward curvature resumed and the root approached a final angle of about 90 degrees. In about 65% of the roots showing a period of reverse curvature, the roots curved steadily past the vertical, reaching maximum curvature about 205 +/- 65 min after gravistimulation. The direction of curvature then reversed back toward the vertical. After one or two oscillations about the vertical the roots obtained a vertical orientation and the distribution of growth within the root tip became the same as that prior to gravistimulation. The period of transient backward curvature coincided with and was evidently caused by enhancement of growth along the concave and inhibition of growth along the convex side of the curve, a pattern opposite to that prevailing in the earlier stages of downward curvature. There were periods during the gravitropic response when the normally unimodal growth-rate distribution within the elongation zone became bimodal with two peaks of rapid elongation separated by a region of reduced elongation rate. This occurred at different times on the convex and concave sides of the graviresponding root. During the period of steady downward curvature the elongation zone along the convex side extended farther toward the tip than in the vertical control. During the period of reduced rate of curvature, the zone of elongation extended farther toward the tip along the concave side of the root. The data show that the gravitropic response pattern varies with time and involves changes in localized elongation rates as well as changes in the length and position of the elongation zone. Models of root gravitropic curvature based on simple unimodal inhibition of growth along the lower side cannot account for these complex growth patterns.     

Circumnutation as a visible plant action and reaction: Physiological,cellular and molecular basis for circumnutations

Circumnutation is a helical organ movement widespread among plants. It is variable due to a different magnitude of trajectory (amplitude) outlined by the organ tip, duration of one cycle (period), circular, elliptical, pendulum-like or irregular shape and clock- and counterclockwise direction of rotation. Some of those movement parameters are regulated by circadian clock and show daily and infradian rhythms. Circumnutation is influenced by light, temperature, chemicals and can depend on organ morphology. The diversity of this phenomenon is easier to see now that the digital time-lapse video method is developing fast. Whether circumnutation is an endogenous action, a reaction to exogenous stimuli or has a combined character has been discussed for a long time. Similarly, the relationship between growth and circumnutation is still unclear. In the mechanism of circumnutation, epidermal and endodermal cells as well as plasmodesmata, plasma membrane, ions (Ca²⁺, K⁺ and Cl⁻), ion channels and the proton pump (H⁺ATPase) are engaged. Based on these data, the hypothetical electrophysiological model of the circumnutation mechanism has been proposed here. In the recent circumnutation studies, gravitropic, auxin, clock and phytochrome mutants are used and new functions of circumnutation in plants'' life have been investigated and described.Key words: circumnutation, Helianthus annuus, plant movement, elongation, growth, ultradian rhythm, circadian rhythm, time-lapse video, ion channels     

The determination of the maximal bending angle inPhycomyces sporangiophores

The maximal phototropic bending angle of thePhycomyces sporangiophore (spph) was always smaller than 90° from the vertical. Experimental results, using a clinostat apparatus and both a gravitropic mutant and the wild-type spphs placed vertically or horizontally and illuminated from different directions, revealed that this angle resulted from a balance between a negative gravitropism and a phototropism whose direction (positive or negative) and magnitude depended on the bending angle of the spph, because of the involvement of the optical properties of the spph, probably the ratio of the maximal light-fluence rate between the proximal side (I_P,max) and the distal side (I_D,max) of the spph. Shadowing of the extension zone by the sporangium was estimated to be complete only when the bending angle was larger than 86.4° from the vertical.     

Chromosaponin I specifically interacts with AUX1 protein in regulating the gravitropic response of Arabidopsis roots

We have found that chromosaponin I (CSI), a gamma-pyronyl-triterpenoid saponin isolated from pea (Pisum sativum L. cv Alaska), specifically interacts with AUX1 protein in regulating the gravitropic response of Arabidopsis roots. Application of 60 microM CSI disrupts the vertically oriented elongation of wild-type roots grown on agar plates but orients the elongation of agravitropic mutant aux1-7 roots toward the gravity. The CSI-induced restoration of gravitropic response in aux1-7 roots was not observed in other agravitropic mutants, axr2 and eir1-1. Because the aux1-7 mutant is reduced in sensitivity to auxin and ethylene, we examined the effects of CSI on another auxin-resistant mutant, axr1-3, and ethylene-insensitive mutant ein2-1. In aux1-7 roots, CSI stimulated the uptake of [(3)H]indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and induced gravitropic bending. In contrast, in wild-type, axr1-3, and ein2-1 roots, CSI slowed down the rates of gravitropic bending and inhibited IAA uptake. In the null allele of aux1, aux1-22, the agravitropic nature of the roots and IAA uptake were not affected by CSI. This close correlation between auxin uptake and gravitropic bending suggests that CSI may regulate gravitropic response by inhibiting or stimulating the uptake of endogenous auxin in root cells. CSI exhibits selective influence toward IAA versus 1-naphthaleneacetic acid as to auxin-induced inhibition in root growth and auxin uptake. The selective action of CSI toward IAA along with the complete insensitivity of the null mutant aux1-22 toward CSI strongly suggest that CSI specifically interacts with AUX1 protein.     

