Effects of synthetic polymer on the filamentous bacteria in activated sludge

Filamentous bulking is one of the solid-liquid separation problems always seen in activated sludge process. The addition of synthetic polymer is always one of the popular ways for the treatment plant operator to immediately solve the poor sludge settling problem. Therefore, it may be interesting to understand the effects of synthetic polymer on the filamentous bacteria in activated sludge. In this study, synthetic polymer was applied to a lab-scale wastewater treatment system with the filamentous bulking problem. The population structure of filamentous bacteria and sludge characteristics were investigated under different conditions. When synthetic polymer was added into the system, it was found that poor sludge settleability caused by filamentous bulking was temporarily solved and filamentous branches growing outside the flocs were damaged or inhibited. However, filamentous growth was still observed inside the flocs. After the addition of polymer was halted, filamentous branches extended out of the flocs immediately. Very serious filamentous bulking occurred and sludge settleability became much worse than that occurring before the addition of polymer. And, it took several weeks for the system to return to normal operation.     

Relationship of species-specific filament levels to filamentous bulking in activated sludge

To examine the relationship between activated-sludge bulking and levels of specific filamentous bacteria, we developed a statistics-based quantification method for estimating the biomass levels of specific filaments using 16S rRNA-targeted fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) probes. The results of quantitative FISH for the filament Sphaerotilus natans were similar to the results of quantitative membrane hybridization in a sample from a full-scale wastewater treatment plant. Laboratory-scale reactors were operated under different flow conditions to develop bulking and nonbulking sludge and were bioaugmented with S. natans cells to stimulate bulking. Instead of S. natans, the filament Eikelboom type 1851 became dominant in the reactors. Levels of type 1851 filaments extending out of the flocs correlated strongly with the sludge volume index, and extended filament lengths of approximately 6 x 10(8) micro m ml(-1) resulted in bulking in laboratory-scale and full-scale activated-sludge samples. Quantitative FISH showed that high levels of filaments occurred inside the flocs in nonbulking sludge, supporting the "substrate diffusion limitation" hypothesis for bulking. The approach will allow the monitoring of incremental improvements in bulking control methods and the delineation of the operational conditions that lead to bulking due to specific filaments.     

Bacteriology of activated sludge,in particular the filamentous bacteria

Microscopic examination of bulking activated sludge samples showed the presence of a variety of filamentous microorganisms, some of which have not yet been described in the literature. A method was developed to obtain pure cultures of these threaded bacteria. To date, five clearly different groups of filamentous bacteria may be distinguished by the determination of a few morphological and physiological characteristics of the isolates. A variety of sheathed bacteria are included in Group I. Group II includes non-motile, gram-negative, orange- or yellow-pigmented filamentous bacteria. These microorganisms are thought to be related to some species of the genusFlavobacterium. The gram-negative, threaded bacteria of Group III show a more or less distinct gliding movement and form red colonies on rich agar media. These bacteria may apparently be related to species described in the generaMicroscilla andFlexibacter. The filamentous bacteria of Group IV structurally resemble someCyanophyceae, but do not contain photosynthetic pigments. They are gram-positive and non-motile. A number of unknown, non-motile bacteria which stain gram-positive with a variable number of gram-negative autolyzed cells in the filaments, are assigned to Group V. The properties of the isolated bacteria are described briefly and their occurrence in bulking activated sludge is discussed.     

Substrate uptake tests and quantitative FISH show differences in kinetic growth of bulking and non-bulking activated sludge

The competition between filaments and floc formers in activated sludge has been historically described using kinetic selection. However, recent studies have suggested that bacterial storage may also be an important factor in microbial selection, since the dynamic nature of substrate flows into wastewater treatment plants elicit transient responses from microorganisms. Respirometry-based kinetic selection should thus be reevaluated by considering cell storage, and a more reliable method should be developed to include bacterial storage in the analysis of growth of filaments and floc formers in activated sludge. In this study, we applied substrate uptake tests combined with metabolic modeling to determine the growth rates, yields and maintenance coefficients of bulking and non-bulking activated sludge developed in lab scale reactors under feast and famine conditions. The results of quantitative fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) showed that the filaments Eikelboom Type 1851, Type 021N, and Thiothrix nivea were dominant in bulking sludge, comprising 42.0 % of mixed liquor volatile suspended solids (MLVSS), with 61.6% of the total filament length extending from flocs into bulk solution. Only low levels of Type 1851 filament length (4.9% of MLVSS) occurred in non-bulking sludge, 83.0% of which grew inside the flocs. The kinetic parameters determined from the substrate uptake tests were consistent with those from respirometry and showed that filamentous bulking sludge had lower growth rates and maintenance coefficients than non-bulking sludge. These results provide support for growth kinetic differences in explaining the competitive strategy of filamentous bacteria.     

