Ethylene-induced leaf senescence depends on age-related changes and OLD genes in Arabidopsis

Ethylene can only induce senescence in leaves that have reached a defined age. Thus, ethylene-induced senescence depends on age-related changes (ARCs) of individual leaves. The relationship between ethylene and age in the induction of leaf senescence was tested in Arabidopsis Ler-0, Col-0, and Ws-0 accessions as well as in eight old (onset of leaf death) mutants, isolated from the Ler-0 background. Plants with a constant final age of 24 d were exposed to ethylene for 3-16 d. The wild-type accessions showed a common response to the ethylene treatment. Increasing ethylene treatments of 3-12 d caused an increase in the number of yellow leaves. However, an ethylene exposure time of 16 d resulted in a decrease in the amount of yellowing. Thus, ethylene can both positively and negatively influence ARCs and the subsequent induction of leaf senescence, depending on the length of the treatment. The old mutants showed altered responses to the ethylene treatments. old1 and old11 were hypersensitive to ethylene in the triple response assay and a 12-d ethylene exposure resulted in a decrease in the amount of yellow leaves. The other six mutants did not show a decrease in yellow leaves with an ethylene treatment of 16 d. The results revealed that the effect of ethylene on the induction of senescence can be modified by at least eight genes.     

Identification of three genetic loci controlling leaf senescence in Arabidopsis thaliana

Four mutants that show the delayed leaf senescence phenotype were isolated from Arabidopsis thaliana . Genetic analyses revealed that they are all monogenic recessive mutations and fall into three complementation groups, identifying three genetic loci controlling leaf senescence in Arabidopsis . Mutations in these loci cause delay in all senescence parameters examined, including chlorophyll content, photochemical efficiency of photosystem II, relative amount of the large subunit of Rubisco, and RNase and peroxidase activity. Delay of the senescence symptoms was observed during both age-dependent in planta senescence and dark-induced artificial senescence in all of the mutant plants. The results indicate that the three genes defined by the mutations are key genetic elements controlling functional leaf senescence and provide decisive genetic evidence that leaf senescence is a genetically programmed phenomenon controlled by several monogenic loci in Arabidopsis . The results further suggest that the three genes function at a common step of age-dependent and dark-induced senescence processes. It is further shown that one of the mutations is allelic to ein2-1 , an ethylene-insensitive mutation, confirming the role of ethylene signal transduction pathway in leaf senescence of Arabidopsis .     

Ethylene as a regulator of senescence in tobacco leaf discs

The regulatory role of ethylene in leaf senescence was studied with excised tobacco leaf discs which were allowed to senesce in darkness. Exogenous ethylene, applied during the first 24 hours of senescence, enhanced chlorophyll loss without accelerating the climacteric-like pattern of rise in both ethylene and CO₂, which occurred in the advanced stage of leaf senescence. Rates of both ethylene and CO₂ evolution increased in the ethylene-treated leaf discs, especially during the first 3 days of senescence. The rhizobitoxine analog, aminoethoxy vinyl glycine, markedly inhibited ethylene production and reduced respiration and chlorophyll loss. Pretreatment of leaf discs with Ag⁺ or enrichment of the atmosphere with 5 to 10% CO₂ reduced chlorophyll loss, reduced rate of respiration, and delayed the climacteric-like rise in both ethylene and respiration. Ag⁺ was much more effective than CO₂ in retarding leaf senescence. Despite their senescence-retarding effect, Ag⁺ and CO₂, which are known to block ethylene action, stimulated ethylene production by the leaf discs during the first 3 days of the senescing period; Ag⁺ was more effective than CO₂. The results suggest that although ethylene production decreases prior to the climacteric-like rise during the later stages of senescence, endogenous ethylene plays a considerable role throughout the senescence process, presumably by interacting with other hormones participating in leaf senescence.     