Chiral and non-chiral nutations in Arabidopsis roots grown on the random positioning machine

Arabidopsis thaliana roots grown on a vertically set plate do not elongate straight down the gravitational vector, but by making waves and coils, and by conspicuously slanting towards the right-hand. This behaviour, in a previous paper, was ascribed to the simultaneous effect of three processes: circumnutation, positive gravitropism and negative thigmotropism. However, when the plants are grown on the Random Positioning Machine (RPM), in conditions that are believed to simulate space microgravitational conditions closely, the roots do not show the usual pattern. In the wild type, the roots make large loops to the right-hand side, whereas in the gravitropic and auxinic mutants aux1, eir1, rha1, they just move randomly around the initial direction. Therefore, if the movements made on the RPM are those produced by the exclusion of gravitropism and negative thigmotropism, as is apparent, the conclusion is that Arabidopsis roots are animated by a form of chiral circumnutation, that is lacking in the auxinic and gravitropic mutants aux1, eir1 and rha1. In addition, the 1 g condition appears to reduce the scatter among the circumnutating tracks produced by the roots of the wild types, but not among those of the mutants. Because there is a scarcity of literature regarding circumnutation in roots, it is not known how widely root chiral circumnutation is spread, but it is known that, in some previously studied species, just random nutations are observed. Two kinds of nutating movements seem to exist in plant roots and, whereas the random process does not seem to be connected with auxin physiology and transport, the chiral process appears to be connected in the same way as gravitropism is.     

Gravitropism in caulonemata of the moss Pottia intermedia

The gravitropism of caulonemata of Pottia intermedia is described and compared with that of other mosses. Spore germination produces primary protonemata including caulonemata which give rise to buds that form the leafy moss plant, the gametophore. Primary caulonemata are negatively gravitropic but their growth and the number of filaments are limited in the dark. Axenic culture of gametophores results in the production of secondary caulonemata that usually arise near the leaf base. Secondary protonemata that form in the light are agravitropic. Secondary caulonemata that form when gametophores are placed in the dark for several days show strong negative gravitropism and grow well in the dark. When upright caulonemata are reorientated to the horizontal or are inverted, upward bending can be detected after 1 h and caulonemata reach the vertical within 1-2 d. Clear amyloplast sedimentation occurs 10-15 minutes after horizontal placement and before the start of upward curvature. This sedimentation takes place in a sub-apical zone. Amyloplast sedimentation also takes place along the length of upright and inverted Pottia protonemata. These results support the hypothesis that amyloplast sedimentation functions in gravitropic sensing since sedimentation occurs before gravitropism in Pottia and since the location and presence of a unique sedimentation zone is conserved in all four mosses known to gravitropic protonomata.     

A pleiotropic Arabidopsis thaliana mutant with inverted root chirality

Circumnutation is an oscillating movement of a growing plant organ that is believed to result from an endogenous rhythmic process intrinsic to growth. Circumnutating organs, as they extend, describe a helical trace. In Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. circumnutation is particularly evident in primary roots and occurs, as in most plants, in a right-handed direction when viewed from above in the direction of the growing tips. We have discovered a pleiotropic mutant of Arabidopsis with left-handed root circumnutation. Major abnormalities of the mutant are: (i) a reduced size of all organs, mainly due to a defect in cell elongation or expansion; (ii) a zigzagging pattern of stem pith cells, reminiscent of the “erectoides” phenotype of the lk mutant of Pisum; (iii) roots of the mutant are gravitropic but as they grow, they form tight, left-handed coils. Genetically, the mutant depends on the presence of two independent monogenic recessive factors acting additively. The mutant alleles of both factors alter the growth of the aerial organs in a similar manner but differ at the root level: one mainly produces non-circumnutating roots, the other changes the direction of circumnutation from right to left hand. Received: 18 July 1996 / Accepted: 30 November 1996