Changes in the microbial community structure of filaments and floc formers in response to various carbon sources and feeding patterns

Filamentous bulking is a complicated problem in wastewater treatment plants treating various wastewaters, leading to the deterioration of the settling properties and the effluent quality. This study systematically investigated long-term effects of various carbon sources and feeding patterns on the growth of filamentous bacteria, in order to reveal the mechanism of filamentous bulking. Sludge volume index (SVI), microscopic observations, staining (Gram and Neisser staining), scan electron microscopic, and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) were used to monitor the bulking and track the changes of microbial morphology and community structure of activated sludge in six lab-scale sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) fed with different carbon sources. Filamentous bulking was not observed in all SBRs under anoxic feeding pattern with a short fill time, in which SVI remained below 150 mL/g. In contrast, serious bulking (SVI?>?500 mL/g) occurred under aerobic feeding pattern when fed with ethanol, propionate, acetate, and glucose, in which Thiothrix and Sphaerotilus natans proliferated as dominant filaments. Compared to glucose-fed reactor, relatively light bulking was caused in starch-fed reactor with the growth of Nostocoida limicola II. In addition, flocs in starch-fed reactor were more open and fluffy than flocs formed on readily biodegradable substrates. Finally, a framework integrating kinetic selection, diffusion selection, storage selection, and protozoa capture mechanism was proposed to explain filamentous bulking.     

Relationship of Species-Specific Filament Levels to Filamentous Bulking in Activated Sludge

To examine the relationship between activated-sludge bulking and levels of specific filamentous bacteria, we developed a statistics-based quantification method for estimating the biomass levels of specific filaments using 16S rRNA-targeted fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) probes. The results of quantitative FISH for the filament Sphaerotilus natans were similar to the results of quantitative membrane hybridization in a sample from a full-scale wastewater treatment plant. Laboratory-scale reactors were operated under different flow conditions to develop bulking and nonbulking sludge and were bioaugmented with S. natans cells to stimulate bulking. Instead of S. natans, the filament Eikelboom type 1851 became dominant in the reactors. Levels of type 1851 filaments extending out of the flocs correlated strongly with the sludge volume index, and extended filament lengths of approximately 6 × 10⁸ μm ml⁻¹ resulted in bulking in laboratory-scale and full-scale activated-sludge samples. Quantitative FISH showed that high levels of filaments occurred inside the flocs in nonbulking sludge, supporting the “substrate diffusion limitation” hypothesis for bulking. The approach will allow the monitoring of incremental improvements in bulking control methods and the delineation of the operational conditions that lead to bulking due to specific filaments.     

Addition of Al and Fe salts during treatment of paper mill effluents to improve activated sludge settlement characteristics

Metal salts, ferrous sulphate and aluminium chloride, were added to laboratory-scale activated sludge plant treating paper mill effluents to investigate the effect on settlement characteristics. Before treatment the sludge was filamentous, had stirred sludge volume index (SSVI) values in excess of 300 and was moderately hydrophobic. The use of FeSO4.7H2O took three weeks to reduce the SSVI to 90. Microscopic examination showed that Fe had converted the filamentous flocs into a compact structure. When the iron dosing was stopped, the sludge returned to its bulking state within four weeks. In a subsequent trial, the addition of AlCl3 initially resulted in an improvement of the settlement index but then caused deterioration of the sludge properties. It is possible that aluminium was overdosed and caused charge reversal, increasing the SSVI.     