Delayed leaf senescence in ethylene-deficient ACC-oxidase antisense tomato plants: molecular and physiological analysis

To determine the role of ethylene during tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. Alisa Craig) leaf senescence, transgenic ACC oxidase antisense plants were analysed. Northern analysis of wild-type plants indicated that ACC oxidase mRNA accumulation normally begins in pre-senescent green leaves but was severely reduced in the antisense plants. Although the levels of ethylene evolved by wild-type and transgenic leaves increased during the progression of senescence, levels were extremely low in transgenic leaves. Leaf senescence, as assessed by colour change from green to yellow, was clearly delayed by 10–14 days in the antisense plants when compared with wild-type plants. Northern analysis of the photosynthesis-associated genes, cab and rbcS, indicated that levels of the corresponding mRNAs were higher in transgenic leaves which were not yet senescing compared with senescing wild-type leaves of exactly the same age. Northern analysis using probes for tomato fruit ripening-related genes expressed during leaf senescence indicated that once senescence was initiated the expression pattern of these mRNAs was similar in transgenic and wild-type leaves. In the antisense plants chlorophyll levels, photosynthetic capacity and chlorophyll fluorescence were higher when compared with senescing wild-type plants of the same age. Photosynthetic capacity and the quantum efficiency of photosystem II were maintained for longer in the transformed plants at values close to those observed in wild-type leaves prior to the visible onset of senescence. These results indicate that inhibiting ACC oxidase expression and ethylene synthesis results in delayed leaf senescence, rather than inducing a stay-green phenotype. Once senescence begins, it progresses normally. Onset of senescence is not, therefore, related to a critical level of ethylene. The correlation between higher levels prior to senescence and early onset, however, suggests that ethylene experienced by the plant may be a significant contributing factor in the timing of senescence.     

Signal transduction in leaf senescence

Leaf senescence is a complex developmental phase that involves both degenerative and nutrient recycling processes. It is characterized by loss of chlorophyll and the degradation of proteins, nucleic acids, lipids, and nutrient remobilization. The onset and progression of leaf senescence are controlled by an array of environmental cues (such as drought, darkness, extreme temperatures, and pathogen attack) and endogenous factors (including age, ethylene, jasmonic acid, salicylic acid, abscisic acid, and cytokinin). This review discusses the major breakthroughs in signal transduction during the onset of leaf senescence, in dark- and drought-mediated leaf senescence, and in various hormones regulating leaf senescence achieved in the past several years. Various signals show different mechanisms of controlling leaf senescence, and cross-talks between different signaling pathways make it more complex. Key senescence regulatory networks still need to be elucidated, including cross-talks and the interaction mechanisms of various environmental signals and internal factors.     

Three positive regulators of leaf senescence in Arabidopsis, ORE1, ORE3 and ORE9, play roles in crosstalk among multiple hormone-mediated senescence pathways

Leaf senescence is a developmentally programmed event, but the initiation and progression of leaf senescence are affected by a range of plant hormones including abscisic acid (ABA), ethylene and methyl jasmonate (MeJA). To investigate plant hormone crosstalk during leaf senescence, hormone-induced senescence phenotypes were analyzed in three leaf senescence mutants [ore1 (oresara1), ore3 and ore9] showing delayed senescence phenotypes in age-dependent and dark-induced senescence. The ore mutants exhibited delayed leaf senescence phenotypes following treatment with ABA, ACC (aminocyclo-propane-1-carboxylic acid) or MeJA. After each hormone treatment, the photochemical efficiency of photosystem II and chlorophyll content were significantly higher in the ore mutant leaves than in the wild-type leaves. The expression of CAB2 and SEN4 in the wild-type was rapidly altered following each hormone treatment. However, the decrease in CAB2 expression and the induction of SEN4 expression in the mutants were less affected by ABA, ACC or MeJA treatment. It is suggested that ORE1, ORE3 and ORE9 are required for the proper progression of leaf senescence mediated by ABA, ethylene and MeJA. This implies that ORE1, ORE3 and ORE9 may be linked to the crosstalk among senescence pathways induced by ABA, ethylene and MeJA, as well as age and darkness.     

The relation between nitrogen deficiency and second leaf senescence in wheat plants

Life span of the second leaf of wheat(Triticum aestivum L., cv. Grana) plants was studied from day 8 to day 50 of plant age in a variant with nitrogen (+N) and in a variant in which plant senescence was induced by the omission of nitrogen from the nutrient solution (−N). Seed protein was the sole source of nitrogen for these plants. Specific leaf mass (SLM) in the −N variant, and specific leaf area (SLA), the mass of fresh leaf, soluble protein content and total nitrogen content in the +N variant peaked by day 22 of plant age (that is by day 19 of leaf age). Dry matter content, leaf length and leaf area, and SLM in the +N variant peaked by day 29 of plant age (that is by day 26 of leaf age). The ontogeny of the second leaf in the variant with enhanced senescence was shorter by at least 14 days. Plants from this variant showed typical symptoms of N deficiency, that is yellowing of leaves, tip burn, and lack of tillering. However, the growth and biochemical characters studied did not indicate an earlier onset of the senescence of the second leaf of −N plants. Both +N and −N variants reached their peaks (with the exception of an earlier peak by day 12 in case of total nitrogen content in the −N variant) on the same day of leaf age. Thus the first part of the leaf life span from leaf growth initiation to full expansion was of the same length in both the control and N-def icient plants. The stage of the proper senescence of the second leaf of −N plants was very short; the leaf completely died away within 7 days after senescence onset.     

ACC synthase expression regulates leaf performance and drought tolerance in maize

Ethylene regulates entry into several types of plant developmental cell death and senescence programs besides mediating plant responses to biotic and abiotic stress. The response of cereals to conditions of drought includes loss of leaf function and premature onset of senescence in older leaves. In this study, ACC synthase ( ACS ) mutants, affecting the first step in ethylene biosynthesis, were isolated in maize and their effect on leaf function examined. Loss of ZmACS6 expression resulted in delayed leaf senescence under normal growth conditions and inhibited drought-induced senescence. Zmacs6 leaves continued to be photosynthetically active under both conditions indicating that leaf function was maintained. The delayed senescence phenotype associated with loss of ZmACS6 expression was complemented by exogenous ACC. Surprisingly, elevated levels of foliar chlorophyll, Rubisco, and soluble protein as well as improved leaf performance was observed for all Zmasc6 leaves, including young and fully expanded leaves which were far from initiating senescence. These observations suggest that ethylene may serve to regulate leaf performance throughout its lifespan as well as to determine the onset of natural senescence and mediate drought-induced senescence.     

The never ripe mutation blocks ethylene perception in tomato.

Seedlings of tomato fruit ripening mutants were screened for their ability to respond to ethylene. Ethylene induced the triple response in etiolated hypocotyls of all tomato ripening mutants tested except for one, Never ripe (Nr). Our results indicated that the lack of ripening in this mutant is caused by ethylene insensitivity. Segregation analysis indicated that Nr-associated ethylene insensitivity is a single codominant trait and is pleiotropic, blocking senescence and abscission of flowers and the epinastic response of petioles. In normal tomato flowers, petal abscission and senescence occur 4 to 5 days after the flower opens and precede fruit expansion. If fertilization does not occur, pedicel abscission occurs 5 to 8 days after petal senescence. If unfertilized, Nr flowers remained attached to the plant indefinitely, and petals remained viable and turgid more than four times longer than their normal counterparts. Fruit development in Nr plants was not preceded by petal senescence; petals and anthers remained attached until they were physically displaced by the expanding ovary. Analysis of engineered 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase-overexpressing plants indicated that they are phenotypic opposites of Nr plants. Constitutive expression of ACC synthase in tomato plants resulted in high rates of ethylene production by many tissues of the plant and induced petiole epinasty and premature senescence and abscission of flowers, usually before anthesis. There were no obvious effects on senescence in leaves of ACC synthase overexpressers, suggesting that although ethylene may be important, it is not sufficient to cause tomato leaf senescence; other signals are clearly involved.     