Application of the Fluorescent-Antibody Technique for the Detection of Sphaerotilus natans in Activated Sludge

Sphaerotilus natans, one of the most widely reported causes of bulking in activated sludge, can exist both within and outside of a sheath. It can easily be confused with similar activated sludge bacteria and thus can be overlooked when present in low numbers. Fluorescent antiserum was successfully prepared against the nonfilamentous form and was shown to be highly specific, showing no reaction with either pure cultures of similar filamentous bacteria or entirely unrelated organisms. It did, however, show a lack of strain specificity since it reacted with S. natans isolates from the Federal Republic of Germany and the United States and with filamentous bacteria in South African activated sludges. Fluorescent antibody is capable of penetrating the filaments of S. natans to stain the cells individually. The use of fluorescent antiserum in the identification of S. natans filaments obscured by activated sludge flocs and other suspended matter was simple since the cells stained brightly and could be observed through the less dense matter, while the use of other microscope techniques would be hampered by these obstructions. The use of fluorescent antibody will facilitate ecological studies of S. natans in activated sludge and other aqueous environments.     

Application of Image Analysis Techniques in Activated Sludge Wastewater Treatment Processes

Image analytical techniques have been extensively developed to evaluate complex microbial aggregates such as sludge flocs and biofilms. This review covers the latest contributions concerning the application of image analysis to the activated sludge systems with respect to the most frequently used morphological parameters and relations between them and traditional wastewater treatment parameters. Recent developments have indicated that image analysis can be successfully used for the quantification of flocs and filamentous bacteria in the operating wastewater treatment plants, which enables prediction of bulking events and pinpoint flocs formation.     

Clarifying the roles of kinetics and diffusion in activated sludge filamentous bulking

We hypothesized that the growth rates of filaments and floc formers in activated sludge are affected by the combination of kinetic selection (Lou and de los Reyes, Biotechnol Bioeng 92(6): 729-739, 2005b) and substrate diffusion limitation (Martins et al., Water Res 37:2555-2570, 2003). To clarify the influence of these factors in explaining filamentous bulking, a conceptual framework was developed in this study. The framework suggests the existence of three different regions corresponding to bulking, non-bulking, and intermediate regions, based on substrate concentration. In the bulking and non-bulking regions, kinetic growth differences control the competition process, and filaments or floc formers dominate, respectively. In the intermediate region, substrate diffusion limitation, determined by the floc size, plays the major role in causing bulking. To test this framework, sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) were operated with influent COD of 100, 300, 600, and 1,000 mg/L, and the sludge settleability was measured at various floc size distributions that were developed using different mixing strengths. The experimental data in the bulking and intermediate regions supported the proposed framework. A model integrating the two factors was developed to simulate the substrate concentrations at different depths and floc sizes under intermittently feeding conditions. The modeling results confirmed that substrate diffusion limitation occurs inside the flocs at a certain range of activated sludge floc sizes over the operation cycle, and provided additional support for the proposed framework.     

Bulking sludge in biological nutrient removal systems

Bulking sludge problems are commonly reported in biological nutrient removal (BNR) systems. This has led to the general belief that intrinsic BNR conditions favor the growth of undesirable and excessive filamentous bacteria. The present study shows that other factors have a major role in bulking, and not the BNR conditions. These factors have been verified in well-controlled, strictly anoxic-aerobic and strictly anaerobic-aerobic sequencing batch reactor systems. The experimental results show that conditions known to be responsible for bulking sludge in aerobic systems (i.e., low concentration of electron donor and/or electron acceptor) did not lead to bulking. Even when acetate was present at very low concentrations in the aerobic stage of an anaerobic-aerobic bio-P system, the sludge settleability remained very good. This clearly demonstrates that good bio-P activity can stabilize and improve sludge settleability. The presence of microaerophilic conditions in the anoxic stage of the anoxic-aerobic system was the only factor leading to worsening sludge settling characteristics. The results are discussed in light of our previous hypothesis about the importance of diffusion-limited substrate uptake for the development of filamentous structures in biological flocs. The hypothesis is extended to anaerobic-aerobic and anoxic-aerobic conditions, typical of BNR-activated sludge systems. Taking into account the effect of feeding patterns on biochemical rates and on the development of filamentous bacterial structures, we recommend the adoption of plug-flow selector configurations, with strictly anaerobic and/or strictly anoxic conditions, wherein microaerophilic conditions are excluded, in order to maintain reliable and robust BNR performance.     