Ethylene regulates the timing of leaf senescence in Arabidopsis

The plant hormone ethylene influences many aspects of plant growth and development, including some specialized forms of programmed senescence such as fruit ripening and flower petal senescence. To study the relationship between ethylene and leaf senescence, etr1-1, an ethylene-insensitive mutant in Arabidopsis, was used. Comparative analysis of rosette leaf senescence between etr1-1 and wild-type plants revealed that etr1-1 leaves live approximately 30% longer than the wild-type leaves. Delayed leaf senescence in etr1-1 coincided with delayed induction of senescence-associated genes (SAGs) and higher expression levels of photosynthesis-associated genes (PAGs). In wild-type plants, exogenous ethylene was able to further accelerate induction of SAGs and decrease expression of PAGs. The extended period of leaf longevity in etr1-1 was associated with low levels of photosynthetic activity. Therefore, the leaves in etr1-1 functionally senesced even though the apparent life span of the leaf was prolonged.     

Mutation of Oryza sativa CORONATINE INSENSITIVE 1b (OsCOI1b) delays leaf senescence

Jasmonic acid (JA) functions in plant development, including senescence and immunity. Arabidopsis thaliana CORONATINE INSENSITIVE 1 encodes a JA receptor and functions in the JA‐responsive signaling pathway. The Arabidopsis genome harbors a single COI gene, but the rice (Oryza sativa) genome harbors three COI homologs, OsCOI1a, OsCOI1b, and OsCOI2. Thus, it remains unclear whether each OsCOI has distinct, additive, synergistic, or redundant functions in development. Here, we use the oscoi1b‐1 knockout mutants to show that OsCOI1b mainly affects leaf senescence under senescence‐promoting conditions. oscoi1b‐1 mutants stayed green during dark‐induced and natural senescence, with substantial retention of chlorophylls and photosynthetic capacity. Furthermore, several senescence‐associated genes were downregulated in oscoi1b‐1 mutants, including homologs of Arabidopsis thaliana ETHYLENE INSENSITIVE 3 and ORESARA 1, important regulators of leaf senescence. These results suggest that crosstalk between JA signaling and ethylene signaling affects leaf senescence. The Arabidopsis coi1‐1 plants containing 35S:OsCOI1a or 35S:OsCOI1b rescued the delayed leaf senescence during dark incubation, suggesting that both OsCOI1a and OsCOI1b are required for promoting leaf senescence in rice. oscoi1b‐1 mutants showed significant decreases in spikelet fertility and grain weight, leading to severe reduction of grain yield, indicating that OsCOI1‐mediated JA signaling affects spikelet fertility and grain filling.     

Natural variation in the regulation of leaf senescence and relation to N and root traits in wheat

Objectives

To identify parameters that can be used for the analysis of natural variation in leaf senescence of wheat; and to understand the association between the onset and progression of leaf senescence with N uptake and root traits.

Methods

Chlorophyll content and the proportion of yellow leaves were used as senescence indicators and their relation with other morphological and physiological traits were measured in contrasting early senescing (ES) and late senescing (LS) wheat lines.

Results

There were significant genotype effects on the onset and progress of senescence. The ES lines in which leaf senescence commenced early had significantly lower root biomass and N uptake than LS lines. The strong negative association between the extent of leaf senescence with root biomass and N uptake indicated that the poor root growth induced N limitation caused the early senescence of ES lines.

Conclusions

The leaf senescence development in ES lines was precocious and constitutive as the trait expressed even under optimal growth conditions suggesting they could be useful in understanding the genetic regulation of senescence under different abiotic stress situations. Accelerated leaf senescence in wheat could be a mechanism to compensate for limitations in the root system that tend to restrict nutrient uptake.     

The delayed leaf senescence mutants of Arabidopsis, ore1, ore3, and ore9 are tolerant to oxidative stress

Reactive oxygen species play a critical role in mediating the oxidative damage that causes senescence in a variety of aerobic organisms, from yeast to mammals. Genetic studies of these organisms have revealed that extended longevity is frequently associated with an increased resistance to stress. However, the relationship between life span and oxidative stress tolerance in plants is poorly understood. We have investigated the responses to oxidative stress in the delayed leaf senescence mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana, ore1, ore3, and ore9. The detached leaves of these mutants exhibit increased tolerance to various types of oxidative stress. The ore1, ore3, and ore9 mutants were also more tolerant to oxidative stress at the level of the whole plant, as determined by measuring physiological and molecular changes associated with oxidative stress. However, the activities of antioxidant enzymes were similar or lower in the mutants, as compared to wild type. These results suggest that the increased resistance to oxidative stress in the ore1, ore3, and ore9 mutants is not due to enhanced activities of these antioxidant enzymes. Taken together, our findings provide genetic evidence that oxidative stress tolerance is linked to control of leaf longevity in plants.     

The role of sugars in integrating environmental signals during the regulation of leaf senescence

Although leaf senescence results in a loss of photosynthetic carbon fixation, the senescence-dependent release of nutrients, especially of nitrogen, is important for the growth of young leaves and for reproduction. Environmental regulation of senescence is therefore a vital factor in the carbon and nitrogen economy of plants. Leaf senescence is a highly plastic trait that is affected by a range of different environmental factors including light, nutrient supply, CO2 concentration, and abiotic and biotic stress. In this review, the focus is on the impact of environmental conditions on sugar accumulation and sugar signalling during senescence. By signalling a high availability of carbon relative to nitrogen in the old leaves, sugar accumulation can trigger leaf senescence. Sugar-induced senescence is therefore particularly important under low nitrogen availability and may also play a role in light signalling. Whether or not sugars are involved in regulating the senescence response of plants to elevated CO2 remains unresolved. Senescence can be delayed or accelerated in elevated CO2 and no clear relationship between sugar accumulation and senescence has been found. Plasticity in the response to environmental factors, such as daylength and sugar accumulation, varies between different Arabidopsis accessions. This natural variation can be exploited to analyse the genetic basis of the regulation of senescence and the consequences for growth and fecundity. Different evolutionary strategies, i.e. early senescence combined with a high reproductive effort or late senescence combined with a low reproductive effort, may be an important adaptation of Arabidopsis accessions to their natural habitat.     

Natural developmental variations in leaf and plant senescence in Arabidopsis thaliana

Leaf senescence is a developmentally regulated process that contributes to nutrient redistribution during reproductive growth and finally leads to tissue death. Manipulating leaf senescence through breeding or genetic engineering may help to improve important agronomic traits, such as crop yield and the storage life of harvested organs. Here, we studied natural variations in the regulation of plant senescence among 16 Arabidopsis thaliana accessions. Chlorophyll content and the proportion of yellow leaves were used as indicator parameters to determine leaf and plant senescence respectively. Our study indicated significant genotype effects on the onset and development of senescence. We selected three late- and five early-senescence accessions for further physiological studies. The relationship between leaf and plant senescence was accession-dependent. There was a significant correlation between plant senescence and the total number of leaves, siliques and plant bolting age. We monitored expression of two senescence marker genes, SAG12 and WRKY53 , to evaluate progression of senescence. Our data revealed that chlorophyll content does not fully reflect leaf age, because even fully green leaves had already commenced senescence at the molecular level. Integrating senescence parameters, such as the proportion of senescent leaves, at the whole plant level provided a better indication of the molecular status of the plant than single leaf senescence parameters.