Microbial Ecological Model of Filamentous Bulking and Mechanisms

The paper proposes a prototype mathematical model for the interactions among filamentous bacteria, floc-forming bacteria and protozoa within completely mixed activated sludge systems, which is capable of describing the practical coexistence of three microorganisms in a generic way. The systems with substrate fluctuation and without substrate fluctuation are investigated, respectively. The results show that filamentous bulking will occur within an interested range of substrate concentrations under unsuitable dilution rates, particularly at low substrate concentrations. When substrate concentration fluctuates, the same-frequency synchronous control parameters are beneficial to prevent filamentous bulking. Thus, the present investigations not only reveal the cause of the problem of filamentous bulking theoretically, but also may provide a crucial theoretical foundation for overcoming it.     

Transient behavior and time aspects of intermittently and continuously fed bacterial cultures with regard to filamentous bulking of activated sludge

Summary Pure culture transient experiments with Arthrobacter globiformis and Sphaerotilus natans revealed that the floc-forming species A. globiformis can adapt better to intermittent feeding (I-feeding) than the filamentous species S. natans. The floc-forming bacterium showed a larger overcapacity for substrate uptake, a larger accumulation of reserves (polysaccharides and poly--hydroxybutyric acid) and a more efficient mobilization of these polymers. As a consequence A. globiformis became dominant in an I-fed dual culture of S. natans and A. globiformis. The transient behaviour of filamentous continuously fed (C-fed) sludge was similar to the response of S. natans. Consequently, I-feeding of activated sludge could prevent the excessive growth of filamentous bacteria. I-fed sludge, showed a higher overcapacity, the accumulation of more reserves and a shorter lag phase in protein synthesis than C-fed activated sludge, during the transient response, after a pulse dose of substrate. However, to be effective in the control of bulking, the frequency of I-feeding should allow for a sufficiently long endogenous phase. In addition the available fraction of the COD is important in the optimization of I-feeding as a control strategy for filamentous bulking.     

Effect of dissolved oxygen concentration on sludge settleability

This laboratory study presents a detailed evaluation of the effects of dissolved oxygen concentration and accumulation of storage polymers on sludge settleability in activated sludge systems with an aerobic selector. The oxygen and substrate availability regime were simulated in laboratory sequencing batch reactor systems. The experiments showed that low dissolved oxygen concentration (1.1 mg O₂ l^–1) had a strong negative effect on sludge settleability, leading to the proliferation of filamentous bacteria (Thiothrix spp., Type 021N and Type 1851). This negative effect was stronger at high chemical oxygen demand loading rate. This indicates that a compartmentalised (plug flow) aerobic contact tank, designed at short hydraulic residence time to guarantee a strong substrate gradient, with low dissolved oxygen concentration, might be worse for sludge settleability than an "overdesigned" completely mixed contact tank. Contrary to the general hypothesis, the maximum specific acetate uptake rate, poly--hydroxybutyrate production rate, and resistance to short starvation periods are similar in both poor- and well-settling sludge. The results of this study support our previous hypothesis on the importance of substrate gradients for the development of filamentous structures in biological flocs, from soluble organic substrate gradients to dissolved oxygen gradients in sludge flocs.     

Quantification of an Eikelboom type 021N bulking event with fluorescence in situ hybridization and real-time PCR

Primers targeting 16S rRNA genes were designed to detect and quantify Eikelboom type 021N organisms by real-time PCR. Eikelboom type 021N filamentous bulking was induced in a laboratory-scale sequencing batch reactor and the evolution of Eikelboom type 021N 16S rRNA and 16S rRNA genes was monitored. A significant correlation was found between the sludge volume index and the amount of these filamentous organisms present in the sludge (r ²=94.6%, n=10, P<0.01), as measured by real-time PCR. The amount of Eikelboom type 021N 16S rRNA genes increased by a factor of 21 during the experiment, while the 16S rRNA increased by a factor of 33. Moreover, Eikelboom type 021N 16S rRNA increased with increased feeding frequency. It was observed that the RNA:DNA ratio peaked before the sludge volume index increased. In parallel, a fluorescence in situ hybridization study indicated a factor of four increase in the length of Eikelboom type 021N filaments, due to a factor of two increase in both length and number of Eikelboom type 021N filaments. Further, an increase in the fraction of filaments extending outside the activated sludge flocs was observed (19–55%). Monitoring of 16S rRNA genes and 16S rRNA of Eikelboom type 021N was shown to be valuable in evaluating activated sludge settling characteristics; and measuring RNA:DNA ratios may be used as an early warning tool for sludge bulking.     

Phage-host associations in a full-scale activated sludge plant during sludge bulking

Sludge bulking, a notorious microbial issue in activated sludge plants, is always accompanied by dramatic changes in the bacterial community. Despite large numbers of phages in sludge systems, their responses to sludge bulking and phage-host associations during bulking are unknown. In this study, high-throughput sequencing of viral metagenomes and bacterial 16S rRNA genes were employed to characterize viral and bacterial communities in a sludge plant under different sludge conditions (sludge volume index (SVI) of 180, 132, and 73 ml/g). Bulking sludges (SVI > 125 ml/g) taken about 10 months apart exhibited similar bacterial and viral composition. This reflects ecological resilience of the sludge microbial community and indicates that changes in viral and bacterial populations correlate closely with each other. Overgrowth of “Candidatus Microthrix parvicella” led to filamentous bulking, but few corresponding viral genotypes were identified. In contrast, sludge viromes were characterized by numerous contigs associated with “Candidatus Accumulibacter phosphatis,” suggesting an abundance of corresponding phages in the sludge viral community. Notably, while nitrifiers (mainly Nitrosomonadaceae and Nitrospiraceae) declined significantly along with sludge bulking, their corresponding viral contigs were identified more frequently and with greater abundance in the bulking viromes, implying that phage-mediated lysis might contribute to the loss of autotrophic nitrifiers under bulking conditions.     

Chlorine-Susceptible and Chlorine-Resistant Type 021N Bacteria Occurring in Bulking Activated Sludges

Two filamentous bacteria causing bulking in two activated sludges were examined. Investigations using morphological features, staining techniques, and fluorescent in situ hybridization identified both filaments as type 021N. However, an examination of the effect of chlorine on the sludges revealed a chlorine-susceptible type 021N in one sludge and a chlorine-resistant type 021N in the other.     

Chlorine-susceptible and chlorine-resistant type 021N bacteria occurring in bulking activated sludges.

Two filamentous bacteria causing bulking in two activated sludges were examined. Investigations using morphological features, staining techniques, and fluorescent in situ hybridization identified both filaments as type 021N. However, an examination of the effect of chlorine on the sludges revealed a chlorine-susceptible type 021N in one sludge and a chlorine-resistant type 021N in the other.     

Application of Microautoradiography to the Study of Substrate Uptake by Filamentous Microorganisms in Activated Sludge

Excessive growth of filamentous microorganisms in activated-sludge treatment plants is a major operational problem which causes poor settlement of activated sludge. An enhanced understanding of the factors controlling growth of different filamentous microorganisms is necessary in order to establish more successful control strategies. In the present study, the in situ substrate uptake was investigated by means of microautoradiography. It was demonstrated that the uptake of labeled organic substrates by the filamentous microorganisms, during short-term incubation, could be detected by microautoradiography. Viability and respiratory activity of the filaments were also detected by reduction of CTC (5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride) and by incorporation of [(sup3)H]thymidine. Gram, Neisser, and fluorescence staining techniques were used for the localization and identification of the filaments. Activated-sludge samples from five wastewater treatment plants with bulking problems due to filamentous microorganisms were investigated. Microthrix parvicella, Nostocoida limicola, and Eikelboom's type 0041 and type 021N were investigated for their ability to take up organic substrates. A panel of six substrates, i.e., [(sup14)C]acetate, [(sup3)H]glucose, [(sup14)C]ethanol, [(sup3)H]glycine, [(sup3)H]leucine, and [(sup3)H]oleic acid, was tested. The uptake response was found to be very specific not only between the different filamentous types but also among filaments of the same type from different treatment plants. Interestingly, M. parvicella consistently took up only oleic acid among the tested substrates. It is concluded that microautoradiography is a useful method for investigation of in situ substrate uptake by filamentous microorganisms in activated sludge.     

Tetrazolium Reduction-Malachite Green Method for Assessing the Viability of Filamentous Bacteria in Activated Sludge

A method was developed to assess the activity of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge. It involves the incubation of activated sludge with 2(p-iodophenyl)-3-(p-nitrophenyl)-5-phenyl tetrazolium chloride followed by staining with malachite green. Both cells and 2(p-iodophenyl)-3-(p-nitrophenyl)-5-phenyl tetrazolium chloride-formazan crystals can be observed in prepared specimens by using bright-field microscopy. This procedure allowed us to distinguish between inactive and actively metabolizing filaments after chlorine application to control the bulking of activated sludge.